American Horror Story: 10 Interesting Theme Ideas For Future Seasons

The apocalypse? Prison? Aliens??

In five short years, American Horror Story has pushed the horror envelope pretty much to hell and back. It has shocked us, terrorized our dreams, made us scream in fear and sometimes it even made us squirm in utter disgust. It's pretty much safe to say that there's never been and never will be anything else quite like it on television. Now that it's been revealed that there will indeed be a 6th installment, we can take a look back at the themes of previous seasons. There's been some rather excellent and disturbing examples. Season 1: Murder House was all about a haunted house; Season 2: Asylum was all about the torture and the freaky happenings inside a 1960's asylum. The New Orleans voodoo scene and witch covens provided the theme of Season 3: Coven, while last year's Freak Show (Season 4) was all about the creepy happenings inside a vintage freak show. Currently gracing our screens, Season 5: Hotel is all about vampires and a murderous hotel owner. So many other great themes that could have been used as main showcases were also used in microscopic settings, such as the slasher theme when they used The Axeman in Coven, and the Saw/Hostel type one that is now being done in Hotel. What crazy and creepy theme could they use in future seasons? Let's see...

10. Civil War

Fans have suggested that Season 6 of American Horror Story be titled "Civil War", with it set between 1861-1865. The war resolved two fundamental questions left unresolved by the revolution: whether the United States was to be a dissolvable confederation of sovereign states or an indivisible nation with a sovereign national government; and whether America, born of a declaration that all men were created with an equal right to liberty, would continue to exist as the largest slaveholding country in the world. But what would make it the perfect "horror story", you ask? Well, for a start, there are the horrors of war, then stories of ghosts, axe murders and other superstitious tales told by the folk that were involved in it. It would take the series further into the past than it has ever been before and it would be an interesting (and new) take on the show.

9. Museum

A theme set in a history or wax museum in the 1960's could focus on the guests and curators in the same way that the current season is doing in Hotel Cortez. It could be based in the Midwest in a haunted museum - there are said to be several in the Midwest - and it could consist of living exhibits, murderous ghosts, wax dolls, mummies, unsuspecting schoolchildren and tourists, taxonomy, ancient relics and robberies. They could take inspiration from The House Of Wax and perhaps make the owners a set of insane twin brothers that "collect" living people (or even dead ones) to display within the museum, or it could be run-down, old and broken with children betting who would go inside it, only to never return. The possibilities of horror in a spooky museum are endless.

8. Prison

Unlike shows such as Orange Is The New Black, an American Horror Story season could take place in a federal penitentiary like Alcatraz. It could be based either in modern day America or it could be based on the real Alcatraz prison after it was modernized to meet the requirements of a top-notch security prison in 1934. Alcatraz is known for loads of ghost hauntings and that could be the angle the producers take on in American Horror Story. To make things more interesting for a modern take, the ghosts could be famous people who were imprisoned there long ago, like Al Capone, George "Machine-Gun" Kelly, Alvin Karpis and Arthur "Doc" Barker. The federal penitentiary was also known for its cruel treatment of its prisoners, and if the AHS producers decided to go with the 1930's angle, then they could focus on the tales of torture or the way they kept prisoners in "hole" cells. It would very much be based around the same idea as Asylum was back in Season 2.

7. Cult

The producers of American Horror Story could focus on something like the Charles Manson's Family Cult that was based in and around the 1960's - a time the producers based Season 4's Freak Show on. In case you don't know, Charles Manson was a racist who took lyrics from The Beatles on their White Album and used it to inspire him to kill, calling it "Helter Skelter" - his definition of a time when white people murdered black people. In 1969, Manson and his family wanted to start "Helter Skelter" by brutally attacking residents at the Tate residence. In all, 102 stab wounds were inflicted on four victims, and a fifth victim was shot. Left dead were actress Sharon Tate, Jay Sebring, Voytek Frykowski, Abigail Folger, and Steven Parent. The murders were discovered by housekeeper Winifred Chapman the next morning, along with the words "Death to Pigs" and "Healter Skelter" that were printed on the refrigerator and walls. Perhaps Evan Peters could portray the psychotic Charles Manson as well as he did Tate Langdon?

6. Aliens

In Season 2's Asylum, aliens were partially used in the story of Kit and Alma, who were inspired by the first people who first claimed they were abducted by aliens, Barney and Betty Hill. In this adaptation, however, the producers could mainly focus on alien abduction as the main theme for the season. There are many alien abduction stories the producers could take inspiration from and it can literally be based on any point in time. There was an alleged abduction in Kentucky where three women were driving and got abducted. Afterwards they were hypnotised and all of them had the same story. They were even given lie detector tests and passed. It was also reported that there were UFO sightings in the area at the same time. Another story that's quite fascinating is the one that the film The Fourth Kind was based on. It's about a number of people in Alaska believing that they're being abducted by aliens. When hyptonised, they all tell similar stories and become murderous and suicidal once their session are over. The film was quite chilling in itself, but an American Horror Story take would probably be so much scarier.

5. Russian Sleep Experiment

If you're a fan of Creepypasta, then you should know the story of the Russian Sleep Experiment. An insane and creepy-as-hell work of fiction, the story is centred around a 1940's Russian experiment where the researchers kept five political prisoners deemed enemies of the state awake for fifteen days using an experimental gas based stimulant. Because it was before video cameras or reality television, they had only microphones and 5-inch thick glass porthole sized windows into the chamber to monitor them. The chamber was stocked with books, cots to sleep on but no bedding, running water and toilet, and enough dried food to last all five for over a month. The subjects had gone mad over time, some died, and some were screaming and fighting and begging to be freed, until one day all sound from inside the chamber stopped. Three days later, the researchers told the subjects that they would be coming in to test the microphones, to which one of them said, "we no longer want to be freed". When the researchers entered, some had eaten their own flesh, were terrified to leave the chamber and put up a huge fight. This would be a really great angle for American Horror Story to take, even if it was a Russian experiment.

4. Viral Outbreak

Perhaps a viral / bacterial / fungal outbreak isn't really something American Horror Story might do, but the idea is quite a compelling one. Instead of it being a "zombiefying" disease, it could just be a horrible outbreak of some other virus that leaves its victims with horrible delusions. Some Redditors believe it would be good to have a season like this on a cruise ship. User iloverunforfun suggests the following: "Cruise ships are perfect petri dishes for disease. And cults could be the type to attempt to propagate disease. ('Plague Ship', any Clive Cussler fans?)." The same user goes on to explain that the producers of American Horror Story can even combine the idea of a cult, a viral outbreak and the cruise ship idea into one and have "A cruise ship, with members of a cult on board who unleash a deadly virus as a part of a sacrificial ritual to some demigod they worship". It would definitely be a unique and interesting take on American Horror Story. They could have Danny Huston as the captain of the ship, Emma Roberts as a spoilt socialite, Denis O'Hare as a crazy cult follower who unleashes the deadly virus, along with his super sexy and super crazy wife, Lady Gaga. Yay or nay?

3. Summer Camp

Summer Camps are generally happy places with overly happy camp counselors, children and teens, but if you take a look at Friday the 13th, Sleepaway Camp, Camp Slaughter and a bunch of other horror films based on serial killers on campus, not all summer camps are as happy as they may seem after all. Perhaps the producers of American Horror Story can work on a 1980's summer camp - a time when Stephen King was the most sought-after author and perhaps have a teenage serial killer (or even serial killers) imitate the killings in his books at summer camp by killing fellow campers and counselors. It could be a nod to the old slasher films of the 1980's that Wes Craven was famous for, and if they manage to give it that old school charm, they might be able to get the older horror-loving generation to watch this season.

2. Dolls

Annabelle, Chucky, Tiffany. There's no doubt that dolls are extremely creepy and make for compelling horrors. Whether they're murderous or possessed, you can't really go wrong in using a children's doll as the sole inspiration for an entire season of American Horror Story. Surprisingly, the show hasn't had a single creepy doll in the series (unless I'm missing one?) and fans think it's high time they used some sort of demonic doll. Instead of going the usual "demonic possessed doll" route, they could derive inspiration from Patty Reed's Doll. The story behind that doll was that eight year old Patty Reed, who was traveling to California in 1846 with her family and other pioneers, a group known to history as the Donner Party, were a group of travelers who became snowbound and turned to eating bits of leather, mice, old bones - and, finally, each other. The fact that this doll was smuggled around the world while Patty Reed ate human flesh is rather disturbing, and it could also make for a compelling AHS theme.

1. Perfection

What could be creepier than the typical things you see on Halloween? Why, happy, wonderful and perfectly trained wives, of course. Think about the Stepford Wives and just how creepy that entire film was for a second. Whether you saw the original or its Nicole Kidman remake, it's all pretty much freaky. The season could be based on the same time as the original Stepford Wives (that was released in 1975) and could be surrounding a town that's terrorized by the men who live there, leaving the women to pretend that all is fine, wonderful and perfect. Of course, the women would obviously have their own agendas as well, and the season could focus on how each household has their own secret ways of murdering their enemies. I could definitely imagine Jessica Lange posing as a Stepford Wife, now if only the American Horror Story producers could convince her to come back to the show... What theme would you love to see American Horror Story take on in the future? Share your thoughts down in the comments.

Contributor
Contributor

"Don't take life too seriously. No one gets out alive anyway." Twitter: @GrungyUnicorn Instagram: https://instagram.com/mlgabriel22/ Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/mlgabrielwriting