American Horror Story: Apocalypse - 2 Ups & 5 Downs From ‘Fire And Reign’
A problematic penultimate episode makes saving the world an impossible task.
Contains spoilers from American Horror Story Season 8, Episode 9.
Michael Langdon dominated last week's episode of American Horror Story: Apocalypse, as the Anti-Christ came to terms with who he is, and what his destiny entails. By the time the credits rolled around, he set about his mission to end the world.
While Sojourn dealt with the beginnings of the end of the world, Fire and Reign focuses on the Coven's plan to prevent it from happening in the first place, as Cordelia, Myrtle and the other witches of Miss Robichaux's Academy take centre stage once more.
While Michael is doing everything he can to initiate the apocalypse, his main goal is to dispose of the witches for what they did to his beloved Miss Mead (the real one, not the robot). In fact, the conflict between the Anti-Christ and the witches is very much the driving force behind this instalment, and it provides for some wonderful moments throughout.
However, while there is a lot to like and appreciate about American Horror Story: Apocalypse's penultimate episode, it's not without its faults. And unfortunately, there are quite a few.
Ups...
2. The Birth Of The Cooperative
American Horror Story undoubtedly has one of the oddest narrative structures we've ever seen on television. The show often employs lengthy flashbacks and flash-forwards when they need to fill in some of the gaps in their stories. By this stage in the game, viewers are used to learning information this way, because if there's one thing we know about Ryan Murphy, it's that he really doesn't do linear storytelling.
Apocalypse is no different to previous seasons of the show, but you could be justified in arguing that it has the oddest narrative structure yet. The first three episodes of Apocalypse dealt with the aftermath of the nuclear warfare, and centred heavily around the goings-on of Outpost 9, before going back in time to fill in the blanks - and we've yet to return to the present.
During those first three episodes, authoritarian leader Wilhemina Venable often mentioned the powers that be - referring to them as the Cooperative. However, in spite of the constant mentions, very little is known about who the Cooperative actually are. That's where Fire and Reign comes in.
If the short instalment accomplishes anything, it's enlightening viewers as to who the Cooperative are, as well as making clear their part in the end of the world. Through this organisation, Michael practically has his own coven - one that will likely go head to head to Cordelia in the next episode.
1. The Fiona Goode Conversation
While Apocalypse has been the most enjoyable season of American Horror Story in quite some time, there has been one large disappointment, and that's the evident absence of Coven queen Fiona Goode. Of course, this is largely in part due to Jessica Lange no longer being a regular cast member on the show, but considering the fact that Murphy was able to convince the Emmy-winning actress into making an appearance as Constance Langdon, surely there was a possibility of having Lange return as the character everybody wanted to see?
While we might not get our wish, it was great to see Cordelia reminiscing about how abhorrent her mother was during the latest episode. The dynamic between the young woman and Fiona was one of Coven's best attributes, which is perhaps why her absence in Apocalypse is so damn noticeable.
The conversation ends with Myrtle confirming that Cordelia is nothing like her mother, while reinforcing how the young Supreme is more important to the fate of the world than Fiona ever was. While it's true that Cordelia is pretty remarkable, it's impossible to not theorise about what Fiona would've done had she found herself in this situation with Michael. The short answer is that Fiona wouldn't be in this situation in the first place, as she would've handled it long ago. She might've been a nightmare, but she was a lot more resourceful than Cordelia.
Downs...
5. It Doesn't Really Escalate Things
As mentioned earlier, Fire and Reign is the penultimate episode of Apocalypse, meaning that the story comes to an end next week. However, you'd never guess that from watching it, as not an awful lot transpires, and the instalment feels like nothing more than you're average episode of American Horror Story. Sure, there's that epic Terminator-esque face-off between Michael and the witches where he obliterates almost all of the coven, but given that we know the likes of Zoe are alive in the present day narrative, this massacre feels unworthy of a place in the second-to-last episode.
What's more, the conclusion - which sees Michael introduce himself to the members of the Cooperative before proceeding to inform them of his mission - does little to suggest that the story comes to an end next week.
The penultimate episodes of Murder House, Asylum, Coven and Roanoke were all incredibly enticing, and left us dying to know how this story was going to end. The perfect penultimate episode of Apocalypse would have returned the story to the present day events, and seen Cordelia and Michael confab one last time, before next week's finale reveals which of the two powerful beings comes up victorious.
4. It's Too Short
Remember the days when episodes of American Horror Story used to be a total of 90 minutes long? Well, it seems that this is well and truly a thing of the past. Last week's episode of Apocalypse ran for a mere 38 minutes, which might've seemed awfully short, but given that the episode was a one-off Michael-centric instalment - carried almost entirely by actor Cody Fern, who has been a real revelation this season - it was completely understandable for it to be a bit shorter than you average episode.
Unfortunately, this trend continues into Fire and Reign, which is also only 38 minutes long. Following on from the previous point, considering this is the penultimate episode of Apocalypse, and considering there is still so much more flashback narrative left to cover before we even get to the present day stuff, you'd think Fire and Reign would've at least been the standard 48 minutes. Instead, we're given a much shorter episode - one that depicts only the events that we already knew, therefore feeling rather pointless.
3. The Flashback Is A Complete Waste Of Time
You'd think that the silver lining in having a much shorter instalment would be that the writers would make use of every single second. Unfortunately this isn't the case. During one particular sequence, in order to see if Mallory has the power to go back in time, Myrtle fills the young witch in on the execution of the Romanov family back in 1918.
However, during Myrtle's would-be brief history lesson, the show opts for the scenic route and dramatises the execution for viewers, giving us a lengthy - and incredibly gory - flashback. If that wasn't bad enough, Mallory doesn't succeed in her mission, which thus renders the entire sequence a waste of time.
Since Mallory was never meant to save the girl, certainly it would've made more sense to have Myrtle briefly explain the events rather than spending quite a lot of time on a destined-to-fail mission?
2. Mallory As The Next Supreme
Speaking of Mallory, she's one of the only Miss Robichuax witches to survive the massacre, which is a questionable creative decision. For some reason, the show has decided to set her up to become the next Supreme without developing her character whatsoever. Viewers know next to nothing about her, and it's hard to see her as anything other than incredibly one dimensional. What's more, she's no Fiona Goode or Cordelia Foxx, so it's hard to buy that she's in the same league as these two powerful witches.
What's worse is that, from a narrative point of view, the Mallory character simply can't hold a candle to any of the previous Coven girls, and yet they're being overlooked in favour of her. She also shares many similarities with fan favourite Misty Day - who's been absent since her resurrection - which doesn't go down to well, as it's coming off as though the writers are compensating for Misty's absence with Mallory who, again, can't compete with the previous creations. At this stage in the game, the viewers would rather spend time with the characters they've grown to love. Perhaps the writers will rectify these issues in the final episode, but by then it might be too late.
1. Plot Conveniences
American Horror Story has always bent the rules a bit when it comes to story conventions, but even if we take that into account, the creative decisions still have to be remotely believable. And yet, there were quite a few implausible moments in Fire and Reign.
For example, we learned previously that, before incinerating the real Miss Mead, Cordelia put a clocking spell on her soul so that Michael would be unable to retrieve her. It's a smart move for the witch, because it meant that the Anti-Christ couldn't hurt her, otherwise he'd never be able to bring back his beloved friend. However, in Fire and Reign Michael makes it his mission to destroy Cordelia and the witches. What about Miss Mead, you might ask? Well, apparently the show expects us to buy that the Miss Mead android is enough for Michael, so therefore he no longer needs his loving companion. Bit of a stretch, don't you think?
Perhaps if Michael were any ordinary human being, then the writers might just get away with this, but he's the freakin' Anti-Christ - surely he'd be smart enough to figure out a way to save his surrogate mother?
This isn't the only narrative thread that's problematic. The other is Cordelia's decision to visit the warlocks. The Supreme and her fellow witches were in hiding at this point in the episode, fearing for their lives - knowing full well that Michael was going to murder them if he had been given half the chance - and yet where do they go for help? To the very place they encountered the Anti-Christ in the first place. Because that makes total sense.
What did you make of the penultimate episode of American Horror Story: Apocalypse? Tell us in the comment section below.