8 Great Characters Marvel And DC's TV Shows Have Completely Screwed Up

And you thought Batman v Superman's Doomsday looked bad.

Just like superhero movies are arguably better now than ever before, so too are the TV shows. However, while the likes of Daredevil, The Flash, and Legends of Tomorrow are in many ways outshining Marvel and DC's big screen adaptations, that hasn't always been the case. In fact, even the greatest shows get some of their best characters horribly wrong. While you'd think that a 13 or 22 episode series would take advantage of all that extra time to get the heroes and villains they feature right, they more often than not somehow completely drop the ball and deliver a version of the character who is either nowhere near as good as their comic book counterpart or just handled poorly enough to do some long lasting damage to their legacy. With so many superhero TV shows and almost countless characters in them, singling out the worst of the worst is no easy feat, but that's what you'll find here. Both Marvel and DC are guilty of f***ing up some of their best creations on the small screen, and these are the eight worst examples of those. Some you'll recognise and others you may have been lucky enough to forget, but they're all great characters who haven't been treated anywhere near as well as they deserved to be on the small screen.

8. Doomsday

The arrival of Doomsday in Smallville should have been a crowning achievement for The CW series, but it instead served as a warning of why TV shows like this should never try to push the boundaries without the budget to match their ambition. As you can see from the image above, he ended up looking terrible, and never once felt like a legitimate threat to Clark Kent as a result (their battle was also massively underwhelming). Rather than making him a mindless beast, the show also turned Doomsday into a werewolf type creature with a human side, an overly convoluted way of telling the villain's story which quickly fell flat despite a mostly decent performance from Sam Witwer as Davis Bloome, the secret child of Zod and Faora. Between this and the laughable rubber costume, everything about this version of Doomsday was ultimately a dismal failure.

7. Agent Coulson

The resurrection of Agent Coulson was a mistake, but Marvel wanted a familiar face to launch Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. with and the popular character (who had been killed off a year earlier in The Avengers) obviously made sense to them. However, following a convoluted explanation about how he was brought back to life, the ABC series has stripped away nearly everything which made fans fall in love with him in the first place. Placing him in charge of S.H.I.E.L.D.-lite has made Coulson just another bureaucrat, and he's become the least interesting character in a show which doesn't exactly have the most exciting leads to begin with. Whereas Coulson's death could have been a memorable way to wrap up Marvel's Phase 1, it's now meaningless, and a long forgotten plot point for a series that feels like it's running on fumes after less than three years.

6. The Penguin

Gotham has so far been very hit and miss, particularly when it comes to the portrayal of some of Batman's most iconic villains. One of the biggest issues is that some have just been introduced far too soon, and that's definitely the case with Robin Lord Taylor's take on Oswald Cobblepot. Forcing the "Penguin" nickname from day one thanks to a ridiculous limp which has never gone away, his rise up the ranks has been ridiculous. He's gone from carrying a gangster's umbrella (geddit?) to pretty much taking over Gotham City, and while things aren't going to well for him right now, this is a story arc which should have played out over several seasons, not just the first. As entertaining as Taylor often is, his hammy performance also doesn't really help matters, and it's fair to say that The Penguin's origin is shaping up to be the worst part of this prequel.

5. Ben Urich

Daredevil was such a fantastic series that I feel almost guilty bringing up a character from the Netflix drama here, but there's no denying that reporter Ben Urich could and should have been handled much better. His death may have come as a shock, but it was tremendous waste of a great character who never met his true potential; the show never even got around to touching on his relationship with Matt Murdock and Daredevil. Comic book fans will be well aware that he sat on the secret that they were one and the same for years, often working closely with Daredevil to help him in his battles against the likes of The Kingpin and Elektra. While the series did a good job of showing off what a great reporter he was, it still never really delved into what makes him such a special character and frustratingly killed Ben off before that ever become a real possibility.

4. The Absorbing Man

Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. often feels like the unwanted child of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, and that perhaps explains why the series so often gets lumbered with the characters Kevin Feige has little interest in doing much with. While the ABC series has handled some of those better than others, The Absorbing Man ended up being a let down and a long way from the same comic book villain who's gone toe to toe with The Hulk. Despite finding a clever way to reference his history as a boxer in Daredevil, Marvel definitely didn't do a good job with Crusher Creel, essentially making him a one off villain who was defeated by Coulson's team with relative ease. Had he just been another Inhuman threat for the team to face this maybe wouldn't have felt so bad, but knowing his comic book history and the amazing things he's done there makes this take a failure.

3. Wonder Woman

This Wonder Woman TV series may have never made it to air, but the pilot was still bad enough to put the breaks on the character's return to live-action for several years. Starring Adrianne Palicki in a costume which looked like it came straight out of a low budget porn parody, the leaked season premiere was savaged by those who managed to get their eyes on it and ridiculed for some baffling deviations from the source material. Had this take on Wonder Woman actually been picked up, the damage would have been irreparable, but Warner Bros. lack of understanding of the character still resulted in another failed TV show on The CW and a string of failed attempts to bring her to the big screen. However, everything from the costume to the inclusion of the Invisible Plane doomed this one from the start, and NBC got literally everything about the hero wrong.

2. Peggy Carter

Following her appearance in Captain America: The First Avenger and the Agent Carter One-Shot, fans were keen to see more of Peggy Carter, but was a TV the best idea? Based on the way things have played out so far, I would say no. While the show isn't exactly bad, it's pretty underwhelming, and two seasons of her adventures have so far done nothing to really shed any light on how she ended up being a founder of S.H.I.E.L.D. Instead, the series has glossed over Peggy's grief over the loss of Steve Rogers, thrown in some familiar names and faces, and got bogged down in the character's transition from fighting during WWII to one day creating that peacekeeping task force. Seeing that now would have been much more interesting, but the longer Agent Carter portrays Peggy "between jobs", the more damage it will do to her as a fan-favourite.

1. Superman

The first five seasons of Smallville actually did a pretty good job with telling the story of the young Clark Kent, but it was all downhill from there. As well as messing up characters like Lex Luthor and Lana Lang, the whole "no tights, no flights" rule really started holding the show back, and Superman soon started coming across as the worst superhero in his own show. Even his cousin Supergirl made him look like a chump. In a desperate bid to prolong the story, Clark was put in a black trencoat to fight crime (the closest the show ever got to a costume, but even then he was still a blur) and not even the series finale managed to redeem years worth of misfires. Tom Welling donned the iconic suit, but was only seen from the neck up, and so it ended up being a blessed relief when Smallville came to an end and stopped damaging Superman's legacy. Which other Marvel and DC TV characters do you think deserve to be on this list? Share your picks below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

Josh Wilding hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.