15 Sci-fi TV Shows That Ended Too Soon
Warning: grieving geeks ahead...
There are some things that leave a void that just can't be filled when they go. Worldy goods are one thing (special mention to pizza, obviously), loved ones and relationships another, but characters and story arcs you're invested in are on another level entirely. And they're the ones that are often the most inevitable.
Every spring and fall schedule has a load of shows included that won't make it past the pilot stage, let alone a full season order. But for every worthy swing of the studio axe - Knight Rider, Defiance, Dracula and, erm, Time Travelling Bong - there are some shows that get the cut, despite being pretty darn good.
The majority of the shows on such death-lists tend to be victims of circumstance; they either arrived at a time where there was not an audience to appreciate them, or, brutally, the numbers just didn't stack. This leaves burgeoning fanbases worldwide choking back tears and wondering what could have been.
Don't despair, we live in a world of relaunches, revamps and reboots. Some of the entries on this list that haven't already been given a second shot might yet make a comeback.
15. Terra Nova
The Beginning:
Spielberg! A $20million pilot! Stephen Lang! Everything about this sci-fi show screamed ‘promising’ when it was announced at the turn of the decade.
Fox were so sure they had a hit on their hands that a full season was ordered before the cameras started rolling. The result was a thrilling, never boring romp where dwellers of a depleted earth were whisked back to the prehistoric period to colonize the planet.
Cue lots of action, Lost esque intrigue and high production values.
The End:
Airing September 2011, in a thirteen-episode run, Fox trembled at the viewing figures and were quick to send the show into extinction, this was despite some decent reviews and a lot of money ploughed into it.
There have been rumblings of a Netflix revival but at this point nothing has been confirmed
14. Alien Nation
The Beginning:
While not the dud some thought it to be, 1988’s Alien Nation was a movie that was perhaps best suited in a different guise. Like, say, a television series maybe? It’s a good thing, then, that Fox spotted potential in the film’s central buddy relationship and made that the focus of the show.
Based on the movie’s concept of alien’s living among us, the series focused on rolled up sleeves police work and the day to day trials of LAPD Detective Matthew Sikes (human) and his other worldly partner, Sam Francisco (yes, that was his name).
Don't let that put you off - the show was brimming with promise.
The End:
The show aired in 1989 but was cancelled after one season. This wasn’t down to poor reviews or viewing figures, mind, but was a result of the then fledgling Fox Network running out of dollar, meaning their 1990 roster of shows were all scrapped.
Despite being cut down in its infancy, the show lived on by way of some TV movies and a full season in comic book form.
13. Journeyman
The Beginning:
Launched as part of NBC’s fall schedule of 2007, Journeyman was a well-meaning show centred on a chap with a nagging ability to flit back in time and change the destiny of a chosen few.
With Kevin McKidd cast as the lead, supported by the likes of Brian Howe, Moon Bloodgood and a sumptuous San Francisco setting, the show was met with positive reviews, with critics and fans citing the show’s balance of romance and sci-fi smarts as being a high point.
The End:
Journeyman’s first season ended on a suitably intriguing note, with McKidd’s protagonist, Dan Vasser, discovering that he wasn’t the only ‘Frisco dweller that could go all Quantum Leap on us.
But, alas, low viewing figures meant that not even a fan campaign could stop NBC from pulling the plug on this one.
12. Stargate Universe
The Beginning:
Airing in fall 2010, Stargate Universe was an exciting chapter in the sci-fi franchise. Taking more of a survivalist approach, the show zoned in on the scuttled crew of the battered ship Destiny, on a mission to first save their skins and, of course, do some interplanetary exploring.
At the centre of all this action was a simmering relationship between the ship’s ranking officer, Everett Young (Louis Ferreira), and its doctor, Nicholas Rush, played by an on form Robert Carlyle.
The End:
Despite audiences being left on tenterhooks following season two finale ‘Gauntlet’, and a general concensus that the show was starting to get into its groove, SyFy announced shortly after that SGU was no more, citing falling viewing figures as the reason for this decision.
Fans were quick to accuse SyFy of not caring about the franchise causing the network’s vice president to engage the rabid hordes in a frank admission, saying that ‘if we didn’t like science fiction, we simply wouldn’t have made SGU’.
11. Star Trek: Enterprise
The Beginning:
Airing from 2001 to 2005, Enterprise was in many ways ahead of its time; the show adopted a prequel format, being set 10 years before the events of The Original Series, and was geared towards the relationship between humans and Vulcans.
Hell, just to make the time element that bit more pertinent, they even let Scott Bakula aboard on captaining duties. Despite only running for four seasons there’s a devoted fanbase out there that bemoan this series not being given even longer on screens.
The End:
While there were folks out there that loved Enterprise, there were avid Trekkies that picked apart every plot strand their greasy fingers could grab onto (Romulan’s using cloaking devices, say what?) so vigorously, that the show’s reputation disappeared down a fan rage-induced black hole.
But the iron clad reason the show met its demise came down to ratings. Roll on the release of Discovery.
10. Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles
The Beginning:
The Sarah Connor Chronicles is one of those shows that, at the time, the wider public weren’t too fussed about; it was 2008, Terminator Salvation was on the horizon and folks were too preoccupied with the thought of Christian Bale and Sam Worthington going all post-apocalyptic on each other.
Looking back, though, the show was two seasons-worth of fun. Slotting nicely into the Terminator timeline – it’s essentially a sequel to Judgement Day – the trials of Sarah and John Connor trying to stop the rise of Skynet, aided by a scene-stealing Summer Glau as T-800 esque Cameron, had so much potential.
The End:
By the time Salvation was released, quelling the flames of hope that the franchise was going to be reborn, Fox (those rascals again) had already pulled the plug on the show.
There have been campaigns and crowd funding efforts to jump start the robo saga, but all have been unsuccessful.
9. Dark Angel
The Beginning:
No stranger to framing kick ass heroines, James Cameron made his TV debut with this cyber-punky series. Set in a post-apocalyptic Seattle, the show focused on a genetically-enhanced Jessica Alba (in her own debut) as she swerved the advances of the sinister Manticore group, while at the same time trying to find her own lab born siblings.
Offering up an enthralling central arc, a great performance from Alba and a theme tune from Chuck D, this was at the top of many end of year polls in 2000, the year of its launch.
The End:
A possible victim of figure-busting pilot syndrome – the series opener was watched by over seventeen million viewers – a sharp decline in ratings and shift to the dreaded Friday night slot saw the show cancelled after season two. Baffling, seeing as the program has worn well and there is a dearth of positive female leads in sci-fi TV shows these days.
But, as it stands, genre fans are still left twiddling their soul patches and hardened Jessica Alba fans are seeking solace in battered Blu-Ray copies of Into The Blue.
8. Amazing Stories
The Beginning:
Amazing Stories couldn’t have been more eighties if it had bounced onto screens astride a Pogo Ball, with a boom box on its shoulders blaring out Blue Monday – chugging on a Tab Cola.
Devised by Steven Spielberg, the intention was to ape the ‘Berg’s beloved Twilight Zone and give audiences a fresh, new anthology series. The result was a show that was packed with memorable episodes – ‘The Mission’ was an Emmy-snatching treat and Scorsese’s ‘Mirror, Mirror’ remains a highpoint – and was successful in getting the family sat on the sofa together, being scared, excited and thrilled on a regular basis.
The End:
Annoyingly, Amazing Stories didn’t attract massive audiences so ended in 1987 – after just two seasons.
It’s not all doom and gloom, though, as along with being something of an inspiration after it was cancelled – family favourite Batteries Not Included derived from an Amazing Stories episode treatment and LucasArts sci-fi adventure, The Dig, was inspired by the series – Hannibal maestro Brian Fuller is currently developing a reboot as you read these very words.
7. Jericho
The Beginning:
Set in the eponymous Texan town, in the aftermath of a nuclear attack on the US, Jericho was the brainchild of Jonathan Steinberg (now of Black Sails fame) and Josh Schaer, who both wanted to create a character drama amid the starkest of settings.
The result was a show that started out with plenty of scavenging escapades but broadened into an exercise in rebuilding with some added blasts of intrigue to boot. Who can forget the neat little Morse code-embedded intro credits, too.
The End
Jericho has one of the more interesting cancellations in TV history; originally cancelled in 2008 having ran for one season to poor ratings, a now infamous fan campaign (nut, anyone?) saw the show resurrected for a shortened second season.
People power may have prevailed, but the viewing figures were – again – not quite there, so the second coming of Jericho was a short one.
While there are no signs of the show being revived – it’s enjoyed a third and fourth season in comic book form – this does beg the question, why the hell not have another roll of the dice but make it a Fallout TV show? We can dream.
6. Space: 1999
The Beginning:
Off the back of successes in Stingray, Thunderbirds and Captain Scarlett, Gerry Anderson probably thought he was the cats pyjamas – and who could blame him? Everything that he attached some strings to was turning to TV gold, and a more recent foray into live action entertainment (UFO) had struck a chord with audiences.
That all changed when this passion project hit screens in 1975, which despite boasting an impressive American cast in Martin Landau and Barbara Bain, some unique Space Odyssey-inspired visuals and a barmy plot only British sci-fi could yield – nuke the moon! – the show only lasted for two seasons.
The End:
At the time, Space: 1999 was the most expensive British television series in history, so the expectation was that viewing figures would justify the spend. While reviews were good, the US arm of production company ITC Entertainment got involved in the development of a second season (Year Two, as it was titled), introducing overly commercial storylines and some unwelcome humour.
With this decline in quality the show never saw a ‘Year Three’.
Its legacy lives on, though, with ITV teasing fans with a revival – as of 2012 it was to be titled Space: 2099 but the project remains in a skewed orbit – and sci-fi icon Ronald D. Moore admitting that he lifted the intro sequence from Space: 1999 for his Battlestar Galactica reboot.
5. Dollhouse
The Beginning:
Not lured away from the flame following the premature demise of his Firefly, Joss Whedon had high hopes for his next sci-fi venture. Set in an alternate present, where humans can be programmed for anything and put up for hire, this show focuses on a Los Angeles ‘House’, where main ‘Doll’, Echo, starts to wriggle out of the various personalities that are being imprinted on her.
First airing in February 2009, viewers were at first tentative; this was, after all, a fairly high concept show with a protagonist that can one minute be a high-kicking assassin and the next a femme fatale, all the while talking about being sent up to something called ‘The Attic’. It took a near cancellation and a strong season two for this to find its way into people’s hearts
The End:
At the close of season one rumours were flinging about that Fox were going to pull the plug on Dollhouse. But strong fan support saw a second season commissioned, which ended up being an altogether grittier affair.
Summer Glau and Battlestar’s Jamie Bamber became series regulars and, despite reviews being strong, come futuristic season finale ‘Epitaph Two: Return’, the writing was on the wall: Fox had cancelled the series once and for all.
4. The Lone Gunmen
The Beginning:
Those lovable nerds over at The Lone Gunmen were hardly the likeliest candidates for being given their own spin-off show; Ringo, Frohike and Byers seemed pretty content unpicking conspiracy theories in their dingy apartment, their portal to the outside world being a visit from Mulder.
But that’s precisely what made this show such an achingly good piece of television. Created by X-Files’ Chris Carter and unveiled in 2001, it hit that perfect balance of shadowy plot lines – no aliens here, just rogue Nazis and some war-mongering crime – and was also damn funny to boot.
The End:
Bit of a pattern forming here, The Lone Gunmen didn’t garner the audience it deserved, therefore, Fox put an end to it. Worse still, not content with lowering the dimmer on the trio’s time in the limelight, Fox decided that it was spin-off or nothing – the Gunmen had to go.
With the series ending early 2001, season nine of the X-Files followed later in the year giving Frohike and co their swansong in divisive episode ‘Jump The Shark’. Only the coldest of fish didn’t get a chill when that security door was brought down on their time on screens
Their sacrifice may have earned them a resting place at Arlington, but the void left by their passing was so great that their deaths were retconned shortly after and they lived on in X-Files season ten, the comic series.
3. The Outer Limits
The Beginning:
The Outer Limits took the Twilight Zone's showcase format and switched the gaze from all things lurking in the beyond, to a pure sci-fi experience like no other.
Created by self-confessed 'hack' Leslie Stevens (he was so much more than that, be assured) the show aired from 1963 to 1965, spawning famous episodes such as The Chameleon (penned by Oscar-winner in waiting, Robert Towne) and Soldier, which is notable for writer Harlen Ellison dragging James Cameron into court over, claiming The Terminator plagerised this his story treatment.
In its hey day this was prime time viewing that introduced legions of viewers to the endless possibilities of science fiction.
The End:
After its cancellation, the show's legacy ripened like an old cheddar, with the likes of Star Trek The Original Series taking a few nods from the series and even horror maestro Stephen King seeking inspiration from it.
Its popularity was enduring enough to spawn a relaunch in 1995, which was well-received and (whisper it) arguably as good as the original series.
2. The Prisoner
The Beginning:
Don’t get folks started on how The Prisoner was conceived; there’s one school of thought out there that it was British writer come journalist George Markstein who came up with the concept, during the filming of Danger Man.
While other sources cite the aforementioned show’s star, Patrick McGoohan, as putting pen to paper on this one. As it stands, the eerily brilliant show has no 'created by’ credit.
Whatever noodle it came from, the result was a show that although only lasting seventeen episodes, had a major impact on the counterculture of its time (the sixties), had plenty of iconic images (Portmeirion, the balls!) and shaped the science fiction genre into something that could be thought-provoking as well as thrilling.
The End:
McGoohan had always envisaged The Prisoner being almost a miniseries affair and it was only at the urging of a colleague that he stretched the series out, resulting in a speedy writing session to get the final episodes written.
Come the cancellation, any plans for a series showing Number Six on the lamb were squished like a Rover had landed on them.
Still, the show is constantly topping polls for the best and most successful sci-fi shows ever and is still being brought back to life in re-launches, comic books and audio stories.
1. Firefly
The Beginning:
Any journalist, writer or keyboard warrior blogger will always feel a sense of trepidation when faced with putting some words together about Firefly.
This is, without argument, the most revered, loved and talked about one-season wonder that’s ever flown onto screens. Too many words of adoration and love of Captain Mal, his crew and their post-Civil War adventures would only appear well worn and tired.
All that needs to be said is that in September 2002, over 14 episodes, sci-fi audiences old and young fell even deeper in love with the genre. This was the power of Joss Whedon's vision.
The End:
Cancelled ten episodes into its solo voyage on screens and brought back to life via a growing media franchise – the Serenity comic series is arguably better than the Serenity movie itself – the success of Firefly in various different guises and the lore that has generated around it could well be the reason a season two or relaunch has never happened.
Fox have made noises they would be open to a new season, but it’s all quiet on the Whedon front. As it stands, fans are left envisaging what could be and checking for updates on the space junk project that is Firefly Online.
We live in hope.
Got a show that you think didn’t get a decent run on screens? An ardent fan of Dark Skies? Then get commenting below.