9 Ups & 1 Down From Star Trek: Discovery 5.8 — Labyrinths

Hiya Hy'Rell; Burnham's Betazoid Mind Palace; Star Trek's baddies in the Badlands.

Star Trek Badlands Discovery
CBS Media Ventures

Library card at the ready, people! To find the final clue this week, we're off to the Eternal Gallery and Archive. I hope they have a good lending policy, as it's pretty hard to return any items to the Badlands. There is only one book Captain Burnham is after — Labyrinths of the Mind by Doctor Marina Derex. Deanna Troi would approve!

For the rest of the crew of the Discovery, no time to request a copy of Breen Nursery Rhymes for Maquis Rebels, the actual Breen are on their way! Whilst the crew dodge the dreadnought in the plasma storms and behind shelves on the Archive, Burnham delves into her own psyche as a test of her Progenitors' tech worthiness.

Labyrinths, on the heel of Erigah, is another strong episode, continuing the mix of action, deftly written dialogue, stunning visuals, character development, and laugh-out-loud humour — that last one especially in the form of episode highlight, and winner of librarian of the year several times running, Hy'Rell. Having lost the love of her life last week, Moll also emerges with a much bigger part to play in Labyrinths as "wife of the Scion," even more determined to get L'ak back. If not the jelly Breen, this episode is pure concentrate of Star Trek once more!

And no, we don't have a dungeon here at TrekCulture either, so stop asking! For your information, it's really more of an oubliette!

11. UP — Head Librarian

Star Trek Discovery Labyrinths Hy'Rell
CBS Media Ventures

SILENCE! The library is open! And there's nothing basic about head of Eternal Gallery and Archive, Hy'Rell. Apart from reading, one thing is fundamental: if you don't follow instructions then, "the Archive is not responsible for any damage, dismemberment or death that may result". In Labyrinths, Hy'Rell is serving high fashion, high principles, and hilarious one-liners ("I'll do you the courtesy to suggest that you rephrase your request"). And is that… Mama Ruhn?

The kind of cheerful serene composure that emanates from head of the flying library Hy'Rell is typically off-putting unless it is absolutely sincere and/or delivered through the gritted teeth that mask a storm beneath the oasis. Hy'Rell isn't hiding anything in her outward niceties and caring nature. She is just the inverse of the Badlands — calm on the surface, badass to the core. Hy'Rell's interactions with Booker were genuinely heart-warming: "How fun to have a book visit me in the library for a change." Then, in her dealings with Primarch Ruhn, her "May you gain knowledge elsewhere!" might just be the best thing anyone's ever said!

The exact identity of Hy'Rell's species has equally been the subject of debate since the sneak peek scene for Labyrinths. The shapely fore-head (and lengthy locks of white hair) of the head of the Archive would tend to suggest that she is an Efrosian, a species that first appeared in Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home and then again in Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country (in the form of the Federation President). That's the conclusion we've settled on at TrekCulture in any case, as did the wonderful Jörg Hillebrand on Twitter. Other suggestions included the as yet unknown species of character Arctus Baran from the Star Trek: The Next Generation two-parter Gambit, and my personal favourite, that of over-thinking-man Kurros from Star Trek: Voyager's Think Tank.


10. LATINUM UP — Burnham's Inner Light

Star Trek Discovery Labyrinths Burnham
CBS Media Ventures

Perhaps one of the fairer criticisms made about Star Trek: Discovery in its earlier years was that it focussed on the character of Michael Burnham to the detriment of the ensemble. There were, no doubt, one too many voice-overs and logs from Burnham's perspective, replete with sentimental (over-)(self-)analysis. What is notable about season five is that Discovery — as a series — has matured to a point of metacognition on the matter. Burnham has begun to self-analyse her own self-analysis, and, in Labyrinths, that led to some great dialogue of, and in, the mind.

As the virtual Booker tells Burnham, "Your consciousness has been transported into a mindscape — a virtual space created from what your neural activity indicates as the most important place in your life". In other words, Burnham is (mostly) talking to herself, and to a 24th century version of ChatGPT in the guise of her former partner. Cast your mind(scape) back, also, to that little known episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation. This isn't J.L. on Kataan with the flute, but it was a "nucleonic beam" from a "nucleonic emitter" that caused the Inner — slowly fading — Light effect for Burnham, too.

At first, this particularly peculiar test envisaged by Dr Derex as only a Betazoid could leads Burnham down the rabbit hole of history of Dominion and various other wars, not to mention that of Betazed, Trill and the Mirror Universe. Sat surrounded by a pile of books, Burnham realises she is going the wrong way about things, not that replica Booker has been any help! "Try being proactive next time!" Perhaps 'Labyrinths' is a literal maze? Grab a bucket of sand and let's get going!

In the end, and right back where she started, it's the '…of the Mind' part that's the real test for Burnham. Perhaps the most knowing nod to prior inner-musings comes when Burnham says, with irony, to ersatz Book: "Or maybe, I should go even more psychobabble here…" All of this then adds to the culminating and sublimely acted scene in the Mindscape in which Burnham admits her true feelings, her insecurities, her fears, honestly, and without jargon or rhetoric to hide behind.

"You passed," says the Booker of the Mind as the lights go back up. In her introspection, Burnham has proven herself a worthy protector of the Progenitors' technology, "to do the right thing with so much power". Next step: smashing crystal!


9. DOWN — Off On The ISS, Wedding Planner Stress

Star Trek Discovery Mirrors ISS Enterprise
CBS Media Ventures

Okay, so we are getting a little worried at this point, and Seán will have this covered too. This week, once more, there was sadly no Detmer, Owosekun, and no Saru. This is only really a DOWN because, as the season and series draws to a close at an alarmingly fast pace, there's so little time left for us to spend with each of these characters who we've followed from the very beginning. Of course, no one knew in 2022 that season five would be the last, so we certainly can't and don't blame anyone for a lack of planning only possible in hindsight (or with one of those Krenim chronophages).

We do know via TrekMovie and a Tweet that Saru actor Doug Jones missed out on the most recent set of episodes — four to now eight (Face the Strange, in fact, re-used footage from season three) — because he was then busy promoting the film Hocus Pocus 2. For Detmer actor Emily Coutts, and Owosekun actor Oyin Oladejo, however, we haven't had any official confirmation as to their absence from the show.

In universe, of course, both Owosekun and Detmer were tasked by Captain Burnham to fly the ISS Enterprise back to Federation HQ at the end of Mirrors. We haven't seen or heard from them or the ship again. Whilst we certainly don't mean to disparage Owosekun or Detmer's replacements on the bridge — Commanders Asha and Jemison (a wonderful reference there too), we need closure for these long-serving characters. We have also yet to attend the wedding of Saru and T'Rina. I certainly wouldn't want to be planning that amongst all the galactic goings-on!


8. UP — The Badlands And The Great Blue-Green-Breen Yonder

Star Trek Discovery Labyrinths Badlands Oassis
CBS Media Ventures

The current — 32nd century — location of the Eternal Gallery and Archive is one of the safest places for it to be (hold that thought as the Primarch Ruhn might have other plans), but it does make it one hell of a job to get to. What's not so great for those in-universe who just want to relax with a good (ancient) book or find an 800-year-old clue as quickly and quietly as possible, is a boon for us, the viewer. The oasis was not only a neat addition in a retro-return, it was also a visual goody at the heart of the Badlands.

To get to the calm of the plasma storms, it appears that the 'Ezri-method' (from Penumbra) is official policy. As the Discovery is battered and bashed around in the currents, voice of Hy'Rell, if a little difficult to make out through all the interference, calmly states, "… cut your engines or it could be catastrophic". Never has the possibility of impending doom been delivered so… brightly. The level of detail on the updated version of the Badlands is just gorgeous, and once the crew has weathered the storm, we are treated to a magnificent blue as the Discovery glides overhead through the clouds towards the Archive.

For all those of us who've been drinking in every last detail on the Breen, Labyrinths also opens on a simply outstanding (extreme) close-up shot of bucket-head green, panning out to reveal lines and lines… and lines of Breen soldiers all banging their high-tech truncheons with exacting simultaneity aboard the dreadnought.


7. UP — Captain Commander Rhys

Star Trek Discovery Labyrinths Rhys
CBS Media Ventures

Labyrinths wasn't the first time the dashing, (now) Lieutenant Commander Gen Rhys had command of the bridge. For example, he was previously given the conn by Saru in Far From Home, not long after Discovery had crashed landed in the 32nd century. About a year later, he was in the chair again when Captain Burnham and Booker were down on Alshain IV. In the present season's Face the Strange, Burnham also put Rhys in command so she could have a little word with one Commander Rayner.

It is surely a shame that Rhys couldn't join Detmer and Owosekun on the ISS Enterprise — 'Connie' class, his favourite — for the trip back to Federation HQ, but then that would have most likely robbed us of his command appearance in Labyrinths. Once more, Rhys proves himself worthy of the chair. He handed out orders and instructions to the crew with such ease, it was like he was channelling every Starfleet captain who ever lived — perhaps most Kirk-like, with a hint of Picard, if such comparisons are worthwhile. Rhys will surely have his own command soon!

As the Breen dreadnought was on approach, Rhys' decision to take the Discovery out of the oasis and back into the plasma storms was a risky, but ultimately bold move. If Discovery couldn't cloak, they'd have to use the 'bad' in Badlands to hide from the Breen instead. "We can only withstand that storm for so long," states Tilly, a little obviously, but with care. "I know. We just need long enough," replies the ever stoic Captain (Commander) Rhys.


6. UP — Talaxian Hairstyles And Other Manuscripts

Star Trek Discovery Labyrinths Betazoid Manuscript
CBS Media Ventures

Of all the books in all the galaxy in all this itinerant Archive — and it seems Dr Derex was quite the bibliophile — you chose Comprehensive Guide to Talaxian Hairstyles?! Well, everyone, they say, has a kink. At least it wasn't Cooking with Neelix, a Culinary Tour of the Delta Quadrant (if that ever did get published)! Being a little less mean to the whiskered and quiff'd of the Delta Quadrant for a moment, the reference was genuinely hilarious — another fine example of Star Trek: Discovery's adept balance of tone this season.

The works housed at the Eternal Gallery and Archive (the real version, not the Mindscape one) weren't as alien as they perhaps could have been, with some notable exceptions nonetheless, and, even by the 32nd century, there was still no copy of The Winds of Winter on the bookshelf (I am told that is a very funny joke)! The Archive scenes were filmed at the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, part of the University of Toronto Libraries. Above and beyond any CGI changes, I doubt very much the production team were allowed to go around popping in lots of fake books in a very real library. If you typically get shushed for a slight raise of the voice, I don't think you'd be allowed The Audio Guide to Klingon Opera!

Dr Derex's original manuscript of Labyrinths of the Mind, housed in the Archive and found for Captain Burnham by Hy'Rell, was equally notable from a canon perspective. This was the first time we'd seen Betazoid writing on screen, and as Burnham turned the pages, there were copious amounts of it for all of us language geeks to pore over!


5. UP — Team Technobabble

Star Trek Discovery Labyrinths Reno Stamets Adira
CBS Media Ventures

Pausing amongst the more high-octane, although things were still moving and shaking (and exploding) around them, to discuss the finer points of positrons is a bit of a risk in the climax of the drama. Then again, there is nothing more Star Trek than allotting time for technobabble when the ship, when the world, when the galaxy is falling down around its protagonists. Labyrinths gives a full minute or so to team Stamets, Adira, and Reno to find a workable solution to the Breen shield tunnelling super tech, and their conversation is up there with the best mid-battle babble put to screen.

The nod to the Trek trope, not in a negative sense, comes also only at the end of the scene. Over the comm, previous UP on this list, Commander Rhys, replies to Stamets' quintessence of an engineering assessment, i.e. the giving of a vague timeframe, with the brilliantly sarcastic, "We'll do our best to survive that long". Before that, our trio were simply left to get on with their figurings-out.

At one point in all the tunnel tech talk, Stamets and Adira are so gloriously in-sync in their thoughts that they can't help but express them out-loud in unison: "…To match the archive's shield frequency!" Reno gives the only reply possible, and one we were all thinking: "I love when you two do that!" They do have a history of it, in season four's Kobayashi Maru, for example. "Geomagnetic compensators!"

We've had perfectly timed twosomes of technobabblers before in Star Trek. In the Voyager episode Parallax, B'Elanna and Janeway are so in-time with temporal mechanics that their speech patterns merge, finishing each other's sentences, until "BOTH: Warp particles," to quote the subtitles.

More on a Reno résumé reference later, too!


4. UP — Booker(s) And Rayner, In The Library, With A Phaser

Star Trek Discovery Labyrinths Book Rayner
CBS Media Ventures

Well, this season is all about clues. There might not quite have been a murder in the library, but there were a few Breen dispatched at the end of Booker and Commander Rayner's phasers.

Sure, the duo's choice of bookcases for cover wasn't the most strategic choice — "Think like a hunter," stand like a fisherman? — and from the Breen's perspective on the dreadnought, things did look a little like they were just playing Doom, but overall, the dynamic pairing worked well. President T'Rina would still have a thing or two to say about Rayner's "gelatinous assh*les," nonetheless!

Xenophobia aside, Rayner does make some pretty tough calls with a lot of panache in this episode. His decision to beam everyone, including Captain Burnham, out of there come what may (i.e. the Breen), is, ultimately, the right one, and the only one that will save the most lives.

There wasn't just one Cleveland Booker in Labyrinths either, but two, sorta. This is, therefore, also an UP for the delightfully sarcastic 'mindscape alternate' Book and for David Ajala's take on him (the program). "My brain shoulda picked Tilly," Burnham jokes at one stage. As much as we adore her, it could only ever have been Book by proxy as Burnham's 'guide' through the labyrinth of the mind. In the real world, Book's love for Burnham is evident for all to see. Let's also take a moment to praise Ajala's standout performance in the viewing room when Book receives the Kwejian artefact!


3. UP — The Burnham Manoeuvre

Star Trek Discovery Labyrinths Burnham Bridge
CBS Media Ventures

Full disclosure: I was tempted to call this the 'Michael Manoeuvre,' but that's too much alliteration even for me! Visually, this updated version of the Badlands also reminded us of the Briar Patch (or the 'Klach D'kel Brakt,' if you prefer the Klingon name), although personally I'd rather face a dozen Breen dreadnoughts than spend another boring minute bird watching with the Ba'ku!

If history did remember shoving metreon gas down the Son'a's throats as the 'Riker Manoeuvre,' I wouldn't be surprised if it recalls the Captain of the Discovery's epic move at the end of Labyrinths as the 'Burnham Manoeuvre'. No joystick, sorry, "manual steering column" (unless that's Stamets' nickname), this time though, just pure tactics! Burnham can indeed add her name to a list that already included the Picard manoeuvre, and the mysterious 'Janeway Protocol' (as mentioned in the Star Trek: Lower Decks episode Envoys).

In Labyrinths, Burnham is faced with an almost impossible decision — Primarch Ruhn wants the clues to the Progenitors' tech, or he'll destroy the Archive and all the people on it. Burnham has little choice but to acquiesce. Xenoanthropologist-mode activated! She makes Ruhn swear a "tergun [a sacred Breen oath] to spare the Archive and all its inhabitants" before she will send over the clues.

Then came the even riskier bit. "Prepare to vent main shuttlebay and all plasma from both nacelles," Burnham orders. "We're going to vent and jump simultaneously." The crew are sceptical at first, but the gambit pays off, in spectacular style. The Discovery escapes, still smouldering, and the Breen think they have destroyed it. As Burnham says to Rayner:

Someone once told me never turn my back on a Breen.

2. UP — Moll. Long May She Reign!

Star Trek Discovery Labyrinths Moll
CBS Media Ventures

A gigantic UP for Eve Harlow this week and her exceptional performance as Moll. Through the subtlest of facial expressions to the most powerful of emotional displays, Harlow adeptly portrays her character's absolute devotion for L'ak, and her steadfast resolve to restore him to life with the help and the hope of the Progenitors' technology. Moll and L'ak continue to be the power couple of the season, in spite of the death of the latter, perhaps even more so with the shift in power dynamics the Scion's demise has caused within the Breen. No offense, Elias. We do want you back too!

What Moll manages so cleverly in Labyrinths is to recognise a certain disquiet amongst the Breen troops when faced with the increasingly irrational Primarch Ruhn, who is only out for himself on a crazed quest for dominance. Over the course of the episode, Moll carefully takes this disquiet and transforms it into dissent. In all that we also learn there is, contrary to popular belief, a lot of nuance to the Breen. And just who is this Lieutenant Arisar?

For one, the Breen have a deep respect for their culture and history. As Hy'Rell informed us, they were contributing members of the Archive, which also stored "several priceless Breen artefacts". The thought of destroying the Archive was anathema to the Breen, as were threats against the life of the wife of the Scion. In his hubris, Ruhn defied this, and paid the price. Moll shoots him dead, and then leads a chant for L'ak: "Long will he reign!"

Nicely done! I'd say it was Machiavellian, but I think it might simply be Moll!


1. Cetacean Observations

Star Trek Lower Decks Where Pleasant Fountains Lie Billups
CBS Media Ventures

Just need you to place your finger on the centre of the metallic doodad in this book, please. There we go. Welcome! I'm a program TrekCulture created, and this is the most important place in both our lives: the marvellous mindscape of Cetacean Observations! If your subconscious really has generated me, I suggest you consult your physician!

So, what did we have in the ol' sand bucket this week? Badlands, Betazoid, a nucleonic beam (which also featured in Star Trek: Voyager's The Cloud), the Dominion War, and the maybe-Efrosian, amongst others, but let's focus on something Commander Reno said mid-Stamets/Adira technobabble in engineering (adding a little of her own):

There was a stint where [as one of her 'odd jobs'] I fixed comms relays near Hysperia. Hysperians really know how to party by the way, but another story.

If you can't quite recall the planet, then have no fear! As Reno would also say, "I live to serve!"

Hysperia was (is) the world from whence Lt. Commander Billups of the Cerritos hailed, which makes this a Star Trek: Lower Decks reference. That's really an UP in and of itself! Aside from being chief engineer, Billups was also a virgin prince (abdicated) who once had a pet dragon called Fiddlesticks, a ferret named Lancelot, and grew up in a castle. You can probably see why Reno had such a good time! We can only assume she visited Hysperia in the 23rd century (before Billups' time, although we don't technically know when he was born), but we are still waiting on the complete copy of her CV to arrive. Now, chief blacksmith, check the levels of the dragonsblood flame, would you?


In this post: 
Star Trek
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jack Kiely is a writer with a PhD in French and almost certainly an unhealthy obsession with Star Trek.