Arrow Season 4: 6 Things The Candidate Got Right (And 4 It Didn't)

Why would you ever run for Mayor of Star City?!

After the misery of Season 3, Arrow Season 4 - The Age Of The Green Arrow - is bringing with it a lighter tone and more humour. This week we had kidnapping, a man burned alive, a spiralling descent into madness, and grave-digging. Oh well. The Candidate is, as you might suspect, structured around a bid for Mayor from newcomer Jessica Danforth, who's an old friend of Moira Queen. Of course, this being Star City and the worst possible place to be an elected official, things don't exactly go to plan. Oliver is now the Green Arrow, with the promise of doing things differently, although that isn't quite as straightforward as he would've liked, especially with Thea experiencing some (majorly delayed) side-effects of the Lazarus Pit. At this very early stage of the season it's content in doing quite a lot of setup for what's to come later down the line, and as such we don't follow up too much on some of the bigger talking points from last week. It's not concerned with resolving anything yet, but is getting everything in place without going to slowly about it. There's a few new characters introduced (with varying degrees of success), some more plots established, and a couple of decisions that will really shake things up, for better or worse.

10. Got Right - Boss Felicity

There was quite a bit of the heroes being out of the Arrow Lair this week, and Felicity's story involved her new role as the head of Palmer Technologies, with some difficult decisions to make. This introduced us to 'Boss Felicity', someone who is now charged with running a large company and dealing with many important people in suits. Felicity handles this like, well, Felicity. She's awkward, funny, and eventually finds a way of solving the problem. If I'm totally honest there was maybe a little bit too much of the Palmer Tech stuff in the episode, but getting to see Felicity in action outside of Oliver (and Ray, even though it's his company) made it worth it. They struggled somewhat with the character last year because of those relationships, but now the writers seem on much surer footing and she's getting back to the Felicity we all (ok, some of us) know and love. Oh, and she got a new fern out of it, which was nice (and a glimpse of the lighter Oliver we're seeing this year).

9. Didn't - Jessica Danforth Running For Mayor

One of the new characters we meet this week is Jessica Danforth, an old friend of Moira Queen, and her daughter Madison. They have a long-overdue catch-up with Oliver and Thea, where Jessica reveals she's going to run for the least desirable job on television, Mayor of Star City. What was previously a running gag that fans used to laugh at becomes a plot device this week, and though the end result is good, getting there isn't. She's a brand new character, so the threat that being Mayor of this city brings isn't quite as keenly felt, and it all comes off as being a little bit predictable. She's going to run, then right at the very second she's about to announce her bid a gun goes off, and she's taken to safety. Despite being under threat and the need for police surveillance 24-7, she still feels it a wise decision to send her daughter to school. Who is then kidnapped. Obviously she's returned later on, and then Jessica decided to pull out of the race that would only exist if she was running because there are no other candidates. It gets the show to where it needs to be by the end, but not much is really done to make her feel like a proper character.

8. Got Right - Keeping Darhk Involved

Arrow made a bold decision in its Season 4 premiere by introducing Damien Darhk in quite a big way. He had a number of moments, all of them rather great, from interrupting the Star City officials having a private meeting, to killing one of his henchmen by touching him, displaying his powers in a fight with Oliver, and the unholy alliance he has with Quentin Lance. It made for an emphatic entrance, but with it just being the first episode left a slight problem of how to pace things from there. He's made himself known and is very much a part of things, but you can't go too quickly with it or it'll run out of steam long before May. It's not an easy task, but they strike a pretty good balance here. Neal McDonough is already one of the highlights of this season, needing a line or even just a look to convey a true sense of menace and power, and he manages that again here in scenes with Anarky and Captain Lance.

7. Didn't - Anarky

There were high hopes when it was announced that Anarky would be coming to Star City this year, played by Alexander Calvert. Traditionally a Batman villain, he fights for what he believes in (whether that's right or not) and believes strongly in social anarchy, but with more political motivations behind him. That could've worked really well on Arrow, with the notion of vigilantism and especially in this episode where you have someone running for Mayor. Instead he's really just more of a villain-of-the-week type, a by0the-numbers madman who just wants to wreak havoc. He's far from being the worst villain on the show, and he actually does a pretty good job in his fight against Green Arrow and Speedy, but it does feel like a bit of a let-down, and that he could've been much more interesting than he was here.

6. Got Right - Quentin Lance's Darhk Secret

Captain Lance's uneasy relationship with Oliver Queen continues this week, as he's forced into working with a man he doesn't trust (or like). One of the best things about this is that we get another of his little speeches to Oliver, about the things he does or doesn't do, and it's always enjoyable to see these scenes because Paul Blackthorne's delivery is generally excellent, and Oliver rarely has any sort of comeback. An even more uneasy relationship for Lance is the one he has with Damien Darhk. That was a pretty big twist last week, and we get another glimpse of it this time around. He obviously has an idea of what Darhk is capable of and wants nothing to do with him, but it's because he knows the threat he poses that he's forced into co-operating. Darhk holds the life of his daughter over his head this week, and it's going to be interesting to see just how long Lance can handle working with him before something snaps.

5. Didn't - Retreading Flashbacks

The flashbacks, yet again, are a big problem for the show. I was worried last week when we saw Oliver being sent back to the island that it would just tread over old ground, and that's largely what happens in this episode. Most of the scenes we get a pretty brief, involving him taking down one of the guards stationed there, but it doesn't give us much we haven't seen before. What's more, they're all quick snapshots of the island, but they don't marry up with the episode, and instead take us out of the main plot at some pivotal moments for Oliver. We do get the introduction of Baron Reiter, and hopefully he and the organisation Shadowspire can breathe new life into the flashbacks, but at the moment they feel too familiar and yet too disconnected. On the plus side, Ollie got a haircut, which means no more of that ridiculous wig.

4. Got Right - Curtis Holt

Another benefit of spending so much time at Palmer Tech, aside from some very good Felicity moments, was the introduction of one of their employees, Curtis Holt (played by Echo Kellum). He gets to share a lot of screen-time with Felicity, and even just from this first episode it's clear that the two have a lot of chemistry between them, showing similar levels of intelligence mixed with their slightly awkward sense of humour. Going forward these two should have a lot of fun together (without a potential romantic subplot to get tangled up in as well, thanks to the mention of Curtis' husband), and of course there's the fact that at some point he should become the heroic Mr Terrific. That's going to be, er, terrific.

3. Didn't - Thea's Side-Effects

It's been a few months since Thea was stabbed (see: run through with a giant freakin' sword), and taken to Nanda Parbat for revival in the Lazarus Pit. While she initially seemed fine, the side-effects of that are now starting to manifest themselves. She goes too far out in the field, close to killing someone last week, and in this episode breaks a man's arm and later sets Anarky on fire, while she's also possessed by pure rage in a fight with Oliver. It's not clear why the effects are only showing themselves now, but hopefully they can sort it out pretty soon (presumably when John Constantine shows up in a few episodes time). I'm not sure if it's Willa Holland's performance to blame, or more just the writing, but it isn't really working at the moment, and feels a bit too close to the Mirakuru storyline they did with Roy.

2. Got Right - Mayor Oliver Queen

As mentioned, the whole Jessica Danforth running for Mayor thing wasn't great, but it did serve as a plot device for a big moment at the end of the episode. Star City needs a leader, a hero, but one who isn't in the shadows. Clearly Captain Lance's words got through to him, as Oliver decided he is going to run for Mayor. Not only does this bring things further in line with the comics, but it makes the non-Green Arrow side of Oliver even more interesting, and will give him a very focused arc of his own.It makes sense in terms of the hero he wants to be, and the sort of person that Star City needs to lead it (aware I'm veering dangerously close to quoting The Dark Knight here). It also makes the position of Mayor a lot more interesting. While in the past it's been just a pretty dark running joke, and we've never had too much need to become attached to the officials, having Oliver in that position really raises the stakes, and means more people are going to be coming after him than ever before.

1. Got Right - Gravedigging

An upside of the Thea story is that Laurel has gotten involved, and found a way of killing (or should I say reviving?) two birds with one stone. Not only is she going to take Thea back to Nanda Parbat and see if there is a way of helping her, but she sees this as an opportunity to bring her sister back as well. Thanks to Legends of Tomorrow's promo-material we already knew that Sara Lance would be returning, as the White Canary, and that she'd be taking a bath in the Lazarus Pit. I had assumed that it would have something to do with Rip Hunter and time-travel, which would've been cool, but tying Laurel into her resurrection makes sense and should provide some more meat for her own arc. It means that right at the end of the episode her and Thea go and do a little gravedigging. Did we really need to see the corpse of Sara? Maybe not, but it was certainly an effective image, and points to the show going in some pretty interesting directions over the next few weeks.

Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.