A Series Of Unfortunate Events Season 2: 10 Miserable Fan Theories You Don't Want To See
9. Count Olaf Is Face Blind
Reddit user ojcoolj has noted that Count Olaf - along with his viciously fearsome deeds and various fantastical disguises - has a tendency to not recognise people. Of course, there's a pretty simple solution to this: Olaf is a self-centred dick.
On the other hand, maybe we're all judging this would-be child murderer a little too harshly in this case, and it's an issue beyond his control. The theory posits that the Count actually suffers from Prosopagnosia, otherwise known as face blindness, a condition that impairs the ability to recognise familiar faces.
In the series, he fails to recognise Justice Strauss, his longtime neighbour; doesn't notice a drastic change in the appearance of his girlfriend; constantly gets the children's names mixed-up or forgets them altogether; and wears a number of terrible disguises that he thinks are convincing. Sure, it could just be because he's a narcissistic a-hole, but maybe it's a serious medical condition, and he needs the Baudelaire fortune to pay for surgery.