7 Ingenious Ways TV Shows Bounced Back From Awful Seasons
The most remarkable turnarounds in small-screen history.
One bad season is often enough to kill off a hit TV show. Once the bad reviews start trickling in and the viewers are tuning out in their thousands, network executives have tough decisions to make. Do they swing the axe now as a means of damage limitation, or give the series a chance to redeem itself with a risky renewal order?
History tells us that once the rot has set in, there's usually no going back. The Simpsons has been on a downward trajectory in quality terms since the turn of the millennium and, while Fox is unlikely to kill off the series that put it on the sitcom map, other shows with similarly inconsistent output haven't been so fortunate.
But every once in a while, broadcasters take a punt on a down-on-its-luck show and are rewarded for their faith. The writers return to the drawing board having learned from their mistakes and bring the series back from the brink.
Flagging TV shows have bounced back from terrible seasons and returned to form in many creative ways, from throwing out their format, to refreshing the cast, and here are some of the most ingenious ways they've pulled it off.
7. The Office US: Ditching The Template
The US version of The Office looked destined to join the long list of failed stateside remakes of British TV shows after its debut season.
It inherited a winning blueprint from the Ricky Gervais version across the pond, but stuck to it too rigidly, regurgitating its first season more or less scene for scene, give or take a few name changes and American accents.
Dunder Mifflin and its employees felt largely pointless to fans of the British Office, bringing nothing new to the paper company's proverbial table, but this changed dramatically in season two when the showrunners made the bold decision to ditch the blueprint and allow the series to stand on its own two feet.
Only when The Office US began to tell original stories did it come into its own and find a unique voice. Michael Scott turned out to be a thoroughly more endearing boss than David Brent, though no less socially or professionally inept, and the supporting cast also proved more than pale imitations of their Wernham Hogg counterparts.
With a larger episode count to flesh out these characters, the show was able to bide its time building relationships and rivalries with a level of depth the UK version was denied (though expert pacing and writing helped it more than compensate).
Did it ever hit the heights of the Gervais original? Not quite, but the American Office had both quality and quantity on its side for much of its nine-season run, and this all began with its stellar second series.
6. Parks And Recreation: Turning The Dynamic On Its Head
There's no denying that Parks and Recreation got off to a rough start, often drawing up favourable comparisons to co-creator Michael Schur's previous effort The Office (which he produced) during its difficult first season.
Amy Poehler's Leslie Knope was dismissed by many as a gender-swapped Michael Scott and the show's focus on cringey humour and generating awkward tension in every scene resulted in characters nobody really warmed to.
NBC could have pulled the plug right there, but the network was rewarded for its faith in the series. The difficult inaugural season was chalked up to experimentation and the show came back with a fresh focus and rejigged dynamic in season two.
Rather than overhauling Poehler's character, the showrunners dramatically changed how the other cast members responded to her overzealous nature. They were no longer annoyed by her, instead holding her in a begrudged esteem. The chemistry that was once missing was now there in spades.
With a new dynamic in place, the show was free to find its own voice, but Schur and his creative team made other meaningful improvements too. They widened the scope by expanding the setting to encompass and an entire town and its residents, avoiding the suffocating sameness that set into The Office in later seasons as a result.
5. Red Dwarf: Going Back To Basics
The general consensus on Red Dwarf is that it peaked somewhere between season five or six of its original run, but fell from grace when the creative duo behind it - Rob Grant and Doug Naylor - parted ways and the budget was increased.
There was a stronger sense of continuity in seasons seven and eight, the final two to air on BBC, and the showrunners pulled out all of the stops to up the scale. In the latter season, they resurrected the titular ship's dead crew to expand the cast of characters.
Red Dwarf was light years from its starting point, no longer a sitcom about a handful of characters in deep space. It was bigger, yet by no means better.
Unfunny and full of hamfisted special effects, season eight was low point for the sci-fi sitcom, with the novelty of the resurrected crew wearing off fast. Yet, almost two decades later Red Dwarf is breaking records on UK comedy channel Dave.
After the broadcaster brought the show back for the three-part special Back to Earth, the interest it generated saw a trio of new seasons commissioned in the ensuing years, and they have helped the channel reach all-time high viewer figures.
Seasons 10, 11 and 12 are regarded as a return to form for the Boys From the Dwarf, recapturing the old magic more times that you might expect from a series that took so many years out, and the secret to its recent success is returning to the original format.
The latest seasons focus squarely on the main quartet lost in deep space, vintage jokes, practical effects and standalone stories. It's a smegging timeless formula.
4. Blackadder: Reinventing The Protagonist
On any list of the greatest British comedies, Blackadder should be up there with Only Fools and Horses, but it's easy to forget the period sitcom got off to a false start.
The first series is widely regarded as the weakest of the bunch, not just by fans and critics, but by the cast and showrunners too, and a big part of the problem is the way the protagonist was portrayed.
The original Blackadder was naive, snivelling and unlikable with less upstairs than Baldrick, whose cunning plans in season one were actually cunning on occasion.
When fans cannot root for the lead, the show has failed, but Blackadder's showrunners got creative in season two, throwing out the format and starting over.
The series upped sticks from the Middle Ages to Elizabethan England and introduced the fans to an all-new Blackadder, a descendent of his predecessor in series one, and this one was cunning, shrewd, witty and a smash hit with audiences.
Edmund 2.0 was the driving force behind Blackadder's rejuvenation, but it wasn't the only sweeping change that paid dividends. The budget was slashed for season two, and this was a blessing in disguise, forcing the writers to focus on dialogue and character interaction, rather than set pieces filmed on location.
Lead actor Rowan Atkinson also handed writing duties over to Ben Elton, the sharp pen behind the Young Ones, and he brought the same youthful energy to Blackadder.
3. Sons Of Anarchy: Risking Predictability
After two solid seasons of traditional biker grit, Sons of Anarchy showrunner Kurt Sutter shook things up in season three and shifted the action to Northern Ireland in the latter half of it. This decision backfired like a poorly-maintained motorcycle.
Not only did the third season suffer from pacing issues as it built up to the trip abroad, taking the story overseas was misguided and the results were forgettable.
They say second seasons are tough, but third and fourth ones can be even tougher. By this point, the audience wants to see that the show they've invested in isn't just a one-trick pony. They want variety, reinvention and new experiences.
Sutter rose to the challenge of delivering those things, and when the Ireland-set series three bombed, some critics assumed Sons of Anarchy was a spent force, while others called for the showrunner to do something drastically creative to reinvent the show.
He was under pressure to have another stab at a fresh format, but ironically, returning to its core themes is what helped the show regain form in season four. After the Ireland excursion turned out to be a failed experiment, Sutter risked being branded with the ‘predictable’ tag by revisiting the original formula - a gamble that paid off.
Sons of Anarchy was able to send Jax and the gang along roads well-travelled because it seriously upped the stakes in season four. Much of the Sons’ upper level got out of prison after 14 months and they returned to a Charming in transition.
Smart additions to the cast, including Ray McKinnon’s intense District Attorney Lincoln Potter, amped up the conflict and the relationship between Jax and Clay mutated when hints that the latter had a hand in the death of the protagonist’s father emerged.
The focus also shifted towards Jax’s desire to succeed where his old man failed and break free of the club, and this cranked the stakes and drama up even further.
Many of the fixes were simple ones that were well executed, but it was Sutter’s decision to look to the past that made season four one of Sons of Anarchy’s strongest.
2. Homeland: Hitting The ‘Soft Reboot’ Button
There’s case to argue that Homeland should have ended after season two, albeit with a modified ending that saw Nicholas Brody perish in its explosive finale.
The spy thriller had wrapped up all of its meaningful loose ends bar Brody’s fate by this point, leaving the third season with one job to do, and it failed miserably at it by denying Damian Lewis’ character any screen time in half of its episodes.
The Brody-free portion of the season was largely dedicated to filler storylines based around his teenage daughter and few things about it worked. The writing seemed to be on the wall for Homeland when the showrunners confirmed they were pressing ahead with plans for an all-new season sans Lewis.
Although some fans will always maintain Homeland should have died with Brody, the majority of those who gave season four a chance will admit it was a return to form. Hitting the soft reboot switch gave the show a renewed energy, focus and relevance. This time, the storytelling was more streamlined and many of the ideas it tabled about America and the war on terrorism rang true.
Claire Danes continued to shine in the role of Carrie, earning Screen Actors Guild Award and Golden Globe nominations for her performance in season four, and the writers plumbed the depths of her character arc and revealed the kind of substance the previous series only hinted at.
1. Lost: Refocusing During Hiatus
After a strong debut season, Lost felt like it was treading water throughout its second run, with nothing of any real consequence happening from episode to episode.
It was posing more questions than answers on a weekly basis and showrunner Damon Lindelof even admitted that most fans he spoke with at the time accused him of making it up as he was going along.
But Lost did recover eventually. During the first half of season three, the tried and tested flashback technique was growing stale, fan-favourite characters were denied the spotlight, and newcomers such as Nikki and Paulo failed to win the audience over.
The second half of the third series, however, was critically acclaimed and it's all because the showrunners used a hiatus wisely. Lost went off for a winter break to refocus and came roaring back with sweeping changes on board.
Nikki and Paulo were killed off, some of the conundrums posed in the first half of the season were dealt with, answers to several of the enduring mysteries were scripted in and the pacing was cranked up.
To assure fans the writers weren't just making things up on the spot, ABC announced at this point that Lost would reach a rounded conclusion within three seasons.