Arrow Season 4: 12 Questions We're Asking After 'Code Of Silence'

"It's like the big bad wolf huffed and puffed or something."

Welcome back, Damien Darhk! Neal McDonough's mysterious and mystical maniac returns to cause chaos in Star City this week, and it's about damn time. He gave the Green Arrow a pass a few weeks ago, in return for saving his wife and daughter, but while life may be easier for Team Arrow without him, the show is worse off. He's not even on-screen all that much here, but he is undoubtedly the one pulling the strings, and its thanks to him that this episode just about succeeds, even though it's still quite an uneven one. Darhk is never anything less than captivating when we do see him, and there were also some great action set pieces in this episode, courtesy of director James Bamford (he also directed Brotherhood, which gave us arguably the best action scenes the show has ever produced). The Oliver and Ruvé storyline was also interesting, as she begins to attack him in the light, but the whole 'superhero keeping a secret' thing has been done to death over both this show and its sibling, The Flash, and it's starting to wear thin. Thankfully, we're promised a resolution to that one way or another, with a twist at the end that leaves all sorts of questions in need of being answered.

12. What Are Phases 4 And 5?

We get another tease of the Genesis project being headed by Damein Darhk and his wife, Ruvé, here, as they have a meeting with their co-conspirators, and questions arise not just about Phase 4, but also Phase 5. Apparently Phase 4 is being put into place, while 5 requires complete control of Star City, which is the explanation given for Ruvé's Mayoral campaign. We've already had a tease of Phase 4, but what exactly it entails is still a bit of a mystery, while the plans for 5 are even more mysterious. The ultimate end-game is apparently some sort of population reset, but just what are they doing in Star City to achieve that end?

11. Why Hasn't Merlyn Told Darhk That Oliver Is The Green Arrow?

Last week, after Oliver helped take the League of Assassins from Malcolm Merlyn, the former Ra's al Ghul promised him pain worse than death, and then told Damien Darhk about William, Oliver's son. That pays off this week, but the interesting thing is that Merlyn hasn't told Darhk the other secret he knows about Oliver: namely, that he is the Green Arrow. Darhk is (somehow) still clueless about this, but knowing it would give him a huge advantage. Given Merlyn wants to do that, why hasn't he told him?

10. How Long Has Merlyn Been Involved With Darhk's Plan?

Another interesting point with Malcolm Merlyn this week is that he's sitting at the table with the rest of Darhk's cronies, listening intently to the plans about Phase 4 and so on, as though he has always been a part of it. As far as we're aware, Merlyn only turned to Darhk last week, although they've known each other a lot longer than that. Is it that turned to the, ahem, Darhk Side* that has led to him dining at the top table, or has Merlyn been involved with Genesis for a lot longer than we know of? He's tried to destroy the city himself, so perhaps they can learn from his mistakes. *Also, how great was it when Damien Darhk essentially Force-choked that guy on his screen? More like Darhk Vader, amirite? Anyone?

9. Is Darhk Still Going To Target Lance?

Quentin Lance has been playing a double agent for most of this season, and not an entirely convincing one. That comes back to bite him this week, as Darhk decides to deal with him once and for all, by way of having a building attack him... Lance survives, obviously, but then spends the rest of the episode hiding out (and also lying to Donna), but by the end he's back in the open, being the heroic police officer we know him to be (and patching things up with Donna, thankfully, because that's a weirdly fun relationship). It's quite clear, then, that he isn't dead, and is still helping the Green Arrow. Is Darhk still going to be after him? It's certainly not going to do anything to dispel talk of him being the one in the grave.

8. What Will Reiter Do To Oliver?

The flashbacks were a little more interesting this week, insofar as Oliver finally did what he should've done a while back and killed Conklin. It'd been coming, and he deserved it to be honest, so thankfully that's taken care of, even if the fight wasn't all that thrilling. His actions, though, have rather upset Baron Reiter. He needs Oliver alive, because he believes he is the key to finding whatever the hell it is he's looking for, but threatens him by saying that there are different ways of keeping someone alive. We haven't fully seen just what Reiter is capable of, but maybe we're about to. And if so, it could be quite a painful learning experience for Oliver (but also an interesting one for the flashbacks, because they need something outside of this long-promised mystery).

7. Curtis Is...Terrific?

"Curtis, you're...terrific." Line of the episode? I'd say so, both because it was incredibly cheesy, and a ridiculously on-the-nose reference to Holt's comic book alter-ego, Mr Terrific. With the fact he's got the name, and has started developing his T-Spheres, it's surely only a matter of time before the transformation takes place, and this reference really pushes that, suggesting that it should be coming soon. Curtis is already a really fun part of the show, but he's mostly on the edges of it, dealing only with Felicity. Making him Mr Terrific would be a way to bring him into the main fold, and based on his appearances this year, that should be a good thing. Curtis' other notable contribution to this episode was developing the technology that should allow Felicity to walk again. It's hardly a surprise that they're finding a way of making this happen, though as always with Arrow, there's the potential for a slight curveball if it doesn't actually work, or at least setup for it failing at a crucial moment somewhere in the future.

6. Isn't Oliver Being Reckless About His Identity?

Oliver Queen is many things, but subtle ain't one of 'em. He has a couple of conversations with Ruvé Adams this week, and doesn't exactly play it coy in either. He starts off by asking whether Adams is her maiden name, a completely random question, and then later on drops the whole "bring the building down...almost" line, right after foiling her plan to do exactly that. It's all fun and games, but at the same time, he's being a little bit obvious, isn't he? Oh, he just so happens to know that Adams might not be her actual surname? Ok, some political digging could maybe get him out of that one. But then a big hint that he knew the building was set to be demolished? Few people could've had that information. It's a big surprise that Ruvé and her husband haven't already figured out Oliver's alter-ego, but his recklessness could well give the game away.

5. Will Ollie Come Clean About His Son?

A lot of this episode is about keeping secrets, with the parallels being drawn between Oliver, keeping his son secret from everyone, and Quentin, who lies to Donna about the real reason he needs to put their relationship on the backburner for a few weeks. There were some good moments in here, such as the conversation between Thea and Oliver (it worked in terms of sibling bonding, even if it didn't make an awful lot of sense for Thea as a character), and some that basically screamed Oliver needed to come clean - Felicity talking to her mother about Quentin having a good reason to keep a secret, the detective telling Oliver that it was good he had a woman he didn't need to keep secrets from. Lance eventually tells Donna the truth, but Oliver is still keeping the secret about his son from Felicity, encouraged to do so by Thea. It's something he'll no doubt continue to struggle with, especially in light of events at the end of this episode, but can he continue to keep it from his friends? Will he even have a choice?

4. Or Will Ruvé Use It Against Him?

Damien Darhk knows about William, and thus so does Ruvé. Given that she is a political opponent of Oliver's, that's a pretty major card to be able to play if necessary. Oliver is currently winning, at least that's what the experts say after their debate, but opinion would surely change in a big way if it were revealed that he has a secret lovechild, and that even his fiancee didn't know. Oliver's trying to dig up dirt on Ruvé, so obviously she'll be trying to do so on him, and now her husband has handed her this. With mud-slinging tactics and dredging up secrets all part and parcel of these political campaigns, it'd certainly make a lot of sense for it to be used against him. Will she do that, or does Darhk have other plans for William?

3. Why Couldn't We Have An Actual Debate?

I understand that Arrow isn't really 'that type of show', but it was nevertheless disappointing that we never actually got to see the debate between Oliver and Ruvé, since the episode was mostly centred around it. Sure, the action is great, and the series is more about the superhero side to their lives and storylines, but it could actually have been a lot of fun to see Oliver and Ruvé go head-to-head, even just for a couple of minutes. It would make the campaign storyline more interesting, and give us more to invest in, and also help flesh out Ruvé's character as well. This was something that was supposedly very important to the election, which is supposedly a big subplot this year, but it was totally glossed over. It'd be good if the show could invest some more time in moments like this to make that plot, and certain characters, really work.

2. What Will Darhk Do To William?

Now we get to the episode's big twist, which follows on from the end of last week's episode and Merlyn telling Darhk about William. The question then was how would he act on that information, and we get an answer here. He's somehow gotten hold of Oliver's son, introducing him as a playdate for his daughter, and that he's going to be spending some time with them. Darhk has always been presented as an extremely dangerous foe, but this takes it to another level, and you wonder - and worry - just what he has planned for William. Has he really just kidnapped him as a way of hurting Oliver, and doesn't have any plans to harm the boy? Or does he have something much more sinister in mind, that would lead to William being the person in that grave we're headed towards? Killing William would make sense in terms of Oliver wanting to kill the person responsible. But even just having possession of him, to use as a way of baiting Oliver into doing something stupid, or forcing his hand - for something like making him withdraw from the Mayoral race, perhaps? - would be exactly the kind of thing Darhk would do.

1. What Happened To Samantha?

So, if Darhk has William, then what has happened to Samantha? She was his sole guardian, and given how incredibly protective she is of her son, it seems highly unlikely that she would just agree to him spending time at the house of this mysterious stranger, no matter how charming Darhk can be. That means something bad has probably happened to her. Has Darhk worked some sort of magic, tricking her into allowing William to go with him? Has he injured her and locked her away somewhere? Or has he killed her? It's a real possibility when it comes to Darhk, although you'd imagine such a big death would play out on screen. Whichever of these is the answer, or even if it's something different, the betting is it won't be good, and it will be designed to provoke Oliver into a response. What did you make of Code of Silence? Any questions you were left with? Share your thoughts in the comments. Stay up-to-date with all things Arrow by following us on Twitter: @WhatCultureTV

Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.