5 Things You Need To Know About HBO's Confederate
HBO's newest show promises a fascinating take on one of history's greatest what ifs.
HBO has announced their newest show, an alternative history in which the Confederate States of America won the American Civil War and became a legitimate nation. In this universe, slavery is a modern institution of Confederate life and tensions between the CSA and the USA are high for a third time, as two civil wars have already been fought. Leading the show will be Game of Thrones directors, David Benioff and D.B. Weiss.
The announcement of Confederate brought an immediate reaction online with widespread dissatisfaction on Twitter. Many complained that it would be profiting off the trauma of real experiences, while other activists worried a show created and directed by two white men would have trouble corroborating a world in which African Americans are still widely enslaved. Another worry is that imagery in the show may be stolen and used as propaganda for white supremacist groups, as well as providing extremists with inspiration and glorification.
Benioff and Weiss recently spoke to Vulture, admitting that they anticipated the backlash, but insisted critics wait for the show's premiere to form final a final judgement.
Shrouded by backlash and controversy, it may be hard to actually understand what Confederate will be about. Let's look through the controversy to reveal the most pertinent facts.
5. Multiple Storylines
For Confederate, HBO promises a wide array of characters that will include abolitionists, journalists, freedom fighters, slave hunters, and leaders of a slave owning corporation. These characters will provide takes on all aspects of life in both nations - the CSA and United States.
This should give Confederate the flexibility it needs to explain the many complications and issues that this world will obviously have. Benioff and Weiss should use their talent to create characters which we can both empathize with and despise, much as they have in Game of Thrones.
The content of the show's material will be very controversial, but could be rewarding. If done right, Confederate could provide viewers with a realistic and chilling view of what might have happened if the US failed to win the Civil War and put an end to the horrors of slavery. A number of views on this will help. We could witness the destruction and tragedy slaves endure, the passion of rebellious heroes, the rage of citizens of both nations who wish the end of slavery, and the many divides along race, class, and now nationality in the formerly united country.
4. Civil War
Confederate's alternate setting leaves the United States and the Confederate States at a breaking point in relations for not the second time, but the third, as there has already been a Second American Civil War in the show's universe. Fraught with division and long standing rivalry, bloodshed appears inevitable as the brother nations look to clash once again.
HBO has not elaborated on who is leading these nations, or their technological and military capabilities, but if the American nations fight again, there is bound to be intense combat and conflict, especially in the modern day. It would likely be a very passionate fight, as relatives and former friends take up arms against one another.
This provides an interesting backplot for the show as characters navigate the brewing conflict. Slavery is likely a reason for the fighting, as it has been historically, and its role would be key in a new civil war in the modern era. With the CSA looking to uphold the system that gave birth to the nation, the plight of modern slaves would be as desperate and crucial as ever. The US and its supporters would likely have the world's support behind them as it is hard to envision a modern global society supportive of slavery.
3. High Tension
A common theme of the show's universe and plot is tension and the divisions that are driving it. Two nations which have been at odds for over 150 years are now threatening to go to war once again, families and friends are split apart by a demilitarized zone, and biggest of all, slavery is commonplace, leading to widespread major racial tension.
While we can't predict the state of race relations in the US, Confederate's main setting will likely be the CSA, and the state of relations there are clearly awful. African Americans are left without rights and enslaved by not just the plantation owners of the past, but now major corporations, using the free labor for profit. In addition, class may play a part as it did in the real life CSA. Poor whites and poor blacks obviously have their differences, but so do poor whites and rich, slave owning whites. This dynamic would be yet another example of division in two nations on the brink of war.
The United States and its lost Southern neighbor are engaged in a sort of cold war, and according to HBO's release of details on Confederate, those tensions may escalate into full scale conflict. Characters will be caught on both sides, promising a full view of two sister nations caught in bloodshed once again.
2. Institutional Slavery
The real world tragic use of slavery by White Americans to enslave African Americans in the United States is a well documented horror that was put to an end at the conclusion of the American Civil War in 1865. However, in Confederate, the CSA has continued its legality and use well into the modern era, evolving it into a modern institution used by individuals and corporations.
We will be seeing this modern slavery first hand as characters announced for the series include slave owning corporate heads, abolitionists, slave hunters, and freedom fighters. This will depict slavery from both sides and if David Benioff and D.B. Weiss' prior work on Game of Thrones is an indicator, they will likely not shy away from the brutal reality of slavery.
Black people in the CSA are likely used as cattle and their plight will probably be the center of what promises to be a controversial show. As evidenced by the negative reactions to the show's announcement, many are skeptical that HBO will be able to deliver on creating a story and depiction of slavery that is accurate and respectful. Benioff and Weiss will have to execute this area of the show's universe carefully and cautiously but if they are able to do so, Confederate will be a success.
1. The Confederate States Of America
As the title and basis of the show indicates, Confederate is set in an alternate history where the Confederacy defeated the Union and achieved its independence. Beyond the civil war, the CSA has continued to exist into the modern day, keeping its slave run economy and society.
Slave owning conglomerates and slave hunters, as well as their opposition from abolitionists make the CSA a nation with deep cracks in its foundations. Its economic state likely relies on slavery in the modern day, much as it did in the real world. Its cultural racism and disdain for African Americans and its northern neighbor will likely play a significant role in the society of the country.
The Confederacy is a controversial and divisive topic in the US and Confederate must respect that. HBO has the responsibility of creating this world, and it has promised a vivid depiction of what its writers and creators wish to create. The CSA's government, culture, history, and society will all have to be explored, and this is something HBO has done excellently in the past with its depictions of 1920s America in Boardwalk Empire, Westeros in Game of Thrones, and the anarchic Westworld. This should give those who are skeptical of Confederate's premise some relief and hope.