20 Greatest Ever Superhero TV Shows

Who said superheroes work better on the big screen?

It's not even up for debate at this point -- we are currently living in an era where the geek is king. Let's take the 2014-2015 television season for example. This year alone, we're being treated to more superhero and comic book shows than we know what to do with. We've got a Green Arrow adaptation, a new version of the Flash, a program about the SHIELD organization from the Marvel universe, and a gritty prequel to Batman. And there are countless more in the works, to be trotted out within the next few years. All this would have been unthinkable just a few short years ago. Back in the 90s, for example, studios were unsure whether or not superhero films, typically being pretty expensive, would be able to make a return on their investment. Now they can't churn them out fast enough -- the Marvel and DC film release schedules are announced years in advance. While these types of shows have always had their own niche audiences, we've never seen so many of them in mainstream culture before, either on television or in the movie theaters. So as we experience this incredibly nerdy golden age, it would seem a bit ungrateful and churlish of us not to celebrate the shows that have paved the way for this success and cemented their place in popular culture. Without them, we surely wouldn't be here today.

20. Arrow

The Green Arrow, like many other DC superheroes, is more than a little bit campy. But in the CW adaption of the comic book figure, he takes on a much more stoic, grounded turn. This is a key example of Nolan's influence on the genre, and you can see elements of Bale's Batman in his character. To be fair, they are relatively similar in general -- a pair of billionaires who experience life changing events after the death of a parent and turn themselves into a walking weapon without actually having any superpowers. Also, there's a lot of brooding. But Arrow takes pains to make itself feel like something in the real world, albeit a particularly gritty and film noir-esque version of the real world. It focuses more on the relationships between people, and the damage that everyday people can do. For most of the first season, he's not fighting supervillains who are threatening to unleash a radioactive monster on Starling City, he's combating the corruption and apathy that plagues his hometown. Stephen Amell is surprisingly good in the lead role of Arrow, managing to bring a lot of emotion and empathy to a character that could be just another one note superhero.

19. The Tick

What is there not to love about The Tick? It starred Patrick Warburton and featured the tagline, "The big blue bug of justice is here!". In 2001, Fox gave us a live action version of the popular comics, created by the same producer who had worked on the animated series of the early 90s. Although the show was genuinely hilarious, Fox didn't do a great job of promoting it (we are Jack's complete lack of surprise), and high production costs led it to be cancelled after only a single series of nine episodes. But there may be a happy ending for The Tick after all -- recently there have been whispers that Amazon plans to revive the series, with Warburton again taking on the lead role.

18. Chuck

Chuck was just a poor, unassuming Buy More employee, until his ex-best friend sent him a computer program which downloaded the entire CIA/NSA database into his head, allowing him to flash on any bad guys he might happen to interact with (there are a surprising amount of bad guys in Burbank, it seems). Throughout the run of the show, he saved the world any number of times, with his crack team of handlers, the clever and athletic CIA agent Sarah Walker and the stoic NSA agent Colonel Casey. As the series went on, he became an agent in his own right, especially once he got an upgrade that would download any skill into his brain when needed, and fans worried that he would lose the adorable geekiness that made him such an engaging hero. But while the show undeniably got darker towards the end, he was still the same Chuck Bartowski at heart.

17. Misfits

What would happen if the kids who steal from convenience stores and get busted for drugs were the ones who got superpowers, instead of the righteous men with strong jaw lines? Well, Misfits answers that question. It's the story of a group of ASBO-wielding teenagers who get struck by lightning during a freak storm while doing community service, and develop strange powers. They range in quality from the bizarre and dangerous (being a rape magnet does not seem like a good superpower, and we're not too keen on the ability to turn into a rage-filled psychopath, like the first probation worker) to the old classics like mind-reading, invisibility, and immortality. While they're not exactly saving the world on a large scale, they've been known to take down the occasional baddie they cross paths with, and sometimes even verge into real hero territory, especially in the case of Superhoodie.

16. Mighty Morphin Power Rangers

Mighty Morphin Power Rangers is one of those shows that does literally everything wrong and still manages to be a hit. You've got a kid's action program that borrows liberally from notoriously low budget Japanese shows (there are entire action sequences that have been ripped off, and the awful dubbing is a sight to behold). It has cheesy dialogue, seriously questionable special effects, and ever so slightly racist undertones with the Black Ranger being African-American and the Yellow Ranger being Asian. But we still loved it. From a commercial standpoint, it was a merchandising dream, with different colors and personalities that could be marketed to all different types of kids. But more importantly, it proved that a show doesn't necessarily have to be good to be fun. Would the current crop of twenty-somethings have developed their highly attuned sense of snark and enjoyment of all things super low budget without the Power Rangers? The world may never know.

15. Hong Kong Phooey

Hong Kong Phooey is without a doubt one of the most underrated superhero shows of all time. It was created in 1974 by Hanna Barbera, in an attempt to capitalize on the martial arts trend that had become popular at the time, and starred Scatman Crothers (a famous jazz vocalist who you may also recognize as Dick Hallorann from The Shining or the voice of Scat Cat in The Aristocats) as Penrod "Penry" Pooch. He was a clumsy, mild-mannered janitor at a police station, but at the first sign of trouble, he would dive into his filing cabinet and transform as Hong Kong Phooey. Despite his superhero identity, he frequently relied on his friend Spot the cat, who would get him out of the scrapes he would inevitably find himself mixed up in. Sure, the show only aired for one year, and yeah, there's something vaguely racist about the whole thing, but it remains a wonderful little vintage show that a lot of people have completely forgotten about.

14. The Powerpuff Girls

It's amazing how a show like The Powerpuff Girls can be both an adorable kid's show and an intelligent, satirical program that tackles larger issues of traditional gender roles and the superhero genre. A genius scientist is attempting to create the perfect little girl (where did he get the funding for that?) when he accidentally adds a mysterious, unstable ingredient, and out pop the Powerpuff Girls. These three adorable little girls who also happen to have superpowers, and when they're not spending their time dealing with regular kid problems, they're taking on the baddies who constantly threaten their town. Despite the fact that they're just three little kids on a Cartoon Network animated program, Bubbles, Blossom, and Buttercup somehow manage to be better examples of well-rounded female characters than half of the women roles written for serious, adult television. That's pretty impressive, and definitely worth a nod on our list.

13. Teen Titans

Teen Titans takes several superheros that we're more or less familiar with from the comic book world and puts their teenage selves together as a crime-fighting unit. This sounds like it had the potential to be incredibly lame, but hear us it -- it's actually not. You've got a young Robin leading the pack, which consists of Cyborg, Beast Boy, Starfire, and Raven. They're all figures who have appeared as various incarnations in different comic books. Cyborg, for example, was featured in the Titans series, then the Teen Titans, before being established as one of the founding members of the Justice League. Despite the fact that the show is aimed at kids and revolves around a group of angsty teenagers, it actually has a remarkable amount of depth and humor that makes it one of the most underrated superhero shows.

12. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles

Whatever drug-addled mind produced the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, we owe them a debt of gratitude. They're a bunch of turtles with superpowers, a serious pizza addiction, California surfer stereotype accents, and the names of several prominent Renaissance artists. Any producer who couldn't see that this was going to be a huge hit was clearly a blind idiot. In all seriousness, you never know what sort of weird thing is going to catch on, and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles was a bit like catching lightning in a bottle. No one can really explain why it's so awesome, and you couldn't replicate it if you tried (as the most recent film adaptation of the show can attest to). But you've got Uncle Phil from the Fresh Prince of Bel Air as the bad guy, and that goes a long way.

11. Alphas

So, this show is sort of what happens when you combine the traditional superhero show with the procedural cop/detective drama that has been flooding our airwaves for the past twenty years or so. Essentially, Alphas is about a group of people with superhuman abilities, who all work for a branch of the Defense Criminal Investigative Service, where they help track down other "Alphas" who are using their abilities for nefarious purposes. They have a wide range of powers, which is appealing as they're different from what we normally see from superheroes. There's no flying, no super strength, no invisible jets. You've got a guy who can see electromagnetic waves, a girl who can amplify any one of her senses, a girl with super power of persuasion, things like that. But what's really interesting about the show is that you also see the crippling side effects of these powers, which gives them an added sense of humanity.

10. Underdog

There's no need to fear -- Underdog is here! With one simple catchphrase, the adorably awesome Underdog sprinted out of a telephone booth and into our hearts. He was an unassuming shoeshine boy (appropriately named "Shoeshine Boy") by day, but as soon as trouble appeared, he transformed into the crimefighting superhero, Underdog. This popular cartoon aired on NBC from 1964 to 1973 (although original production ceased in 1967), and was introduced to a whole new generation of fans on Nickelodeon in the early 1990s. We loved his penchant for verse, and his surprisingly self aware nature. For example, Underdog was one of the very few shows to address the massive property damage caused by superheroes. When questioned about it, Underdog would wave criticisms aside, saying, "I am a hero who never fails; I cannot be bothered with such details."

9. Spider-Man

One of the biggest things that makes people like Spider-Man is his sense of humor. There are other superheroes who make wise cracks here and there, but Peter Parker is just on an entirely different level. He's basically just one giant ball of snark. We see that side of his character more in the newer movies with Andrew Garfield than the ones with Tobey Maguire (no matter how hard we try, we can never forget the line, "It's you who's out, Gobby -- out of your mind!"). But one of the best parts of Spider-Man cartoon from the early 1990s was how well they portray his character. Not just the guy in spandex, but the very unique personality behind the mask. Unlike many other superheroes, Peter Parker has never been what you might call stoic. He's a complete and utter smart ass, and he can't resist the urge to spout one-liners whenever half a chance presents itself. The cartoon creates a version of his character that's rarely seen outside of the comic books, and for that reason Spider-Man deserves a spot on the list.

8. Buffy The Vampire Slayer

Buffy the Vampire Slayer isn't a conventional superhero story. Buffy doesn't wear a costume or mask, her villains are supernatural, and she didn't get her start in the pages of a comic book. But she fits all the criteria for a superhero. She has special powers that were granted to her through a mystical, sacred birthright. She has to hide her identity from the rest of the world, except for a small, dedicated group of friends who are affectionately referred to as the Scooby Gang. And she spends most of her time fighting against the forces of darkness. While a lot of superheroes are plucky outsiders when shown in high school (probably due to their writers working out issues about their own adolescence), Joss Whedon takes Buffy in a different direction. She's a beautiful blond cheerleader, who would probably be the most popular girl in school if she didn't keep getting into weird unexplainable hijinks week after week.

7. Wonder Woman

Once upon a time, female superheros were exclusively used as a sidekick to their more successful male counterparts. You've got Superman, so you get Supergirl too. There's Batman, so there's also Batgirl. While they're strong figures in their own right, they don't have a distinct identity. That's why Wonder Woman is so revolutionary. She's a female superhero who isn't reliant on a male franchise -- she has her own canon, her own unique set of powers, and her own mythology. Lynda Carter owned the role, and it's a testament to her ability that the many proposed reboots have failed, unable to stand up to the quality of the original.

6. The Incredible Hulk

Lou Ferrigno. Gallons of green makeup. One pair of strangely indestructible shorts. What's not to love? Lou Ferrigno (and Bill Brixby, to be fair -- he's the one who played Bruce Banner, after all) was not the first incarnation of the giant green superhero with lots of pent-up aggression, but he is arguably the most recognizable. Over the years, Hollywood has struggled to build a film franchise out of the Hulk. The 2002 film may have been psychologically interesting, but it failed to engage audiences, and the 2008 adaptation with Edward Norton made money but left the fanboys cold. In recent years, he's only really worked as part of a larger ensemble, like when he appeared in The Avengers. Could that be because they're struggling to live up to the iconic 1978 series? Well...probably.

5. He-Man And The Masters Of The Universe

He-Man and Skeletor, the original Ambiguously Gay Duo. Complete with a resplendent blond page boy haircut and rippling muscles that would put Arnold Schwarzenegger to shame, He-Man was an icon of mid-1980s cartoon television. Unlike many other superheroes, whose humble origins are frequently a key point in their characterization, He-Man is actually a prince named Adam, who accesses his powers by brandishing a sword and invoking the name of Greyskull. Originally designed as an action figure line meant to capitalize on the success of Star Wars, He-Man (and its spinoff, She-Ra) captured the minds of kids everywhere, and have been seen in a number of different types of media over the past thirty years. It's easy to make fun of him now, with the S+M costume and everything that goes along with it, but he is nonetheless a beloved superhero who shouldn't be overlooked.

4. Smallville

Smallville is the forefather for the rush of superhero shows that have been hitting television over the past couple years. It's strange to think of how different the entertainment landscape was back when Smallville first came on the air. Now, superheroes are a beloved quantity by everyone, not just comic nerds, but back then the producers of Smallville had to tread lightly. They were quick to assure people that this was not going to be some goofy show about a man flying around in spandex, it was going to deal with the day to day life of a young Clark Kent (the geeky outcast played by former underwear model Tom Welling in a particularly impressive example of Hollywood Nerd casting). "No tights, no flights" was their mantra, presumably because they assumed that they wouldn't be able to maintain mainstream viewers if they overtly used the more fantasy elements of Superman canon.

3. The Greatest American Hero

How much fun is this show? The Greatest American Hero is the story of a single father who works at a particularly rough high school, and is given a special spandex suit that imbues the wearer with super strength and the ability to fly. Only problem is, he lost the manual, and has no idea how to make the suit work. Crazy hijinks ensue, with the suit's rather intimidating learning curve, and he helps the world in a rather haphazard way. Honestly, the show earns it's place on this list through the sheer catchiness of its theme song alone. They don't make them like that anymore. Ralph Hinkley is an endearing hero, one who doesn't take himself too seriously but still manages to get the job done. A show with such a simple premise shouldn't have been able to stay interesting for several seasons, but it somehow managed it, and only faltered towards the end when he actually became adept at using the suit.

2. X-Men

Out of all the superhero franchises, X-Men has always been the most willing to tackle complex social issues. With such a large ensemble of characters, it makes sense that they would be in the best position to have the mutants address a variety of problems. With the mutants in the show consistently being treated with mistrust and hostility, it's easy to see themes of prejudice and intolerance that we deal with in our own society. The great thing about the X-Men television show was that it was able to have so many different types of story lines, and they handled all of them incredibly well, especially considering that this show was primarily meant for children. It never felt the same from week to week, with the focus shifting to put different members of the X-Men team in the spotlight, each one engaging and interesting enough to carry their own stories.

1. Batman: The Animated Series

Batman: The Animated Series was one of the first shows that proved that cartoons about superheroes could be more complex and nuanced than your average Saturday morning fare. Despite the fact that it is an animated program, it's darker and more noir-ish than you might expect. While the original Batman television series was gleefully campy, the animated series from the early 90s had a surprising amount of gravitas. It's clear that Nolan's gritty interpretation of Batman owes a debt of gratitude to this version, which undoubtedly served as an inspiration on some level. It's consistently ranked among the greatest animated series of all time, and represents one of the most interesting and faithful adaption of the popular superhero and his revolving door of villains.

In this post: 
Smallville
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Audrey Fox is an ex-film student, which means that she prefers to spend her days in the dark, watching movies and pondering the director's use of diegetic sound. She currently works as an entertainment writer, joyfully rambling about all things film and television related. Add her on Twitter at @audonamission and check out her film blog at 1001moviesandbeyond.com.