7 Dangerous Stereotypes In Glee

Before I begin with this list it is important for me to point out to that I am actually a GLEE fan... however, if that puts you off this post, the following list can also been seen as a negative points for all you haters out there (or those who love to hate-watch Glee). It is my opinion that Glee is the most misunderstood series on TV and the most harshly judged. Glee is not a drama nor is it a comedy, it is somewhere in between with a good dose of musical glued on. Glee also isn't supposed to be realistic- it's supposed to be silly, poppy, ironic, satirical and edgy in a similar vein to such films as Clueless and Mean Girls. What I am getting at is, if you take this show too seriously you are not going to like it, but if you understand what it is and what it is supposed to be you can have a hell of a lot of fun watching Glee. Despite not being a comedy, if you get into the shows rhythm, it is one of the more funny programs on TV. Having said that, even as a big fan of the show, it isn't perfect by any means. It can get repetitive, it can get too sentimental and cheesy at times and, and although I don't have a huge problem with a show that tries to promote a political message (in fact, I love and respect Glee for this very reason), occasionally the odd message here and there can come off a little heavy-handed. But it least it tries. Glee does many things really well. The show's production values are top notch, the shows cast are some of the most hard working and talented actors on TV, and the musical numbers are actually pretty good if you can get past your music snobbery- Paul McCartney, Bono, Katy Perry, Stevie Nicks, Lady Gaga, Elton John and many many other big name musicians aren't insulted, so why should you be? But Glee also does a few things badly... and although, like I said previously, the show is satirical and ironic, the show does seem to use pretty embarrassing, silly and occasionally offensive character stereotyping. Here are Glee's seven worst examples (with a couple of honourable mentions later on)... p.s. It is difficult to talk about stereotypes without sounding a little stereotypical yourself, so if this list offends anyone, know that this is not intentional at all, and I love you all.

7. "Crazy Redhead"

It is a common stereotype in film and television to show redheads as one of either two things (or sometimes both)... either wild and adventurous, or crazy, and Emma Pillsbury fits into the later section of this stereotyping. Before people start to get insulted with my use of the word "crazy" I don't mean it... I am just trying to make a point of how insulting some stereotypes can be. Emma on Glee suffers with quite severe OCD; and no, I don't think OCD is "crazy", but it is an illness. Not that you need to know anything about me (or want to), but I also suffer from OCD, similar but less severely than Emma's, and surprisingly, I am not insulted by this representation. In fact, I think it is one of the better few representations of this illness on television, and I am thankful to see my condition represented on TV. But the "Crazy Redhead" stereotype (for example Catherine Tate on the US Office) is used too many times, and is not only arguably insulting to people who suffer from mental illnesses, but more so to redheads themselves who often get a hard time from the media and even the world... stereotypes like this one, or the stereotype of them being fiery, feisty and adventurous won't do that much to help. However, there are a lot of redheads currently on TV who don't fit into these categories, and due to their popularity - Christina Hendricks and Damien Lewis for example - this will help give much needed balance to the redheaded stereotypes.

6. "Bitchy Blonde Cheerleader"

Perhaps there are actually a lot of real life examples of these types of people, however that doesn't mean it isn't a stereotype, and the fact that I think many cheerleaders (because of the nature of highschools) will often be bitchy and often have blonde hair is probably only because I watch a lot of TV and this particular stereotype is pretty much used on every television show set in highschool. In fact, please, if any of you can think of a show set in a school which doesn't have at least one bitchy blonde I'd love to be educated in the comments section. Quinn Fabray is the perfect example of this stereotype, all except for the fact that the character (who is now at Yale) is actually shown to be one of the smarter members of the Glee club for a change. Quinn's characterization on the show has had a lot of criticisms for being inconsistent... sometimes she is nice, sometimes she is just pure evil, and sometimes she is somewhere in between (also, for two episodes she was a punk and had pink hair) however I'd make the argument that real people are actually pretty inconsistent themselves. Quinn ended season 3 as pretty much the nicest girl: she let Rachel win Prom Queen which was a big deal for her, and she did a lot of growing up in the latter half of the season... whether she will have turned back into her bitchy self when she returns fairly soon in season 4 is anyone's guess. I'd wager not, however considering Sue Sylvester (Jane Lynch's character) has been evil then nice then evil again so many times, it wouldn't be a safe bet.

5. "Exotic Lesbian"

Santana Lopez, the Latina lesbian cheerleader is probably my favourite character on Glee, and the writers have actually shown her coming to terms and fully embracing her sexuality in brilliant, engaging ways, and I am thankful there is a strong sympathetic and truly interesting lesbian character on the show. This is not a criticism of the character, simply the overuse of characters of races other than white portraying homosexual characters on television. I am not a fool, I know that there are many lesbians of every ethnicity in the world, and it would be wrong not to represent them in television, however TV writers and producers too often pile on all the interesting character differences into one character, and it seems, if your cast is made up of mostly white people and there are one or two racially diverse characters, show creators like to bundle them all into a neat package. Tara from True Blood for example, one of the only non-white characters on the show who started off the show straight (she had a major crush on Jason), has now seemed to have turned lesbian with very little character development leading to this sudden character change. Callie Torres from Grey's Anatomy is also Latina and bisexual and Jesus from True Blood, again Latina and gay. This isn't to say that there aren't plenty of lesbian white characters on TV, but I just feel white show creators think other races are somewhat "exotic", therefore mysterious, so because of this they like to make these characters homosexuals.

4. "Sensitive Jock"

This is probably Glee's go-to stereotype, and one of the most boring and overused stereotypes in TV history. It's as if TV producers really think we are so stupid and couldn't possibly work out on our own that some jock football players can actually be nice guys. It wouldn't be so bad if Glee was subtle about it either, but the way they play up Finn's nice guy persona can get very irritating, especially considering his if far from the nicest in the cast. Finn gets all the credit on the show for being the nicest guy, and the writers obviously consider Finn to be their protagonist, their hero, but he can actually be pretty harsh. He started off the series as a bully (though a nicer one- if nice bullies even exist): when all his friends were throwing Kurt into a trash-bin, Finn allowed them to do it, but would hold items of Kurt's clothing so they wouldn't get damaged. His behaviour could only be considered nice in relative terms, and since then he has also called Kurt a homophobic term and outed Santana before she was ready. What a hero!? All this considered, I don't hate the character, and he has changed considerably, however people love to give all the credit to horrible people who change as apposed to people who have always been nice guys. Artie, Sam and Mike for example are much more heroic than Finn ever was. Puck also fits into this character mold, as does his brother Jake introduced into Season 4. In fact, stupidly, every single male member (at least most of them) appear to be members of the football team, and are therefore all sensitive jocks. In reality, this is entirely ridiculous- even wheel-chaired Artie is in the team. If they aren't all in the team, they spend a lot of their male bonding time in the locker-rooms.

3. "Sassy/Lazy/Food Obsessed African American"

This is probably the most insulting, unfair stereotype on this list, but this description fits for Mercedes, at least for the most part. I love the character and she has proved to be much less lazy toward the end of season 3, but episodes have been devoted to her love of Tater Tots in which she imagined that people were food and want to eat them. In the great episode devoted to Mercedes in Season 3 (Asian F) Mr Schue has a go at her for oversleeping and not putting enough effort into rehearsals like her white friends, and that from day one Mercedes has been nothing but a diva. Some could argue that the fact that Mercedes says what is on her mind, is confident and sassy, and demands solos (but never gets them) are strong character attributes to have- and a lot of the time they are, for example when she sings "Beautiful" in front of the whole school or tells Sue that she shouldn't have to loose weight to be cheerleader. However you would have a difficult time arguing that this was a tricky character to come up with in the development stage. Ryan Murphy probably just said "overweight, African-America diva" and this is pretty much what Mercedes is for the most part. We never get to meet even one of her parents (like we do with most of the other seniors) and know very little of her back-story which unfortunately makes a character that could have been so interesting, into one of the least developed, boring characters on the show. Mercedes deserved a lot more than just a stereotype. Her boyfriend Shane, one of the only other black cast members was obese and did very little to change this overused, insulting representation.

2. "Dumb Blonde"

Glee could have almost have gotten away with this one because Quinn, another blonde, is one of the smartest of the glee club bunch, however Brittany S Pierce is so dumb that dumb is pretty much all she is. In fact, by making a character as dumb as this one, Ryan Murphy and co have kind of dug themselves into a hole - how will she ever graduate?! She certainly is nowhere intelligent enough to stand half a chance. Stupidly though she is ridiculously talented at dancing and choreography so it is actually pretty difficult to imagine a character could be a genius at one thing and so obviously remedial at most others. Clearly, the creators of Glee know that the cast is full up with mostly stereotypes, and they have a lot of fun with this particular one that we can almost forgive them. The fact that there is also almost no section of the human race who isn't stereotyped in Glee means at least everyone suffers the same treatment. As much as you want to hate Brittany for being portrayed as the obvious dumb blonde that the other Glee club members like to take fun of, you can't, because her character is too damn funny for that, and gets all the best lines. However, of all the characters on Glee (or on TV full stop), Brittany is the most unbelievable human being, and if she were really that dumb, she would certainly be dead by now.

1. "Evil Gay"

This is probably TV and Film's favourite, most overused and insulting stereotype there is. The media loves to portray gay or slightly effeminate males as villains, and this trait played a huge role in film and TV in the 80's and 90's (see Silence of The Lambs for your best example of this). When the media wasn't using gay characters in these roles, they were likely using British actors pretending to be German... and I have a feeling a lot Americans think all British people are homosexuals anyway. Even as a huge fan of Buffy, another show that like Glee has done a lot for the gay rights movement and public opinion, even Buffy delved into this stereotype when Willow became the Big Bad of Season 6 (in fact, the "Crazy Redhead" category could also fit her in this season too). Sebastian Smythe, the antagonist and leader of the rival show choir the Warblers in Season 3, was not only a homosexual predator out to steel Blaine (another appalling stereotype) but also a villain out to even use violent means to win at regionals. He almost blinds Blaine in perhaps the silliest storyline Glee has ever come up with (despite the episode actually being pretty good) but he also insults everyone and has his part to blame in the attempted suicide of another Glee character. Also, despite their characters in the show actually being straight, you could argue that the gay actors Jane Lynch, Niel Patrick Harris and Cheyenne Jackson also played "evil gays" in the series - all gay in real life and all antagonists. This all said, Glee is one of the best shows on TV at including and representing LGBT characters and there are plenty of lovely gay characters including Kurt and Blaine on the show to perhaps cancel this one out a little. Had the only gay character on the show who was gay been the villain then this would have been unforgivable... but because there are about 8 gay characters and only a few of them are ever antagonists this is probably actually a fair and equal representation of homosexuals. HONOURABLE MENTIONS: "Irish Leprechaun Type" (Rory) "Smart Asians" (Mike and Tina) "Asians Who Are All The Same, And Have The Same Last Names" (Mike Chang and Tina Cohen Chang) "Gay Teacher Sexual Predator" (Sandy Ryerson) "Fashion Obsessed Gay Guy" (Kurt Hummel) "Transgendered/Transvestite- The Two Are Not The Same!!!" (Wade "Unique" Adams) Thanks for reading, and if I missed any great ones out, please inform me in the comments section, but don't let this put you off Glee or turn you away... it truly is one of the most exciting things on TV at the moment and I could probably have conducted this same list for most TV shows anyway. At least Glee is still very good at representing a vast majority of minority characters, much more so than almost every other. Despite these stereotypes (which for the most part are intentional and satirical,) I still love the show.

In this post: 
Glee
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

I am a recent Screenwriting for Film and Television graduate from the UK. I am an unashamed geek who loves everything Marvel, and anything Joss Whedon has ever touched (except for maybe Alien Resurrection and Titan A.E). My current favorite TV shows are Breaking Bad, Family Guy, House of Cards, Game of Thrones, American Horror Story, Homeland and Glee. I look forward to debating things with all of you in the future. (As of January 2013 I have had over 1 million views since joining WhatCulture in September 2012. You can reach me at danieljamesbowen@hotmail.co.uk)