Arrow Season 5: 8 Things That Must Happen Next

Oliver Queen - you have failed this city.

Arrow Oliver
The CW

I think we can all agree that Arrow's fifth season has so far been the best thing since... Well, Arrow's second season. The show has gone back to its season 1 roots, with the return of serial killer Oliver, and the introduction of a villain who wants him to pay in blood for the people he has killed.

This all came to a head in the mid-season finale, with Prometheus tricking Ollie into killing Felicity's boyfriend, and the episode ticked all the boxes. The choreography is better than ever - that one shot of Prometheus's throwing star splitting Ollie's arrow in two is better than the entirety of Seasons 3 and 4 - and we even got some flashbacks we care about.

The show has taken a huge step in putting the mysticism of Season 3 and the soap opera of Season 4 behind it and starting afresh, but the execution leaves a lot to be desired.

Something as simple as filling in a few plot-holes will be enough to paper over some cracks, while more extreme measures are warranted in others. And that's not to mention that the season hinges heavily on how the show deals with Prometheus's reveal, and [SPOILER]'s return.

Arrow Season 5 has made some improvements, but there's plenty that still needs to happen when it returns from the mid-season break.

8. Thea Needs To Make Up Her Mind

Arrow Thea Queen Speedy
The CW

At the end of the last season, Thea claimed that her Speedy days were behind her, instead vowing to save the city as Thea Queen, working to fight crime from the Mayor's office. It was a shame to see her hang up the Red Arrow suit, but it paved the way for a fresh start within the Arrow Cave, and Thea has been one of the strongest characters this season as a result.

She's often been the voice of reason, a wise head on young shoulders, and the way her experience has come full circle is a credit to the show. But if this is what you're going for, then commit. Thea has already worn the Speedy suit three times this year, and as long as there is a chance that she will return to Team Arrow, we will never fully invest in the new recruits.

Arrow is at its worst when it's toying with ideas, not sure if it's willing to go all in; Oliver and Felicity's relationship being the definitive example of this. Either have Thea commit to Team Arrow, or have her give up the suit for good. You can't just bring her back when the story needs another bow-and-arrowed character.


7. We Need More Of Ragman In Action

Arrow Rory Ragman
The CW

Speaking of the new recruits, we've known Curtis for over a year now, and we can see where the Wild Dog character is going from a mile off, but at least he's developed enough for us to know something about him in the first place. Ragman (AKA Rory Regan) lost his family in the destruction of Havenrock, and he inherited his father's super suit, but besides the fact he is sad and magical, we don't know much about him at all.

I get that the show is about Green Arrow and everything, but Rory is practically immortal in that suit. There is literally no reason that Oliver shouldn't walk around with Ragman stood in front of him, just in case someone tries to shoot at him. We need more details on the suit and its weaknesses before we just discount Ragman as a secondary character, and frankly, you don't waste a voice like his on quips and exposition.


6. Just Get The Vigilante Reveal Over With

Arrow Vigilante
The CW

I don't want to be the bearer of spoilers, but if Vigilante is not the new district attorney, Adrian Chase, then I don't know anything anymore. During his interrogation of Eric Dunn's henchwoman a couple of weeks ago, Chase revealed his dark side, and this week, he straight up told Oliver that the Arrow was being too lenient with Prometheus. He's Vigilante in the comics, too. But I figured it out before I knew that. Just saying.

I'm not taking anything away from the idea of Vigilante, but the sooner we get his reveal over and done with, the sooner we can move on to Prometheus. Amid the plot twists of the mid-season finale, a Vigilante reveal we know is coming is the last thing we want to be waiting for.


5. Felicity Should Ease Up On The Quips

Arrow Felicity Smoak
The CW

Well here's an argument I never thought I'd be making. Whatever you think of her relationship with Oliver, we can all agree that seasons 1 and 2 Felicity was adorable, and it's such a relief to see her back to her old self in season 5. But she just lost her boyfriend.

Not taking in to account the fact that Billy's death was a brilliantly executed move by Prometheus, if it turns out to be just a plot device and nothing more than that, then we're back to seasons 3 and 4 as far as writing goes.

There's also the fact that Felicity went home alone the night of Billy's death, while Oliver had a smashing night with Susan Williams (which is season 3 writing if ever I've seen it). Oliver and the team have to be there for Felicity while she grieves (especially after what happened with Susan), and if that means that someone else has to make the quips for a few episodes, then that's what that means.


4. Lose The 'Diggle Is A Fugitive' Idea

Arrow Diggle
The CW

Even with everything else going on, Diggle gets his very own cliffhanger in the mid-season finale, as he is tricked and cornered by the secret service, who apparently want to take him back to prison. But that doesn't make any sense.

Last week, Diggle stood alongside the President of the United States, who said bluntly that she and the world owed Diggle and the rest a debt of gratitude. I didn't realise a debt of gratitude expired after a week.

As with Thea, if Diggle has to give up Team Arrow, then he has to give up Team Arrow. If that's where this is going (and that's probably best-case scenario at this point), then just get it over with. But under no circumstances do you send a man who just helped saved the world from aliens back to jail.


3. Prometheus Has To Be Someone We Know

Arrow Prometheus
The CW

Arrow's season 5 theme is legacy, and we saw this week that serial killer Oliver is ultimately the reason that Prometheus exists. Ollie killed businessman Justin Claybourne, and the man under the mask is supposedly 'his son', who would be 'around 30 years old', which makes a lot of sense - but Justin Claybourne's random child is not the Big Bad of season 5. The show is preparing us for a big reveal, because surely, Justin Claybourne's unknown child is someone we're going to know.

Now, Susan Williams is obviously connected to Prometheus. Right after Ollie sees Prometheus do a cool backflip that he learned in Russia, we linger on a Russian vodka bottle at Susan's apartment. She might even be Prometheus, but she could very well by Talia al Ghul, who is confirmed to appear in Russia in this season's flashbacks, and with her obvious ties to the lazarus pit, Prometheus could well be another resurrected character.

Tommy is the obvious pick, with the Dark Archer arc coming full circle this season, but Colin Donnell is busy in Chicago, so we could be looking at someone like Shado (because the show could be doing a Dark Knight Rises and having Claybourne's son actually be a daughter). It's a stretch, but as long as it's someone that we know better than Justin Claybourne, that's fine by me.


2. Stop Hinting At Oliver And Felicity (For Now)

arrow oliver queen felicity smoak olicity
The CW

Whether it happens or whether it doesn't, the Arrow writers need to put Olicity (ugh) on the shelf for a little while. 'What We Leave Behind' hinted strongly that it is still very much a thing ('I do believe in magic'), but then Oliver killed Felicity's boyfriend and Laurel came back (so maybe there's hope for us all).

Oliver and Felicity is probably going to happen, and we all have to come to terms with that. The writers have made it very clear that that's where they want to go, but right now isn't the best time for either of them to be thinking about it.

Oliver and Felicity, though great individual characters, turned seasons 3 and 4 into a soap opera, and so far, season 5 has done a good job at leaving them well alone. The back end of the season needs to continue with that tradition, because bringing Laurel back into the equation is not an excuse to bring back any kind of love triangle, and do so after what happened to Billy would be insulting to every one of the characters involved.


1. Laurel Can't Really Be Back

Arrow Laurel
The CW

Laurel's death made it difficult for me to keep watching Arrow - it felt to me like the writers gave up on her, ironically, just as she was beginning to resemble Black Canary - but they made it very clear that she was gone for good, and the one redeeming factor of her death is how they have gone about honouring her legacy.

If Laurel is back, the theme of legacy is put into question, and if she isn't (it could be that she's a hallucination or a Laurel from another Earth) and the whole things turns out to be a red herring, then the writers have gone and dug themselves the deepest hole in the history of holes.

I'm not sure how they get out of this one, unless she somehow turns out to be Prometheus, but I'd rather see her gone than have her return only to be a secondary character all over again. Either way, the show loses credibility, but after everything that has happened since her death, and everything we and the characters have gone through, bringing her back is not really an option.

What do you want to see happen next on Arrow? Share your thoughts down in the comments.


Contributor
Contributor

Writer, serial binge-watcher, Mother of Dragons. Completed Netflix.