15 Star Trek Deaths That Didn't Last
You can't keep a good character down so why make killing them off the end of the road?
With its rich collection of characters, Star Trek has given every sci-fi fan someone to back at some point during its lifetime. Whether it's an unconditional admiration for Spock's logic or love-to-hate with the deliciously wicked Kai Winn, there's always a reason to tune in and see them evolve.
Yet there have been times when even the most beloved character seems to be at the end of the road. It might be a sudden rug-pull moment, it could be something that the writers have been leading to for a while but, for some, there's a certain point of finality.
The changing landscape of serialised TV has a lot to give when it comes to killing off its characters yet Star Trek has never had to worry about the grave being the last point in the story. Indeed it has relished the point where no one has gone before and run with it on more than one (or two) occasions.
In the land of science-fiction TV anything goes and it could be said that in some cases anything comes back. Death not only acts as a juicy bit of suspense and action but also just part of the day job as we will see from this list of the franchise's best and bizarre resurrections to date. This applies to specific individual characters so Cause and Effect, for instance, is not counted!
15. James Kirk - Star Trek: Into Darkness
If there's one of these resurrections that threw fandom into a maelstrom it was Kirk's demise in Star Trek Into Darkness.
Not content with reviving Khan for the Kelvin Timeline, the writers decided to switch the monumental sacrifice from probably what is THE quintessential Star Trek movie and slide it into Abrams' return to the franchise. This time it would be Kirk saving the Enterprise from destruction at the cost of his own life rather than Spock, kicking the main reactor back into life.
This offered the chance to have hands separated by protective glass, Spock screaming for Khan and mirror key pieces of what many fans hold as the best of the classic crew movies but somehow manage to not quite hit the mark at any point. Kirk's death is a major blow to the crew but for the audience the very nature of the movie screamed "resurrection".
They didn't even keep Kirk dead to be brought back in a third movie, electing instead to have Spock chase Khan down across San Francisco to get a larger sample of his superblood. It had already revived a Tribble and lo and behold it was capable of bringing back James T. Luckily he had a year to recover before the Enterprise was recommissioned and stepped out on her first five year mission.
14. Seska - Worst Case Scenario
If only for the brilliance of the holodeck we got to see Seska chew up and spit out the Voyager crew one last time in the third season episode Worst Case Scenario.
Seska had already died in the retaking of the stranded starship back at the conclusion of the Kazon arc and Basics, Part II but death is just another hurdle to get over in the Star Trek universe.
The Cardassian spy had spent her time on Voyager more wisely than anyone, even Tuvok expected and led to one of the franchise's more unique holodeck adventures. Tuvok's Insurrection Alpha programme gave viewers the chance to see what might have happened if the Starfleet and Maquis crew hadn't set aside their differences. It also gave Seska a chance to have one final swing at Starfleet and Tuvok in particular by rewriting the programme into her own version of Hell on a Starship.
Ok, it's not an actual physical resurrection but it does show that even from beyond the grave the most scenery-chewing baddies can return. As a final note Seska did return in the flesh for the time shifting Shattered in the final season but not with quite the same impact!
13. Tom Paris - Threshold
What could be worse than reaching warp 10, being at every point in the universe, dying and then returning from the grave only to father lizard babies with the captain of your own ship?
If the answer is nothing then correct! Yes, that's Threshold and an episode that has had its very existence within Star Trek canon questioned over the last 25 years. Is this the story that went just that bit too far?
At its heart there's a good concept - as always - with the attempt to hit warp 10 as a way home. Yet as Paris mutates and slimes his way through the episode, shedding a tongue or some hair around the ship, the episode swings from Voyager High Concept to What Exactly Is Going On Here?
Nor does it stop, with Paris' demise being merely a breather before the real weirdness kicks in and the crew are off searching for space salamanders. In all honesty, this has to hold the top spot when it comes to most bizarre resurrection. Most characters tend to get to be reborn with very little to no ill effects but coming back as a scaly reptile isn't great. But in retrospect neither is it the most crackers part of the story.
12. Jean-Luc Picard- Star Trek: Picard
Oh, Jean-Luc. What have you become?
In a literal sense, an android. One of the numerous but possibly most serious accusations laid at the return of Jean-Luc Picard was that his death in the series finale was utterly ruined by the choice to transfer his essence into a golem.
Picard's irumodic syndrome had been mentioned before in All Good Things... with the new adventures of Jean-Luc acknowledging it almost from the first episode. Yet what fans might have expected - to see this develop over the next few seasons in the background - was all played out in season one.
The finale provided a great Star Trek moment in the meeting of Picard and Data one final time but left a bitter taste for many with the subsequent activation of robo-Picard. Now not only his heart is artificial and fans have been left to wonder if Jean-Luc is really Jean-Luc after the bold plot twist.
Also worth a mention is Q's intervention in Tapestry in which Picard is killed on an away mission and given the chance to alter his own past and avoid that heart replacement. After an Ebeneezer Scrooge "look what you could have won" view, Picard decides to stay the man he was and awakens in sickbay, most likely saved by Q.
11. Montgomery Scott - The Changeling
Y'cannae change the laws of physics but you can change the laws of biology if you're a sentient space probe.
When Nomad wipes Uhura's mind (which will be 100% recovered by the following episode), Scotty tries to intervene and finds himself dead on the bridge of the Enterprise. Curtains, finito.
Strangely, while recovering Uhura's entire memory, Starfleet career and communications expertise can't be achieved by the sentient space probe, returning the Enterprise's chief engineer to life is just one more job to tick off the "To Do" list. Uhura would be back at her station for the following episode with not a hint of PTSD or ongoing learning help and Scotty would be even more fine seconds after actually dying.
Resurrected quicker than you can say "It's green," Scotty would later be presumed dead for 75 years after the USS Jenolan crashed on the Dyson Sphere. He would later be recovered by the Enterprise-D after cleverly surviving in a transporter buffer. Somehow he seemed to forget that he was present when another Starfleet officer was killed in action with the distinct inclination that Kirk would have come and searched for him. Maybe this was just a bit of a delayed reaction or a bit of memory that didn't quite get saved in the buffer.
10. Worf - Hide And Q / Ethics
Heading for the record of most returns from death is the franchise's most seen character, Worf, with a trilogy of life-ending scenarios in TNG.
As far back as season one the writers were trying to find ways to kill Worf. While the first time they would resort to using aliens dressed in Napoleonic uniforms as part of a Q game (Note also that Wesley is killed during this scenario).
In season three's Transfigurations Worf is stopped dead by evolving alien John Doe and dies after being on the receiving of an energy blast that breaks his neck. Doctor Crusher confirms there's no pulse but having already demonstrated his growing powers, Doe revives the Klingon in a second. But that's not the last time Worf would end up throwing off the mortal coil.
In the powerfully written Ethics, Worf's career seems to be over after he suffers a crippling back injury leading him to question his place in the galaxy. Vying with what the future might hold, even contemplating suicide, Worf opts for radical spinal transplant surgery. But things only get worse and he dies on the operating table. However, while Spock had his backup eyelids in TOS, Worf maxes out on luck with annotomical redundancies that happens to kick in and reboot the Klingon's body.
9. Spock - Star Trek: The Wrath Of Khan
Gather the hankies ladies and gents, it's the big one.
Sure we'd seen crew die and come back in TOS but if ever there's a moment in Star Trek history that not only fans, but general movie audiences know, it's this one.
Faced with an impossible situation and with the needs of the many in the balance, Spock logically and calmly leaves the bridge of the limping Enterprise to initiate the necessary repairs in Engineering and save the ship from the imminent explosion of the Genesis Device.
Of course the ship is saved but with the sacrifice of her captain. The ending is full of mixed emotions and at the time, genuine disbelief that Spock had actually been killed. As fans know, the Kobayashi Maru scenario at the beginning was set in to add a red herring after news leaked about the demise of the Vulcan. 40 years on and it still kicks where it hurts.
But what would Star Trek be without Spock? A very different landscape and Nimoy couldn't stay away with both directing and acting duties on the sequel to The Wrath of Khan. At least its title kept his return a secret if nothing else... ?!
8. Trip Tucker - These Are The Voyages
Why include this one? Surely Trip died at the end of the final episode of Enterprise and therefore didn't come back?
Well, yes and no. Trip is a great example of where Alpha canon and Beta canon come into play (books, Online etc).
Killed off in the uneven and generally disliked These are the Voyages, Tucker's death was nearly as barely registered in impact as Tasha Yar's from Skin of Evil. But something bigger came out of it because Conner Trinneer's Chief Engineer did return... in the literary universe.
The expanded Star Trek footprint has offered up a lot of returns including Shatner's desire to resurrect Kirk. With Trip it's an occasion where something that canon Trek messed up a little to get fixed at least in one reality.
His return in the Rise of the Federation series intertwines with the work of Section 31 and paints up a much broader picture of Tucker than we ever got in the series. Tucker went on to become a key player during the Romulan Wars of the 2150's deep undercover once his mission to sabotage their development of the warp 7 engine was complete.
Eventually he would return to Federation space and continue working for Section 31 and recoup his relationship with T'Pol.
7. Tasha Yar - Yesterday's Enterprise
The most successful return of Denise Crosby to Star Trek was thanks to the death of Tasha Yar.
Killed off by the oil slick known as Armus, fans thought she'd be right back at it after a few hypos from Doctor Crusher but it wasn't to be.
The series moved on and aside from a reference to her in The Measure of a Man it looked like Tasha was gone for good. But not so.
The now-legendary appearance of the Enterprise-C into the TNG time period skews everything. The ship didn't save a Klingon outpost from Romulan attack and has led to the Federation and Klingons still being at war. Worf is, as you would expect, no longer on the Enterprise-D, and in his place is Tasha. Surprisingly, it's probably Yar's most expressive appearance and utilises the opportunity perfectly in what is one of the show's very finest hours.
Ultimately choosing to return with the crew of the Enterprise-C, Yar looks to make an impact on history rather than the "empty" death Guinan tells her about. Crosby would return thanks to this alternative timeline as Commander Sela the following year and would manage a further guest slot as Tasha Yar during the pre-Farpoint flashbacks of All Good Things...
6. Kirk - Amok Time / Ent Inc / Generations
As fake deaths go, James T Kirk is an absolute professional/prolific offender and needs to be thoroughly recognised for his efforts on this list.
Everyone else on here successfully managed to cheat actual death but that's, bizarrely, the only time he didn't (unless you're a fan of William Shatner's book series starting with The Return).
In Amok Time from TOS, Kirk gets slipped a sedative by McCoy and for all intents and purposes appears to be killed by Spock during the fight. As viewers will know, by the end it's uncovered to be a ruse and he lives to enunciate sentences badly for another day.
In The Enterprise Incident, Spock administers the Vulcan Death Grip to see off his captain and assist in his integration with the Romulans - but again it's all part of an elaborate plan and Kirk is very much alive although surgically altered.
Then in 1994's Star Trek Generations he's at it again, although to everyone in the 23rd Century this time he is actually dead. Snatched away from the USS Enterprise-B as he battled to save the ship, Kirk ended up in the utopia of the Nexus however on his exit with Picard it wasn't such a happy ending and definitely abridged.
5. The Borg Queen - Star Trek: First Contact
A death that defies space, time and possibly logic.
At the end of Star Trek First Contact, the Borg Queen was defeated. Her organic parts melted away and Picard defiantly snapped the twitching spinal column of the remaining cybernetic elements to rid the galaxy of the menace once and for all. Roll credits.
Skip forward in time and a couple of quadrants to Voyager's trip home and the Borg Queen is back. No explanation or real reason is given except that you need to think about it beyond the confines of human intelligence. Basically, just deal with it.
Played by Susanna Thompson for the majority of her appearances on Voyager, the Borg Queen was a constant thorn in the side of Janeway and Seven of Nine. Thompson would, ironically, survive her encounters with Voyager and First Contact's Alice Krige would return for series finale Endgame. That saw the Queen quite literally in pieces as the heavily upgraded Voyager made mincemeat of the Borg Hub. Krige was two for two.
Providing a face and a focal point to the Collective, fans have been left wondering if she'll be dropping by any time soon as part of the Picard spin off.
4. Weyoun - Repeatedly
A death that manufactured a key characteristic of the delicious Vorta meant that viewers got more Jeffery Combs in DS9.
The cloning of the Vorta was an unknown concept when First Omet'iklan vapourised Weyoun (Four) at the end of a joint mission with the crew of the Defiant to destroy an Iconian gateway protected by renegade Jem'Hadar (To The Death, DS9).
Proving their loyalty to the Founders and not to the Vorta granting their next vial of Ketracel-White, the Jem'Hadar had not even a flicker of hesitation in pulling the trigger and that was that.
Yet Weyoun would return again... and again... and again because of a very clever loophole built into the Vorta themselves. The fifth incarnation was killed in a mysterious transporter accident (which was probably engineered by Damar), Weyoun Six would be "defective" and escape from the Dominion to seek sanctuary from the Federation. Seven was killed by Worf when the Klingon and Ezri Dax were captured by the Dominion and Weyoun Eight, the final edition, would be shot by Garak during the final movements of the liberation of Cardassia.
This time though there was no escape from the finality of death as the facility that produced the Weyoun clones had been destroyed.
3. Kai Opaka - Battle Lines
Set up from DS9's pilot to be a key figure in the ongoing Bajoran storyline, the death of Kai Opaka Sulan came as a bit of a curveball especially so early in proceedings.
Lasting only a handful of episodes into the series and appearing in less than that, Camile Saviola's spiritual leader would meet her demise in a runabout crash and it seemed very clear cut.
But here's the twist. It turned out that the world on which the ship crashed is inhabited by two factions (Ennis and Noi-Ennis) who are constantly at war with each other. Nothing too interesting there however no-one ever really dies and they are dying and being brought back to life every single day to continue an endless and pointless battle thanks to nanotechnology.
Should the Kai leave the planet then she would be dead permanently, so she chooses to stay and kicks off one of DS9's most enthralling plot lines leading to the arrival of the wonderfully evil (Kai) Winn Adami.
Opaka would return fleetingly in the series as part of orb visions (The Collaborator and Assession) but there would never be further mention of the planet nor how she was from the end of Battle Lines to the conclusion of DS9.
2. Miles O'Brien - Visionary
How many times do you need to kill someone?
Miles Edward O'Brien is DS9's continual whipping boy. If something tragic needs to happen and someone has to suffer then the station's Chief of Operations has a ticket for the front of the queue.
Season three's Visionary takes that even further with the Chief skipping forward in time and seeing future events. Each time, Miles is able to skip back and change the course of the future, however it leads to another path where he ends up dead due to a concealed weapon in one of the station's corridors.
A further trip into the future reveals O'Brien has died due to the radiation buildup of the time-shifting, the next shows the station destroyed by an unknown force. Gradually building up a picture of events, the final jump reveals Romulan involvement and that a Warbird has been circling the station and is partially responsible for the timeshifting.
However, this "original" O'Brien is now too heavily irradiated and switches places with his "future" counterpart who returns to warn DS9 and avoid the Romulan attack. The audience can only assume that the first O'Brien is therefore killed in that alternate timeline while the "future" O'Brien takes his place.
1. Harry Kim - Deadlock
Even getting killed in the line of duty doesn't get Harry Kim an honorary promotion when he's spaced in Voyager's season two masterpiece Deadlock.
With the ship being bombarded with proton bursts seemingly from nowhere, Harry is sucked out into the cold vacuum of space while trying to seal a hull breach caused by the mysterious phenomena. Not only that, but this is a two for one episode with Ensign Wildman's baby also tragically dying minutes after birth.
What transpires is that Voyager has been duplicated and both ships are drawing power from the same antimatter source. Those proton bursts that were damaging the ship were in fact coming from the other Voyager attempting to fix the issue.
With the Vidiians closing in, the two crews pull together but only one ship can survive. In those last few moments before the organ-harvesting Phage-sufferers arrive, the less damaged Voyager's Kim and baby Wildman leap through onto the alternative ship.
The surprise that the damaged ship survives is only second to the fact that this episode manages to reverse two deaths within an hour. The deceased Harry's story would be continued through the Star Trek Online game where he was brought back to life by the Kobali, who were also responsible for saving Ensign Ballard as featured in Voyager's Ashes to Ashes.