6 Reasons Breaking Bad Could Only Have Worked As A TV Show

It's clear as crystal why it was a TV show...

Frozen Breaking Bad
YouTube

Breaking Bad is quite rightly hailed as one of the most successful dramas of the twenty-first century. But in this age of multi-platform entertainment, could it have survived in another format? Say creator Vince Gilligan's insistence on the casting of Bryan Cranston over preferred choices like John Cusack had led to the whole project being aborted. Would Gilligan have gotten his idea to live outside the confines of the small screen?

Absolutely not. The show has one of the all-time great concepts, but an unusual one in that it was perfectly suited to TV. Other great offerings of the age can easily transfer to different mediums. For example, House would make a good novel as well as an essential prescription for the cathode ray tube. True Detective had the stuff of an epic movie. The adventures of Walter White on the other hand could only have flown one way - in a creative setting that allowed for the unique blend of complex character arcs and ambiguity that Gilligan and his team demanded.

To demonstrate this point, here are six imaginary paths Breaking Bad may have followed in other media, showing how things panned out for Walt had AMC not come calling. As you'll see, it would've looked like Breaking Bad. Sounded like Breaking Bad. But it wouldn't have been Breaking Bad.

6. Breaking Bad - The Animated Series

Frozen Breaking Bad Do You Want To Build A Meth Lab
YouTube

Let's start with a silly one. Walt and the gang brightening up a Saturday morning kids' slot. Or maybe starring in an adult-oriented cartoon along the lines of Aeon Flux or Afro Samurai. You could certainly present the events of Breaking Bad in animated form but the emphasis would be very different, the younger participants likely to be seen as a better draw for an audience. Badger's a loose cannon, but he'd also work brilliantly as a cel-by-cel goofball.

All that sitting around talking and the sharing of feelings? Out the window. The gunfights, set pieces and more eye-catching elements? They'd come to the fore. The idea of a high school chemistry teacher with a secret identity is one that could be adopted by producers like Warner Bros, or even Studio Ghibli.

Walter White as we know him may be suffering from a serious disease, but the pitch would place him squarely in the field of a guy trying to do the right thing. The Jekyll & Hyde aspect of the character could be accentuated. Cranston's icon trying to invent a cure for his condition, only to wind up turning himself into a monster. Either that or he's Heisenberg the superhero, flying around taking out drug dealers with his chemical expertise...


5. Breaking Bad - The Video Game

Breaking Bad Jesse Walt
AMC

Out of all mediums, this one has the potential to most accurately reflect the events of the show, at least in terms of the supporting cast. With the gaming world's immersive environments, you can see a player having the option of controlling Jesse, Hank, or Mike. The female contingent wouldn't fare so well in these circumstances though, a definite drawback.

In this version Walt would be the enigma he's shown as onscreen. With his fluctuating motivations he's too complex to be simply piloted via console. But he'd work well as a figure everyone else circles around, never quite knowing what he's going to do next.

Ultimately however the intimate moments of the drama will go by the wayside, programmers concentrating on dynamic forward momentum to keep their audience in the zone. An interesting take on the idea, but a dude-centric, streamlined one also.


4. Breaking Bad - The Novel

Better Call Saul
AMC

You could argue that Breaking Bad has the richness of a great novel, and to an extent I'd say you're right. Opening the pages and diving into such an involving plot, populated with vivid but identifiable characters, is the meat and drink of a rattling good read.

Unlike the other options presented so far, this one allows the male/female relationships to breathe. Skylar and Marie's stories are amply-served on the printed page, each connected to the main plot in contrasting but strangely similar fashion. Skylar is the rock for the bad guy, Marie for the good.

There's just one problem - Walt. His great strength is his unknowability. Despite following him around for much of the time on television, you're never entirely aware of what he's thinking. In prose you'd have to show his thought process. Mr White's power derives from his inner-workings being a constant source of debate. Even if he was only depicted through the eyes of others, you still wouldn't have Bryan Cranston's expressive features to guide you through his darker actions.


3. Breaking Bad - The Musical

Breaking Bad
AMC
Staging Breaking Bad? It'd have a running time that would put Shakespeare to shame. The core narrative of Walt's transformation from pillar of the community to meth wizard could form the basis of a play. Or how about an opera? Am I the only one who wants to see Leonel and Marco Salamanca (aka "The Cousins") suddenly burst into an aria? Hmm, maybe I am.

A musical incarnation of the show on the other hand... that isn't so far-fetched. Everything from Dirty Dancing to American Psycho has had the razzle dazzle treatment. It's only a matter of time before some enterprising producer sees potential box office gold in yet another unlikely source.

But in all seriousness, a musical would be the worst idea since Gus's right hand man Victor bought that box cutter. White and Pinkman sharing a duet in the Winnebago? Hank and Steve Gomez belting out a high energy number over the donuts? Mike drowning his sorrows and growling out a slow blues number? I'd rather put my head under a cash machine.


2. Breaking Bad - The Comic Book

Breaking Bad Gus
AMC

Heisenberg's crimes as filtered through a child-friendly format have been covered to a degree in the 'Animated Series' entry. So we'll train our attention here on Gilligan's opus being rendered on the long-standing platform of the graphic novel, with its target market tall enough to actually reach the counter.

This may improve upon a wordy book in that you can see the character's faces, getting the portrayal of Walt a lot closer to how we know him now. The sticking point is action. There's plenty of sitting around in Breaking Bad. A strain on any artist's wrists. So as with an animation or video game the quickfire blood and carnage would be heavily promoted.

Key moments from the show would look great in a painted panel. Jesse floating into the air while high or Gus's half-faced demise in particular. Yet while an amount of subtlety could be shown, it'd just lack the depth of the end result that made an impression on viewers around the world. A single interaction between Cranston and Aaron Paul has more punch than a thousand pages sitting on a comic store shelf.


1. Breaking Bad - The Movie

Breaking Bad Bryan Cranston
AMC

An idea mooted for a while after Walt seemingly dropped dead was a continuation film. A rogue instalment showing everyone's favourite warped educator is a fun prospect, like a cerebral variation on The A-Team perhaps, as White gets into hot water with another bad crowd.

This would be fine to keep the vibe going a little. Totally wrong for the TV story though. For starters there's simply too much going on for a two, or even three hour feature to do justice by. Breaking Bad is a slow burn. A movie is all about a single shot to the system, something that'll send you out into the light blinking. The closest you'd get to that'd be throwing open the curtains after a boxset marathon after realizing you need to take a bathroom break, having consumed several bags of Funyuns. If you sat through all five seasons in one sitting... you may want to consult your doctor.

Crucially, if Gilligan were trying to secure a movie-level budget they'd face big opposition over its most important element: Bryan Cranston, back then known as Tim Whatley from Seinfeld or the guy from Malcolm In The Middle. John Cusack may well have wound up playing Walter White. Nothing necessarily wrong with that. I like John Cusack. However, imagining a BB without BC for too long...? That gives me the fear beeyatches.

Do you agree with this article? Could Breaking Bad have been anything other than a TV classic? Let us know in the comments section.


Contributor
Contributor

I am a journalist and comedian who enjoys American movies of the 70s, Amicus horror compendiums, Doctor Who, Twin Peaks, Naomi Watts and sitting down. My short fiction has been published as part of the Iris Wildthyme range from Obverse Books.