American Horror Story: 10 Best Minor Characters

10 American Horror Story minor characters we could never forget!

Shelley American Horror Story Asylum
FX

American Horror Story is known for its collection of dark and gripping storylines that blend throwbacks and homages to classic pieces of horror over the years, with some of the most original and imaginative ideas seen in the genre. However, the show wouldn't have half the legacy it currently possesses without its combination of memorable characters and ensemble cast of actors.

From Tate and Violet all the way back in Murder House to Emma Roberts' Brooke Thompson in 1984, the colourful collection of characters each and every season has been huge in selling not only the thrills and terrors of each story, but also deliver the theme of each season in a memorable way. The likes of Sarah Paulson, Evan Peters, Jessica Lange and Kathy Bates have all scooped up awards and won huge acclaim for their portrayals over the seasons, and it's hard to imagine the show without them.

However, it's important to remember that the show is equally home to some of the most vibrant characters who might not have had the bulk of the limelight, but were still a hit for critics and audiences alike. Here are the 10 best minor characters in American Horror Story.

10. The Angel Of Death

The Angel
FX

Though she is portrayed by longstanding AHS veteran Frances Conroy, her character in Asylum is far less major than most others she plays. Throughout the second season, Shachath aka. The Angel of Death is shown to be a wholly benign entity that appears to people in great deals of pain or close to death and asks if they're ready to die. Should they say yes, The Angel will grant them the sweet release of death with a kiss on their lips, but not before showing off her swanky black wings.

The Angel doesn't take sides or pass any judgement, and there's a good level of character depth left to the viewer's imagination thanks to her interactions with Sister Jude, Father Timothy Howard and the possessed version of Sister Mary Eunice. Asylum is certainly one of the standout darker moments in the AHS series, filled with desolate moments and characters who lie and betray the audience throughout, so it's immensely calming just having an actually good individual like the Angel on hand to help out and provide some restpite.

But whilst she might not appear in any other stories other than Asylum, the AHS series is nothing if not filled with deaths, so there's nothing to say the Angel isn't still out there visiting the show's many departed moments before their eyes close.


9. Chef Bertie

Chef Bertie AHS 1984
FX

Introduced in the 1984 chapter, Chef Bertie is the on-site cook who had been working at Camp Redwood for years and years by the time the events of the season take place. The character is portrayed by Tara Karsian and she gives the character a unique identity, despite only appearing in six episodes across the series.

Having been around the camp for yonks in the same role and doing the same things over and over again, Chef Bertie has a playful distinctiveness that really helps her stand out from the other side characters amassed at Redwood. She has a real dirty look to her and certainly won't be on the shortlist for any kitchen cleanliness awards, but her witty remarks, brutal comebacks and obvious pursuits of the young men in the group really make Bertie a fun character on the outside for viewers.

But, her ultimate demise in the season really goes to show the surprising amount of depth the character has, and why Bertie is so much more than just a sleazy cook that usually feels like a staple stereotype for these kinds of slasher stories. She stalls Mr. Jingles admirably well, attempts to defend Xavier by taking on the intruder and her tearful request to be put out of her misery is honestly one of the more touching moments from the season.


8. Hazel Evers

Hazel Ever AHS Hotel
FX

To date, Mare Winningham has portrayed four minor characters in the American Horror Story anthology: Alicia Spencers (the troubled mother of Kyle in Coven), Rita Gayheart (Pepper's sister in Freakshow), Sally Keffler (a politician who ran against Kai in Cult) and Hazel Evers in Hotel. Whilst she has certainly amassed some of the most loathsome characters in the series, the way in which Winningham is able to establish a presence in such a short space of time is seriously commendable.

However, out of all of her memorable characters, Hotel's Hazel Evers stands out the best.

A longstanding employee at the Hotel Cortez, Evers is a cheery laundress who has a particularly close devotion to Mr. March. Seeing her merrily busying herself by cleaning up bloodied rags and and other evidence of Mr. March's brutal acts is one of the more strange dynamics going on in Hotel, but it nevertheless helps sell just how crazed this season's setting really is.

On top of that, it's her loyalty, cheeriness and faith towards Mr. March that really sells in the tragedy of Hazel Evers' arc, and her eventual downfall at the hands of her employer is still one of the most upsetting betrayals in the show's history.


7. Cricket Marlowe

Cricket Marlowe AHS Roanoke
FX

Leslie Jordan has appeared in three seasons of the show to date, and whilst his appearances in Coven, Roanoke and 1984 have all been fairly minor, he never fails to stand out and steal the show with his unique characters.

Roanoke's Cricket Marlowe might just be the most important and showcased of these, being introduced as a New Orleans native and one of the finest mediums in the world. Flamboyant and self-assured, he comes in as a beacon of hope for the Millers, promising to help them find their missing daughter and his personality is so convincing more than a few audience members might have been convinced he was the man to do so.

His playfulness was completely stripped away during his death at the hands of Ambrose White and the Lost Colony however, in what was perhaps the most gruesome scene in the entire season.

What's more, there are numerous rumours and theories swirling about that claim Cricket Marlowe could in fact even be the Leslie's character in Coven, the Warlock Quentin Fleming. Admittedly this wouldn't be the most earth-shattering of revelations the show has ever produced, but it would be a nice nod and a further confirmation that Ryan Murphy's worlds are all connected.


6. Anna Leigh Leighton

Supreme Anna Leigh Leighton AHS Coven
FX

Portrayed by Christine Ebersole in Coven, Anna Leigh Leighton was the latest Supreme descendant of the Salem Witch Trials before her death at the hands of her protege, Fiona Good.

Despite only having a handful of scenes across a couple of episodes, what makes Anna Leigh Leighton such an interesting and likeable character is her complete juxtaposition to her successor. She might have been the one who killed her, but Fiona made it clear over the course of Coven that she still had a huge amount of respect for the person who taught her everything she knew. In fact, Leighton is one of the few characters in the world of witchcraft that seems to have been liked and respected by all who met her.

When put next to Fiona, Leighton embodied the classical majesty of the coven. She was sweet, kind and understanding as well as boasting a powerful understanding of the seven wonders needed to be confirmed as a Supreme. She also had a rare understanding of what was good for her coven and managed to sign a truce with Marie Laveau, preventing the hostilities that would arise over the course of the Fiona's Supremacy in the season.


5. Jeffrey Dahmer

Jeffrey Dahmer AHS Hotel
FX

"Who owns me? I own myself."

Devil's Night is the fourth episode in the Hotel story, and revolves around one sinister night at the Hotel Cortez being hosted by Mr. March and some seriously unsavoury guests. The likes of the Zodiac Killer and John Wayne Gacey are in attendance, however the most shocking of all guests present at the Hotel is undoubtedly Jeffrey Dahmer aka. the Milwaukee Cannibal who murdered, ate and preserved at least seventeen boys and men between 1978 and 1991.

Jeffrey Dahmer and the presence of other sick and twisted killers from history was the first instance of American Horror Story really drawing some of its terror from grounded real life tales, and the coldness exhibited by Dahmer during his admittedly brief time on screen absolutely reeks of a believable psycopath.

His quote: "See, I want to control them. I want to make them mine. Make them part of me. I want to make them a part of me." perfectly captures the heinous nature of Dahmer's psyche and motivations, and he seamlessly slots in as one of the most chilling side baddies AHS have ever produced.


4. Shelley

Shelley American Horror Story Asylum
FX

Responsible for what just might be one of the finest pieces of dialogue in the entire with her: ""I've got a cucumber in my room but it's not because I was hungry." quip, Shelley is a patient at Briarcliffe Manor during the second season of the show, Asylum.

Portrayed in the show by Chloƫ Sevigny, Shelley found herself at Briarcliffe thanks to her supposed lust and promiscuous ways. She makes no attempt to hide the fact that she enjoys all things pleasureful in life, and uses her looks to manipulate the guards and various others around her during her time in the show. However, she is also an important character in highlighting the warped dynamics and hypocrisy between groups both inside and out of the asylum, lambasting Arden for calling her a slut and making the point that society views men who enjoy pleasure much different to how they view women.

Brave and one of the wholly moral figures in the season, she puts the likes of Lana, Kit and Grace before herself in providing a distraction, though that is what turns out to be the event that leads to her gruesome and tragic downfall.


3. Amazon Eve

Amazon Eve American Horror Story
FX

One of the most important and uplifting themes of Freakshow was the togetherness of the Freaks, and the lengths they would go to look out for and protect one another. It's shown time and time again throughout the season, and the character who embodies this theme better than all others is Amazon Eve.

The actual stage name of actor Erika Ervin, Amazon Eve has every good attribute any audience member could hope to see. From her protection and close relationship with Ma Petite, her support for Penny after her abuse from her father, to the way she dealt with Dell's attempt to murder her, Eve showed that she was strong with her values as well as her physicality.

She was also not someone to be trifled with mentally either, catching onto the schemes concocted by Elsa and Dandy before they became common knowledge to the other Freaks. Whilst the likes of Paul and Jimmy were prone to bursts angry outbursts over the course of the season, Eve was so often the calming influence on the pair, understanding the bigger picture at play and encouraging a more level-headed approach.


2. Papa Legba

Papa Legba American Horror Story Apocalypse
FX

Introduced in Coven and returning along with the Miss Robichaux's Academy Witches in Apocalypse, Papa Legba is the Loa gatekeeper to the afterlife and the being charged with keeping the scales between the living and the dead finely balanced.

Portrayed by Lance Reddick and his whimsical accent, Papa Legba's distinctive look and witty remarks help him dominate every single scene he's in and completely sell the feel of being in the presence of a powerful voodoo spirit. Papa Legba is shown to be a sadistic and cruel figure at times, turning on the likes of Marie Laveau when she refused to give him a soul and revelling in the eternal torture inflicted on Fiona Goode, though this evil is presented in a more unique way than other characters in the show.

Unlike other enemies and figures in the show, Papa Legba's evil comes purely from a lawful and fair position. He has to first be summoned by someone, he runs through the contract he presents them with and he always keeps up his side of the deal after all.

Deeply rooted in the spiritual history of voodo, Papa Legba is a wonderfully handled addition to the AHS universe and fits in beautifully alongside his fellow witches and warlocks.


1. Pepper

Pepper American Horror Story
FX

A real fan favourite and one of the most recognisable faces outside of the main ensemble cast thanks to her appearances in Asylum and Freakshow, Pepper is a microcephalic woman with so much more to her than what meets the eye.

Though she's given limited screentime over the course of her appearances, Pepper's presence (be it at Elsa Mars' Freakshow or confined to the halls of Briacliffe Manor) is always a powerful personification of the tones and themes of the story she appears in. Her character practically introduced the idea of the show's anthology actually being a connected universe, and her story being explained as a prequel to Asylum has unlocked so many more creative trees for the writers going forward.

Pepper is the absolute definition of purity, innocence, unconditional love and the desperate pursuit of family and belonging somewhere, a theme that every single season of the show has layered into it. This purity and innocence just serves to make the neverending tragedies that follow her all the more harrowing to watch.

To see someone who only ever wants to love and belong be constantly thrown away and held in contempt is a serious tear-jerker, but it is still undeniably one of the most powerful moments in the show's history.


Contributor
Contributor

Horror fan, gamer, all round subpar content creator. Strongly believes that Toad is the real hero of the Mario universe, and that we've probably had enough Batman origin stories.