4 Reasons Sherlock Should End With Season 4

It's better to go out with a bang at the top than an over-familiar whimper...

The one bad thing about being a Sherlock fan is the incredibly long wait between frustratingly short seasons. Each season has just three episodes (though, to their credit, each episode is 90 minutes long), and have all been divided by two-year gaps thanks to the increasingly busy schedules of the show's dynamic duo, Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman. We had to wait an excruciating two years between seasons 2 and 3, which had fans rabidly theorizing about how Sherlock faked his own death in The Reichenbach Fall. Now, just a few short weeks after (sort of) finding out how he duped us, we've got another as-yet-unspecified amount of time to wait before finding out how another character seems to have fooled us into thinking he was gone. Alas, season 3, we hardly knew you! It's been getting a bit of a mixed reaction from fans, some claiming that showrunner Steven Moffat is turning the show into Doctor Who and relying too much on fan service and not enough on case-solving, with episode 2, The Sign of Three, being particularly divisive. But luckily the season finale, His Last Vow, succeeded in balancing the humour and mystery, raising the stakes, and reminding us why we love the show so much. Season 4 has been confirmed for some time now, and it was recently revealed that Season 5 has been mapped out by Moffat and Mark Gatiss; though Cumberbatch and Freeman aren't officially signed on (yet). As great as the show has been, and as enjoyable season 3 was, I would argue that we don't actually need a fifth go-around, and that the show might be better off ending with season 4. Trust me, I love Sherlock just as much as the next guy, but sometimes you've got to learn to let a show go, and end on a high note before going out with a whimper. After all, isn't it better for a show to leave you wanting more, than to leave you wishing you'd seen less?

4. How Long Must We Keep Waiting?

As I mentioned, the biggest problem with the show is the two-year gaps between seasons: any other show is gone for a few months at most before airing again, but Sherlock doesn't have that luxury. The two stars have become hot commodities in Hollywood: Cumberbatch had a great year in 2013 with films like 12 Years A Slave, Star Trek Into Darkness, The Fifth Estate, and The Desolation Of Smaug (in which he played not one, but two iconic villains.) Freeman, on the other hand, has been headlining the Hobbit trilogy while making comparatively smaller films like Edgar Wright's The World's End. Of course, with the Hobbit films coming to a close this year, perhaps the actors will have more time on their hands, but that inevitably means they'll have time for other high-profile projects as well. How long can the show honestly go on if we have to keep waiting two years for it to come back? The actors aren't getting any younger (Cumberbatch is 37, Freeman is 42), and frankly, neither are we. I'd love to see the show go on forever, but logistically it has to end at some point.

3. John Watson: Family Man

With John now married and no longer living at Baker Street, we are unfortunately going to miss out on one of the show's best dynamics. Sherlock and John's living situation may not have been one of the biggest aspects of the show, but it was entertaining to see how the two detectives interacted with one another in the same space. Sure, John will be over to visit, but unless something happens to Mary, it appears that Sherlock will be sharing his flat only with Mrs. Hudson. This provides an interesting challenge for the show going forward. John and Sherlock together are for more interesting than they are apart, and with a baby on the way, will John really have time to solve crimes with his old pal? Will he even want to put himself in danger to do so? An interesting take on their relationship, yes, but maybe not good for the show past season 4 where it all may start getting in the way and feel more tedious than anything. Think of what happened to Dexter once that show introduced a baby. Domesticating your heroes is only interesting for so long before you begin to come up with excuses for never seeing the wife and kids again. I say give them one last adventure, one big challenge before John enjoys the happy ending he deserves. In fact, bring back an old foe to make it all come full circle...

2. The Return Of Moriarty

It appeared that Sherlock would be getting a new nemesis in Season 3, with the introduction of Charles Augustus Magnussen. Magnussen was an interesting villain, and the only man Sherlock has ever really hated or felt threatened by. He made the season finale stand out as one of the show's best episodes, though he unfortunately won't be returning. His death was anticlimactic, and it would have been great to see more of him going forward. Instead, we got the tease that Moriarty (or someone simply using Moriarty's image as a cover) has returned, which effectively ends Sherlock's exile. Moriarty's return feels a bit too much like fanservice, and is quite honestly a bit of a cop-out. It's like the writers of the show tried to think of a way to continue the show without him, and couldn't really do it. We didn't get any hints that this was a possibility throughout the season, and I get that that was done in order to make his reappearance feel more like a twist, but it just came off as a desperate move. In any case, whether or not his return was planned from the beginning is unimportant. He's coming back, in some fashion, and people seem pretty excited about it. Moriarty is to Sherlock what The Joker is to Batman. Or Lex Luthor is to Superman. He's his true nemesis through and through, and it was incredibly fun seeing his mystery unfold over the course of the first two seasons. So, what better way to end the show than with a final showdown between Sherlock and Moriarty, a three-episode arc chronicling Sherlock's final victory over his nemesis? After all, once you introduce him again, where is there to go from there?

1. How Big Can (And Should) The Show Get?

One of the biggest criticisms about the show going forward is the fact that it's becoming less and less about private investigation and more about bigger threats. It's inevitable that the stakes would continue to go up year by year, but at this point Sherlock is slowly becoming James Bond. Hell, at one point Mycroft even tries recruiting him to MI6. He's already thwarted a plan to blow up parliament, and once it's revealed that Moriarty has returned, Mycroft brings Sherlock out of his four-minute exile claiming that London needs him. I get that the world needs a man like Sherlock Holmes to stop big terrorist threats, but the show's far more enjoyable when he and Watson are investigating the smaller crimes. That's where Conan Doyle's stories really shine, and keeping the show smaller and more personal, rather than giving Sherlock world-saving missions and turning him into some kind of secret agent, would be the best way to go. At this point, and with Moriarty coming back, that's probably not going to happen, so I say wrap up the Moriarty/Sherlock story, and end the show before it gets too big for its own good. Of course, Sherlock will most likely keep going, after the third season broke the show's own records for viewership (which will only continue to grow once the show airs in the States). But, however and whenever the show ends, I hope it goes out with a bang. Make sure to follow me on Twitter @JimLovesMovies for more Sherlock news and articles!

Contributor
Contributor

James is a 24 year old writer and filmmaker living in Portland, OR. He attended college for graphic design and writes for various sources on the web about film, television, and entertainment. You can view all of his work on his website, www.thereeljames.wordpress.com