8 Times Robin Outsmarted Batman

Those times that the Boy Wonder was able to one-up the Caped Crusader.

Jason Todd
DC Comics

Barely a year after Batman was created in 1939, Detective Comics #38 saw Robin arrive to work alongside the Caped Crusader.

For so long, wherever there has been a Batman, there has been a Robin at his side. Much like there have been several people to take on the moniker of the Batman, of course, there have also been several different incarnations of Robin over the decades since the character's April 1940 debut.

In the standard narrative of DC Comics' accepted canon, Dick Grayson, Jason Todd, Tim Drake, Stephanie Brown, and Damian Wayne have all at one point or another been Robin, while alternative worlds and different timelines have seen a slew of others take on that particular mantle.

Some Robins have been great, some Robins have been less than great - and some Robins have managed to prove themselves as being just as smart, if not smarter, than the World's Greatest Detective.

Taking a look through the various people to have taken on the Robin name throughout the history of DC Comics, then, here are eight examples of times when Batman has been outright outsmarted by his supposed sidekick.

8. Tim Drake Works Out Batman's Identity - A Lonely Place Of Dying

Batman Tim Drake Robin
DC Comics

After the death of the second Robin, Jason Todd, a broken Batman was adamant that he'd be working alone from that moment on. No longer would Bruce Wayne put children in danger, and he was even reluctant to work with Alfred at times.

Of course, Batman has since gone on to have several further Robins over the subsequent decades since Jason's death, and one of the main reasons for this is down to the sheer smarts of Tim Drake.

Tim would become the third person to take on the Robin moniker, but it took the youngster outsmarting the Caped Crusader to fully cement himself in that role.

By all accounts, a 9-year-old Tim had already worked out that Batman was Bruce Wayne and Robin was Dick Grayson. It was only following Jason's death, however, that Drake reached out to assist a clearly troubled World's Greatest Detective.

Seeing that Batman had become reckless and ruthless in a post-Jason world, the then-13-year-old Tim Drake managed to convince Batman to let him fight by his side as the new Robin. And the biggest reason for this was that Tim had proven his smarts time and time again, such as letting Bruce know how he'd established who was the man behind the cowl, before then making his case for Batman always needing a Robin.


7. Jason Todd Causes Chaos - Hush

Jason Todd Hush
DC Comics

Jeph Loeb and Jim Lee's Hush arc is one of the most fascinating Batman stories in recent memory. Not only did Hush feature a true who's who of the Caped Crusader and his supporting characters, not only did the story introduce a hugely intriguing new villain, but the tale also brought Jason Todd back from the dead.

The second Robin, Jason had famously been offed back in 1988's A Death in the Family - a fan vote deciding the fate of Todd - yet Hush shockingly saw this fallen hero resurrected.

Hush himself would be revealed to be Bruce Wayne's childhood best pal, Tommy Elliot, although the biggest twist of this story was how readers saw the long-dead Jason back in the fold.

Despite switching places with Clayface for parts of Hush's finale, it would be explained that Jason Todd had been working alongside Hush and The Riddler as part of a greater plan to torment the Dark Knight on every possible level. And for the majority of Hush's 12-issue run, that plan succeeded and played out perfectly.

Every time that Bruce thought he'd solved the mystery of Hush, he'd suddenly be left perplexed as this story took yet another twist. It was masterful, it was brilliant to watch, and it led to Jason coming back as a genius, brutal figure who was a breath of a fresh air to the Bat-books of the day.


6. Damian Wayne Schools Jim Gordon - Robin War

Robin War #1 Damian Wayne Jim Gordon Batman
DC Comics

After Bruce Wayne had memory loss, got a new brain, and grew a big ol' beard in the aftermath of Endgame - no, not that Endgame - an agreement between The Powers Corporation and GCPD saw Jim Gordon take on the moniker of Batman. Well, kind of.

Gordon was indeed known as Batman, but his Batsuit was a mechanical contraption and he had no working relationship with the famed Bat Family of heroes. Instead, Jimbo was at the beck and call of Gotham's decision makers, taking orders like the good soldier he is.

Said orders, of course, would soon put him on a collision course with some of Batman's fellow heroes. And in Robin War, Gordon's Batman first came face to face with Damian Wayne's Robin.

In the absence of Batman - as in, the proper Batman - the residents of Gotham City began to rise up and declare themselves as "I am Robin". Councilwoman Noctua looked to shoot down this movement, and so outlawed anything to do with Robin. Not only were the police force instructed to arrest anybody sporting an R emblem or Robin colours, but so too was Jim Gordon.

This didn't work out too well for Gordon, for his Batman was taken to school and electrocuted upon confronting Damian Wayne in Robin War #1.


5. Dick Grayson Kills Batman - Titans

Titans Dick Batman
Warner Bros.

It may have been a twisted fantasy dreamed up by the demonic Trigon, but the the first season of Titans concluded with Dick Grayson having to use all of his skill and intelligence to permanently take down Batman.

As the show skips ahead five years, we see the Caped Crusader finally reaching his breaking point. Deciding that the only way he can properly stop The Joker is to kill him, Batman embarks on a murderous rampage that includes the death of the Clown Prince of Crime and every other person held at Arkham Asylum.

With no choice, it's Dick who's forced to confront his mentor and put a stop to his bloodthirsty ways. And put a stop to them, Grayson does.

Using his smarts, Robin decides that the best way to flush Batman out is to reveal the Dark Knight's secret identity to the police. That doesn't work out all that well, for the ensuing ambush on Wayne Manor sees Starfire and a slew of FBI agents added to the body count amassed by the World's Greatest Detective.

Having blown up Wayne Manor, Dick finds the fallen Bat and puts him out of his misery.

This, as said, would all be the creation of Trigon as he tried to get Dick Grayson to embrace the darkness - but it was yet another example of a Robin outwitting Batman.


4. Tim Drake Stops His Future Self - Titans Tomorrow

Titans Tomorrow Tim Drake Robin Batman
DC Comics

At several points over the years, comic book readers have been treated to a potential future that sees Tim Drake take on the Batman mantle.

When looking at all of the Robins, Tim is easily the most like Bruce Wayne in his ways. A genius level intellect, the skills of a true tech wizard, a multitude of fighting styles, and with a fondness for working in brooding solitude, the third person to take on the Robin name is very much Batman-in-waiting.

Back in 2004 and 2005, Geoff Johns and Mike McKone's Titans Tomorrow story was one such tale that gave a glimpse into the future - and indeed, this was very much a future in which Tim took on the role of Batman.

This future Tim Drake has one notable difference to the Bruce Wayne version of Batman, for Tim's Dark Knight uses a gun to take down criminals. And not just any gun, for Drake has modified the exact same gun that was used to kill Thomas and Martha Wayne, and he's used it to kill off every major rogue that Gotham has to offer.

Before this older Tim is returned to the future, he's desperate to wipe the younger Tim's memory of their meeting. Fortunately for the present-day Drake, he's able to counter all of this with his trusty staff, rendering his future self unconscious and proving that the optimism of youth can topple the cynicism that so often comes with experience.


3. Damian Wayne Gets One Over A Murderous Dark Knight - Battle For The Cowl

Battle for the Cowl Damian Wayne Tim Drake Batman Robin Squire
DC Comics

In Battle for the Cowl, Gotham was left with a Batman-shaped hole after Bruce Wayne's death in Final Crisis.

While Dick Grayson was reluctant to pick up the cape and cowl, one person who was more than happy to become Batman was Jason Todd. And in typical Jason fashion, the dark was well and truly put in the Dark Knight nickname during Todd's tenure as the Bat.

Complete with an itchy trigger finger, Jason's Batman was a murderous one. So much so, that Tim Drake decided to don his own Batsuit and hunt Todd down. For Tim, this didn't work out too well, with Jason nearly killing him once they finally did battle.

As far as Jason Todd was concerned, Tim Drake was dead. Having left Tim with fatal wounds, Todd's attention was soon switched to Dick Grayson in a fight that Dick would eventually win - Grayson then finally accepting his fate as the next Batman.

Despite Damian Wayne having earlier been left wounded at the hands of Jason, Damian (with the assistance of Squire) would, unbeknown to Todd's Batman, return to the scene of the fight and rescue the bloody, unconscious Drake from certain death - getting one over on the Jason Todd incarnation of Batman, as the young Damian Wayne continued his ascension to becoming the next Robin.


2. Jason Todd Kills A Rapist - The Diplomat's Son

Jason Todd
DC Comics

In one way, the events of The Diplomat's Son were the beginning of the end for Jason Todd. Well, the beginning of the end... at least until Jason was resurrected some 15 years later.

Just two issues after The Diplomat's Son appeared in Batman #424, the stunning A Death in the Family arc would begin - an arc that would culminate in Jason Todd's death at the hands of The Joker. The thing is, part of the reason for Jason's demise was down to his brash attitude and rash thinking.

It was that same brash attitude and rash thinking, however, that saw Todd outsmart Batman in that one-shot Batman #424 story.

After the clearly guilty Felipe Garzonas managed to avoid a sexual assault and battery charge due to having diplomatic immunity, Jason decided to take matters into his own hands. Despite Batman clearly telling Todd that their hands were unfortunately tied on this issue, Jason pulled a vanishing act on the Caped Crusader.

By the time Batman had arrived at Garzonas' penthouse apartment, Felipe had fallen to his death and Jason Todd was the only person at the scene.

This was Jason Todd in one of his darker moments, with it implied that he'd pushed the sexual predator to his death. For Batman, he couldn't prove this, and all Jason would say on the matter was, "I guess I spooked him."

As alluded to, while this was a prime example of the second Robin being one step ahead of his mentor, this was the beginning of the end for Jason Todd.


1. Dick Grayson Strings Batman Along - The Dark Knight Strikes Again

Joker Robin Dark Knight Strikes
DC Comics

Frank Miller's The Dark Knight Strikes Again was never going to live up to Miller's iconic The Dark Knight Returns, yet this 2001 sequel offering did at least provide a, err, unique spin on Dick Grayson.

With The Joker having died during The Dark Knight Returns, one of the central plot points of The Dark Knight Strikes Again is the reemergence of The Clown Prince of Crime. As the elderly Bruce Wayne and his team are stumped by the murderous crime spree of this resurrected Joker, it soon becomes clear that this maybe isn't quite The Joker that Batman had spent so many decades battling.

By the time this follow-up tale gallops towards its climax, the big reveal of The Dark Knight Strikes Again is that this Joker is in fact Dick Grayson - the longtime sidekick of Batman.

Not only does this original Robin spend the majority of The Dark Knight Strikes Again leading the Caped Crusader on a merry dance, his impact is so sinister and clinical that he manages to kill off The Martian Manhunter, Creeper, and The Guardian.

This may be the skewed alt-world view of Frank Miller, but this is still one super smart, super evil incarnation of Dick Grayson who outsmarted Batman at every turn until his ultimate demise.


Watch Next


In this post: 
robin
 
Posted On: 
Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.