American Horror Story: 10 Saddest Deaths
The saddest deaths in American Horror Story fans can't stop thinking about.
Death is an everyday occurrence in the twisted world of American Horror Story - it's expected when the show features the likes of murderous ghosts and serial killers.
Throughout all ten seasons of creators Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk's multi award-winning anthology, plenty of characters have been axed off - sometimes literally. While some of these victims desperately had it coming, plenty of the other characters we meet throughout the show didn't deserve their horrific fate.
Alongside the show's joyously campy tone, brazen sexuality, and grizzly violence, another aspect which made AHS great was its ensemble of memorable characters. Played by an all-star cast and brilliantly written, viewers would soon find themselves invested in each of their plights.
Everyone entangled in whatever monstrous happenings occurred in their respective season has their own hopes, dreams, love, and fears. And as the series continues, viewers will find themselves growing more and more attached to certain characters.
But there's rarely a pleasant ending to be found in this show, meaning that not all these beloved characters will get their happily ever after. And it's these loses that can be the most shocking of all to see.
Beware massive spoilers for American Horror Story ahead.
10. Winter Anderson
Played by the wonderful Billie Lourd in her debut role, Winter is the devout sister to Kai Andeson, Evan Peters' fanatical cult leader and main antagonist to the show's seventh season.
Viewers are first introduced to Winter when she takes a babysitting job for Ally and Ivy's son Oz. Though she initially seems like the perfect candidate (she even shares the couple's political views), her dark side is slowly revealed. Not only does she introduce the youngster to the Dark Web and give them front row seats to a real-life murder, but she also manipulates the couple to try to drive a wedge between them.
It's later revealed that Winter was in league with her brother and his cult the entire time. The siblings are shown to share an uncomfortably close bond throughout the series, with a pinky swear being a binding sign of their loyalty.
Unfortunately for Winter, though, Kai's derangement eventually sees him turn against her, falsely believing that she betrayed him.
This suspenseful encounter culminates in an intense sequence in which an enraged Kai strangles her. Peters and Lourd's dedicated performances are what make this death resonate so much. Winter did some terrible things, but she didn't deserve this.
9. Lee Harris
Thanks to a curse that sees the ghosts of a blood-thirsty colony wreak havoc whenever there's a blood moon, the inhabitants of Roanoke's Shaker Mansion don't tend to make it out alive. The most recent victims of The Butcher's fury were couple Shelby and Matt Miller alongside Matt's sister Lee. It was the latter who'd become the series' most tragic character.
Played by Adina Porter, Lee is a recovering alcoholic when viewers first meet her. Reeling from the loss of her first child and battling with a drug addiction that caused her to lose her job as a police officer, Lee is now battling for custody of her other daughter, Flora.
Throughout Lee's ordeal in this house, all she ever wanted was to be Flora's mother. At the end of the season when she learns that
Lee burns down the house and, in an ending reminiscent to Dark Water, Flora waves goodbye to the ghosts of Lee and Pracilla.
After everything Lee went through, her ultimate sacrifice closes Roanoke on a sombre note.
8. Benjamin Richter
In the show's ninth season, 1984, viewers were introduced to notorious serial killer Benjamin Richter (John Carroll Lynch) - aka Mr Jingles. He's a towering force of power who was allegedly responsible for a massacre in 1970 at Camp Redwood. And now that he's escaped from prison, he's about to return to the summer camp for more bloodshed.
His brutal kills and seemingly unstoppability made him a frightening presence within the show. And yet he would turn out to be one of the most tragic characters to appear within the anthology.
As the series progressed, viewers would discover that Richter wasn't the villain he was said to be. It's revealed that he took the blame for the real killer (Margaret Booth) and had a tragic childhood related to the camp's curse.
Years later, a newly reformed Richter would find himself at Camp Redwood again to protect his infant son from Richard Ramirez. However, in an intimate conversation with his mother, he realises that the only way he can accomplish this is if by killing himself and join the other spirits trapped at the camp.
It's a sombre scene that shows Richter wasn't the monster he was made out to be.
7. Meep
Freak Show - the show's fourth season - is home to a vibrant ensemble that viewers would spend their time getting to know. One character which audiences wouldn't become as well acquainted with, however, was Meep (Ben Woolf).
Part of Elsa Mars's sideshow attraction, Meep is the embodiment of innocence. During the brief time viewers are acquainted with him, it's clear from his child-like and sweet tendencies that this person wouldn't be capable of harming anyone - let alone being a serial killer.
Unfortunately for poor Meep, he finds himself a victim of circumstance. It turns out that Evan Peters' Jimmy Darling was the one who killed the missing detective and tried to frame the villainous Del. But Del caught on to Jimmy's plans and planted the evidence on Meep instead.
Dragged from his trailer still in full costume, Meep is taken to the local jail by the investigators and thrown in a cell.
As soon as the investigators leave, Meep is immediately surrounded by his cellmates who violently beat him to death, believing him to be the killer.
The next time audiences see Meep is when his battered body is dumped outside the freak show.
6. Ma Petite
Another character in Freak Show who didn't deserve their cruel fate was Ma Petite (who was portrayed by Jyoti Amge, the world's smallest woman).
Ever since she was brought into the sideshow, Ma Petite was like a daughter to both Elsa and Pepper. She completed their family and was likewise adored by the rest of the troupe.
Much like Meep, Ma Petite's playful spirit and cheerful attitude marked her as an instantly loveable character. But this is American Horror Story, and nothing good happens to good people here.
Ma Petite would find herself in the sights of swindler Stanley who means to exploit the sideshow to acquire new exhibits to sell to a museum, and Ma Petite would make the perfect new addition to his collection.
Though he initially tasked his partner in crime Maggie to kill her, she was unable to bring herself to do the horrific act. Stanley, however, wasn't so easily dissuaded by Ma Petite's charms.
This sequence is one of Freak Show's most harrowing moments and a death which audiences weren't soon to forget.
5. Karen
Set in a wintery Cape Cod, Red Tide (the first segment of Double Feature) saw a success-hungry author discover that he could unlock the full potential of his creativity by taking a mysterious black pill. If the user is talented, they'll achieve brilliance but develop a hungering appetite for blood. If they're merely mediocre, though, they'll be transformed into a shambling husk.
Caught in the middle of the blood and mayhem that ensues in this seaside town is an eccentric local dubbed Tuberculosis Karen, who's played by AHS veteran Sarah Paulson.
A talented artist who'd rather live a life of depravity than take the pills, Karen is forced to do the dirty work for the vampires. Her only loyal friend is fellow addict and aspiring screenwriter Mickey. But when he swallows the pills and becomes successful, he offers Karen the opportunity to have the life she's always wanted.
To Karen, though, the price is simply too much. After Mickey forces her
Leaving her masterpiece and Mickey's body on the beach, Karen slits her wrists and walks into the ocean.
4. Sister Mary Eunice
Making her debut in the first season, the sensationally talented Lily Rabe has since become an invaluable asset to the anthology's ensemble. Appearing in every season except Cult, Rabe has portrayed numerous fan favourite characters. But it's the unfortunate end to Sister Mary Eunice from Asylum which sees Rabe appear on this list.
A kindly but timid nun working at the nefarious Briarcliff Manor, Mary Eunice spent the first part of the season living under the thumb of Jessica Lange's domineering Sister Jude and the devious Dr Arden. But everything changes when Eunice becomes possessed by the devil during a botched exorcism.
From herein, the once sweet nun is transformed into one of the series main antagonists, becoming a murderous and manipulative vessel for evil who'll do whatever she can to cause chaos within the asylum.
Despite her satanic tendencies, however, the real Mary Eunice remained present within her body. It was only when Monsignor Timothy Howard was able to appeal directly to her purity that an exhausted Mary was able to briefly take back control.
Just as Mary looks to be saved, though, the monsignor throws her to her death, which she solemnly accepts.
If anyone in AHS deserved to live, it was Sister Mary Eunice.
3. LIz Taylor
Amongst all the cruelty and death trapped within the fifth season's Hotel Cortez, there was one ray of light, and that was bartender Liz Taylor (Denis O'Hare).
Originally arriving at the hotel on a business trip in the 1980s, Liz was suffering from gender dysphoria until she met The Countess. The vampiric owner of the establishment instantly sensed and sympathised with Liz's struggle and helped her transition into who she is now. Grateful for her help, Liz would leave her old life behind and take a job at the hotel's Blue Parrot Lounge.
Over the ensuing years, Liz would get to know all the Cortez's undead residents and would become somewhat of a maternal figure and friend to them.
At the end of the series, however, Liz announces that she has terminal cancer. Rather than spending the last days of her life in hospital, she decides to end her life at the hotel so that she might live on with her surrogate family.
To the moving soundtrack of Marianne Faithfull's 'The Ballad Of Lucy Jones', Liz allows a tearful Countess to slit her throat.
In AHS, death isn't always the end. For Liz, it was a new beginning.
2. Adelaide Langdon
The many ghosts which populate the eponymous Murder House of American Horror Story's first season are each bound to the house by their own tragic turn of events. But the horrors of the show aren't just reserved for inside the house. One character who experienced this first-hand was Adelaide Langdon (Jamie Brewer), who met their devastating end on Halloween night.
Tate's sister and the daughter of the cold and calculating Constance, Adelaide (Addie for short) used to live in the Murder House before the Harmons moved in and knows all about the house's spectral residents. Despite her troubled upbringing, Addie remained one of the most loving and compassionate characters in the show. And it's this which makes her death infinitely more painful.
Jessica Lange's gut-wrenching performance only underscores the shocking loss of one of American Horror Story's most cherished characters.
1. Violet Harmon
In the first series of American Horror Story, fans were introduced to the Harmon family when they moved into their new, stylish Californian home in hopes of mending their fractured relationships.
Unfortunately for them, the titular Murder House which this series took its name is one of the most haunted houses in America.
Stuck in the middle of the turbulent family drama was Violet Harmon (Taissa Farmiga). An angsty teenager suffering from depression, Violet would soon become captivated with her new home's dark history as well as her new neighbour, Tate Langdon (Evan Peters). The pair form a strong bond, with Tate being the only source of true happiness in Violet's life.
However, when the teenager learns of Tate's murderous past, tragedy strikes. Heartbroken by the revelation, Violet attempts suicide with sleeping pills to be saved by Tate - or so we're led to believe.
Later, in the anthology's most harrowing twist to date, we learn that Violet did succeed in taking her own life.
When Tate shows Violet her body under the floorboards, the image of her rotting corpse is shocking enough, but it's the pair's raw performances that renders this scene completely devastating. It's as shocking or viewers as it is for Violet.