5 Most Cringeworthy Doctor Who Moments From '90s

A TV Movie and a Children In Need Special - what could there be to cringe over? Plenty.

The '90s was a dark decade for Doctor Who. The show had been canceled in 1989. The only new Who productions for the longest time were films produced by professional fans, and while they were decent, they didn't make up for the real thing. Doctor Who went dark in a different way as well: the Virgin New Adventures series quickly became the most adult Doctor Who-related productions ever, until Torchwood premiered the following decade (or until Abducted By The Daleks in 2005, depending on how you're defining "adult"). In fact, there were only two new "official" iterations of Who produced in the '90s until Big Finish Productions started their licensed audio dramas in 1999 - and the air quotes are used here because, while one of these iterations has since been canonized, the other one, though written by the incumbent producer, still has a large fluorescent question mark hanging over its canonicity. Both productions caused fans worldwide to cringe for various reasons, and yet the current series might not exist at all were it not for the popularity of both of them. This list will, by necessity, be a lot shorter than the rest (on the '60s, '70s and '80s), as it's not delving into cringeworthy moments from the book series or the audios - it's going to cover only with the "official" stuff, the productions that aired on television (albeit in less-than-glorious 3D). The TV Movie is likeable well enough in parts that we're not including it here as a single entry, so if there are moments from it that made you cringe that have not been included, please tell us in the comments below - and give us a head start on the Cringeworthy 2000's List by telling us what moments from 2005-2010 made you cringe as well!

5. Pete - The TV Movie

Let's start off by saying that Will Sasso is awesome - he was brilliant on MAD TV, and his Vine videos about lemons are some of the best short comedy sketches ever. That being said, his turn as Pete the Morgue Intern is not his finest hour. Perhaps it's because Pete acts exactly as everyone fears that morgue attendants actually act. He does a little comedic bit with the Seventh Doctor's corpse - or what passes for a comedic bit, anyway - and then shouts, "Party on!" down the dead man's ear. Luckily McCoy had previously walked unflinchingly away from an enormous explosion while filming an episode, so he was probably better prepared for this than we were. It's also hard to say which bit of the rest of Pete's time onscreen is more embarrassing: the heavy-handed foreshadowing of Pete watching the 1931 Frankenstein movie while the Doctor has a spasm, er, regenerates in his freezer; or Pete's fainting, accompanied by a "funny" music cue, when the Doctor emerges. It's somewhat made up for by his genuinely funny interactions with Grace the next morning, but it's one of those moments in the TV movie you just have to gird your loins for and endure.

4. "The Doctor Is Half-Human!" - The TV Movie

Had it not been the Master saying this line, coupled with some nonsense about the Doctor having human retinas (what?), this little nugget of Doctor Who lore could easily have been ignored, and the Doctor's later line about being "half-human - on my mother's side" could easily be passed off as a witticism. But there it is, and it makes us cringe every time. What exactly is it about this failed attempt to add something new to the Doctor Who mythos that rubs fans the wrong way? For one thing, it doesn't seem to have any purpose - had this backdoor pilot gone to series, perhaps they might have picked up on it in later episodes, since at least one version of the series bible said something or other about the Doctor's father being an explorer and marrying the Doctor's human mother during his travels. But in the context of the movie, it just sits there, unless it's meant to be some justification of why the Doctor is suddenly interested in romance - and as wittier people than us have noted, if the reason the Doctor is interested in Grace is because he's half-human, it must be his lower half. If there had never been a 2005 series or a series of books that carried on the story after the TV movie, it may not have been such a big deal - but there were, and both have had to address the thorny question of the Doctor's genetics by either ignoring it entirely or coming up with ever-increasingly bizarre fan theories to explain the line. Our favourite is that the Master had the Eye of Harmony turned round the wrong way and he was looking at his own retina, not the Doctor's... In any case, it's only one of several scenes to fast-forward over when rewatching the movie.

3. The TARDIS Brings The Doctor's Friends Back To Life - The TV Movie

Wait, what? No, really, seriously...what?! If there's anything that takes the TV Movie from territory that's merely sentimental to the genuinely mawkish, it's the scene in which the Eighth Doctor lovingly carries Grace Holloway's broken form up the stairs to rest beside the still body of Chang Lee - just before the TARDIS decides to belch some time dust out and bring them both back to life. Bet the Doctor wishes he'd known about that feature back in Earthshock - though maybe he wouldn't have used it, anyway. Seriously, what is going on here? Had this movie been made in 2006 rather than 1996, we might have gotten a much darker ending: the Doctor witnesses the Master killing his friends, manages not to save the Master from going into the Eye of Harmony, and now must carry on traveling alone with the knowledge that there are two people that he couldn't save who are no longer in the universe as a result of his coming to Earth. But it wasn't 2006, and the world apparently wasn't ready for that dark a take on Doctor Who yet. Except in the books, of course. It may very well be that last bit that makes many fans cringe at that sequence with the time pixie dust: we actually had been prepared for darker Doctor Who stories by that point, and having a downer ending might very well have sealed the fate of the movie ever going to series, but it would have felt more satisfying in its own way. As it is, there's the big red reset button, which would pave the way for further, more embarrassing reset buttons in the 2005 series. Nothing against Grace or Lee, but couldn't they just have stayed dead?

2. The Daleks' Voices - The TV Movie

Back in the run-up to the premiere of the TV Movie, the Internet had been awash with speculation about it, particularly the news that the Daleks would be making an appearance. Those who were around back then scoured the virgin territory of previously unseen newsboards and chats to find grainy animation tests of the CGI spider Daleks - which everyone hated on principle, of course, but were still psyched about the possibility of seeing. Then came the actual movie, and all we got of the Daleks were the voices. God, those voices... It's a sign of how universally loathed this sequence is that you can't find a single clip of it on YouTube. Instead, there are plenty of revisions that either take the audio out entirely, insert footage of Anthony Ainley from the PC game Destiny Of The Doctors, or dub in Gordon Tipple's original voiceover as the Master (it appears we dodged a bullet there, as it's far inferior to McGann's narration). The Daleks' voices were done by the director, who somehow managed to f**k them up despite his being British. In his defense, Dalek voices were notoriously difficult to reproduce faithfully - the original series itself sometimes ran into trouble with it, as is evidenced by the first two stories and by Day Of The Daleks - but this is barely a passable attempt. Yeah, spider Daleks would've been a lot better.

1. Dimensions in Time

Until the TV Movie, the only official bit of new Doctor Who that fans had to enjoy (though that's stretching it a bit) was the Children In Need special from 1993, Dimensions in Time, marking the 30th anniversary of the show. As much as it's been said the other proposed special, The Dark Dimension, would also have been awful, it's hard to imagine anything being worse than this. Yes, it was done for charity, and this should excuse any flaws in it because it was done for a good cause. But there are so many flaws in it, so many things to make both Doctor Who and Eastenders fans want to hide their faces in shame, that that justification simply doesn't hold water. Where to start? Let's kick off with the very beginning, in which we see the Rani and her hot companion Cyrian in her TARDIS, being buzzed by ohmygodwhatthebloodyhellarethose?! Because William Hartnell and Patrick Troughton were both long gone by this point, the production team opted to use floating sculpted heads of the two to suggest that they had been trapped in time "like gherkins in a jar" (yes, that's the actual line - John Nathan-Turner may have been able to produce the pants off a show, but that didn't mean he knew how to write it). The heads are...not successfully rendered, let's say. Then we cut to the Fourth Doctor, sending out an S.O.S. to all of his other selves (which, apparently, they never got), explaining that the Rani is gunning for them and that the Rani "even hates children!" Well, who doesn't? He then tells them "Good luck, my dears" - and that's it. After waiting ten years for Baker to finally take part in an anniversary special, that's what fans got - and all those geometric shapes floating around him in 3-D don't help, either. Then the true dementia in time begins, when the Seventh Doctor and Ace arrive near the setting of Eastenders, before the Doctor transmogrifies for no apparent reason into the Sixth Doctor, then he and Ace become Mel and the Third Doctor...and it goes on and on and on... Most of these performances are OK, with Peter Davison and Colin Baker having particular fun, but then we get people like Caroline John, who seems like she could use a jolt of caffeine, and Deborah Watling, who's had a little too much. And to top it all off, there's the phone-in portion... The special was shown in two parts, and in between the two parts, viewers could phone in and decide whether Big Ron or Mandy would help the Rani. Such a major plot point, left to the whims of the British public? Surely not! And that only scratches the surface. The special can be seen in its entirety here, though you should be warned it takes a particularly strong set of shoulders (and a firm stomach) to sit through all of its cringey glory. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EqWYOdlXzJM Was there anything from the '90s we left out - and what particularly would you like to see in the upcoming Cringeworthy Moments from the 2000's list? Let us know in the comments below!

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Tony Whitt has previously written TV, DVD, and comic reviews for CINESCAPE, NOW PLAYING, and iF MAGAZINE. His weekly COMICSCAPE columns from the early 2000s can still be found archived on Mania.com. He has also written a book of gay-themed short stories titled CRESCENT CITY CONNECTIONS, available on Amazon.com in both paperback and Kindle format. Whitt currently lives and works in Chicago, Illinois.