8 Times American Horror Story Went Too Far

AHS is known for being controversial - but these moments remind you just how bad it can be!

American Horror Story Murder House Piggy Piggy Violet Harmon
FOX

American Horror Story has never shied away from difficult to tackle and taboo issues, which is why so many of its repeat audience members love it so much. Hailing it for addressing these topics is something viewers are quick to do, but there have been some very questionable moments over the show's ten seasons that simply do not sit well with even the most seasoned AHS fan.

Many of these moments take place up to and including the seventh season, as the more recent seasons are somewhat tame in comparison to their predecessors.

From graphic depictions of rape and murder, all the way to historically insensitive topics that should have stayed in the past, there is certainly more than one bone to pick with series creators Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk. Their loose and somewhat uncaring explanations behind many of their creative decisions plot-wise keep you second guessing whether or not they see their choices as artistic or just are incapable of providing apt apologies to their main target audiences.

Either way, take a look at these moments and see if you agree!

8. Violet's Corpse - Murder House

American Horror Story Murder House Piggy Piggy Violet Harmon
FOX

Violet Harmon has a doomed storyline from the get-go, and this is solidified when she becomes entangled romantically with troubled teen, Tate Langdon. She is the daughter of Vivienne and Ben Harmon who are the most recent occupants of the aptly dubbed "Murder House", which is what this very first season of American Horror Story is focused on.

Much of Violet's own character arc is a difficult-to-watch downward spiral, with simply no sign that she will get out of her deep depression. It's an upsetting thing to witness, especially as it can be so relatable for many people watching it who also experienced periods of hardship during their own teenage years. After attempting (and succeeding) to take her own life, her boyfriend Tate shows the new unaware 'ghost Violet' where he stored her corpse, and this revelation is completely unexpected for the audience, as it also was for Violet.

Evidently, the corpse had been there for a considerable amount of time, and therefore had begun to decompose and is covered in flies. It is a harrowing depiction of a dead body, and one that is arguably a bit too realistic.


7. Madison's Rape - Coven

American Horror Story Coven Madison
FX

American Horror Story often tackles taboo and uncomfortable topics that other prime time television shows choose not to examine in detail. Madison Montgomery's rape in the anthology series third season, Coven, certainly falls into this category of perhaps being depicted in just a bit too much of a realistic light.

The thing that tipped many viewers over the edge with Madison's rape scene is that it seemed to feed into a more pornographic and voyeuristic view of rape instead of depicting it as a heinous crime. The main reason it was viewed this way by audiences is because of the fact it wasn't just one perpetrator assaulting Madison, but a group of young men. It glorified Madison's rape, and despite the men being punished by her soon after the assault, it still holds a certain degree of unnecessarily pornographic violence.

Her assault is violent and uncomfortable to watch, which despite being the main point Murphy tries to convey, is unnecessarily graphic and does not really feel as though it serves the political point that was intended and instead comes across as a voyeuristic take on a serious issue.


6. The Concept Of Freak Show - Freak Show

AHS Freak Show Sarah Paulson
FX

Freak Show is hailed by many American Horror Story fans as one of the top-tier seasons in the anthology series thanks to its great storylines and character development. However, something about the concept of the season as a whole is just a little bit off.

We already know by this point that American Horror Story exploits situations and concepts that often are not explored on television due to their taboo nature, but perhaps this is one concept that should have never progressed beyond the pitch meeting.

Even though the concept of Freak Show as a season is to depict those who are typically marginalised by society due to their physical differences as being the same as the general population who reject them, we can't help but still question the good that the season claims to have done. As the timeline for the show is set in the 1950s, there is still a significant amount of discrimination and inappropriate behaviour portrayed by most of the characters; in keeping with attitudes displayed toward these individuals at the time.

Despite being historically accurate, arguably even portraying these attitudes on-screen produced more harm than good.


5. Rally Shooting - Cult

american horror story cult Ally
FX

Cult has many American Horror Story fans split on whether or not it was a good season. Many people who enjoyed the season did so because of its real-life parallels to the anxiety experienced by many Americans during the 2016 elections that saw Donald Trump inaugurated as President.

Following a cult-like figure played by Evan Peters who gains control of his followers through tactics of coercion and fear, the season as a whole succeeds in portraying the ease at which a tyrant with worrying ideologies can in fact rise to power.

However, one of the moments that was so controversial to the point where it was actually cut from episode six before airing, is the shooting carried out by Sarah Paulson's character at a political rally. Coming at a time that would have hurt its fans rather than be entertaining due to the very recent Las Vegas mass shooting, this particular topic - and more specifically its harrowingly realistic nature - meant that it would have, at the very least, been extremely disrespectful to the families of those who lost individuals in the attack.

For this reason, Cult knocks a couple of gold stars off of itself as a season for hitting a bit too close to home.


4. The Impaling - Roanoke

American Horror Story Roanoke Milo
FX

Viewed by many fans as the worst season of American Horror Story, Roanoke really went to town with the amount of blood and gore it contained. However, one of the moments where viewers felt this was certainly a bit too far, was the sequence of three friends attempting to document the mystery surrounding Roanoke.

Minor characters in terms of the series as a whole, Milo and Sophie's deaths will definitely be remembered as arguably one of the most grizzly scenes AHS fans have ever seen. American Horror Story is no stranger to frequent references to pop culture horror, and here we witness an immaculately crafted homage to The Blair Witch Project; a film that arguably redefined the sub-genre of found footage within horror.

Sporting Go-Pro's in an attempt to capture the mysterious goings-on in the area, this decision is ultimately what allows us as the audience to witness their deaths in a first-person point of view. The cameras pick up a chilling image of the colonisers as they use two large poles to impale Milo and Sophie and then set their bodies on fire Cannibal Holocaust-style.

Despite leaning into the gory nature of the season with this sequence, there seems to be a general consensus that this particular death scene was just that step too far!


3. Tate's Character - Murder House/Apocalypse

Tv Tate American Horror Story
FX

Tate Langdon (played by Evan Peters) is arguably the most difficult character to break down. He is a loveable and hateable individual at the same time, and the more that is discovered about the Murder House in seasons such as Apocalypse, it seriously makes you question if Ryan Murphy was just looking for ways to give Tate a redemption arc.

The first introduction of Tate in Murder House depicts him as a troubled teenager who seems to have a few psychological problems. Soon enough, it is uncovered that Tate was a school shooter when he was alive and he took the lives of 15 students during that rampage. Not only did Tate commit a crime that left 15 teenagers dead, but he also then proceeded to rape Vivienne Harmon (the current occupant of the house) and then tell Vivienne's daughter, Violet, how to kill herself, which she carries out due to her severe depression.

American Horror Story creators were slammed at the time of this season being aired for 'romanticising' Tate's character through his relationship with Violet, and the decision to redeem the Langdon character in a crossover episode in Apocalypse was also heavily criticised, with some believing that Tate was the last character who deserved a redemption arc.


2. Anne Frank - Asylum

American Horror Story Asylum Anne Frank
FX

Asylum is often hailed as the best season of American Horror Story, with storylines of demonic possession, serial killers, and aliens only being a small part of what the season entails. However, this particular sub-plot of Asylum centred around a fictionalised adult version of Anne Frank that certainly had audiences split on whether or not it was distasteful.

Ryan Murphy stated on more than one occasion that his intention with this storyline was never to offend, but rather that he had been fascinated by stories of women in the years that followed the end of World War II who had come forward claiming to be the adult Anne after the release of Frank’s diary. He explained how each of the women had later been diagnosed with various mental illnesses which acted as explanations for their delusions.

As this series was based in an asylum, Murphy thought that including this storyline was within keeping of the seasons general trajectory. Much of the issue that was taken by viewers who criticised this storyline was that it sensationalised a girl who had been dead for many years by this point and allowed her story to be one that was warped for the purposes of a tv show.


1. The Addiction Demon - Hotel

American Horror Story Hotel Addiction Demon
FX

The fifth instalment to the AHS anthology series, Hotel is an interesting season to say the least and has many fans split between finding it painfully boring or devilishly good. Regardless of fans divided views of the season as a whole, one thing that can be agreed upon is the disturbing and grotesque scene of the so-called 'addiction demon' who rapes an addict to death with a metal spike in place of a phallic object.

As bad as it sounds, this scene takes the top spot for being the best at making its audience as uncomfortable as humanly possible. Despite not knowing much in terms of a backstory of the addict himself, it simply does not take a super-empath to identify that the scene is harrowingly terrifying. Even down to Sarah Paulson's character coming in mid-assault and speaking to the man as he is being raped, there are so many elements of the sequence that all add up to create a truly horrible piece of television.

From the quick-cut editing to create a feeling of urgency, all the way to the sound design of the sequence that includes screams, squelches and all sorts of other horrible noises, it certainly earns its place at the top of this list for assaulting the senses of the audience indiscriminately.


Contributor

Amy James hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.