American Horror Story: 10 Things Freak Show Must Do Better Than Its Predecessors

Or how to send Jessica Lange out on a high...

With series creator Ryan Murphy revealing that the forthcoming American Horror Story season will be called Freak Show, the internet has become abuzz with anticipation. Each year the show has taken a different horror premise and Freak Show is set to follow in the footsteps of Murder House, Asylum and Coven. What we know exactly about Freak Show is limited, but described here. In the previous three seasons American Horror Story has covered a wide range of horror staples, from alien abductions to witches, serial killers, voodoo and evil Nazi doctors. But what must Freak Show do to stand out from the seasons that came before it? With a simply astounding ensemble cast lined up, there is high hopes that Freak Show can be the best American Horror Story year yet. But it will be the last season to feature Jessica Lange, so there is the expectation that she will go out on a high. With Angela Bassett, Kathy Bates and Emma Roberts all returning from their debuts in Coven to join the ongoing cast of Evan Peters, Sarah Paulson and Jamie Brewer, there is a wide range of acting talent available €“ especially as the big signing for this year is Michael Chiklis (sans the Thing costume, which he's presumably given to Jamie Bell). But what exactly must Freak Show improve on to give Lange the send-off that she deserves? Here are ten tweaks that the production team need to get right in Freak Show to make it the best season of American Horror Story ever.

10. Keep It Unpredictable

It may simply be that viewers have become more accustomed to American Horror Story over the years, but each season is getting more and more predictable. At no point during Murder House did you think that you could guess what was going to happen. When Violet was revealed as a ghost, it came as a complete shock - and was an utterly absorbing twist (having been done in a far better manner than The Sixth Sense). But by the time Coven came around the twists were all used up. Sure when it was revealed that Cordelia was the Supreme it was interesting, but not much of a shock as it seemed like a suitable choice, especially since the show had been heavily hinting that it was going to be either Madison or Zoe. So Freak Show needs to keep things coming at the viewer out of left field. Remember that fans are expecting twists €“ so by trying to make something obvious, it is only natural for them to look in the opposite direction €“ exactly what happened with Cordelia. So play to the genre's strengths and keep those fans on the rails, because if the viewers are sitting on the edge of their seats then they'll come back for more.

9. Put The HORROR In American Horror Story

Simply put, the end of Coven was not frightening by any means, and the last few episodes would not have been out of place in a teen drama about witches. But all you need to do is to skip back a year to Asylum and there was a mad Nazi doctor cutting the legs off of poor Chloë Sevingy. Murder House had jars of foetuses in a basement. Even just the credits for the first two years were hard to watch. While Coven was an excellent series, it was a diet version of American Horror Story. It didn't look that way from the start as there were scenes of torture and an immortal Minotaur running around. But for some reason about two thirds in the series just stopped being scary €“ right about the time that the witch hunters got involved. People being shot isn't frightening in a horror context anymore €“ otherwise you'd have to call 24 a horror series too. So to the writers: remember the Horror part of American Horror Story and try to scare the pants off us. The forthcoming season is called Freak Show and so immediately harks more back to Asylum €“ which hopefully means that it'll be far scarier than Coven ended up being. Plus there's bound to be clowns €“ and anyone who's seen Stephen King's IT will already have a deep ingrained fear of clowns.

8. Guest Stars

Previously there has been some excellent star turns by guest stars in American Horror Story. No one will look at a party Santa in the same way again after seeing Ian McShane being so menacing in Asylum. It came out of absolutely nowhere and probably confused a lot of British viewers who are more used to McShane being in Lovejoy. But there is one actor who needs to be involved in American Horror Story €“ and last year the writers wrote him a love letter. In one scene during Coven, Zoe grabs a chainsaw and goes to town on several zombies. That can only be a reference to Ash from The Evil Dead, aka Bruce Campbell. If they could somehow land Campbell in any role then it would be a triumph and a decent return to series television for such a great genre actor. But given the wide number of actors who have appeared over the past three years of the series, there is certainly room for one or more of them to appear in only an episode or two of Freak Show as a form of goodbye to Jessica Lange. Anyone of them could be a guest star in the forthcoming season. It would be wonderful to see Zachery Quinto and Dylan McDermott crop up in Freak Show, if only for an episode or two.

7. Flash Backs/Forwards

Both Asylum and Coven featured a series of time jumps which were repeated throughout the seasons. While Asylum jumped forward to the present to show what was happened at the then derelict asylum, Coven jumped back to see the origins of Madam LaLaurie in the 1830s. Each time they worked slightly differently €“ Asylum opened each time with a flash forward whereas Coven only used them for character development. The problem with Asylum's use of them was that they were quite distracting €“ it took quite a few episodes before it became clear at all about what was going on, but then it used them to wrap up the season at the end. This improved somewhat with Coven €“ but the reverse in this case was the problem due to the lack of true horror that year, with the exception of the flash backs. It is quite obvious that they will play some part in Freak Show €“ after all, Jessica Lange is going to play a German, and with the series set in 1950 it would be rather strange if there were no flash backs to the events of the Second World War. Freak Show needs to show a better balance in the events both in the main setting and any other time period to ensure that the themes are carried through to stop the season from feeling disjointed.

6. Keep It Simple

Murder House kept it simple. Well... comparatively simple. There was a house that trapped the souls of anyone who died within its walls. Oh, and a devil baby. Asylum went completely overboard with the horror themes it attempted to cram into the season €“ there were multiple serial killers, Nazi doctors, human experimentation, alien abduction and death... and then the asylum setting itself. Two or three of these could have been removed and there still would have been enough to carry the season. Asylum learnt from this to some degree as it only introduced certain elements over time, but even then there were stories involving witchcraft, voodoo, witch hunters and the afterlife. At least with Coven they were tailored better to fit together, whereas it felt like the ideas for Asylum were chosen randomly with a bingo machine. So Freak Show needs to learn from Coven in this regard and make sure that where it employs multiple horror themes that they naturally fit together. Fortunately a 1950's setting should make this easier as there will be the after effects from the Second World War and of course the dawn of McCarthyism gripping the United States. In amongst this there are the obvious carnival links €“ you only need to see (or read) Something Wicked This Way Comes to see the potential.

5. There Are Two Sides To Every Horror Story

One of the key things that a horror film sometimes needs to balance itself is a dash of comedy €“ and American Horror Story is no different, but it either does this badly or really accidentally. Take the most recent episode €“ the finale of Coven. It had Stevie Nicks singing a song and opened with a music video €“ which naturally was a big pile of cheese... very, very amusing cheese. You have to believe that this wasn't an intentional move. You can't really imagine Ryan Murphy asking Stevie Nicks to appear in the finale in order to sing a song to make us all laugh. She always seems a bit too intense to ever consider such a move €“ although that season did also cover her showing Misty Day how to do the twirl with the shawl properly. So perhaps it was deliberately funny. But don't go the fully Army of Darkness route either. That is way too far down the comedy track to ever be considered a true horror film anymore €“ even if it is only compared to Evil Dead or the first sequel. The sarcasm or charm that AHS has occasionally shown needs to come more to the fore €“ more lines like Jessica Lange referring to Bewitched in Coven.

4. Leave The Dead Alone

Frankly unless you're going to give us zombies, vampires or some other undead creature as a result of someone being killed, then American Horror Story needs to remember the value of killing off characters. It became a bit of a joke in Coven €“ sure, the first time that someone was brought back from the dead was pretty neat. But by the end it became surprising when someone wasn't resurrected. It seems unlikely that there will be such in and out coffin antics, because the producers wouldn't want to return immediately to the witchcraft theme once again. But they can learn from this €“ don't introduce something and then overuse it. The audience gets bored, and it stops being either a shock or anything remotely like a twist. Naturally there is no way to tell what elements Freak Show might yet overuse until there are some further details released on the show. The producers need to keep everything in check €“ this isn't their first season, or even their first series. They simply need to keep an eye on the overall series to make sure that nothing is overused as badly as the resurrection of Coven.

3. Don't Exploit For The Sake Of A Storyline

One of the concerns levelled at American Horror Story is that it can come across as exploitative. In Coven, these complaints mostly pointed at the black/white divide and war between the two types of witches, and that isn't even to start on the slavery issues. Naturally with the forthcoming season being subtitled Freak Show there is some potential concern that it could exploit the disabilities of background actors. But this need not be the case. For example, despite the look of Pepper in Asylum (as seen above), it was a look developed entirely via make up. This shows a level of creativity inherent in the production team that should mean that these concerns can be put to rest. The easiest comparison has to be to HBO's Carnivàle €“ despite certain characters being recruited for their look, others were enhanced using makeup. For example, the conjoined twins were played by the non-conjoined Steben Twins, and the Gecko's scaly skin was simply make-up applied to the non-scaly John Fleck. None of these are particular challenges for a decent television make-up department, and there must be plenty of film quality make-up artists who would want to take up the challenge. Mind you, this didn't stop certain people from thinking that Pepper really looked like that, and it won't stop this mistake (and the ensuing accusation of exploitation) being directed towards AHS in the future.

2. Keep Character Development Consistent

While some characters such as Madam LaLaurie received some quite intense character development, others were almost entirely overlooked. For example, Fiona Goode never really got more than a couple of flashbacks which while set up her actions, didn't explain why she did what she did. In the hands of anyone but Jessica Lange, it would have been a dreadful character but giving it to such a fine actress saved it. These important character evolutions are opportunities for writing. Rather than trying to create something new, if the writers can seize the chance to explain a character's motivation, then the audience will thank them for it, especially if that motivation also moves the overall story forward as well. Admittedly this is something that American Horror Story is getting better at - back in the days of Murder House this didn't appear to happen at all. American Horror Story needs to get even better at this. While they have a good cast, they need to give them the type of complex characters that they can handle rather than use them to cover the cracks in the writing. To be honest, this is a Ryan Murphy trait €“ just look at Quinn or Tina on Glee, who both end up changing major character traits for no reason at a quicker speed than WWE drops a terrible gimmick.

1. Give Jessica Lange A Good Send Off

American Horror Story and Jessica Lange are hand in hand €“ she is a fabulous actress and was a complete stand-out star in Murder House, so much so that she was made effectively the main character for quite large portions of the following two seasons. This is to be expected once again in Freak Show €“ but one thing that hasn't been done yet is to give her character a happy ending. In Murder House she ended up looking after the demon baby, while in Asylum she died from an illness after undergoing some rather unfortunate treatment in the asylum itself. As for Coven €“ well, there can only be one Supreme at a time, and in order for a new one to take over the old one must die. Certainly it might not be normal for a character in a horror story to have a happy ending, but certain characters had theirs in past seasons €“ but this does seem to be restricted to Sarah Paulson's characters in Asylum and Coven. It's about time that Lange's character got a swing at happiness, and it would be a wonderful send off to such a marvellous actress, especially as the person who really put American Horror Story on the map. What else do you think American Horror Story needs to improve on? Leave your thoughts and opinions below!

Contributor
Contributor

I'm a pop culture addict. Television, cinema, comics, games - you name it, and I've done it. Or at least read the plot synopsis on Wikipedia.