8 Actors Who Regretted Leaving Doctor Who

After being in a show as big as Doctor Who, the only way to go is down.

Rose Tyler Doomsday beach Doctor Who
BBC

From an actor's perspective, one of the strange things about joining Doctor Who must be the short-term nature of the job. If you're entering the Whoniverse as a companion or even as a Doctor, you know you're only going to be there for two or three years, at which point, you'll essentially be replaced - and the show will continue on.

But even though most actors probably have this rough end date in mind from the moment they set foot in the TARDIS, that doesn't mean they won't end up feeling regretful when those last moments finally arrive.

Whether their tenure ended on a sour note or they felt like they had more to give, some Doctor Who actors feel huge regret over their decisions - whether voluntary or forced - to leave the show. And hell, you can't blame them - a lot of fans would crawl across ten miles of broken glass just to smell David Tennant's old PE shoes.

Now yes, every Doctor Who actor probably regrets leaving the show in some small way, but here are a few stars who actually spoke about these feelings publicly.

8. Elisabeth Sladen

Sarah Jane Smith
BBC

During her initial run in the classic series, Elisabeth Sladen worked with two Doctors over a three-year period, appearing in four separate seasons to boot. She became a fan-favourite, an important part of the show, and an icon in her own right.

Because of how well her tenure was received, Sladen felt quite fulfilled when the time came for her to move on, and she was pleased with what she'd managed to achieve.

However... she did also feel a touch of regret.

In an interview from the 1980's, Sladen talks about how her Doctor Who exit was entirely her decision, and how she was pleased that none of the BBC higher-ups gave her "a quiet push". At the same time, she also says that she "felt regret" about leaving, presumably because a part of her wanted to stick with the show for even longer.

With hindsight, we now know that Sladen's relationship with Doctor Who was far from over (she even ended up getting her own spinoff), but back then, she probably thought she was done for good, so it's no surprise that she felt that small twinge of regret.


7. Sylvester McCoy

Sylvester McCoy Doctor Who
BBC

On the opposite side of things, Sylvester McCoy's Doctor Who exit was something that he didn't get to decide for himself. Instead, the show was cancelled and he was effectively just left without a job, but even though he had no say in the matter, McCoy still feels deep regret over everything that happened around that time.

Due to several factors - including falling ratings - Doctor Who was taken off the air in 1989, through no fault of the actors. In fact, the show had started to improve in quality since the Colin Baker years, and it really felt like McCoy (along with co-star Sophie Aldred) had hit his stride when the BBC suddenly pulled the plug - and this is precisely why he feels regret over the premature end of his tenure:

"[My] third season was great, and I think if we’d gone to a fourth season it might have been really great. But we didn’t, and life is full of regrets."

McCoy's final season wasn't spectacular or anything, but it worked quite well, and there was definitely the potential for greatness if the show had been given more time. Sadly, as it stands, all we can do is join McCoy in regretting that missed opportunity.


6. Matt Smith

Doctor Who-Matt-Smith-Eleventh-Doctor-Old
BBC

Matt Smith's Eleventh Doctor spent the second half of his final series travelling the universe with companion Clara Oswald, played by Jenna Coleman.

It was a typically friendly Doctor-companion dynamic, albeit one with a lot of tension bubbling beneath the surface, mainly on the Doctor's part. He couldn't fully trust her because he didn't really know who she was, a mystery that wasn't resolved until series finale The Name Of The Doctor, which revealed Clara's "Impossible Girl" backstory.

The Eleventh Doctor regenerated a couple of episodes later, which, from Smith's point of view, was a bit of a shame, because he wishes he'd got to spend more time with Coleman by doing an extra series of the show.

At New York Comic-Con in 2016, Smith stated that one of his "great regrets" is that he left Doctor Who without getting to do a full series with Coleman (remember, they only got to do half a series together, at the back end of Series 7).

Eleven and Clara were a fun pair, and it would've been nice to see them get a complete series set after the conclusion of the Impossible Girl arc. Big Finish, help us!


5. Peter Davison

Fifth Doctor Peter Davison Doctor Who
BBC Studios

In what is a rare situation for the majority of Doctors, Peter Davison bowed out on what might be his very best story. 1984's The Caves Of Androzani is a perennial classic, and even though ending on a high note is good, it was a shame that he regenerated at the exact same time his era peaked in quality.

Depending on your stance then, Davison's exit can either be viewed as timely or wasteful, and it seems like the actor himself may lean slightly towards the latter.

Over the years, Davison has expressed regret at not doing an extra season of the show. Even though he set himself a three-year limit when he first signed up, he wasn't so certain when the time came to actually regenerate, and due to the strength of some of his later stories, he came very close to sticking with Doctor Who for another year:

"I hummed and hawed for a long time. I had set myself three years, not knowing how I would feel at the end of those three years. It was touch and go - I almost did a fourth year. If I’d been offered Doctor Who when I was, say, fifty, then I would have gone on for many, many years."

While it does have its moments, the Colin Baker era is a low point for classic Who, so it definitely would've been interesting to see how things went if Davison had held on just a little bit longer. If The Caves Of Androzani is any indication, then a fourth season of the Fifth Doctor would've turned out really well.


4. Lalla Ward

Doctor Who Romana Lalla Ward
BBC Studios

A companion to the Fourth Doctor towards the end of his run, Lalla Ward played the Time Lady Romana from 1979's Destiny Of The Daleks, to 1981's Warriors' Gate.

Like most Doctor Who stars, the decision to leave was entirely her own, with Ward informing producer John Nathan-Turner that she wanted to exit in the middle of her next season, which was a choice that he completely supported.

However, when the time came to actually sign off for good, Ward began to regret her decision - to the extent that she ended up absolutely hating her final story:

"I absolutely loathed ‘Warriors' Gate’ because it was my last one. I felt particularly regretful, I’d become so very close to the show."

Now, Warriors' Gate is actually a pretty good serial, which Ward does also acknowledge. But you can understand her emotions here: imagine if you had the best party of your life, and afterwards, you were banned from having any more parties in the future. You still had a great last hurrah... but you'd probably hate it at the same time.


3. Christopher Eccleston

Christopher Eccleston Doctor Who
BBC Studios

We've all heard the stories about how Christopher Eccleston felt drained after working on Doctor Who, and it feels fair to say that, overall, the production of his sole series was a negative experience for him. But even in spite of this, there were still elements of positivity to be found.

Eccleston loved playing the Ninth Doctor, something he recently reiterated when it was announced that he'd be returning to the role for Big Finish. He found joy in this character, and despite certain other factors leading to a poor time on set, he actually came to regret the fact that he didn't get a second series.

In 2016, he said that it was "tragic" that he didn't get to do more with the role, and that he harbours some regrets about the early end of his tenure, because he believes that his performance would've only improved if he'd continued for a second series.

Instead, David Tennant was cast as the Tenth Doctor and he ended up being fantastic, but it does sting a little that we missed out on a bit more onscreen Eccleston. Let's hope that his upcoming audio adventures knock it out of the park.


2. Paul McGann

Paul McGann Doctor Who
BBC Studios

While Paul McGann didn't have a say when it came to the end of his Doctor Who tenure, he still has some regrets about how the whole situation went down.

Easily one of the most underappreciated Doctors of all time (seriously, that outfit is a work of art), McGann's stint behind the TARDIS controls lasted for just a single television movie, which - due to some low ratings - was not picked up for a full series.

It was an unfortunate turn of events, and while McGann did nothing wrong, he still feels regretful about the premature end of his Doctor Who era, and in a chat with The Independent, he unabashedly admitted that continuing to play the Eighth Doctor would've had a very lucrative impact on his career:

"[Doctor Who] could've been very different. I would've been there for five or six years... and I'd have earned a s**t-load of dough. Life wouldn't have been the same but it didn't happen."

The 1996 TV movie wasn't the end of McGann's Doctor Who career: he starred in his very own 50th anniversary mini-episode, as well as appearing in countless Big Finish audio dramas. Still, it's hard not to feel a little bit sorry for him, considering that this role of a lifetime was cut short due to factors outside his control.


1. Billie Piper

Doctor Who Rose Tyler Sad
BBC

Billie Piper returned to Doctor Who a number of times after her initial 2006 exit. The actress played Rose in 2008's series finale and 2010's The End Of Time: Part Two, before playing a different character - The Moment - in 2013's The Day Of The Doctor.

She's also done lots of Big Finish audio dramas over the last several years, making it clear that she really loves Doctor Who, and that she's really enjoyed getting to explore Rose over such a long period of time. The easy paycheques probably don't hurt, either.

Unsurprisingly then - for someone who finds great joy in the Doctor Who world - the actress was somewhat regretful over her decision to leave the show in 2006.

In an interview from that same year, she confessed that she misses Rose desperately, and that she's "jealous" that she's no longer a part of the Doctor Who machine. Then, in early 2007, she admitted that leaving "could still turn out to be a really bad choice", adding that her Doctor Who exit was partly because she wanted to try new things.

In hindsight, it obviously wasn't a bad choice - again, she returned to Doctor Who many more times, and has starred in various acclaimed projects over the last ten years - but still, Piper clearly struggled with her decision to leave the Whoniverse behind.


Watch Next


Doctor Who Quiz: Rose Tyler - True Or False?

Doctor Who Captain Jack Harkness
BBC Studios

1. Jack Believed Rose Was A Time Agent Upon Meeting Her In "The Empty Child".

In this post: 
Doctor Who
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Danny has been with WhatCulture for over ten years, and is currently Doctor Who Editor and WhoCulture Channel Manager, overseeing all of WhatCulture's Whoniverse coverage. In 2022, he took charge of WhoCulture and has grown it into the biggest Doctor Who channel on YouTube, and one of the biggest Doctor Who communities on the web full-stop. He has been writing and video editing since his early teens, and first got a taste for content creation after making his own Doctor Who trailers, off the back of a burning obsession with the Matt Smith era of the show. Like many his age, he first got into Doctor Who with the 2005 revival, but has since gone back and fallen in love with the classic years too. If you need someone to recite every Doctor Who episode in order, or to give you a random factoid about the making of Gridlock, Danny is the person to ask!