5 Ways Geordie Shore Is Just Not Jersey Shore
Currently broadcasting its Fifth Series, I can't help but wonder what the shelf-life of Jersey's Shore British remake, Geordie Shore. Although it has only been on the air less than two years, reality shows often burn bright and fast, especially those which are spin-offs/adaptations of others. Although I've watched Geordie Shore from the beginning I'm only really continuing to invest in it to make the transition to post-Jersey Shore life more bearable. However, I'm finding, more and more, Geordie Shore is providing very little solace. The remake is, sadly, unable to match the success of its predecessor and although it continues to be a ratings hit for MTV UK, there are several aspects of the show's premise which really annoy me, even though I enjoy it for the most part.
5. Jersey Shore is a Summer Holiday
Jersey Shore, both the show and the location, screams summer! Even the seasons that did not take place in Jersey (Miami, Season Two. Italy, Season Four) were still filmed around AprilJune time and took place just before the Jersey seasons. So, not only did they have a Spring Break-esque holiday feel but also that summer anticipation that they will soon be going back to Jersey. Geordie Shore, on the other hand, has more of an Im going back into that house down the road and will get to lie in bed and do nothing for a month. Jersey Shore provided the viewers a sense of escapism because they themselves were escaping their urban, New York/New Jersey/New England hometowns and going a summer hotspot. Here in the UK, we are a much smaller country with pretty uniform weather throughout. Thus, British people rarely summer in Britain, especially young people, who will go to Mediterranean party towns such as Ibiza, Magaluf, Zante and Ayia Napa. Whilst, understandably, the producers wouldnt have wanted the whole show based abroad, they could have opted for a UK resort which still has some holiday reputation, such as Blackpool or Brighton, both of which are shore cities. However, heres the problem, neither city has particularly distinctive locals. In the UK, northerners have the strongest local identities (Geordies, Scousers, Scots) but, honestly, northern cities are kind of, well, rough. Geordie Shore would have fared much better, and appeared much more original, had it not tried to stay too faithful to the Shore concept.
4. Newcastle: Seaside, It Aint!
I can understand why the producers chose Newcastle to find its cast for their adaptation of Jersey Shore. Its northern, working-class and renowned for its nightlife, basically the home of a perfect reality star. However, now in Series Five, I cant help feel they made a HUGE mistake BASING the show in Newcastle. Yes it has good nightclubs but, firstly, the cast are forbidden to film in most of them and, two, thats ALL its got going for it. Lets be honest, its hardly a pretty coastal village. Oh, and another thing, its not even on a shore! Its got a manky, grey river running through it. Surely it should be Geordie Riverbank? or, better still, just The Toon! Regardless of those, pedantic, points Ive made, the main problem I have with the shows location is it is not a place where you would stay for a length of time, a boozy weekend with your mates at the most. Its not a summer, or any seasonal, hotspot and, given that most of the cast live in the city, there isnt that holiday buzz of going to Newcastle as the Jersey lot have about travelling down the Shore. Frankly, the show isnt doing a job at convincing us that Newcastle is really the UK equivalent to Guido heaven, Seaside Heights.3. A Geordie Is NOT A Guido Equivalent
Were gonna show em how Geordies party!, You cant be a Geordie without a tan! Oh well, they tried. They failed. Simply copying platitudes from your parent show is not an worthy adaptation, but more like a bad parody. It has never really been clearly explained exactly what being a Geordie means by the cast. Dont get me wrong Im not crediting the Jersey Shore cast as the personification of the Guido but, somehow, they did come across as more authentic and really did portray an uncommon lifestyle. Whether a Guido really is a true representation of an Italian American is another story. However, the cast themselves have even denied representing American-Italian culture on many occasions. Conversely, the Geordies are put on a platform as representatives of a small city of the Northern East of England and have little choice in the matter. Really weekly spray tans, getting mortal and bucking has little to do with being Geordie. Thus, other than the accent, theres nothing really distinguishable about these kids that warrants giving them a tv show. Britain isnt anywhere neat as diverse as America so we do not really have secret subcultures, such as Guidos. In fact, the closest I could really consider would be a Chav, but thats hardly a title of self-proclamation.
2. Jersey Shore Is SUBculture, Geordie Shore Is POPULAR culture
Oh dear, the mark of an amateur is, indeed, failing at the pivotal moment, sigh! Im sorry but when it comes to moulding the Geordie culture, our Newcastle mob are woefully inadequate. Part of the thrill of Jersey Shore was the newness of it, the discovery of this hidden neo-Italian American, Guido lifestyle. One thing the Jersey folk knew how to do, and well, was to brand their Guido-ness. From their daily GTL mantra (Gym, Tan, Laundry) to their odd dance rituals of fist-pumping and beating up the beat. From blow-outs and poufs to gorilla juiceheads and grenades and from gender cliques the Meatballs and MVP, Jersey Shores cast offered a plethora of interesting new phrases, euphemisms and insults which made us cringe and crease ourselves at the same time. Sadly, this has never really been the case with the shows British drunker, more inappropriate cousin. Although, I think Vicky, at least, deserves special mention for her attempts to brand the Geordie. She is a smart girl who knows exactly what shes doing (she is apparently a university graduate) and has carefully crafted a working-class, Geordie-dun-good image for herself which she perfects by throwing out impressive vocabulary such as euphoric and ostentatious amongst her colourful expletives. After all, she was the one to introduce the phrase, tashing on (snogging basically) and found any excuse to use it throughout the first couple of series. She implanted phrases such as pet, alreet and gaan into her speech and even set about entangling herself in a Sam-Ron-esque romance in the first series, with hapless Neanderthal, Jay. She, at the very least, knows how to play the game and what the Jersey Shore audience in Britain want out of her show. I wouldnt be surprised if she sits with a pen, pad and a dictionary in her downtime and storyboards her narrative for each series. However, now in Series Five, even she seems to have become weary.
1. The Premise is Lost in Translation
Basically, the Geordies dont realise that they are nothing out of the ordinary (and why would they) and their over-rehearsed one-liners are more forgettable than quotable. Geordie Shore has basically just descended into a northern Big Brother, with the cast even referring to the house as the Geordie Shore house. They arent even trying to disguise the fact that they are on a set-up television show. At least Jersey Shore persisted with the 'summer job', in Dannys t-shirt shop, even though they are all rich enough to buy the whole boardwalk. They even kept the illusion that they are still unknown, anonymous kids from the Shore, editing out the crowds of fans that follow them relentlessly. In addition, the relationships between the housemates is either non-existent or comes across a extremely forced. Whilst it took Jersey Shore at least five or six seasons to get visibly fed up of each other, Geordie Shore never really developed that family bond. Of course, the reason being, there was nothing for them to really bond over in the first place. The life of a young Geordie is nothing special. Its basically the same as every other 18 30 year old Brit. They literally could have plucked anyone from any city in the UK and pretty much would have got similar results. There are no real periphery subcultures in this culture that could mirror Guidos/Guidettes and accent is the only real marker of a Geordie.