Angel: Every Main Character Ranked Worst To Best
The bad and the great of Angel Investigations.
As a spin-off to the cultural phenomenon Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Angel did an impressive job of separating itself from its predecessor and solidifying itself as a great, inventive and daring show in its own right.
This is down to a number things, from the change in setting to the much darker tone, but the most pivotal aspect of Angel came with its characters.
Though title character Angel and Cordelia Chase were already established characters by the time the spin-off was commissioned, new characters such as Charles Gunn, Lorne and Fred Burkle allowed the show to feel fresh and easily separated from the adventures of Sunnydale and the Scooby Gang. With new characters to watch and admire, Angel became a much-loved supernatural drama, often rivalling the ratings of its sister show.
Each character in Angel has something interesting to offer, with the vast majority growing massively over the show's epic five season run.
The following list will have a look at all of Angel's key players, from the titular vampire himself to his closest allies, from his long-time foes to his most trusted confidants. Whether they're eccentric demons, former Watchers or failed actresses, here are the main characters of Angel ranked from worst to best.
11. Connor
There were moments when Connor (Vincent Kartheiser) looked like he was going to be one of the show's best characters. Son of Angel (David Boreanaz) and Darla (Julie Benz), he was kidnapped by Angel's arch-nemesis Holtz (Keith Szarabajka), and raised in another dimension to despise his father and want him dead.
Though when he returns, intent on killing Angel, there are sparks of brilliance anchored by the pair's seriously fractured relationship, Connor gets tiresome very quick, and by Season 4 he's nothing but a frustratingly inconsistent, naive kid with no defining characteristics outside of his "I'm-good-I'm-evil" persona.
His ugly, ill-advised relationship with Cordelia (Charisma Carpenter) and makes the low point of the character (and the show), and his shifting allegiances makes for a painful series of episodes.
In the show's fifth season, he reappears as a guest star and proves more likeable and compelling than ever, forming a genuine bond with his father and allowing Kartheiser (a serious talent who would go on to star in Mad Men) something interesting to chew on. Unfortunately, it was all too little too late, and the damage had been done.
10. Harmony Kendall
Mean-girl-turned-vampire Harmony Kendall (Mercedes McNab) first appeared on Angel in the second season, reuniting with her old BFF Cordelia before revealing herself as a vampire. She then disappears, before reappearing in the show's final season to act as Angel's new secretary in his offices at Wolfram and Hart.
This opens up some great moments of dark comedy, as Harmony - always materialistic and a bit naive - proves to be the funniest and most awkward vampire in the Buffyverse. Her blunt, sarcastic nature makes it clear why she was brought in following the loss of Cordelia, and her interactions with the likes of Angel and Spike (James Marsters) are simply hysterical.
This is all well and good, but there's just not enough of Harmony to make her work as a main character. McNab has great acting chops and her comedic timing is to die for, but as a character that's all Harmony seems to be - a funny, silly side character who offers nothing to the team's dynamic or the show's overall plot. At least we still have the jokes, though.
9. Charles Gunn
This might seem a low ranking for one of Angel's longest serving protagonists, but there are pretty clear reasons for his position here if you think back over his time on the show.
Introduced at the back-end of season one, Gunn (J. August Richards) was revealed as a freelance vampire hunter who worked the streets of Los Angeles with his crew and committed himself tirelessly to ridding the world of such evil. After meeting Angel, he was forced to stake his recently-turned sister and eventually found himself allied with Angel and his team.
Providing some more muscle to Angel Investigations and some much needed street smarts, he held up as a fairly compelling character during the early stages of the show's run. Loyal, strong and calm, he formed a very unlikely bond with Wesley Wyndam-Pryce (Alexis Denisof) and briefly dated Fred Burkle (Amy Acker), but by Season 4 his character had begun to wear thin.
Not because he was in any way a poor character or because Richards had lost his touch, but because the writers clearly found themselves struggling to fit him into the narrative, and he often felt out-of-place and lost amongst much larger personalities. He became a super-cool lawyer in the final season, which was decent and refreshing, but even then he ended up cast aside and left out of the big moments.
8. Illyria
She may not have been around for long, but Illyria (played by Fred actress Amy Acker) made a great impression on audiences. An ancient demon risen from an eternal sleep by an unhinged Wolfram and Hart employee, she rose up and took over the mind and body of the first human host she came across - the endlessly lovable, innocent Fred.
Illyria is arguably the strongest character to ever grace the Buffyverse, able to slow down time and defeat Angel, Spike, Wesley and more in combat. Outside of her power, she quickly proved to be much more than a powerful, near-invincible warrior, but a conflicted former god who found herself coming to terms with the trials of humanity as she joined forces with the core team.
Her growing attachment with Wesley and Spike makes for a character high point, and Acker's performance - perhaps risky on paper - is simply a revelation, allowing her to play a character completely removed from Fred and loving every second of it. We wish we got to see her more.
7. Allen Francis Doyle
It's a testament to the writers and the acting brilliance of Glenn Quinn that Doyle ended up being as good a character as he is. Starring in only nine episodes of the show's debut season, Doyle set Angel on the path that would take up the rest of the show (and the vampire's arc), but he was not simply put in place as a walking piece of exposition.
No, Doyle was something really special. Fully formed right from the get-go, the half-demon was as funny, sweet, innocent and bashful as any character in the series, a witty but believably flawed man who just wanted to do some good in the world and help his new pal Angel on his path to redemption.
As it turned out, Doyle too had some skeletons in his closest, which came into the spotlight in his final episode, as he races to save members of his own people and makes the ultimate sacrifice to save the day. In only nine episodes, Doyle and Quinn formed a brilliant character whose death set the tone of the show and remained a major part of the series until its final days.
He and Quinn may be gone now, and they may not have been around for long, but their impact is tough to beat.
6. Angel
The fact that Angel ranks here shouldn't be seen as an insult, but rather a shout-out to the greatness of the rest of the show's characters.
Angel is one of TV's most twisting, complex and intriguing characters, an evil vampire cursed with a soul, forced to atone for his sins, and thrust into a world where he must now right his wrongs by becoming a hero. In Buffy, he fell in love, turned evil and was sent to a hell dimension. In Angel, thanks to some new and old faces, he finds purpose by "helping the helpless."
Thus begins his journey as a brooding hero. But there are issues with the vampire - he's inconsistent, messing with his personal relationships whenever he has a bad day, struggling to decide if he's the champion the Shanshu Prophecy speaks of, and constantly torn between being alone and surrounding himself with friends.
He never really grows throughout the show, ending the series on much the same ground he started - a hero taking on evil, unsure about his future but willing to fight for it.
All of this is easy to ignore, though, really. Angel is a selfless hero when the big moments come knocking, and his quest to seek redemption is often the most compelling aspect of the entire franchise. It's just not consistent enough to rank him any higher.
5. Spike
Spike had some brief guest spots in the show's first two seasons, and spent the vast majority of his unrivalled arc over on Buffy, fighting for his soul and falling in with the Scooby Gang. But just when you thought he couldn't get any better, he turned up as a main character in Angel's final season, putting his and Angel's centuries long feud on full display and almost single-handedly saving the show from its dismal fourth outing.
Spike has always been one of the Buffyverse's most complex characters, but by the time he comes to Angel, this isn't quite the case anymore. He knows exactly what he stands for, where his allegiances lie, and how he feels about himself and the world. But he still manages to be the final season's most interesting player, his rivalry with Angel reaching a violent conclusion and his place on the team seeming as though he's been with them since day one.
Funny, rebellious, brash and heroic as ever, Spike proves himself not only to be a changed man, but maybe even the vampire champion Angel's prophecy speaks of. Honestly, the only reason he's not number one (like Doyle) is because there simply wasn't as much of him as the following characters.
4. Lorne
Lorne (Andy Hallett) is about as loveable as any character in either Buffy or Angel has ever been. An empath demon, he is able to read the emotions and futures of people if they sing to him, a weird skill which nonetheless comes in very handy for Angel and his team's crusade against evil and all things villainy.
Like Doyle before him, though, Lorne is far more than a neat bit of exposition used to drive the plot when the others have hit a dead end. With the acting (and singing) talent of Hallett, and some killer make-up, Lorne is exactly the character that the show needed - light-hearted, fun, bizarre, innocent and just plain cool.
He's goes through quite a bit on the show, losing his precious club and being decapitated thanks to his relationship with Angel and company, but he never once loses that giddy optimism that makes him so endearing. Fans aren't likely to get over the demon's final moment, where he takes a human life and loses himself to the violence, but there's no denying that that ending - and what came before it - was simply divine.
3. Cordelia Chase
Watching Buffy, it would have been impossible to imagine Cordelia Chase as anything more than a mean girl master of sarcasm who had no interest in dealing with the supernatural. But that's exactly what happened. Leaving Sunnydale for LA, she reunited with Angel, as a failing actress who comes to realise she can help Angel help people.
Still as sassy and confrontational as ever, Queen C was quick to grow into a caring and compassionate friend and fighter of evil. Given the ability to see future evil before it happens by The Powers That Be, she had to adapt to the way of world quickly, and did so with little fault.
Her storyline may be marred slightly by the character assassination of season four, but no matter how poor and ill conceived it all was, it never took away from the greatness of her character and her arc. She was selfless, relatable, funny and strong, and (no apologies here) the perfect woman for Angel.
A true original gone before her time, Cordelia was the glue that held the show together for its first three and a half seasons, and things would have been much worse had she not been around.
2. Wesley Wyndam-Pryce
Between these last two, it's really a game of inches. For this list, Wesley Wyndam-Pryce takes the runner-up spot, but really there's very little (if anything) to fault with his character. His arc rivals that of Spike, Buffy and Willow, Denisof's acting is second-to-none, and Wesley's development from prissy Watcher to full-fledged action man with injuries to spare is a near-unbeatable revelation.
Wesley started out as he was in season three of Buffy - pompous, smarmy, annoying, and laugh-at-him funny. But after a Season 2 with Angel and the team, he began to grow more than anyone, becoming a leader, a fighter, a broken but loyal friend and a conflicted man beaten down but never broken by the world around him.
He tried to save Connor when he thought Angel was going to kill him; he had his throat cut; his friends left him; he fell in love only to have the relationship cut short by tragedy; he shot his "father" to protect those he loved; and he finally died fighting the forces of darkness, willingly laying his life on the line to do the right thing.
It doesn't get much better than that...
1. Winifred "Fred" Burkle
Finally, we come to the creme de la creme of the show. Fred was a god-send. Encountered in a demon dimension in Season 2 and brought back to LA with the rest of the team, she was a bit of a mess thanks to her five-year confinement, but soon grew to prove herself as one of the team's most integral and important members.
The smartest on the team, there's no doubt Fred was a touch loopy, but she was also care-free, honest, loyal to a fault and wise. She was never annoying; she also never did the wrong thing. She represented everything that Angel, Spike, Wesley, Gunn and Cordelia were fighting for, and had no issues with getting her hands dirty.
Of course, Joss Whedon had to come along and kill her - slowly and cruelly - creating an episode as devastating as Buffy's The Body. Fred's death solidified the fact that the show wouldn't end on a major high, as it snuffed out the series' brightest light and biggest reason to fight.
Fred stands as the best character in the series, despite the fierce competition, and just goes to show how great Angel is.
Watch Next
Quiz: How Well Do You Remember Angel?