American Horror Story: 10 Scariest Moments

Asylums and slaughter and killer clowns, oh my...

American Horror Story is somewhat of a cultural phenomenon, rarely experienced by mainstream media, despite not being a truly mainstream hit. The FX-produced horror series, from the minds of Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk, began life as the tale of the Harmon family, moving to Los Angeles to begin anew and finding themselves living in what was dubbed 'the Murder House', following a string of murders, suicides, and 'accidental' deaths. The next year, the show reinvigorated itself with a new story, and old regulars from the first season playing entirely new characters, becoming a performing troupe that every year would become new faces and new stories. Each season took place in a new supernatural or horrific centre - an asylum, a coven, and a freak show circus respectively. However, Murphy recently confirmed that the seasons are interconnected - with the re-introduction of two faces from American Horror Story's second season Asylum into the story of fourth and current season Freak Show - meaning that the key stand-alone rule has been broken; anything goes. American Horror Story is both renowned and reviled for its horrific, bloody, and gory moments, bringing more serial killers to the table than an average season of Law & Order. Everything from mutilation, incest, eye gouging, physical and sexual assault, mass killings, brutality of every kind, and supernatural occurrences that would terrify even the most stalwart and hardy of horror fans are on display. So, to look back on the past three and a half years of bloodshed, mayhem, and a lot of murder, here are ten of the most simply scariest and truly horrifying moments that American Horror Story brought to our screens...

10. Madison's Attack (Coven)

Coming in at the beginning of this terrifying top ten, is one of the most human and hauntingly horrific moments American Horror Story showed us - the brutal attack of spoiled movie star witch Madison Montgomery (Emma Roberts) at a frat party down the block from the witch school Ms. Robichaux's Academy, after she decides to attend to blow off some steam. Madison is by no means, an easily sympathetic character, but this brutal, terrifying assault by a group of disgusting frat boys sickens no matter who the victim. Madison manages to make her way out of the attack, but only with the help of new girl Zoe (Taissa Farmiga) and after she's been violated and raped. She then, in a fugue state, crashes the bus of the escaping frat boys with her telekinetic rage, a la Carrie White, and gives a brutal, bloody act of vengeance as the climax of episode one of Coven.

9. The High School Massacre (Murder House)

You know a show is going to be brutal when the horrific slaying a number of teenagers in an all-too-close hit on school shootings barely makes the top ten spot. This particular mass killing - because in the world of American Horror Story, there are quite a few of them - is highlighted through its POV of troubled shooter Tate (Evan Peters), whose portrayal of the conflicted, desperately dark and broken Tate proved to be a highlight of Murder House for viewers. Tate slaughters his classmates, remorselessly gunning them down in a sequence fraught with tension and fear, even though you already know who doesn't make it through the firefight. Tate then escapes to his house where he is gunned down by a SWAT team, kickstarting the journey of one of American Horror Story's most troubled, dangerous, and charming characters, and an iconic role for Peters. Suffice it to say, this is not the last time he'll be featured on this list...

8. The Monsignor's Crucifixion (Asylum)

Okay, so Monsignor Timothy Howard (Joseph Fiennes) wasn't perhaps one of American Horror Story's's most popular lead characters, but he proved to be an intriguing moral force, darker beneath the surface than he appeared, and more powerless than his title allowed him to be. Timothy proved his mettle in various ways, such as the mercy killing of one of Arden's mutated experiments, and in ridding the asylum of the Devil that possessed the body and soul of the sweet Sister Mary Eunice. However, the Monsignor's most memorable moment isn't a heroic one - it's a brutally violent one. Whilst trying to give psychotic murderer Leigh Emerson (a scene-stealing Ian McShane) baptism and redemption, the Monsignor is knocked out by Emerson who then brutalises and crucifies the man of God in his own church, nailing him to the large cross inside the church, and leaving him for the mercy of the Angel of Death, Shachath (Frances Conroy). It's a brutal scene, particularly for those of the Christian faith, and it's no wonder Monsignor Howard's journey became even darker following that terrifying ordeal...

7. Shelley's Mutilation (Asylum)

Shelley was one of the less memorable side-characters in AHS's repertoire of freaks, geeks, and psychotic murderers, but thanks to a solid performance by Chloe Sevigny, she relishes one of the most horrifying moments in American Horror Story history thanks to the villainous Dr Arthur Arden, a Nazi doctor performing experiments in an American asylum. Shelley, a nymphomaniac banished to the asylum for having extramarital sex, is tortured, mutilated, amputated, and shockingly experimented on by Dr Arden after she finds his... well, manhood, less than adequate following a rape attempt. His overreaction almost kills Shelley as he experiments with the limits of humanity. His previous experiments the Raspers have become monstrous savages chained in the woods outside of Briarcliff and, sadly, Shelley comes out even worse. The possessed Sister Mary Eunice dumps the barely-alive, monstrous Shelley in a school playground; just in time for a young girl to find her and give us one of the most haunting and horrible moments in American Horror Story history.

6. Vivien And The Rubber Man (Murder House)

Poor Vivien. The beleaguered matriarch of the Harmon family (Connie Britton), as the central lead in Murder House Vivien arguably suffered the most during the first season, enduring a failing marriage, an unexpected pregnancy, spooky goings on with the neighbours and her own house. However, it all falls short to her attack and sexual assault by the Rubber Man, one of Season 1's most iconic images (especially during promotional pictures). Vivien awakens one night to find herself being seduced by a man in a leather gimp suit she assumes is her husband Ben, attempting a physical and emotional reconnection with Vivien following his adultery and her subsquent miscarriage. She consents under this illusion, but soon discovers that the rough sex she experienced was not only a sexual assault and rape by the twisted Tate, attempting to procure children, but that she is experiencing a mysterious, and sinister, pregnancy. And all this happens in the first ever episode. Spooky indeed...

5. The Zombie Assault On The Academy (Coven)

Zombies. Why did it have to be zombies? The third season of American Horror Story featured some impressive horror trope moments amidst the black humour and supernatural elements, including the invocation of a zombie army by voodoo queen Marie Laveau (an indomitable Angela Bassett), to attack the students of Miss Robichaux's Academy on Halloween. With their leaders scattered thanks to a power vacuum and a brutal acid attack on headmistress Cordelia, rendering both her and Supreme mother Fiona (Jessica Lange) MIA, the girls were forced to scramble to survive, and LaLaurie faced her horrific treatment of her daughters, now zombie horde slaves. The sequence, which played over that year's Hallowe'en two-parter, gave viewers some truly gruesome moments, such as the hapless trick-or-treaters getting snacked on, or the terrifying beats as Nan (Jamie Brewer) and an injured Luke (Alexander Dreymon) trying to escape inside for safety. Fortunately, new girl Zoe (Taissa Farmiga) proved her salt by channeling her inner Ash Williams and letting loose a chainsaw on the zombie horde, unleashing a powerful, subconscious power display (one strong enough to shatter Laveau's control). Even though she was woefully underused the rest of the season, Zoe had a crowning moment of gore-splattered glory, and the sequence gave everyone nightmares for the rest of the week.

4. Lana's Capture And Ordeal (Asylum)

Lana Winters is one of the most powerful and iconic characters in the history of American Horror Story, largely because she was arguably the character who suffered the most trauma and yet emerged as a survivor at the end of her season, enduring more than any one person - fictional or not - should ever have to go through. One of the crowning horrors in Lana's life has to be her brief escape from Briarcliff... and into the arms of Dr Thredson, otherwise known as the serial killer Bloody Face, in a role made for Heroes and Star Trek actor Zachary Quinto. When Lana deduces his true identity (thanks to some skin appropriated as furniture, and his creepy basement chamber), he shoves her down a trapdoor, abuses her, shows the corpse of her lover Wendy (Clea Duvall) and then makes her kiss Wendy's corpse while he dresses in Bloody Face's attire, all despite Lana's heartrending sobs of anguish and despair. A truly horrific, bleak moment only redeemed by Lana's escape shortly after.

3. LaLaurie's Torture Chamber (Coven)

Easily the highlight of an uneven but enjoyable third outing for American Horror Story, newcomer to the series Kathy Bates flexed her acting chops to give a complicated, funny, relentlessly dark and brutal take on one of history's great mass murderers - Madame Delphine LaLaurie, a notorious racist and torturer. Delphine soon finds herself immortal after being cursed by Marie Laveau, and awakened in the modern day in order to be a bargaining chip between Jessica Lange's selfish Supreme Fiona and the modern, ageless Marie. In the series opener, LaLaurie discovers a dalliance between one of her beleaguered daughters and a house servant, Bastien. In revenge, she tortures Bastien and then sews the head of a bull to his head, transforming him into a minotaur in a sequence that is equally brutal and mesmerising in its cruelty. Bates sells the role of Delphine with panache, and while she almost softens down the line, at the start she is at her genial finest, blending elegance with senseless and bigoted violence that's tough to stomach.

2. Twisty's Attack (Freak Show)

The only mention on this list from the ongoing fourth season of the anthology series, Freak Show, Twisty the Clown more than earned his spot on this list of haunting terrors for being one of the frightening presences to ever grace televisual screens, thanks in no small part to John Carroll Lewis' career-making turn. In his first full appearance, Twisty surprises a canoodling young couple and soon knocks them out with his juggling clubs. The girl, Bonnie Lipton (Skyler Samuels) awakens to find Twisty stabbing her beau violently to death. Screaming, she manages to get up and run, only to soon find herself captured by the macabre clown in a frightening and frenetic moment that establishes Twisty as an American Horror Story fan favourite, of sorts. His current status as the most twisted individual on Freak Show remains to be challenged - Twisty and Carroll Lynch have more than earned their spots in the great hall of American Horror Story alumn. Twisty is psychotic, twisted, and is soon discover, more than he seems, making him truly terrifying, and his attacks on the town even darker than anyone could ever have imagined...

1. Lana's Escapes (Asylum)

Lana Winters is one of those rare characters who comes along once in a lifetime, and is destined to become iconic, in one way or another. Lana (Sarah Paulson, in an award-winning turn) earned her fame and notoriety as a character who survived more than any one person ever should, enduring to the modern day when she faced a final showdown with her murderous son, becoming both a true survivor and a modern televisual hero. Lana suffers not one, but two brutal, shocking escape attempts during her trials as a result of Briarcliff, each respectively terrifying in their own respect. The first, seems like false hope granted by Lana's ingenuity - she escapes the lair of Bloody Face, only to get picked up by a raging, random misogynist (a scene-stealing William Mapother) and driven into a tree, where she is soon picked up and sent back to Briarcliff. The second escape, one engineered by the simply saintly Mother Claudia (the underused Barbara Tarbuck), and at the behest of a redeemed if mentally traumatised Sister Jude (Lange), has Lana walk out of the front doors of Briarcliff with Claudia and Thredson's confession on tape, in a sequence worthy of Hitchcock. All while her captor, Dr Thredson, stands by, talking to Kit (Peters) about the tape which will exonerate Kit and damn Thredson as the true murderer. Fortunately, Lana escapes into a taxicab, thanks to a sacrifice by foe-turned-friend Kit to keep Thredson distracted, allowing Lana to show him both the stolen tape, and a grimly exultant one-fingered salute to her once-captor. It's a wonderful, fist-pumping, triumphant moment that gives this story of true, unbridled terror, the pay-off it deserves, and jump-starts the final moment of Lana's flawed and heroic arc - taking down Thredson and Briarcliff once and for all, in a classic final act. There are way too many shocking, terrifying, or gruesome American Horror Story moments to cover in just one article - what are your favourite scary moments? Write them down in the comments below.

Contributor
Contributor

Leeds native, film fanatic, TV obsessive and relentless pop music fan. Sings off-key at any chance.