20 Things Doctor Who Wants You To Forget
Because there are just a few things that the Doctor and his creators are not at all proud of.
The Doctor once said that forgetfulness is a human superpower. It’s a gift that he envies because the benefits (making more babies) outweigh the negatives (making more wars). There are many things that he would love to be able to banish from his own memory, so much so that the best man at his (next) wedding, would have a field day.
In that respect, the Doctor is as human as the rest of us. And so too are those who make the show. Poor creative decisions, continuity errors, and other missteps and blunders can be erased and yet also repeated through the sweet convenience of forgetfulness.
Making the same mistakes is a price worth paying for making more Doctor Who, but just sometimes, things do go so terribly wrong that our superpower is tested to its very limits.
There are some things that the Doctor and the makers of the show would like to forget themselves, but unfortunately once they are out in the open, there’s no going back.
Read on if you dare, but when you’re done you might want to follow Amy Pond’s lead in The Beast Below and press the button marked FORGET…
20. I've Made A Terrible Mistake
This Christmas the Doctor will be coming face to face with an actual superhero in The Return of Doctor Mysterio. All will probably not be as it seems, but the contrast between the kind of hero the Doctor is and the superheroes of the American comic-books, will almost certainly be explored in one way or another.
The Doctor is a fallible hero, one who according to Steven Moffat wrestles with and overcomes his weaknesses. But in truth there have only been a few occasions in which he has got things so spectacularly wrong that he has made an already bad situation 1,000 times worse. In The Horror of Fang-Rock he unwittingly locks the enemy inside the lighthouse and almost everybody ends up dead as a result. The usually controlling Fourth Doctor cries out in anguish, ‘I’ve made a terrible mistake.’
In The God Complex the Eleventh Doctor encourages Rita to turn to her faith with confronting the Minotaur, only to realise that the creature was feeding off faith and not fear. It is tempting to see the character’s eagerness to run into danger as a way of running away from himself.
19. How To Open The TARDIS
The Doctor’s TARDIS has had many facelifts even to her exterior, but St John’s ambulance badge or not, the doors have almost always been opened the wrong way – inwards. The TARDIS herself flags up the error in an in-house joke penned by Neil Gaiman. The Doctor responds indignantly: ‘I think I have earned the right to open my front door any way I like.’
That would be fine, a nice little nod to the Doctor’s non-conformity, were it not for the fact that occasionally he and his creators forget or ignore his preference.
The doors open outwards in The Eleventh Hour, in an infamous Piper and Eccleston publicity shot, and in Matt Smith’s title credits. The TARDIS once even had a back door that opened outwards (The Abominable Snowmen).
Coupled with the ever changing design of the TARDIS key and River Song's surprising suggestion that the wheezing groaning sound is down to the Doctor not properly applying the brake (a mistake which is therefore also repeated by the Master and the Rani among others), it's probably best not to take as gospel any fact about the Doctor's remarkable ship.
18. Exactly How Old Was She?
The concept of a complete stranger taking usually young girls to travel the universe, inside a box that masquerades as police property, is in itself a little bit concerning. Motivation for countless adult parodies, the show has always been aware of the awkwardness of its central premise right from the very first episode when Susan Foreman’s teachers were concerned for her welfare.
The Doctor’s latest companion was even more explicit. Clara nicknamed the TARDIS the snog-box, and questioned the Doctor’s motivations for seeking a ‘companion’ (The Bells of Saint John).
Occasionally the age of the companion is quite troubling. The Doctor promised to come back for Amelia Pond, when she was only seven. Thankfully he got the dates wrong on that occasion and Amy Pond is the grand old age of 19 when she finally gets to join him. But the character notes for the Second Doctor’s companion, Zoe Herriot, described her as a child-genius, aged 14. Fortunately, this was not stated on-screen and in the officially licenced audio adventures, her age when meeting the Doctor was upped to 16 (the same age as Ace when she started travelling with the Seventh Doctor).
17. Invasion Of The Nortons
The British TV presenter, Graham Norton, may have helped to promote Doctor Who in recent years (even playing himself in a special Doctor Who sketch written for the National Television Awards 2011), but he has also made two appearances that caused quite an outrage.
Shortly after the opening credits rolled for the first time on the resurrected show, due to a technical fault Norton could be heard hosting Strictly Dance Fever, spoiling the creepy mood for Billie Piper’s opening scene.
Fans could just about forgive that error, but the deliberate overlay of an animated, gurning Norton during the Time of Angels cliff-hanger incensed over 5,000 fans - enough for them to write in to complain. Norton took it all with great humour, apologising in his chat show as another animation rolled - a Dalek exterminating his cartoon alter-ego. Norton might still be a valuable asset when it comes to marketing the show, but let’s hope his cartoon avatar has been banished for life.
16. Leaving His Granddaughter With A Man She Barely Knows
The first companion to leave Doctor Who was his granddaughter Susan, and although the Doctor gives a lovely speech about going forward in all your dreams, it still feels a touch irresponsible of him to just leave her with David Campbell at the end of The Dalek Invasion of Earth.
It wasn’t the last time he’d do this of course – he makes no effort to stop Leela from inexplicably settling down with the chancellery guard Andred in The Invasion of Time. And dear old Peri – fixed up with Yrcanos? At least when Jo Grant decided to hook up with Clifford Jones he went off on a sulk.
The Doctor is rubbish when it comes to saying goodbye and knowing when it’s time to go. He seemed genuinely shocked when Tegan said it had stopped being fun, he left Sarah without even checking she was in the right location, and after gifting Amy and Rory with a house, knowing they’d be better off without him, he still couldn’t keep away.
15. The Other First Doctor
The Five Doctors is many a Doctor Who fan’s guilty pleasure, we forgive its weaknesses because of its ambition. Take for instance, Richard Hurndall’s fondly remembered performance as the First Doctor. Hurndall may have fooled the general audience, but in reality, apart from sharing a similar surname he was nothing like Hartnell’s original first Doctor.
Even the unmarketable figurine that Borusa plays with to show that the First Doctor has entered the death zone is a more realistic representation. But for ninety minutes in 1983 even the diehard fan was expected to forget the ‘original you might say’, despite the archive footage in the pre-credits sequence.
Whatever next – publicity stills with a stand-in Madam Tussauds Fourth Doctor? Ridiculous.
14. The Gentle Art Of Fisticuffs
He might like us to all think that he abhors violence, but the Doctor harbours a secret love of hand to hand combat, even if he rarely gets to use it. After fending off an assassin in The Romans the First Doctor describes such combat as a delight and a satisfaction. Both the Fourth and Seventh Doctors chose companions who wouldn’t be afraid to kill their opponents, whether with a Janus thorn (Leela) or some nitro-nine explosives (Ace). He might show disapproval of their methods, but when needs must he is prepared to let them break his rules.
On occasion the Doctor’s claim that he only uses violence in self-defence is tenuous. Whether it be cracking the skull of an already injured caveman (An Unearthly Child), paralysing Stahlman for life and boasting about it (Inferno), shooting an Ogron (Day of the Daleks), poisoning Shockeye with chloroform (The Two Doctors), causing two guards to fall into an acid pit (Vengeance on Varos), or forcing a Time Lord general to regenerate (Hell Bent), the Doctor can take things too far.
13. The Other Ninth Doctor
Following the unsuccessful 1996 relaunch (The TV movie) Doctor Who remained off our screens for another nine years, but that didn’t stop talented fans from creating new adventures and exploring new ways to continue the myth. Perhaps the boldest and riskiest of all was the flash animation, The Scream of the Shalka.
Officially released through the BBC’s flagship website, Paul Cornell’s fine script was written for a new Doctor – played by Richard E Grant. His stint in the TARDIS was limited to a single adventure (and as an unrelated Doctor in the comic relief sketch, The Curse of Fatal Death). When Shalka was released, advanced discussions for a television comeback were already taking place with Russell T Davies, and the poor old ‘Reg’ Doctor as fans affectionately came to know him, was quietly ditched from the counting system.
In theory the producers could have made Eccleston the Tenth Doctor, especially with Derek Jacobi playing the Master in both Shalka and Utopia, but instead Richard E Grant is completely stripped of his association with the character when Steven Moffat recasts him as the host for the Great Intelligence.
12. Are You My Mummy?
The one thing that the Doctor is most reticent to talk about is his family. The Second Doctor admits to Victoria that he does not really want to remember them, instead he lets them ‘sleep in (his) mind.’ The memories are clearly too painful for the Doctor as we later learn when Donna asks him why he never mentions his children: ‘when they died, that part of me died with them. It’ll never come back. Not now.’
Aside from his granddaughter, Susan, the only other member of the Doctor’s family to have appeared in the show is his mother, played by Claire Bloom in The End of Time. She is only credited as the ‘woman in white’ but in his book, The Writer’s Tale, Russell T Davies confirms that she was meant to be the Doctor’s mother. She is never referenced again, but in Hell Bent the Doctor arrives at the barn where he once slept as a child (Listen) and meets an old woman he recognises who is caring for ‘the boys’.
Steven Moffat says he has no idea who the woman is, leaving it to fans to speculate as to whether she and the woman in white are one and the same – the Doctor’s mother. The Eighth Doctor said he was ‘half-human, on his mother’s side’, but apart from that we know nothing about her or any of his family. And that’s the way he (and it seems the show’s producers) would like it to stay.
11. A Fix With Sontarans
Colin Baker once said that ‘Jimmy Savile is much more frightening than the Sontarans.’ At the time it might have been a joke. Not anymore. Back in 1986 when eight year old Gareth Jenkins got to star alongside the Sixth Doctor in a specially written sketch, almost every young Doctor Who fan was deeply envious. It was a fun script, but even at the time it went downhill once Savile entered the TARDIS.
It had been available on the BBC worldwide DVD release of The Two Doctors, but following the posthumous reports of Savile’s sexual abuses the disk was re-pressed minus that particular extra. Ironically, Jones went on to be a campaign manager for Save the Children, but sadly, few will now even want to see his brief moment of fame.
10. The Destroyer Of Worlds
In Journey’s End, Davros might have been furious (not to mention just a tad hypocritical) with the Doctor for turning the reality bomb against the Daleks, but he had a point when he accused him of being the destroyer of worlds.
Technically this time it wasn’t the Doctor but his human/Time Lord double, and the Doctor ‘punishes’ his genocidal blue-suited clone by banishing him to the alternate earth (for a life of misery with Rose Tyler!).
The Doctor sometimes regrets the trail of devastation left in his wake, with his Fifth incarnation saying ‘there should have been another way.’ But sometimes he acts without a hint of conscience, most notably when he tricks the Daleks into blowing up Skaro (Remembrance of the Daleks) and when he revels in wiping out the Silence (Day of the Moon).
9. Name That Tune In One
Ask any non-fan to hum the Doctor Who theme tune and nine times out of ten it would be instantly recognisable. That’s not to say that Delia Derbyshire and Ron Grainger’s haunting original melody hasn’t been through various make overs over the last fifty three years. The first major update came in 1980, complete with a radically new title sequence, but prior to this, in 1972 a monstrous perversion of the classic tune was created. It was all thanks to the latest toy - the Delaware synthesizer, with its characteristic tinny Jew’s harp sound.
The update ought to have worked out, given that Derbyshire was involved, but the result was aptly described by Gavin Fuller in the Telegraph as sounding like ‘martians on drugs’. BBC executives stepped in just in time to stop this version from being broadcast in the UK. However, a couple of episodes were mistakenly sold to Australia still containing the abandoned theme.
Unable to complete erase it from history, BBC worldwide decided they may as well use it as a DVD extra (Carnival of Monsters). Anyone who is still smarting about Murray Gold’s radical change to the theme in 2010 would do well to have a listen to the Delaware tune. Perhaps Gold didn’t do so bad after all.
8. Don't Worry About Taking Your Medication
Doctor Who might be an entertainment show, but right from its beginning it has taken seriously its duty to educate. Science and history play a part in this, but the show has always been more about teaching children values, such as welcoming the stranger, not judging by appearances, and dealing with bullies.
In the Forest of the Night, one of the latest episodes to take this responsibility seriously, was written by children’s author Frank Cottrell-Boyce. It contains a positive message about caring for the environment, but inexplicably carries another, more dubious one. A young girl, Maebh, becomes the hero but only by stopping her medication and, following the Doctor’s advice, listening to the voices inside her head.
Medicine isn’t the answer to every ailment, but to make even one unwell child think that it’s good to defy the will of parents and Doctors, and throw away the pills is frankly (excuse the pun) inexcusable.
7. Ooh I Say Matron
Doctor Who is good old fashioned, clean-humoured family entertainment. Most of the time. Its target audience is 0-99 and the program continues to appeal to the younger market with various ranges of cuddly toys, video games, books and kiddies clothing. In the UK, that all-ages reach gives booksellers and libraries cataloguing issues, with Doctor Who books being variously displayed in the children’s section, the teen section or the adult sci-fi/fantasy section.
For a pre-watershed program, the BBC has at times sailed close to the wind. To be fair, some of the material just lends itself to smutty innuendos – none more so than the sonic screwdriver. But rather than turning in her grave, Mary Whitehouse (who founded in 1965 the National Viewers’ and Listeners’ Association) would probably be rolling her eyes as if to say, not again, because Doctor Who has always allowed its writers and actors to have a little bit of fun at the expense of childhood innocence.
It’s all there to have a snigger at, but the Fourth Doctor blowing on the phallic shaped creature from the pit is not something the BBC particularly wants to draw attention to. And to be honest, it’s a sight that most of us would like to forget too.
6. The Vengeance Of The Doctor
In The Five Doctors, the Time Lord Borusa brought the Doctors to the Death Zone on Gallifrey to inadvertently aid him in his quest for immortality. He gets what he wished for, only to discover that it is a poisoned chalice, when he ends up eternally trapped within Rassilon’s sarcophagus.
The Doctor must have taken inspiration from Rassilon’s trap, because he goes a step further when years later he nets out individually tailored punishments to the Family of Blood. They too wanted to be immortal, and get more than they bargained for. “We wanted to live forever. So the Doctor made sure that we did.”
In the Doctor’s defence, he gave up being a Time Lord, using the fob-watch in order to avoid such an outcome. But when that plan backfired, did he really have to be so creative with his punishments? The Father is chained forever in an underground chamber, the mother trapped in the event horizon of a collapsing galaxy, the daughter hidden inside every mirror in existence, and the son time-locked as a scarecrow. It takes quite an effort to be so cruel. Either the Doctor really didn’t want to return to being a Time Lord or he’d learnt far too much in his short spell as a human.
5. Doctor Who - The Missing Years
The BBC loves to celebrate and even boast about the show’s ‘record breaking’ run of 53 years. In 2013 BBC worldwide made a shedload of money on the back of the heavily promoted golden anniversary events and related memorabilia, and Doctor Who continues to be one of the corporation’s flagship outputs across the globe. But this jewel in the BBC’s crown was once a source of embarrassment, especially for the top brass of the organisation.
It was only thanks to the perseverance of fans during the so-called wilderness years that Doctor Who’s flame kept burning. Throughout the early nineties, in an effort to appease fans, the BBC insisted that Doctor had not in fact been cancelled, and that it was only being ‘rested’. There were a few attempts to bring the show back in partnership with other agencies, most notably the 1996 TV Movie, but it was the work of fans in continuing the myth through other mediums that kept Doctor Who on the map. Doctor Who as a community might be 53 years old, but as a BBC series the show has only run for 35 seasons across 37 years.
4. The One Who Cannot Be Named Or Numbered
As secrets go, this one had to be the Doctor’s darkest. A version of himself that the Time Lord completely disowned on account of his involvement in the Time War, the War Doctor was supposed to have been irredeemably lost. But by the end of The Day of the Doctor, all is forgiven after he meets his Tenth and Eleventh selves. He discovers again what it means to be the Doctor as between the three of them, with a little bit of help from Clara and the conscience of the Moment (In the form of Billie Piper as bad wolf), they find a way to save Gallifrey.
In reality, the War Doctor shouldn’t have been blamed in the first place, it was the decision of the Eighth Doctor to trade being a Doctor for a Warrior, so really he is the one the others should have disowned. There was however, of course, the thorny issue of how to number the Doctors, and discounting this never-before-the-Doctor didn’t mess up the established BBC numbering.
Now that the War Doctor has been redeemed, why shouldn’t he count as Doctor number 9? Certainly his escapades in those dark days are well and truly out of the bag, in officially licensed Big Finish audio adventures, in George Mann’s official Engines of War novel and the fan-made charity anthology, Seasons of War.
3. Eeny, Meeny, Miny, Moe
It is a testament to the inclusivity at the heart of Doctor Who that charges of racism against it are few and far between – even retrospective ones. That’s not to say the show hasn’t courted controversy or mirrored the prejudices of its day. When the official soundtrack to the missing Hartnell episode The Celestial Toymaker was released, an exception was made to the meticulous efforts to remain as faithful to the original broadcast as possible. The use of the n-word by the Doctor when singing the children’s rhyme ‘Eeny, Meeny, Miny, Moe’ was sufficiently obscured to avoid offense.
It wasn’t quite so easy to cover up two other notorious incidents, and the rather weak attempts to soften the blow in both cases don’t really wash. In The Tomb of the Cybermen, the sole African on the multinational expedition to Telos, Toberman is characterised as a gentle, but simple giant. Apparently he was supposed to be deaf too, but this was cut from the shooting script, raising the suspicion that he was characterised as thick because he was black.
Fast forward to 1977 and having already got away with Louise Jameson’s make-up for the savage Leela, a white actor was cast as Li H’sen Chang. It was argued by some that a lack of oriental actors in the UK made this unavoidable, but even so the fact that the Doctor does not challenge the racism levelled at the Chinese immigrants in the story was enough for TVOntario not to broadcast the serial.
2. Doctor Who??????
Before Steven Moffat made it the thematic arc for the whole of series 7 there really wasn’t anything that mysterious about not knowing the Doctor’s real name. It was just accepted that this was one secret that he would take with him to his grave, just like Inspector Morse’s first name.
One thing’s for sure, his name is not literally Doctor Who. Well, not unless you’re a giant supercomputer called Wotan (The War Machines), or the Doctor’s robot dog K9 (K9 and Company). The Doctor however, quite mischievously loves to play on it, almost as if he knows that there’s a television show about him called Doctor Who.
In The Gunfighters the First Doctor calls himself Doctor Caligari, but when somebody asks him “Doctor who?” he replies “yes, quite right.” And the Second Doctor does more or less the same when he introduces himself as Doctor Von Wer (The Highlanders). Again, he is asked “Doctor who?” This time he replies “that’s what I said,” in what could be the earliest example of the classic ‘knock-knock’ joke.
1. The New Paradigm Daleks
Victory of the Daleks was anything but for the Doctor’s most iconic enemy. The idea sounded great on paper – after all, short of giving them an extended break (allegedly not possible for contractual reasons), a redesign could be the very thing to freshen them up, boosting toy sales and creating new storytelling possibilities with their specific ranks. It turned out to be the show’s biggest mistake since the Sixth Doctor’s tasteless coat.
Steven Moffat didn’t let them go down without a fight however, efforts were made to persuade a sceptical public that the new design could be just as menacing as Russell T Davies’ bronze Daleks. First came the stone version (The Big Bang), and when that didn’t work, the metallic ones (Asylum of the Daleks). They were both marked improvements but it all smacked of desperation and proved the truth behind the maxim ‘if it aint broken, don’t fix it.’ Thankfully, the next time we were treated to ‘every dalek ever’ (The Witch’s Familiar), the new paradigm were conspicuous for their absence.
With their garish colours they were the pantomime dames of Dalek. Worryingly they are presumably still out there somewhere, but hopefully on their travels they will run into the Sixth Doctor and in an epic battle, both the coat of many colours and the daleks of many classes will be gone forever.