8 Reasons You're Allowed To Hate Daryl From The Walking Dead

Don't worry, it's okay to yank him off the pedestal.

Daryl Dixon is the most popular character on television today. That might sound like hyperbole, but if you've ever typed his name (or the actor who plays him, Norman Reedus) into Google, you would know this to be true. And it's not hard to see why, either. As the loner redneck/ultimate pragmatist in a group full of codependent, emotional pinballs (a reasonable thing to be in a zombie apocalypse, to be fair), Daryl represents the kind of stoic badass we all would like to be in that situation. He acts as a blank slate for fans of the show to project themselves onto. And because of that, it makes it very difficult to find any flaws in him. Finding flaws in Daryl is like finding flaws in ourselves. And who wants to do that? Certainly not the fans of this show. But despite his status as the de facto fan favorite, there actually are some things wrong with Mr. Dixon. I know no one wants to admit this, but he is not perfect. And we do have several reasons to dislike him. It's just a matter of admitting it to ourselves.

8. His Brother's Dickish Ways Rubbed Off On Him

In the early episodes of The Walking Dead, Daryl was known just the littlest Dixon. His big brother, Merle, was the primary antagonist against Rick and his ragtag group in the second episode, wherein Merle is left to die, chained to a pipe on a rooftop swarming with walkers. For a brief period after this, Daryl is a belligerent, unpleasant jerk to the rest of the survivors. As the season progressed, his edges softened, but he still remained firmly entrenched in the backwoods-y, morally questionable code of the Dixons. It would take a long time to shake the demons of his brother, because even when Merle wasn't physically there, he was always there in spirit to try to drive a wedge between his little brother and the group he'd chosen to stay with. Obviously, Daryl never went full-on "dark side" toward Rick or anyone else, but there were many times early on when Daryl wasn't the cool, calm, all-around nice dude he is now.

7. He's Too "Safe" To Be Killed Off

Does anyone really fret about Reedus' character being killed off? Even in the most harrowing of circumstances, it's almost a guarantee that, as long as The Walking Dead anticipates another season on the horizon, Daryl will make it to the next episode physically unscathed. Aside from Rick (and perhaps Rick's children), there's no one else on the show that has that kind of built-in safety net. And just like Rick (and his children), that makes Daryl a really boring character sometimes. Just once it would be nice to have Daryl wander into the woods with a legitimate threat to his safety lurking in the background. Of course, in order for that to happen, AMC would have to be willing to lose the sizable, very vocal Daryl Dixon fan club as routine viewers. From a business standpoint, Daryl is simply un-killable.

6. Daryl Dixon Fans Tend To Be Annoying As All Hell

Speaking of the Daryl Dixon fan club, it's about time someone stated just how obnoxious this group can be. It's fine to like Daryl. It's even okay to love him like he was a real person. (Television is all about escapism, after all.) What's unacceptable is to heave your glowing praise of him onto everyone else's plate and make them take a giant, heaping bite before you're willing to drop the subject and move onto literally anything else. Not all fans are this way, of course. But there's a large chunk of super fans that cast a rather substantial shadow over the character, embracing him like he was the fifth Beatle, or the sixth member of One Direction. It really is that kind of shrieking, over-the-top fandom with Daryl. And, for the most part, they seem unwilling to accept the fact that there are some--hell, any--flaws in the character. In fact, I'd be willing to bet that most Daryl fans only clicked on this article so they could immediately scroll to the bottom of the page and tell me what an idiot I am for trying to poke holes in their ideal man. And I'd be downright shocked if any hardcore fans even made it past the first couple of critiques to read this.

5. He Always Defers To Rick

If there's any character on the Walking Dead that urges fans to shout "Grow some balls, man!" at the screen, it's Daryl Dixon. It's now been multiple seasons of Rick overpowering the rest of the group with his varying levels of Ricktatorship, and even in the harshest of these times, when Rick goes completely berserk with power, no one steps up to question his authority. Not...even...Daryl. Not Daryl, the boy scout. Not Daryl, the expert tracker. Not Daryl, the guy with a nearly flawless record when it comes to his decision-making skills. From a narrative standpoint, the guy may not be as obvious of a leader as Rick (who is used to wielding this kind of power from his days as a deputy sheriff), but Daryl's ideas are consistently helpful. He's also proven himself a worthy fill-in (for an episode or two in Season 3) when Rick is overwhelmed with the death of his wife, and he isn't half as reckless as the majority of these boneheads tend to be. ...Oh wait, so he is an obvious leader. Why doesn't he take over those duties again?

4. He's Too Often Used To Give Other Characters Story Arcs

There's a term in professional wrestling for people who routinely lose matches to help other wrestlers look better and get them over with the fans. They call these guys "jobbers." They rarely get the glory. They just do the job and move on. In episodic television, Daryl is the ultimate jobber. Not only does he always play second fiddle to Rick, but with the exception of his relationship with his brother (and one specific, soul-baring episode with Beth), Daryl has always been used to stoke the fires of other character's development. He single-handedly turned Carol into a recurring character. He somehow managed the impossible feat of making both Beth and Merle tolerable at different points in the series. This may not seem like much of a critique, since someone like that is an asset purely from a writer's standpoint, but it's frustrating to see it happen repeatedly because it almost always takes the focus away from his own emotional arc. To be fair, the writers finally started cracking away at the layers of mystery at the end of Season 5, but now it's time for a character to be of service to Daryl's needs.

3. He's Become More Of A Habit Than Anything

When you really stop to think about it, there hasn't been a new story arc for Daryl in quite some time. Sure, he gets involved with the story in big ways every now and again, but it's never anything different enough to be truly exciting. Daryl is stuck in a funk that relies on this very simple formula: Love, lose, repeat. It's how we were introduced to the character in the first season, when he's told that his brother was left to die in a zombie attack. It happens again in Season 3 when Merle is discovered to be alive, but ultimately has to be put down by Daryl once the Governor actually kills him and he turns into a walker. And it happens with Carol once she's excised from the group in Season 4 (just as it happened with Carol's daughter in Season 2), and again in Season 5 with the loss of Beth. There are no new storylines for Daryl, and he seems to be hanging around simply because the fans are so rabidly devotional to this badass hunter that, as previously mentioned, it practically makes him untouchable. So I guess we're all stuck on this rollercoaster until someone finally works up the gumption to shut it down.

2. He Often Affects Other Character's Storylines In A Bad Way

Daryl, as fans of the comic book know, was a character written specifically for the television show. He did not exist in the comics. And since the creators of the TV show like to use the comic book as a working template, they constantly have to figure out ways to include Daryl's character in the storylines. One way they do this is by swapping other characters out of the storyline in favor of Daryl. For instance, Chad Coleman (who played Tyreese), believes Reedus' awkward placement in the series ultimately lead to his own character's demise. In the comics, Tyreese was Rick's go-to guy. In the series, however, that falls on Daryl. He also overshadows what should have been a defining moment for Lauren Cohan's character, Maggie. Following the death of Maggie's sister, Beth, there's a graphic scene in the comics that has Maggie so distraught that she attempts suicide. In the show, however, a lot of the pain and grief is shouldered by Daryl, with Maggie barely getting any screen time. It's such a weird absence that many viewers wondered if Maggie even remembered she had a sister, or if she was so entrenched in her relationship with Glenn that she couldn't be bothered to mourn. Daryl is constantly stealing thunder.

1. He's Too Perfect At Times

Despite everything that I just said, it's impossible to not see Daryl Dixon as the most perfect version of a post-apocalyptic, zombie-fighting survivor. He easily outmatches everyone else on the show in terms of being both a fan favorite (he somehow makes Michonne look like chopped liver) and a consistent character that provides a steady presence in an otherwise chaotic (and sometimes very fickle) landscape. That's all well and good if you're one of those people who fears change, but when you're living in a zombie apocalypse, you should not be perfect. You should be the exact opposite of that. But as I mentioned previously, Daryl has a terrible habit of always doing the right thing. He's always the moral center, with an unshakably level-headed worldview. And that, more than anything else, makes Daryl Dixon a Walking Dead character that is perfectly acceptable to hate.

Contributor

Jacob is a part-time contributor for WhatCulture, specializing in music, movies, and really, really dumb humor.