After Life Season 2 Review: 4 Ups & 3 Downs

Though it holds its own rather well, the Netflix show's second season is a mixed bag...

After Life Season 2
Netflix

The first season of After Life was an unusual gem of a show that was both authentically poignant and outlandishly absurd, finding the right balance between both comedy and tragedy to endear itself to viewers.

Centering on the life of a grieving widower in the aftermath of his wife's death, the Netflix black comedy premiered on the streaming service last March and received rave reviews from critics, with many citing it as the performance of Ricky Gervais' career. And it's easy to see why because the man who created, wrote and directed the show was nothing short of captivating in every one of those six episodes.

However, it did tell something of a full-circle story for the character and this understandably left some viewers concerned when they heard that it would be returning for a second season. How could After Life carry on when it had begun wrapping up the protagonist's arc? That right there is a question we intend to examine today as the follow-up has officially dropped on Netflix.

Without going into detail (yet), the second season of After Life is a worthy follow-up to its successor, but it only occasionally reaches the same heights - and when it does, it takes a little too long getting there.

First, the negatives...


Downs...

3. That DAMN Psychiatrist

Netflix After Life Psychiatrist Paul Kaye
Netflix

As odious and offensive as Tony's psychiatrist was last season, there could be an argument made for his existence because at least he served a purpose. The egotistical narcissist was a sounding board for Tony, yes, as the grieving man could tell him how he was feeling about the world, why he hated people and, in the process, ultimately realise that the man sitting in the chair opposite him was one of those people.

The funniest thing about the character was Tony's bewildered reactions to the dreadful stuff he spouted, so the mind really does boggle as to why he needed to return for the second offering when Tony had left him behind.

This time, he's paired off with Tony's brother-in-law Matt and the result is far less appealing, resulting in boring monologues with offensive commentary that might (at a stretch) have been funny in the first episode. We didn't need the five that followed.

Look, Paul Kaye is wonderful, but his character has been stretched beyond his limits.

We don't care about him, his vitriolic rants or his cardboard friends. We just don't care.


2. The Gags Don't ALWAYS Land

Netflix After Life Brian
Netflix

After Life's first season was understandably commended for just how witty its dialogue was, as Gervais never failed to lighten a situation in a second's notice.

He's very much on his game once again as Tony, but some of the humour doesn't work quite as well when it comes to other characters. Whether it be endlessly abusive monologues or a cringe-worthy joke or two, the comedy just falls completely flat on occasion.

Again, it doesn't happen often, but because of how strong Season 1 was, it's noticeable when it does.


1. Underdeveloped Subplots

Netflix After Life Matt Tom Basden
Netflix

While After Life was very much just a one-man show in its first season, the second incorporates other characters into the narrative in more significant ways. And while you might have your own opinions on that (this writer happened to enjoy it - and we will get to that), it's hard to deny that it wasn't without its issues.

Supporting and guest characters had increased roles, more screen-time and some even had their own narratives, but some of these subplots never feel like they truly pay off - especially Matt's marriage problems - instead serving as a diversion from Tony's storyline whenever convenient so that it wouldn't come off as too much of a retread.

If you're going to go there, you need to go the full way. The problem, however, is that After Life didn't.

Now, for the positives...


Ups...

4. It's More Of An Ensemble Piece

Netflix After Life
Netflix

The one thing that is noticeably different about After Life's second season - and something that really works for it (for the first half at least) - is how it's more inclusive in terms of characters.

It's not just Tony's story anymore which is something that the premiere episode reflects as the supporting characters all begin to play into the story more, making this season more of an ensemble piece.

Kath is no longer solely relied on for comic relief, Sandy is given more of a backstory and, most of all, Matt has his own problems that he needs to deal with. No, it's not all handled perfectly as there are a number of promising subplots kicked to the curb without the resolution (or screen-time) they required, but it does allow us to get to know each of them a bit better and at least toys with taking the story in new directions.

Speaking of the supporting cast..


3. The Supporting Cast Excels Again

After Life Season 2 Ricky Gervais Ashley Jensen Tony Emma
Netflix

While Gervais was undoubtedly the star performer of the show's debut series, he couldn't have pulled off what he did without the talent of the cast around him. And this writer is thrilled to say that they take things up a notch here, excelling with the beefier material.

It's hard not to laugh every time Diane Morgan's Kath goes off on one of her strangely philosophical rants, or whenever Joe Wilkinson's Postman Pat shows up at Tony's house for some bizarre reason that completely defies logic; it's hard not to smile whenever Penelope Wilton's Anne gives Tony some heartfelt advice, and it's hard not to cry every time that Kerry Godliman's Lisa speaks from her heart via a laptop screen.

Each cast member brings something special to the show, and the second season gives them a much better chance to showcase that. They were excellent.


2. It's STILL Very Moving

Netflix After Life Tony Anne Ricky Gervais Penelope Wilton
Netflix

One of the things that made After Life such an engaging watch was its ability to thoroughly move viewers with its thought-provoking look at grief and the relationships that developed from it. Now, while Season 2's narrative may not have been as coherent as the first's, it nailed the emotional heart every bit as well.

Not only did incorporating the rest of the cast in a more significant way add more of an overall warmth to the show, it provided their respective characters with interesting backstories that we never knew existed before now. And in doing so, it also provided Gervais' Tony with a chance to showcase how much he had developed from last season by making the world a better place... not for himself, but for his loved ones.

The most moving moments, however, are the quiet ones, when Tony is reflecting on his idyllic life with Lisa through more of those heartbreaking messages from her, which is then taken even further with a new series of home videos. And yet again his heartwarming friendship with Anne remains the most endearing on the show.

After Life remains a heartfelt watch and that, more than anything, ensures its strengths outweigh its weaknesses.


1. Ricky Gervais' Performance

Netflix After Life Tony Ricky Gervais
Netflix

Some said that Ricky Gervais' performance in After Life's first season was the beginning of a new era for the comedy veteran, showcasing a completely different side to his talents by highlighting how powerful a performer he is. Those that said it were right.

Once again, he is at the emotional core of the show and once again, he thrives - delivering a nuanced, layered performance as Tony that feels every bit as raw and authentic as it did in the previous season. His on-screen partnerships with Penelope Wilton, Ashley Jensen, Mandeep Dhillon, Roisin Conaty and, of course, Anti the dog are sublime.

Shining in its best moments - and almost always responsible for them - while carrying it through its worst, Gervais is once again a revelation, turning in another award-worthy performance.

-

What did you make of After Life Season 2? Tell us in the comment section below.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.