Arrow Season 5: 8 Ups And 2 Downs From 'Legacy'
Brutality, badassery, and brilliance from the season premiere.
After much hype and anticipation, The CW's Arrow has now returned to our screens, and what a return it was.
We've all seen how much negativity surrounded the show's previous season - be it the uber-dull flashbacks, the fall from grace of Felicity Smoak, or the odd 'Truman Show' bubble - but there was so much hope that Season 5 was going to be taking Arrow back to the high standards that it had set with its first two seasons.
Picking things up with Oliver Queen now as Mayor of Star City, we've got a Green Arrow who's largely working alone. Felicity is in the Arrowcave to help out, but Diggle is away in the military, Thea is trying to leave her Speedy moniker behind, Quentin Lance has hit the bottle again, and Laurel Lance, of course, is dead.
With the new threat of Tobias Church, and Prometheus arriving too, Oliver is sure to have his hands full on both fronts - both as Mayor and as the Green Arrow. Whilst Prometheus' presence was kept to a perfectly-played minimal here, we did at least get a nice introduction to Church in an episode that felt fresh and vibrant whilst also capturing so much of the charm that has previously made Arrow must-see TV.
So, with all of that in mind, let's have a look at what this season premiere got right, and what maybe didn't quite hit the mark.
10. Ups - Starting With A Bang
In the build-up to Arrow’s fifth season, we’d heard plenty from the show’s executive
producers, and even Stephen Amell himself, about how this upcoming season was
to be more full of brutal, bloody action that we’ve seen since the days when
Oliver Queen was happily killing people as ‘The Hood’.
Living up to that hype, when we’re reintroduced to Ollie here, he’s in the middle of a brilliantly-choreographed battle with another returning face: Lonnie Machin, aka Anarky.
The fight between the Emerald Archer and Anarky here, whilst brief, was arguably as good as any fight scene Season 4 had to offer bar Thea Queen’s elevator-driven brawl with one of Damien Darhk’s Ghosts. Added to that, when the Green Arrow was done with Lonnie, he turned his attention to the fresh-on-the-scene Wild Dog.
Never one to be labelled much of a people person, the Master Bowman gave Wild Dog a verbal beat down before then firing an arrow into his leg. Nice.
9. Oliver's Hope
For so much of Arrow’s run to date, we’ve seen Oliver Queen either a) being a total loner, or b) reluctantly working alongside other heroes. As Season 5 opens, though, Ollie is more alone than we’ve seen him in a long time.
What was so well done here was in how the show gave us a slightly different side to Oliver, a side that saw him holding out hope that the old, familiar Team Arrow unit would be back together before we know it. Sure, Diggle may be serving overseas with the Military, Thea may be refusing to return to the hero life, and Laurel may be dead, but Ollie is hesitant to really move on.
This shows a change in attitude for Ollie, as previously he’d have thought nothing of just leaving his previous partners behind the moment that their working arrangement was up. Whilst he’s still hesitant to bring in new faces here, seeing Oliver yearning for the return of some former faces was something fantastically handled by Arrow in this season premiere.
Unfortunately for Ollie, Felicity is far more realistic when it comes to the prospects of bringing the old gang back together.
8. Thea's Hesitancy
Typically when a superhero hangs up the spandex, it’s only a matter of time before they once again suit-up to fight the good fight.
Now we may have seen Thea Queen put on the Speedy outfit once more in Legacy, but the exploration into Thea’s mindset and reluctance to return to the hero game was there for all to see. At times, we had Oliver, Felicity, and Quentin Lance all drop hints (or flat-out ask) that Thea suits-up to help fight the bad guys.
With her bloodlust seemingly now behind her, and with the death of Laurel Lance still very raw and fresh in memory, Thea is hesitant to give up the normalcy that she now has. In fact, she even makes a point of saying how this is the first time that she’s really felt like herself in years.
Seeing Thea back in the Speedy outfit was great while it lasted in Legacy, but here’s hoping that her full-time return to the hero life is drawn out over a substantial part of Season 5’s first half or even longer.
7. Saving The City Takes Precedent
Given how the Season 4 finale saw Oliver Queen snag the gig of Mayor of Star City, some were wondering whether that would mean him stepping back from the hero gig for a little while. Fortunately, that’s not the case.
From the early moments of Legacy, we see that Ollie is more than happy to run late for his Mayoral duties when Green Arrow duty comes calling. As he puts it himself, “Saving the city takes priority over running it." Then again, he’s not flaunting his fighting prowess, as shown by his decision not to fight back against Charon’s henchman when he realised cameras were present.
Despite his allegiance to serving as Mayor, it’s hugely important for the show right now that Oliver doesn’t put his superhero outings on the back-burner, so having this established straight away in Season 5 is great to see. If anything, he’s even more singularly focussed on the hero gig than he’s been in a long time due to spending this season premiere largely fighting the bad guys on his lonesome.
With a new Team Arrow set to come together over the next few episodes, it will likely be that we’ll be seeing more of Oliver’s time eventually dedicated to running the city as Mayor, but for now we at least get to enjoy him first and foremost as the Green Arrow.
6. The Return Of 'The Book'
When Arrow debuted, so much of the entire first season was dedicated to Oliver hunting down the names in his father’s book. After all, they had failed his city, and Ollie was the one to make them pay for their sins.
Since then, though, ‘the book’ has barely been mentioned. With Arrow’s flashbacks this season heading to where it all began, it was good to see Oliver’s prized possession revisited.
As Arrow started with Oliver Queen having been away from Star(ling) City for 5 years (that comes with being presumed dead!), the flashbacks were introduced as a way to explain just what happened to Ollie during this period. By the time that Season 5 is all said and done, the flashbacks will have caught up with Season 1’s ‘present’, and so the return of Robert Queen’s book is a nice way to make the show feel as if it’s heading to where we picked things up with the present day Ollie in the series’ debut season.
5. Better Flashbacks
For the first two seasons, the Lian Yu-set flashbacks of Arrow felt just as interesting as the modern-day action, especially in Season 2 as we further explored the relationship between Oliver Queen and Slade Wilson. Season 3’s Hong Kong flashbacks were decent enough, but last year’s return to Lian Yu was the dullest part of Arrow’s run so far.
Granted, Matt Ryan’s John Constantine was awesome to briefly see during those flashbacks, but the overall arc of Baron Reiter’s search for a magic totem was a turn-off to many and a major reason why Season 4 struggled to reach the heights of its predecessors.
It’s only been one episode, but the Russia-set flashbacks of this new season have already eclipsed Season 4’s flashbacks. Obviously it was great to see the return of Anatoli Knyazev, but we also got to see the brutal, clinical side of Oliver that we were given in the show’s first season.
We’ve all been looking forward for the moment that Ollie’s adventures in Russia were explored, and this season premiere has certainly lived up to expectations. Here’s hoping that the rest of the season matches up to this explosive introduction to Russia.
4. The Renewed Edge
You could say it’s an old edge, you could say it’s a new edge. Either way, this season premiere showed that Oliver Queen certainly has a renewed edge.
Yes, it may not be exactly superhero behaviour to be snapping people’s necks, and it may technically be morally wrong, but it definitely makes for awesome TV to see Stephen Amell’s Emerald Archer cracking skulls with a clinical edge not seen for a good few seasons now.
Obviously the flashback version of Ollie has that vicious side to him – after all, that is the Oliver who turned up back in Star(ling) City in Season 1 with the aim of killing anyone who had failed the city – but it’s a little different to see the present day Oliver taking a more kill-happy approach to proceedings, too.
We all know that the formation of a new Team Arrow will ultimately lead to Ollie eventually taking less of a killer approach, but it’s good to see him using the fate of Laurel Lance to fuel his more aggressive, somewhat effective gameplan.
3. Stepping Up
When Arrow first debuted, there was no The Flash, no Gotham, no Supergirl, no Daredevil, no Jessica Jones, no… you get the idea.
Arrow was more-or-less the only real comic book show on TV at that point, and as such it had a huge head-start over those other shows. Since those times though, the ante has been well and truly upped; The Flash has brought in meta-humans; Supergirl has brought an other-worldly charm; Gotham has explored corruption and dirty streets; and Daredevil has given us fantastic fist-on-face action rarely seen before in a television show. As such, some have said that Arrow has fallen behind its contemporaries.
After a third season that was decent at best, then a fourth season that was simply dull when highlighting its flashback elements, Arrow needed to step up to the plate with Legacy. And boy, did the show deliver.
Back to basics, we’d heard. A grittier edge, we’d heard. Brutal violence, we’d heard. Firmly living up to the build-up and hype, this fifth season premiere stepped up to the plate in a way that we’d all hoped and all yearned for since the phenomenal Season 2 came to a close.
Legacy has raised the bar once more for Arrow, giving us something far superior to the previous season. Now the rest of Season 5 just has to live up to these high standards.
2. Downs - Guest Star
This is something that has been happening
on a whole host of shows over the past few years. Arrow has done it, The Flash has
done it, and even non-CW shows such as The
Walking Dead and Game of Thrones have
done it. Still, that doesn’t make it right, though.
Within mere seconds of Legacy starting, the credits revealed that we’d be seeing an appearance from “ special guest star” Katie Cassidy. And from that moment on, we all knew to expect an appearance from the deceased Laurel Lance.
The appearance itself was another look at Laurel’s death scene, with us now being made privy as to what the promise was that she made Ollie take with her dying breath: she wants him to continue the Black Canary moniker on.
Either way, Laurel’s reappearance instantly lost any of its shock value the moment Katie Cassidy’s name appeared in the episode’s opening credits. It may only be a minor thing, but it’s still a major annoyance.
1. The Statue
Yes, Laurel Lance went out a hero – known as the Black Canary, she was one of Star City’s sworn protectors – but this was the way that the city chose to remember her?
Now don’t get me wrong, the notion of acknowledging a legacy with a statue is a mighty fine idea – well, unless you’re erecting a Michael Jackson statue outside of Craven Cottage (sorry, Fulham fans) – but the statue chosen to represent the fallen Black Canary here was absolutely hideous.
Given how Ollie is the Mayor of Star City, not to mention how Team Arrow always seem to be flush with money between them, you'd have expected the powers-that-be to have gone all-out on a top, top quality statue for Laurel. Something classy, well-constructed, and with no expense spared.
Instead, we were given a statue of Laurel Lance that look as if it was made out of slightly melted chocolate.
So, how did you enjoy Legacy? Let us know in the comments section below.