7 Problems With True Detective Season 2 That Nobody Wants To Admit

Season 1 was a flat circle, but Season 2 might just be a dead end.

The rabidly-awaited of True Detective season two airs on HBO this Sunday (with a repeat on Monday for fans in the UK), and will surely draw huge numbers thanks to its star-studded cast - and the success of its initial run. Nic Pizzolatto's crime drama drew immense critical acclaim when it hit screens in early 2014, managing to be simultaneously gritty and spectacular as it told the tale of two mutually-loathing police detectives on the trail of a nightmarish Louisiana cult. But Pizzolatto and co. have taken a huge risk in ripping up their successful formula and starting all over again, banishing McConaughey, Harrelson, and its haunting deep south setting to the past. The new season promises an entirely different location and a set of new (but similarly renowned) stars in the form of Colin Farrell, Vince Vaughn and Rachel McAdams. Could this be a catastrophic mistake? Although the build to Sunday's premier has set fans' pulses racing, several potentially key flaws have been revealed along the way - chinks in the True Detective armour that could tarnish the series' much-admired legacy. Here are seven big reasons True Detective season two won't live up to the hype, especially after such a well received initial outing.

7. It Can't Live Up To The Original

True Detective's first season was hailed as a masterpiece of atmosphere, fragmented storytelling and visual impact. It's breathtaking look and feel - courtesy of Cary Fukunga's inspired directing - aligned with a chilling, dramatic, and ultimately optimistic storyline to create one of the most unique shows of its highly-populated genre. Simply put, season two has a great deal to live up to, and it probably can't. The series' newcomer's advantages are gone, meaning it now has to generate interest entirely under its own esteem. The decision to start all over again, ditching the initial cast and setting in favour of a whole new direction, is a huge gamble - one which could prove to be a serious mistake.

6. Forgivable Flaws Could Become Repeated Mistakes

As great as the first season was, it was far from perfect - yet these flaws were often overlooked or forgiven due to the show's more obvious strengths. However, if repeated, such missteps could become far more detrimental. The main flaw with season one was the feeling that not every loose end was properly tied up. Fans of any series as fanatically followed as True Detective are going to demand total closure, an incredibly difficult thing to achieve in just a few hour-long episodes. In the end, many key plot points weren't as fully expanded on as they perhaps should have been (the bizarre family history of the antagonistic cult, for one), and the finale boiled down to a chase-and-fight sequence which felt disappointingly generic for such a unique series. Season two now has to avoid such convention at all costs, or risk feeling the wrath of unfulfilled fans of its older brother. Season one could get away with such mistakes - season two will have no such excuse.

5. The Actors Have Unfillable Shoes To Fill

True Detective has again pushed the boat out in terms of casting, finding a trio of big names to play three of its main characters. Colin Farrell and Rachel McAdams are a pair of detectives-at-odds, whose clashing methods and personalities are sure to bring back memories of Marty and Rust. Meanwhile, Vince Vaughn co-stars as a career criminal looking to legitimise his empire, and will surely act as the chief suspect (and potential red herring?) of the series. The black sheep is Taylor Kitsch in the suspiciously action-hero role of war veteran/motorcycle cop, an actor whose questionable pedigree pales into insignificance next to his co-stars, let alone his lauded predecessors Woody Harrelson and Matthew McConaughey. True Detective's original leading lights turned in a near-flawless pair of performances, stacking the odds firmly against season two's newcomers.

4. The Location Is Too Conventional

While season one's uniqueness was further highlighted by its distinctive location, the deep backwaters of rural Louisiana, the screenwriters have taken the incredibly risky decision of setting season two in the far more conventional location of California. The seldom dwelled-upon expanse between Los Angeles and San Francisco leaves some room for originality, but its setting on the instantly familiar west coast anchors the whole series in a way which could render it disappointingly predictable and conventional. In order to avoid resembling a new CSI spin-off, the creators of True Detective are going to have to pull some truly unique locations and shots out of the bag. Another blow is the loss of season one director Cary Fukunga. His now-legendary six minute tracking shot is regarded as one of the best long sequences in television history, and his departure will be sorely felt.

3. It Could Lose Its Sense Of Originality

As well as the obvious visual change, its California location, True Detective could also lose its atmospheric originality. With a larger cast and bustling setting, as well as an incredibly excited fanbase to satisfy, there's a very real worry that season two could tear along at breakneck speed, a necessary increase of pace to cram everything into its eight episodes. If it does so, all sense of season one's intoxicating originality could be lost. Although often guilty of crawling along at a snail's pace, Rust and Marty's storyline was more measured than plodding, taking time to properly develop characters and tantalise the audience with the slow unravelling of its central mystery. This also ensured that the high-octane moments had the capacity to truly stand out and shock. Season two looks set to ditch its characteristic poise in favour of a decidedly cheaper set of thrills.

2. The Plot Isn't As Immediately Grabbing

Season one introduced viewers to an utterly compelling pair of central figures - establishing an immediate tension between the pair, as well as a fully developed set of three-dimensional traits and flaws. The plot was also sprinkled with nuggets of unsettling, irresistible information: a young girls' ritualistic murder, rumours of a satanic cult, and abstract (but intriguing) clues such as "the Yellow King" and "Carcosa". From the trailer and released information of season two, nothing quite measures up. The protagonists are investigating the murder of a man involved in local transportation, an introduction not nearly as grabbing as the sordid nature of season one. Fortunately there's plenty of depravity in store (at least one orgy scene is rumoured, and sexual scandal is thought to be a key theme) but nobody is immediately excited by talk of traffic patterns and freeway plans.

1. It's Straying Into Cliche

True Detective originally earned such acclaim through its originality; it was truly like no other crime drama before it, showcasing a depth and philosophical nature atypical of the genre. Season two simply can't live up to such a unique predecessor, already hamstrung by its setting and basic plot. So many aspects of season two have been seen many times before: friction between law enforcement departments; an undercurrent of potential sexual scandal and/or deprivation; shady mob kingpins with links to legitimate businesses - all have been explored and dissected in detail before. Even the characters reek of cliche. Colin Farrell is a morally ambiguous cop with potential ties to the criminal underworld, while Rachel McAdams is an ethically-obsessed by-the-book type. Hopefully True Detective proves this article wrong and knocks it out of the park over the next eight weeks, but all the signs seem to indicate that it won't.

Content Producer
Content Producer

Highly overrated 23 year old from the North East of England. Hanging off of your gangster car.