8 Doctor Who Episodes Ruined By Their Endings
Love & Monsters was a decent episode - right up until the Abzorbaloff ruined the whole thing.
Doctor Who episodes have to cram a lot of things into a brief 45-minute runtime.
They have to introduce a complicated sci-fi or fantasy concept, bring in a large group of supporting characters (and, more often than not, find inventive ways to kill them off), create an interesting and memorable villain, give the companions something useful to do, and, most importantly, find a way for the Doctor to fix everything that doesn't feel too easy.
And just to make things even more complicated, the BBC gives the showrunners a budget of about five quid.
To put it another way, creating Doctor Who is a highly difficult task, so it should be considered a small miracle when we get an episode that's merely okay - but at the same time, this doesn't mean we should forgive an episode's weak points.
One weak point that many NuWho stories have in common is an underwhelming ending, which can ruin a potentially great episode, or make a bad one even worse. Either way, it's painful to see a story fall flat on its face at the finish line...
8. Can You Hear Me?
Series 12's Can You Hear Me? introduced a pair of villains who rank among the most powerful in Doctor Who lore.
Eternals who've been kicking around for millennia, Zellin and Rakaya are basically gods, and to them, humans are nothing more than ants beneath their feet. Their powers are immense: they can move throughout time and space, teleport inside the TARDIS, induce nightmares in their victims, and destroy planets for a bit of fun.
Basically, they're unbelievably strong and nearly impossible to defeat, which the episode makes clear on numerous occasions - but for some reason, they didn't get the ending that their skillset would seem to warrant.
In a noticeably rushed conclusion, the Doctor dispatches not just one of them, but both of them in 90 seconds flat, without the two villains putting up much of a fight. Perhaps realising that Zellin and Rakaya were too powerful, it feels like the writers nerfed them in order to wrap the story up on time, sucking all the energy out of what should have been an epic final showdown.
The episode was all twisty and trippy up until this point too, one of the more unique episodes of the Whittaker era - so it's a shame that it fumbled the ending.
7. The Next Doctor
It might not seem possible for a show as crazy as Doctor Who to go too over-the-top, but sometimes, it does.
2008 Christmas special The Next Doctor is a brilliant episode for most of its runtime, with the unusual connection between the Tenth Doctor and Jackson Lake leading to several funny, heart-warming, and emotional moments, supported by two excellent performances from David Tennant and David Morrissey.
It's a character-focused and surprisingly intimate tale of a man who is struggling with his identity, and even the villain plot - featuring the Cybermen - is quite low-key, and doesn't distract from that heavy emotional core.
Annoyingly though, the episode completely jumps the shark in its final third, in which an enormous, Iron Giant-style Cyberman stomps around Victorian London, firing off missiles and blowing everything to bits.
Sure, it's mindlessly entertaining, but following on from the rest of the episode, you can't help but feel like a more grounded finale would work much better. This Cyber-King represents a jarring shift in scale - figuratively and literally - and it feels inconsistent with the personal character drama at the core of the episode.
6. Closing Time
British export James Corden is that rare celebrity guest star who returned to Doctor Who for a second time.
His first episode was Series 5's The Lodger - a fun comedy caper that was intended as a bit of light relief before all the universe-destroying in the finale. Then, his second episode was Series 6's Closing Time, which also served as a breezy adventure, letting audiences have a laugh and a giggle before the much darker final story.
As a result, Closing Time is an entertaining yet unremarkable episode that finds comedy in thrusting the Doctor into a fish-out-of-water domestic setting, with a Cyberman plot thrown in to give the Time Lord an enemy to defeat.
It's all very serviceable and the story works well enough, right up until a cringey and quite frankly ridiculous climax in which the Cybermen are defeated via the power of love. Sigh. This happens when Corden's character, Craig, hears his baby son crying out for him, which somehow sends an "emotional influx" into all of the Cybermen, blowing them up. It doesn't make sense, and the melodrama is unbearable.
"Love conquers all" endings are rarely satisfying. But the fact that the Cybermen are one of the most iconic and powerful foes in Doctor Who history makes Closing Time's ending ten times worse than any other example of this trope in the show.
5. Resolution
Resolution is easily one of the better episodes in the lacklustre Series 11, but it isn't without its flaws, and the ending is a big one.
The plot of the episode centres around an immensely powerful lone Dalek, which is capable of possessing the bodies of humans in order to remain undetected. This thing is an absolute monster - in one scene, it single-handedly takes down a small army of trigger-happy soldiers with apparent ease - but frustratingly, the ending does a complete 180 on its portrayal, making it seem quite weak and incompetent.
In a baffling scene, this Dalek - which was previously shown to have pinpoint accuracy - fails to hit the Doctor (or her allies) when they're running right towards it, in a wide open room. Then - to make things worse - the Doctor defeats it by simply sticking microwave components to its casing. Right.
The episode seemed to be building to a much more interesting and difficult confrontation between the Doctor and the Dalek, but the confrontation we did get was laughable, completely stripping the Dalek of its established badass status.
Another thing that drags the episode down in its final stretch is the painfully unfunny wi-fi joke, one of many instances in the Chibnall era in which the showrunner forces in some lame dad humour. And let's not even talk about the fact that the Doctor nearly fires an innocent man into a supernova...
4. The Almost People
While most Doctor Who episodes include a big bad monster for the Doctor to vanquish, Series 6's The Rebel Flesh/The Almost People did things a bit differently.
In this story, the "villains" are just ordinary humans, who are desperately trying to survive. A solar storm at an isolated factory has led to the small group of people who work there (along with the Doctor, who is paying them a visit) being duplicated, meaning that they have to fight themselves - literally - in order to escape.
This results in an atmospheric and tense story that explores several fascinating philosophical questions: what does it mean to be human? Should the duplicates be considered real people? Do the original humans have the right to kill their clones?
It's interesting to watch the characters struggle with these questions, and the story shows some impressive restraint by remaining in this grounded territory throughout, not feeling the need to shoehorn in one of those aforementioned big bad monsters.
That is, until the very end of the second episode, in which our characters run down a suspiciously long corridor while being chased by an unconvincing, messy blob of pixels. This is easily the worst scene in the entire two-parter: not only is the CGI terrible, but this monster really does come out of nowhere, almost like the writers felt the need to cram in a monster at the eleventh hour.
It's a shame that the story didn't have an ending that was as engaging as the deep-seated drama that preceded it - this one was a real missed opportunity.
3. Last Of The Time Lords
Series 3's Utopia/The Sound Of Drums/Last Of The Time Lords is the most underappreciated finale in the Russell T Davies era. Sure, people generally like it, but compared to The Parting Of The Ways, Doomsday, Journey's End, and The End Of Time, Last Of The Time Lords is definitely the red-headed stepchild of the bunch.
There are many possible reasons why people don't give it as much credit as the others, and a big one has to be the episode's weak conclusion.
In Last Of The Time Lords, the Doctor faces one of the most devastating predicaments of his time-travelling career, having been reduced to a weak and frail old man by the Master, who reigns supreme over planet Earth. It feels like there's no way out for the Doctor, setting the stage for that clever and satisfying moment where he manages to overcome the odds and save the Earth from its tyrannical dictator.
Unfortunately though, "satisfying" cannot be used to describe Last Of The Time Lords' ending, in which the Doctor magically turns into space Jesus after everyone on planet Earth chants his name at the exact same time.
This resolution of an epic and thoroughly engaging three-part story was a massive letdown. It felt as though Davies had written himself into a corner and couldn't figure out a compelling solution, forcing him to go with something stupid and easy instead.
2. The Power Of Three
The Power Of Three gave us the chance to spend some quality time with Amy and Rory, before their departure in the following episode.
We get to see them living their ordinary domestic lives, including parties, barbeques, TV-watching, and work, and on top of this, there are also tons of scenes featuring Rory's dad, Brian - and more Brian is never a bad thing.
This side of the episode is satisfying and fun to see, but the same cannot be said of the other major component of the story: the invasion of the black cubes.
To be more precise, it's the conclusion of this specific plot thread that feels completely underwhelming (the air of mystery and dread surrounding the cubes for the first two-thirds of the story is handled really well). The perpetrator of the invasion shows up for a minute or two, does nothing, and then just disappears into thin air, while the Doctor fixes everything with a few waves of his sonic screwdriver.
There are rumours that behind-the-scenes drama led to this rushed and disappointing climax, but whatever the cause, The Power Of Three was only a polished ending away from being a truly great episode.
1. Love & Monsters
Love & Monsters has a reputation for being one of the worst episodes in Doctor Who history, and while it's certainly a contender, it's not as though the entire episode is an irredeemable trainwreck.
The premise - a group of strangers, fascinated by the Doctor, form a club to try and track him down - is a strong one, and it's interesting to see how the ordinary citizens of the Whoniverse perceive all the alien chaos that occurs on a regular basis. Sure, the Tenth Doctor could've had more screen time, but the characters are entertaining enough to carry the story - and you can't go wrong with a bit of ELO.
Unfortunately, the episode's good work does not extend into its painfully low-budget finale, in which the monster-of-the-week - basically, Peter Kay in a green fat suit - runs through the back alleys of Cardiff, screeching in an annoying auto-tuned voice.
It's the kind of scene that gives Doctor Who a bad reputation with people who aren't fans of the show - the people who think it's just a silly kids programme with naff special effects. We're certainly not saying that the first two-thirds of Love & Monsters is top-tier Doctor Who. It's not. But the ending is the worst thing about it, and if it had been a bit better? Then the episode would've been just fine.
Not exactly high praise, but "fine" is far better than "makes you want to claw your eyeballs out".
Watch Next
Doctor Who Quiz: How Well Do You REALLY Know David Tennant's 10th Doctor?