Arrow: Ranking Every Character From Worst To Best

Who has saved the show over the last seven years, and who has failed it?

nyssa al ghul
The CW

After seven years of reinventing the superhero genre on television, Arrow will bid us adieu with its shortened final season in October.

The show that many credit for kick-starting the endless wave of superhero TV shows that are on our screens these days first arrived on The CW back in 2012 and reminded audiences that superheroes were capable of having movie-like adventures in a 40-minute program.

Boasting a large cast, it focused on the adventures of Oliver Queen, who returned after five years stranded on an island named Lian Yu in order to save the city that he loved so much. As he did so, we met his mother, his sister and other characters who played an important part in his life such as Tommy Merlyn and Laurel Lance.

Since then, however, Arrow has grown into something of a much grander scale and, as it did so, introduced us to other superheroes, countless villains and a ton of new characters that were just waiting to be explored. While some of those characters made a lasting impression, others were mistreated and cast aside.

From archers to assassins and Canaries to criminals, let's take a look back at every major character to have graced Arrow and, while we're at it, rank them.

35. Evelyn Sharp

Arrow Evelyn
The CW

Insensitively introduced as a knock-off Black Canary following Laurel Lance's death, Evelyn Sharp felt totally out of place right from the very beginning and, by the end of the episode, we didn't feel any better about her. That being said, the show did attempt to make her more of an interesting character in Season 5 when she was reintroduced as a member of Oliver Queen's new team and, at the time, it seemed like it was going to work.

Unfortunately, an unnecessary heel turn that was never fully explained turned her into a one-note villain that became nothing more than an annoying henchwoman - which was a real shame because Madison McLaughlin is one heck of an actress (something she demonstrated to perfection in 'Kapiushon').


34. Damien Darhk

Arrow Damien Darhk
The CW

The Big Bad of Season 4 (a.k.a. Arrow's worst season), Damien Darhk was thinly-written, full of corny dialogue and simply far too powerful for a show like Arrow. On top of that, his motivations were poor and predictable (he literally tried to blow up the world) and was responsible for one of the biggest mistakes the show had ever made (Black Canary's death).

In spite of an excellent charismatic performance from Neal McDonagh, it's hard to see the character as anything other than a major loss in the villains department. His magic and mysticism was everything Arrow was not, and resulted in the show losing the last remnants of that charm it once possessed - which is why it was so nice to see McDonagh thrive on Legends of Tomorrow when the character was moved there.


33. Emiko Adachi

Arrow Emiko Oliver Queen
The CW

Oliver Queen's secret sister turned up in Season 7 intent on making her brother's life a living hell, but not before convincing everyone that she was to be trusted - taking on his mantle as the new Green Arrow while he was behind bars.

Emiko's biggest offence was that she was full of potential that was just never realised. As an ally she was intriguing, while as a villain, she was formidable. The problem is that we needed more time spent on developing her as a character (as opposed to developing the roles she had taken on). And although Sea Shimooka did a fantastic job of portraying her as a worthy threat to Oliver, the rushed season finale undercut all the hard work that she did.


32. Ra's Al Ghul

Arrow Ra's Al Ghul
The CW

When we first heard that Ra's Al Ghul was coming to Arrow, we were intrigued. After all, he is one of Batman's most famous enemies. Unfortunately, that was the problem, as the introduction of Ra's marked the moment in which the show officially became a watered-down Batman series, as the iconic villain wanted Oliver to become his heir (even though we now know The Dark Knight exists in this universe).

While that would have been forgivable (at a push), the character ended up becoming a watered-down version of himself. Though he certainly looked the part, and Matt Nable did a great job with what he had, this Ra's was petty and, despite his actions, he lacked a sense of purpose and just didn't feel all that threatening.


31. Cayden James

Arrow Cayden James
The CW

Cayden James' long-teased arrival finally took place in the first half of the sixth season, when he put together a villainous faction to destroy Star City. A man scorned by the death of his son, he was manipulated into thinking that the Green Arrow was responsible for it.

On paper, you would think that it could work. The only problem is that we had an expert computer hacker who could even outdo Felicity Smoak, and yet he was easily manipulated by a fraudulent image created by one of his heavies (Diaz) in bid to stage a city-wide takeover. Yeah, saying it out loud, you realise that maybe it couldn't have worked after all.

In spite of a well-developed backstory, and a strong performance from Michael Emerson, James never felt like more than an evil genius spouting cliché villainous monologues.


30. Curtis Holt

Arrow Curtis Holt
The CW

Curtis Holt was a part of Arrow for four seasons and yet failed to ever really find his footing. A variation of the DC Comics character Michael Holt, he eventually followed his comic book destiny and became the hero known as Mr. Terrific - but not before spending half a season being nothing more than essentially just another Felicity.

As Mr. Terrific, he realised some of his potential, but like we've seen on the show before, a lack of focus on his development made his sudden transformation into a vigilante hard to buy.

He was incredibly likeable and, without a doubt, a great device when it came to comic relief, but an over-reliance on the latter quickly made him feel like redundant character. Furthermore, his marriage (and divorce) to Paul was highly underdeveloped, while his burgeoning relationship with hunky SPCD officer Nick Anastas was barely a footnote - a bit like his role on the show.


29. Rory Regan

Arrow Rory Ragman
The CW

Another of Oliver's new recruits at the beginning of Season 5, Rory Regan was undoubtedly the most interesting of the bunch.

As Ragman, he was both illusive and intriguing and, unlike Damien Darhk and Ra's Al Ghul, he was a supernatural entity that worked incredibly well in this environment. However, his real charm lay in his backstory, as the fact that he was the last survivor of Havenrock (the city that Felicity was forced to redirect one of Darhk's missiles to) led to some strong emotional turmoil within Team Arrow.

A sight to behold in the rags, and a loveable character without them, Rory was overflowing with potential. A character that was so much more than what he should have been, he still could have been much more than what he actually was - and that, alongside Joe Dinicol's infectious performance, is why it was so frustrating to see him written out so quickly.


28. Robert Queen

Arrow Robert Queen
The CW

Oliver's morally ambiguous father, Robert Queen is a character that is rather hard to pin down. Of course, that was intentional, as he's never actually alive in the present during the show and thus, all we know about him is through the flashbacks of various characters. However, that doesn't make it any easier to analyze him.

There were times when he came across like the hungry business tycoon that he was perceived to be, and yet there were moments where he exhibited genuine affection for his children that ended up making us question everything we ever knew about him.

That makes him, in a sense, like a lesser-developed version of his wife, Moira: Someone who, on the surface, was driven by success but still cared a great deal for his children - even if he wasn't always willing to show it.


27. Connor Hawke

Arrow Connor Hawke
The CW

The original Connor Hawke that appeared in Legends of Tomorrow's alternate 2046 timeline eventually became the Green Arrow, so when the character was reintroduced as part of the main timeline's flash-forward narrative on Arrow, we knew to expect big things.

Although we're still kind of waiting on those big things to happen, the character has proven a solid addition to the futuristic story and it was a somewhat refreshing surprise to hear that he wasn't actually John Diggle's biological son and was, instead the child of Bronze Tiger.

With the Diggle family drama set to be explored in Season 8, let's hope the character gets that long-awaited chance to shine. That being said: so far, so good for Connor Hawke.


26. Mia Smoak

Arrow Mia Smoak
The CW

With her impressive combat techniques and archery skills, the daughter of Oliver and Felicity is the personification of badass and, from her in-ring record as Blackstar to her eventual role in Team Arrow: Next Gen, she never missed an opportunity to prove it.

Mia Smoak is both the person you'd hope to never cross paths with and the ally you'd want on your team. But despite her hard exterior, there's a big heart in there; one that is willing to fight for the greater good - even if it goes against everything she previously stood for.

Though she was initially held back by some cliché broodiness (and the world's most predictable parental 'twist'), she underwent quite a satisfying journey throughout the Season 7 flash-forwards. And that ultimately makes fans excited to see where she goes next.


In this post: 
Arrow
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.