Angel: Every Season Ranked From Worst To Best

Which of this moody Buffy spin-off is the best?

Angel TV show
Mutant Enemy Productions

When it was announced that Angel, having left Sunnydale at the end of Season Three of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, would be re-located to Los Angeles with his own show, there was a lot of anticipation.

Where would his story go? What kind of new characters would we meet? How would David Boreanaz fare as the star of the show?

Over the course of five seasons, it's fair to say that Angel had some rough moments to counter the moments of brilliance. What fans got from the spin-off was a much darker and mature show than Buffy ever was, and for the most part this paid off in spades, with broader themes being tackled and more compelling character arcs.

Sometimes, though, it fell flat on its face: too dark, too brooding, trying too hard.

The show introduced us a slew of great characters, with Doyle, Gunn, Lindsey, Lilah and Lorne all proving to be welcome additions to the franchise. Older characters, such as Cordelia, Wesley, Faith, Spike and Angel himself all proved to be arguably greater characters on the show than its predecessor.

And though it sometimes slipped into the over-dramatic and dark, it cannot be denied that Angel was a fantastic show with an awful lot to love.

The following list will have a look at all five seasons of Angel, from the unforgivable to the best of the best. Major spoilers follow, so take caution, but enjoy.

5. Season Four

Angel David Boreanaz
Fox

Without question the lowest Angel ever stooped, Season Four featured a change in studio and less involvement from the master Joss Whedon, and the behind the scenes mash-up saw the show suffer big time.

Sporting a darker tone than ever before and some seriously questionable storylines, the whole season is a never-ending parade of character assassination and poor narrative choices.

Take Connor, for example. Angel's son is the most annoying character in the entire franchise, performed by Vincent Kartheiser with little to no passion or drive.

Because of him, the group dynamic fans had come to love was left in taters. Adding insult to injury, Cordelia - who has one of the franchise's best character arcs - is sidelined, forgotten about, and then completely betrayed with a sub-plot designed, it seems, to alienate the show's long-time fans.

There are some good moments, including Wesley's journey to bring Angel back to the group and the welcome return of both Willow and Faith, but aside from that Season Four is a mostly unforgivable mess with no real cohesion and lacklustre villains.

Ending on a happier note, the episodes "Spin the Bottle" (from Joss Whedon, marking his only involvement in Season Four) and the season finale "Home" are both solid, offering up some shenanigans reminiscent of the show's earlier run. It's just a shame the rest of the episodes failed to keep up with them.


4. Season Two

1438093

Aside from Season Four, the rest of the show is all very strong, balancing drama, mystery, action and well-controlled character arcs with masterful precision. Unfortunately, one of the remaining four has to make the bottom of the pile, and that (dis)honour falls on the shoulders of the show's second outing.

Season Two has some stunning storylines, character plots and affecting stand-alone entries designed to make our heroes more layered and compelling. For the most part, this all works wonders.

However, the latter episodes of the season, which take place in an alternate dimension, are just ridiculous. Sure, they have some typically fun moments and exciting fight scenes, but it's a powerfully weak end to a season which, up until that point, had been simply phenomenal.

All that aside, Season Two introduced fans to Lorne and Fred, truly unforgettable characters who stole the fans' hearts from the get-go. It also gave audiences the chance to learn more about Darla, a villain from Buffy's first outing who was, at the time, criminally underused.

On the whole, Season Two is a strong effort, capturing much of the essence of the first season with episodes like "The Thin Dead Line", "The Trial", "Darla" and "Are You Now or Have You Ever Been?". It's just let down in the rankings by its bizarre and out-of-place final arc.


3. Season Three

Angel David Boreanaz
Fox

It may seem odd to some that Season Three is being placed above its predecessor, but there is a reason for this: character. Season Three does everything that Season Four tried (and failed) to do when it comes its characters, giving each member of Angel Investigations moments to shine and grow like never before.

Whilst Wesley and Angel's biblical falling-out doesn't sound like a good idea on paper, given all they've been through together, it works wonders on the screen. The acting is stronger than ever from Boreanaz and Alexis Denisof, and the feud makes the whole season more personal and emotionally charged than ever.

On top of this intense and shocking arc, Darla returns with surprising news and Angel must cope with parenthood despite it being "impossible" for vampires to have kids. It's a nice added layer to the titular character's story.

Even better, though, is the increased screen presence of Fred and Lorne, who get some moments to show fans what they're really made of and what they can bring to the team.

Sure, Holtz is a boring villain (though he sure had potential going in) and older Connor proves to be almost as misjudged as Season Four's efforts, but the emotional journeys of Season Three make it one of the show's best additions.

And, seriously, "Waiting in the Wings" is a stunning episode worthy of a re-watch once you've read this list.


2. Season One

Angel Cordelia Doyle
Mutant Enemy Productions

Season One of Angel had a lot of pressure on its shoulders going in. The expectations of what the spin-off would bring were seriously high and it was wondered whether it would even work. It's safe to say, though, that Angel's debut shattered any doubts anyone had about the show, and pulled off a modern miracle.

The tone is gloomy and darker than Buffy, which proved a welcome and well-crafted narrative choice. Also, it re-introduced fans to Cordelia Chase, beginning a fantastic arc and a genuinely effective relationship between her and Angel.

Doyle was a solid addition, too, and his (spoiler) death in only the ninth episode of the season helped cement Angel as a risky and more mature take on the Buffyverse.

We also met Wolfram and Hart, who make for a brilliant show-long villain, and were re-introduced to Wesley Wyndam-Pryce, who proves much better suited to Angel than Buffy. In order to understand just how unique and clever the show is, you need look no further than episodes like "City Of", "I Will Remember You", "Hero" and "Five By Five".

This also also does well with connecting itself to Buffy whilst being its own show, featuring guest spots from Buffy, Oz, Spike, and Faith, all of whom get some solid mini-arcs.

It's a hell of start to a hell of a show.


1. Season Five

Angel Spike
20th Television

Season Five is an absolute revelation. Taking place after the final season of Buffy and shifting focus to Angel and co taking over the law offices of Wolfram and Hart, Season Five comes in swinging and never once lets up. The characters are all better than ever, the emotion is at all time high, and the writing is more confident and well-paced than previous entries.

The season offers some of the show's most rewarding and compelling arcs, from the welcome and well-executed return of Spike to the growth of Fred and Wesley and their far-too-brief relationship which ends with an episode to rival to anything on Buffy - "A Hole in the World."

It also gave us "Smile Time", "You're Welcome" (which helped, somehow, to clean up the mess that had been made of Cordelia in the previous season), and "Hell Bound".

The star of the show is the relationship between Angel and Spike, who make one of TV's best odd couples, as proven with episodes "Destiny" and "The Girl in Question", where their chemistry is wonderful to watch and their rivalry is electric

We also get to see Andrew again, who proves a solid returning face, and we get to have a look at how the world has changed with the original show's finale. The final arc, wherein the group band together to take on an unstoppable army, is well-done, with numerous twists, deaths and character pay-offs.

And who could ever forget that ending? It's a stroke of genius.


Watch Next


Buffy The Vampire Slayer Quiz: How Well Do You Remember Season 1?

xander cordelia Buffy
The WB

1. What Did Buffy And Cordelia Think Of Vamp Nail Polish?

In this post: 
Angel
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

I get to write about what I love, which is cool. You'll typically find me in front of a TV, or hunkered down behind a book, or dreaming of things far away. Be good to each other. Find my other writings here: https://allthethingsineversaid.substack.com/