Arrow Season 8 Review: 7 Ups & 3 Downs From 'Purgatory'

The Crisis arrives as Arrow goes right back to the beginning in a poignant tribute to Season 1.

Arrow Season 8 Team
The CW

Contains spoilers from Arrow Season 8, Episode 7.

Arrow's eighth season has prided itself on its ability to pull the rug out from under us. This is something that it usually manages to accomplish with the return of a former character or a jaw-dropping cliffhanger - both of which you already know the latest installment will feature.

Last week's shocks came in the form of Quentin Lance's return as this apparent gift from The Monitor proved to both Oliver Queen and Laurel Lance that good old Mar Novu was actually telling the truth about wanting to save the multiverse. And after this surprisingly kind gesture, he sent them back to where it all began for Arrow, as the pair found themselves back on Lian Yu.

The island in which Oliver was stranded on for five years - and has returned to a disturbing number of times since - it serves as the perfect backdrop for the Emerald Archer's final test. Thankfully for him, that's not a test that he, or even Team Arrow, has to tackle alone.

A love letter to Season 1, the aptly titled 'Purgatory' takes Arrow right back to the beginning in order to propel it towards the end, and the result is poignant trip down memory lane that successfully kicks off the Crisis.

First, the negatives...


Downs...

3. Canary Cry

Arrow Season 8 Laurel
The CW

While we can certainly appreciate the fact that Arrow is allowing its primary Black Canary, Laurel Lance, to show how formidable she is in hand-to-hand combat (something it has failed to do in the past), the refusal to allow her to use her Canary Cry this season is getting beyond a joke.

Though we've heard the Cry used multiple times through the season, we've only seen her use it once. This suggests that the powers-that-be are saving the budget for the Crisis which, when you think about it, is quite understandable. However, they got away with it until now.

Out in the open of Lian Yu, there were no doors or walls to conceal the visual effect behind and, thus, they just outright decided not to have her use it. And that would have been fine if the team was actually winning the battle... but they weren't.

You know what would temporarily take down an army of relentless undead soldiers? A sonic scream. But hey, let's have Mia shoot an explosive arrow instead, right? That makes total sense.


2. Mia's Behaviour

Arrow Oliver Queen Mia Smoak
The CW

"Clearly your daughter," Laurel Lance said with sarcastic tone a few episodes back as she looked at Oliver, referring to Mia Smoak. And, well, she wasn't wrong.

The moment in which Mia found out that Oliver was destined to die in the Crisis she predictably reacted by pushing him away, throwing a tantrum and attempting to call the shots on a mission that was run by far more experienced heroes.

There should be something sweet in fact that she reacted exactly like her father does when he goes into one of his blind rages, but that wasn't one of Oliver's greatest qualities as a character (and one that the writers relied far too heavily on for convenience).

The fact that she was simply heartbroken at the prospect of losing him again was great, but it would have come off as more authentic if she hadn't wasted this reaction time and time again over the past seven episodes. And this forced conflict has gotten so repetitive now that is just drags the episode down.


1. The Little Things

Arrow Season 8 Wild Dog Mia Smoak Dinah Drake
The CW

When you're dealing with events as world-changing as the end of the multiverse, it's important to remember how effective and poignant the little things, or more importantly the little moments, can be. While these are elements that all of The CW's Arrowverse shows tend to overlook from time to time, Arrow's final season has mostly done a great job of avoiding that mistake. However, given the emotional gravity of 'Purgatory', it overlooked one too many of them.

While the plane crash reaction had moments of greatness, such as the panic in Dinah's voice, the visual of the missile, and Laurel's urgent "Oh my God", the moment that it crashed, the show adopted a very business as usual approach. Oh yes, the plutonium conveniently happened to land away from the rest of the plane which, of course, had to spawn two separate missions instead of, um, oh well, finding out if your friends are still alive!

Juliana Harkavy, Rick Gonzalez and Colton Haynes all did a great job conveying the damage of the crash in their performances, but the episode's insistence on rushing over it to the overall goal undercut the emotional gravity of it all.

The same could be said for the fact that following the activation of 'The Weapon' the ghosts just disappeared - something that robbed Oliver of a final moment with Yao Fei. And that just didn't feel right.

There were no moments to stop and take in what was happening, and very few of them which allowed the characters to react like real people. In situations like this, that really could have added some deeper emotional layers.

Now, for the positives...


Ups...

7. Back To The Beginning...

Arrow Oliver Queen
The CW

There's something oddly poetic about the fact that Arrow had to go back to the beginning before it could truly end, and that poetry came to life in 'Purgatory'. An episode inspired a great deal by the first season, it contained so many throwbacks to Oliver's time on the island that it just felt like one of those original 23 episodes.

It wasn't just the Lian Yu setting that accomplished this. The returns of Yao Fei, Edward Fyers and Billy Wintergreen were wonderful touches, while the fact that the whole episode was accompanied by the first season's (far superior) dramatic score added gravity to its most emotional moments.

Though the season premiere already paid tribute to the pilot episode,it still felt right for the show to do a separate tribute to the debut season. Season 1 was something of its own monster that took the show in directions that the pilot did not, and 'Purgatory' captured that splendidly.

Speaking of Yao Fei...


6. Yao Fei's Return

Arrow Season 8 Yao Fei
The CW

It wouldn't be a tribute episode to Season 1 without the return of a character specific to the show's debut offering. With that in mind, it's rather fitting that Byron Mann made an epic comeback. Reprising his role as Oliver's mentor Yao Fei, he was there to offer guidance to his former protege - and can we please have a standing ovation for him because he finally made Oliver see that his refusal to change was holding him back.

Fans will remember that Yao Fei was an integral part of the first season, as he taught Oliver the most basic survival instincts and ultimately kick-started the journey that forged him into the multiverse-saving warrior he is today. Though the Emerald Archer isn't a perfect character, he was stronger because of Yao Fei, and it was nice to see the pair share some reflective moments together.

Byron Mann's contribution to the show was much greater than his episode count would have you believing, and this episode was vital in proving that.


5. The Family Bonding

Arrow Oliver Queen William Clayton
The CW

As problematic as Mia Smoak's behavior was, there was promise in the fact that underneath all of it, she just didn't want to lose her father. And no matter how annoying she ultimately became, those solid foundations couldn't be faulted.

This made for a compelling tale of how a heartbroken daughter must come to terms with the fact that she might lose her father all over again and, in the process, confront how she really feels about it. Similarly, it forced a son (William) to open up about why he was at peace with the fact that he was abandoned all those years ago. And finally, it gave a father in denial the opportunity to deal with his own feelings by opening up to his children.

The emotional heart of the Queen family saga was something that really shined in this episode, as it paved the way for some heartbreaking, and heartwarming moments between Oliver and his children, while also giving William more to do that churn out (some admittedly hilarious) one-liners.

On that note, Stephen Amell, Ben Lewis and Katherine McNamara all did a great job here with the heavy-hitting stuff and you'd be hard-pressed to find someone who wasn't reaching for their tissues during the episode's multiple heart-to-hearts.


4. A New Direction For Roy

Arrow Roy Harper
The CW

The decision to amputate Roy Harper's right arm came as something of a shock for a show that tends to play it safe as much as Arrow does and, at this point in time, it's probably one that didn't really need to happen. That being said, it was one that made comic book fans sit up and pay attention.

Of course, fans will know that in the comics (and Young Justice), the character eventually loses his arm in battle and is forced to adopt a prosthetic arm instead, so it's highly likely that we'll be seeing this take place at some point over the remaining three episodes.

Though some may not take too kindly to the decision, it's worth remembering that Colton Haynes isn't a series regular this season, so he likely won't be taking part in much of Crisis On Infinite Earths (if at all). With that in mind, this was an effective way of ensuring that Roy remains out of the picture during the Crisis and one that pays tribute to the comics at the same time.

Don't worry, Arsenal will rise again before the show comes to an end.


3. Best Team Arrow Ever

Arrow Season 8 Team
The CW

Forget OTA and forget NTA, because 'Purgatory' introduced us to the greatest iteration of Team Arrow the show has ever produced. Yes, when Oliver found himself confronted by Fyers and his men, he proudly told them that he wasn't alone either. And with that, he was backed up by Spartan, Black Canary (Laurel Lance), Wild Dog, Mia Smoak-Queen, Black Canary II (Dinah Drake), Connor Hawke and even Yao Fei.

The moment in which they all stepped out of the shadows to support Oliver was one that was unexpectedly emotional, for we knew that this would likely be the very last time that Team Arrow would fight side-by-side. And with a team that incredible, it's safe to say that Arrow saved the best for last.


2. The Fight Scene

Arrow Season 8 Oliver Queen John Diggle Laurel Lance Black Canary
The CW

There was something almost cathartic about watching that final fight scene on Lian Yu. Between the fact that it allowed each member of Team Arrow some well-earned moments to shine to the fact that multiple shots were long and continuous, it gave us one last chance to appreciate the show's fight choreography in all its glory.

With explosions, gunshots and plenty of roundhouse kicks, there was so much goin on that it should have been hard to focus your eyes in one specific area, but the strong camerawork made it easy to look at what the show wanted us to see. More than that, it highlighted just how much of it actually took place in the same shot.

But perhaps the best part about all of it was the slow motion segment, in which Oliver stopped and looked back at the all-out war unfolding before his eyes. It was a moment in which he, and by extension we, could appreciate the legacy that he (and the show) has left behind in Team Arrow... and a unique perspective as we watched one more of those wonderful, wonderful fight scenes.


1. The Crisis (And Harbinger) Is Here

Arrow Harbinger Lyla Michaels Crisis
The CW

Though undoubtedly a farewell to a great show, Arrow's final season has been equally effective in setting up Crisis On Infinite Earths. Successfully utilising each of its seven episodes to set the stage for the annual crossover - one that has been five years in the making - it has built towards the Crisis in a natural and authentic way. But 'Purgatory' significantly upped the ante.

The discovery that Lyla wasn't just the answer to activating the plutonium weapon, but that she was the weapon was a unique and effective manner of kick-starting her evolution into Harbinger - and the completion of that transformation in the episode's closing moments (which coincided with the arrival of the red skies) could only mean one thing: The Crisis has begun.

Five years of storytelling, and a season full of planning has taken us to this moment, and Arrow has done an outstanding job pulling it altogether. That being said, as excited as we've been for the Crisis, we've been just as excited for each weekly installment of the show's final offering - and to make a show that once fell from grace that compelling again is no small feat.

The Crisis is here, and it couldn't be more exciting. Bravo Arrow, bravo indeed.

-

What did you make of 'Purgatory'? Tell us in the comment section below.


You'll Never Get 100% On This Arrowverse Quiz

Arrow Oliver Queen
The CW

1. According To The Reverse-Flash, What Age Does Oliver Queen Live To Be?

In this post: 
Arrow
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.