20 Best Superhero TV Show Performances Ever

Daredevil's thunder was stolen in his own show thanks to Vincent D'Onofrio.

Daredevil Kingpin Vincent DOnofrio
Netflix

There may not be any genre in the current cinematic landscape as big or as lucrative as that of the superhero movie. Of course, the majority of this comes from the MCU, going strong since 2008, but there is also DC slate both inside and outside the confines of the DCEU, and contributions from Sony's Spider-Man universe, and the likes of Hellboy from Dark Horse Comics.

Naturally, this is where the money is for these brands, with each movie having the potential to make millions, even billions of dollars. But there are also many superhero successes on the small screen.

There is absolutely no shortage of incredible television based on superheroes from Marvel, DC, and beyond, and with them come a plethora of truly wonderful characters. Some simply found there was no room in the movies for them at a certain point, and so were 'relegated' to the small screen, and others had their time on the big screen and underwhelmed somewhat.

While this may be less lucrative, stretching a story over 13 episodes rather than one two hour movie allows for much more screen time and deeper character development, resulting in some of the best characters in the superhero genre living on the small screen.

20. Karl Urban As Billy Butcher

The Boys Karl Urban
Amazon Studios

The Boys isn't your typical superhero TV show. While it is based around those gifted with super human ability being marketed as heroes, they really couldn't be further from it. The true hero, or anti-hero, of the show is Billy Butcher, brought to life by Karl Urban.

Of the series' main cast, Urban is easily the most recognisable name, and thus had the pressure of some in the mainstream audience tuning in just because of his face on the adverts and trailers. To the surprise of no one, the Star Trek actor absolutely nailed his performance as Billy Butcher.

In the comics, Billy is a no nonsense, foul mouthed brute who takes in pleasure in being an active pain in the arse of any and all superheroes. This perfectly translates to the screen thanks to Urban, who can even show his softer side every now and then, with the incredibly rare compliment toward Hughie.

The only reason Urban doesn't climb any higher on this list is the accent. Homelander might comment that he loves Billy's accent, but anyone in the UK who knows what a proper English accent should sound like... not so much.


19. Robert Sheehan As Klaus Hargreeves

The Umbrella Academy Klaus
Netflix

Based on the comic book series of the same name, the Umbrella Academy was an absolute hit on Netflix, and while there are so many factors to consider, the characters themselves may well be the most important. Brought to life by Irish actor Robert Sheehan, Klaus Hargreeves is certainly the most entertaining member of the academy.

Number Four starts the story as a junkie with no respect for his siblings, and no intention of doing anything other than pawning his dead dad's things as a way to get high. In other words, pure comic relief.

As the series goes on however, Sheehan is able to add more and more layers into his character and his performance. After coming back from a year serving in the war and losing someone very close to him, Klaus is much more depressed and intense, yet still able to hold the comedy value that made him so loved in the first place.

Clearly, Sheehan's time as Nathan in Misfits held him in good stead to play another jokester with powers, only this time, he is able to delve much deeper into Klaus as a character.


18. Matt Ryan As John Constantine

John Constantine Legends Of Tomorrow
The CW

After Keanu Reeves' version of Constantine in 2005 left a lot to be desired, Matt Ryan was given the chance to reinvent the character in 2014 with a series of the same name. Instead of just one movie to explore the depths of John Constantine, and the lore behind him, Ryan was given an entire series.

Though the Welsh actor's performance deserved more than just 13 episodes, thankfully the character was brought back for more in a cameo in Arrow, a recurring role in Legends of Tomorrow, and an appearance in DC's mega crossover, Crisis on Infinite Earths.

Striking a tough balance between being a somewhat arrogant anti-hero, and a genuinely likeable protagonist, Ryan lends John Constantine not only the appearance pulled straight from the comics, but every personality trait that goes into making the character as complex and strangely endearing as he should be.


17. Tyler Hoechlin As Clark Kent/Superman

Superman Crisis On Infinite Earths
The CW

The DC properties across both TV and the movies can be incredibly confusing to follow, from the DCEU and the upcoming kind of sequel, kind of reboot of the Suicide Squad and where The Batman will stand, to having to keep up with a number of shows to fully understand Crisis on Infinite Earths. One thing that remains constant however, is the importance and legacy of Superman.

It is the biggest name in all of superhero lore, and with incredible portrayals from the likes of Brandon Routh, Christopher Reeve, and Henry Cavill before him, Tyler Hoechlin had his work cut out for him.

Through his few performances across the Arrowverse shows, the actor has portrayed the character in a reminscent light to that of Reeve, gaining incredible plaudits along the way. As something of a stark contrast to Henry Cavill's Man of Steel, Hoechlin's refreshing performance has seen not only the order of the Superman and Lois series, but also calls for the actor to replace Cavill's iteration in the DCEU.

While Hoechlin's version may not suit the gritty landscape of the DCEU, he has certainly created a version of the character that perfectly fits within the Arrowverse next to the character's cousin.


16. Melissa Benoist As Kara Danvers/Supergirl

Crisis On Infinite Earths Supergirl
The CW

No matter who was cast in the role as Kara Danvers, there would always be the tough and unenviable task of stepping out of the shadow cast by her cousin, Kal-El. Even after Tyler Hoechlin was brought into the series, Melissa Benoist never allowed herself or her character to be pushed to one side.

The actress is allowed to explore her wide range as both Kara and Supergirl, fighting two incredibly different fights, before and after suiting up. Remaining strong as an inspiration to everyone, with the ability to bring a tear to the eye of anyone watching with her words of hope, Melissa Benoist truly enables the Girl of Steel to stand shoulder to shoulder with her younger, more famous cousin.

Not only did Benoist put forward an incredible performance as Kara, she pulled double duty as the villainous Red Daughter. Through season four she was able to pull off playing a character either side of good and evil, showcasing her range as both a beacon of hope and an evil follower of Lex Luthor.


15. Dan Stevens As David Haller/Legion

Legion David Haller
FX

With the likes of The Boys and Gotham throwing genre stereotypes out the window, there may not be such a thing as a typical superhero TV show anymore, however Legion is possibly the strangest, most bizarre, and furthest from what may be considered traditional.

As David Haller, a man with often crippling mental struggles and almost limitless power, Dan Stevens is able to bring to life a character like none other on this list. He is able to balance every aspect of Haller's personality and what being so misunderstood can do to the mind.

He can seem scared to an almost child-like degree, before transitioning into intimidating, arrogant, or even unhinged and suicidal. As the son of Charles Xavier, naturally there would be a lot of eyes on Stevens' performance, which he handles with incredible commitment, while looking like he is having the time of his life.

A show this ambitious and off the wall needs to have a lead to embrace its differences and outlandishness, and in Dan Stevens, Legion couldn't have done any better.


14. Tom Welling As Clark Kent/Superman

Smallville Tom Welling
Warner Bros.

Tom Welling is the second iteration of Superman on this list, and easily the most experienced Man of Steel out of any of them. Over 218 episodes of Smallville, and a small cameo in Crisis on Infinite Earths, it's fair to say the actor had time to perfect his craft.

What sets the Smallville iteration apart may stem from the premise of a younger Clark Kent before donning the Superman mantle, however it is Welling's performance that makes it so different. His youth and naivety may play against the usual Superman type, but here it made for a compelling and complex character.

Though this was the initial story of Tom Welling's Clark Kent, the show was so successful its run went far beyond the young version of the character, eventually transitioning into the Man of Steel we all know and love.

While this may not have been what the showrunners had planned for Welling at the very beginning, he stepped up to the challenge and was able to portray a more traditional Superman just as well as when he had been trying to hide his powers back in the titular town.


13. Krysten Ritter As Jessica Jones

Jessica Jones Drink
Netflix

For the longest time, superheroes were looked at as these perfect beings and beacons of hope, justice and all that is good, like Superman or Captain America. Jessica Jones however, is not a typical superhero. She would reject the label entirely, but there is no denying the strength and power of her character.

Damaged by having her mind toyed with by Kilgrave years ago, and unable to ever forget what happened or trust that anyone's actions are truly their own, she takes to whiskey and keeping those she loves at arms length. Krysten Ritter captures the tragedy of the character perfectly.

Having been given license to explore the consequences and lasting damage of great personal trauma, Ritter portrays Jessica in a different light to any superhero before her, while staying true to the dark and gritty tone of the comics.

Despite the damage and the darkness surrounding the character, she is not without humour. Krysten Ritter has found a wonderful balance between the two aspects, and has become something of an expert in the delivery of Jessica's now trademark sarcasm and insults.


12. Adam West As Bruce Wayne/Batman

Adam West Batman
Warner Bros.

Over the years there have been so many different iterations of live action Bruce Wayne. From the traditional Batmen of Ben Affleck, Christian Bale, and Michael Keaton, to the iterations before and after Bruce Wayne in his prime from David Mazouz in Gotham, and Iain Glen in Titans. Before all of these however, came Adam West.

In a time when superhero TV shows and movies were years and years away from the kind of mainstream prominence they enjoy today, Batman was unique, and gained an incredibly following, even earning itself a movie in 1966. The majority of the appeal in truth came down to Adam West.

Compared to today's superhero properties, Batman was as campy as anything, obviously lacking CGI and any real budget, and nowhere near the grittier tone the dark knight takes on today. Through all this, and the often awful acting of those around him, West managed to maintain the overall feel of the show, while managing to give a genuinely compelling performance.

It would have been easy to phone in a performance when his character was being saved by noble porpoises and shark repellent spray, but Adam West gave his all to making a genuinely strong iteration of the character.


11. Alan Tudyk As Eric Morden/Mr. Nobody

Mr  Nobody
DC Universe

These days Alan Tudyk seems to have a role in just about everything, and certainly has more than enough experience with comic book properties. From his role as Joker in the animated Harley Quinn series, Oliver Queen in Young Justice, to Van Wayne in the short lived series about Bruce's cousin, Powerless.

In Doom Patrol, the actor portrays Mr. Nobody, an eccentric, narcissistic villain, unique in the fact that he is the narrator of the show. Whether he is on the screen or just voicing over, he is able to inject his own brand of fun and energy into every scene.

Coming up against the likes of Cliff Steele and The Chief, Tudyk is given license to have so much fun with the role, naturally translating into a show stealing performance. The actor simply oozes a winning combination of evil, charisma, and humour - everything you could ever want from a compelling villain.

Mr. Nobody on his own is one of the many good reasons to watch Doom Patrol.


10. Rosario Dawson As Claire Temple

Iron Fist Claire Temple
Myles Aronowitz/Netflix

Though the Netflix corner of the MCU existed on its own little island away from the movie side of the franchise, there was very little crossover initially between the shows. Daredevil, Jessica Jones, Luke Cage, and Iron Fist all came together for The Defenders, but before this the only link between the shows, and the person who ultimately brought them together, was Claire Temple.

From lending her voice to an animated Wonder Woman and a Lego Batgirl, to playing Nevada in Zombieland 2, among many, many others, Rosario Dawson is used to playing bad ass women. Claire is, of course, no different.

Though she could be seen as the Nick Fury of the Netflix corner after bringing the Defenders together, Dawson's Claire Temple is much more reminiscent of Natasha Romanoff, in that as a normal human being, she doesn't seem out of place next to a team of super humans.

Rosario Dawson lends her character empathy and concern, with the confidence and attitude to stand up to anyone, whether they have super powers or not, and it's no surprise her name has been mentioned in the same sentence as Jennifer Walters. Here's hoping her existing role in the MCU won't get in the way of her being cast in She-Hulk.


9. Stephen Amell As Oliver Queen/ Green Arrow

Green Arrow Oliver Queen
The CW

Over eight seasons and multiple crossovers into the other Arrowverse properties, there are few characters that have been on a journey quite the same as Oliver Queen. From a selfish billionaire with no concerns past his own well being to the saviour of the entire universe, Stephen Amell has walked us through every step of the way.

Without the actor's compelling performance as the titular character, there would be no Arrowverse, (it's only named after his character after all), none of the incredible characters that came with it, and no Crisis on Infinite Earths crossover.

Amell's gritty, almost grumpy take on the character suits the tone of the DC landscape, and particularly juxtaposed brilliantly when opposite the likes of Grant Gustin and Melissa Benoist, capturing the solemn and serious nature of a man who has been through the trials such as Oliver's.

The character's journey finally came to an end in Crisis on Infinite Earths, allowing Stephen Amell an emotional goodbye, not only from Oliver to his fellow heroes, but from the actor himself to his friends and colleagues. You can't help but get emotional and respect the commitment to the character and the performance.


8. Charlie Cox As Matt Murdoch/Daredevil

Daredevil Season 3 Prison Fight
Netflix

Some character reboots find themselves with incredibly big shoes to fill, making the task something close to impossible. Darevdevil however, did not. Ben Affleck's stint as the character is not looked back on fondly by anyone, and while this allowed Charlie Cox less pressure than he may have been under, it does highlight the complete gulf in quality of the two portrayals.

When portraying this particular character there are two very different sides to get right. The ruthless, ass-kicking vigilante, and the mild-mannered, religious lawyer, both while pretending to be blind. Charlie Cox truly brought both Daredevil and Matt Murdoch to life like never before.

Despite not fitting the usual light hearted tone of Marvel Studios' movies, Charlie Cox found a balance between dark and gritty, and the very occasional humour that sets him apart from the rest of the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

Similarly to Arrow in the world of DC, Daredevil launched the Netflix corner of the MCU, and became the mini universe's flagship show. If Charlie Cox hadn't impressed as much as he had, it's hard to imagine any of the other Netflix shows being greenlit and becoming ultimately as successful as they did.


7. Grant Gustin As Barry Allen/The Flash

Crisis On Infinite Earths The Flash Barry Allen
The CW

Next to Stephen Amell's broody Oliver Queen, Grant Gustin's Barry Allen is the other pillar of the Arrowverse, and the complete polar opposite of his green hooded colleague.

His charisma, boyish charm and good looks with nothing else would make for a wonderful depiction of Barry Allen, but the character goes so much deeper than handsome comic relief. The series couldn't have stood for so long if this was the case.

When the Flash first aired Gustin was just 24 years old, and we have seen him mature on screen along with his character, tackling deeper and tougher challenges, adding to the core of his performance that made him so loved in the first place.

Not only has Gustin portrayed the Flash for six years, like Melissa Benoist, he has dabbled in villainy. Season three saw a time travelling, evil Barry by the name of of Savitar, looking to protect his own existence. This, along with a hilarious experience as Oliver Queen in the Elseworlds crossover, are the icing on the cake of an incredible career for Gustin in the superhero world.


6. Tom Ellis As Lucifer Morningstar

Lucifer Weaponizer Scene21 JA0176 Hires2
Fox

It's not just Marvel that loves casting a good British actor. Since 2016, Tom Ellis has portrayed the titular character in Lucifer, and has helped to make the show as incredibly popular as it has become. Fans were outraged at the show seemingly coming to close after the upcoming season five, but with Ellis reportedly happy to continue further, we may yet get our wish for more Lucfier.

Every aspect of the character is played to perfection by the incredibly charismatic Tom Ellis. The work hard, play hard womanizer, the surprisingly gentle, sensitive being, and the demon of horrific punishments and unparalleled evil are all balanced beautifully, topped off with the kind of haunting English accent that spells both class and often villainy.

It is no surprise fans were delighted at the Devil's cameo during Crisis on Infinite Earths, and if there was just one down side to come from it, it's that we're left wanting to see more of Lucifer and Constantine opposite each other. Is a Matt Ryan cameo in a future episode of Lucifer too much to ask?


5. Hayley Attwell As Peggy Carter

Agent Carter Pilot Peggy E1420980473715
Marvel Studios

Though the future of the MCU will see the movies and the shows on Disney+ intertwine, any crossover between them in the past has been minimal. One character that was able to bridge the gap however, was Peggy Carter. After her appearance as one of the highlights of Captain America: The First Avenger, she was given her own TV series.

In the movies, Hayley Attwell brings to life an incredible, strong, simply bad-ass character, and her own show saw no change in that whatsoever. After all, Peggy was the woman that inspired Steve Rogers himself.

In Agent Carter, Hayley Attwell's performance does evolve somewhat, as she is dealing with the apparent death of Steve Rogers, on top of everything else she has to come up against.

Because of her looks and the fact that she is a woman, Peggy Carter is always underestimated by those around her, which is something she has had to deal with all her life. This gives Attwell the license to lend Peggy a little arrogance and self-satisfaction, which she manages with class, grace, and a mean right hook.


4. Jon Bernthal As Frank Castle/The Punisher

A blood-stained Jon Bernthal stalks the streets in The Punisher
Marvel Television

So many men came before Jon Bernthal's portrayal of Frank Castle, and Thomas Jane, Dolph Lundgren, and Ray Stevenson all left something to be desired. It seemed impossible to bring the character to life and do him justice, so naturally there was some skepticism regarding yet another iteration for Daredevil in the MCU.

However, the character ended up being the single best thing about the show's second season. Not only did the Walking Dead actor have the look down to begin with, he nailed the gruff voice and tone, the no nonsense attitude, and the absolutely ruthless aggression.

Of course, this doesn't paint the full picture of the Punisher as a character. Jon Bernthal had to show off his softer side too, the love he had for his family, and how much he cared about innocent characters like Micro's son. He was a ruthless killer, but he was also a great father and husband, and this iteration captured both the Punisher, and Frank Castle, incredibly well.

It is no surprise that The Punisher was commissioned off the back of Bernthal's performance in Daredevil, and though his own series wasn't quite as captivating as it could have been, the fault certainly doesn't fall at the actor's door. If the MCU decides to re-introduce the character in the future, it will be hard see anyone else take on the mantle after such a show stopping performance.


3. David Tennant As Kilgrave

Kilgrave JJ
Netflix

The Marvel Cinematic Universe does seem to have something of an obsession with British actors, and it's really not hard to see why. Though many, like Benedict Cumberbatch, Martin Freeman, and Charlie Cox put on an American accent for their roles, the likes of Tom Hiddleston and David Tennant don't. This almost automatically makes them compelling villains.

The latter's performance as Kilgrave in the first season of Jessica Jones, much like Frank Castle in Daredevil, absolutely stole the show.

The way the series opened, simply speaking of Kilgrave rather than seeing him for the first couple episodes, built a huge amount of expectation for David Tennant's character. He delivered, and then some. The character was portrayed as positively evil, intimidating, and without remorse, making viewers genuinely uncomfortable at the thought of him.

With any good villain however, this wasn't the only aspect to the complex character. David Tennant was actually able to make us feel sorry for the man who controlled people's minds, and even injected a great amount of humour into the role.


2. Vincent D'Onofrio As Wilson Fisk

Wilson Fisk
Netflix

Some characters you just never known how they'll translate from the page to the screen. Daredevil and Spider-Man villain, Kingpin, ought to have been a struggle, since in the source material he is usually depicted to be about ten feet tall and eight feet wide. Somehow though, this iteration worked incredibly well.

This comes down to Vincent D'Onofrio's chilling performance as the man known as Wilson Fisk. Again, as with David Tennant's Kilgrave, we are made to wait to see the villain of the series, and D'Onofrio is no disappointment.

Clearly an intelligent, tasteful man, with pride in his work and his business, there is an underlying anger bubbling away inside. This is ever present throughout every episode the character appears in, and it is a testament to the actor's performance that it seems to be instilled almost effortlessly.

As physically dominant as the man can be, he is even more feared thanks to his words and general presence in a room. He doesn't need to swing any fists to be intimidating, but when he does, there is a terrifying intensity that is genuinely quite jarring.


1. Aiden Gallagher As Number Five

The Umbrella Academy
Netflix

The Umbrella Academy is full of bizarre characters, from the monkey man who was sent to the moon, to the woman who can make anything she says come true, and the talking ape. The weirdest by far, and unquestioned best character of the series, is Number Five.

As a child, Number Five decided to dabble in time travel. After living in the future for a few decades, he and his 58 year old mind were shot back in time, settling in his 13 year old body and resulting in one of the most unique comic book characters on TV.

Aiden Gallagher, as a 17 year old at the time, had the mammoth task of portraying a wise, well-traveled, 58 year old man, and he couldn't have done it any better. The young actor put in an excellent performance beyond his years as a more than believable old man in a young body. As believable as that gets, anyway.

From needing his fix of coffee, hunting down assassins, and having to put up with his younger siblings and their squabbles, Gallagher truly embodied the greatest and most compelling of Reginald Hargreeves' seven children.


In this post: 
Daredevil
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

This standard nerd combines the looks of Shaggy with the brains of Scooby, has an unhealthy obsession with the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and is a firm believer that Alter Bridge are the greatest band in the world.