Battlestar Galactica: 10 Most Disturbing Episodes

All of this has happened before and we hope will never happen to us again.

Battlestar Galatica Starbuck Maelstrom
Universal

Space is the endless void, completely uninhabitable and possessed of boundless horror. There are planets whose atmosphere will burn and corrode the lungs, there are asteroid storms that can shred the hull of the most resilient Battlestar. More than that, there is a race of sentient machines out there that are hell-bent on the complete destruction of humanity.

When the Cylons rained nuclear fire on the twelve colonies of Mankind, a rag-tag exodus of ships fled into the cold darkness of space, desperate to find a way to survive. Led by Commander Adama and President Roslin, the tight-knit remnants of humanity were guided by astronomical calculations and blind faith in mystical history.

While some episodes of this fantastic show were heart-warming and victorious, others were downright chilling as the lengths that humanity would go to in order to survive became clear.

So here are ten of the most disturbing episodes of Battlestar Galactica, presented in almost chronological order. You may notice the recurring theme of punishing Starbuck, whose trials by pain are greater than any other character in the show.

Her pain is their salvation, you see.

10. 33

Battlestar Galactica
Universal

The first proper episode of the series after the 2003 miniseries was called 33. That's because the Cylon fleet was hot on the heels of the fleeing Colonials and was able to determine their new location every 33 minutes. The Colonial Fleet was then forced to perform an FTL Jump every 33 minutes to stay out of harm's way.

From the outset of the episode, we can see the effect that this is having on the crew. Bloodshot eyes, ragged nerves, unshaven faces. Commander Adama and Colonel Tigh are taking it in turns to man the bridge of the Galactica, but both are so tired that they can't even remember whose turn it is half of the time.

You see, this has been going on for days on end. While the destruction of the compromised Olympic Carrier seems to provide relief from this endless pursuit, the lines of stress and trembling hands speak for themselves. No supernatural fear, no mystical dread. Just fatigue.

No sleep, no rest, can't let your guard down for a moment, because they'll be here in thirty-three minutes.


9. The Farm

Battlestar Galactica Cylon Simon
Universal Studios

During the early story-arc of the second season, Kara 'Starbuck' Thrace has travelled back to the devastated planet of Caprica. There she has been injured and taken to a strangely quiet hospital and tended too by a doctor called Simon. Here, he tells her that he can tend to her injuries while others in other rooms are dying of radiation poisoning.

He then asks probing questions about her history, hinting at her fear of pregnancy and the abusive nature of her own mother. When Starbuck comes to the realisation that this set-up is a little too convenient for Simon, she starts to look around. Injured and relying on her drip-stand for support, she tries to explore the hospital.

She finds a scene from a body-horror film, with numerous women strapped down onto tables and being experimented upon in an attempt to find a way to crossbreed humans and human-Cylons. Simon, revealed to be one of the Cylon models, states that she should be helping him. Fortunately for her, Samuel Anders and his survivor group were on hand to help.

They swear to find and destroy as many of these 'farms' as they can.


8. Scar

Battlestar Galactica Scar
Universal

During that brief, glorious period of the show when the Colonial fleet had two fully functional Battlestars at its disposal, there is an episode called Scar. Scar is a Cylon Raider who has died over and over again, each time its consciousness is placed inside a new body it has learned to become deadlier and faster.

With the nearby Resurrection Ship destroyed a few episodes previously, Scar now knows that its next death will be its last. Thus it has become truly vicious, ambushing Viper pilots in an asteroid field that the fleet is trying to mine resources from. Both Starbuck and younger pilot Kat swear that they'll be the one to kill it.

While the set-up for the showdown with Scar continues, we see how devastated Starbuck has become at the separation from Samuel Anders, who was left behind on Caprica. We see her descend into alcoholism and despair, lashing out at her friends and engaging in self-destructive behaviour. Her record as being the Galactica's best pilot is under threat and she can't deal with it. In the end, she almost throws away her life to kill Scar, but has to duck out and let Kat take the shot.

As they drink victorious, Starbuck recites the list of every pilot that they've lost since the exodus began. She's defeated herself.


7. Occupation

Battlestar Galactica s2 finale
Universal Television

This episode opens hard and it closes harder. We first see Saul Tigh imprisoned by the Cylons and now missing his right eye. Bitterly, he is released to rejoin with his companions, Galen Tyrol and Samuel Anders. The three of them have formed the New Caprica Resistance against their Cylon overlords. It's been four months since the Cylons arrived and the fleet jumped away. Four months since they were abandoned here.

We see the state that humanity has been reduced too, living in fear, continuously rounded up and oppressed. Leoben Conoy has Starbuck as his personal prisoner and he's trying to convince her that she should accept her imprisonment. While the grim reality plays out behind them, we're reminded of the events of the web-series Resistance, where Duck's wife Nora is killed by the Cylons during a raid of a temple.

In retaliation, Duck has agreed to join the New Caprica Police and there he detonates an explosive, killing the various new recruits to the force, himself and a number of Cylons. While those Cylons will be resurrected, the humans that were willing to collaborate with them cannot be replaced and the message was clear sent. But stooping to that level, to send a man willing to die and kill everyone around him?

In reality, we know that as suicide bombing, a heinous act of cowardice in a war of terror. And this is what our heroes have sunk too.


6. Collaborators

Battlestar Galactica The Resistance
Universal

There are vigilantes amongst the Colonial Fleet, now that they are in the midst of this, the second exodus. Six members of a circle, which includes Colonel Saul Tigh, Galen Tyrol and Samuel Anders, are discussing those people who collaborated with the Cylons on New Caprica and then systematically murdering them. At least thirteen people are killed for their dealings with the Cylons by this group.

As the episode progresses, Sam Anders decides that he can't be a part of this anymore and leaves the group. The group then select Starbuck to take his place and they go after Felix Gaeta, the technical officer who left the military to serve as assistant to the puppet President Gaius Baltar. Gaeta is dragged into a launch tube and given a chance to exonerate himself. At first he refuses, until Starbuck beats it out of him.

He tells them that during the occupation, he would sneak information to the Resistance, specifically to Galen Tyrol. Tyrol never knew who the informant was, but since Gaeta got the details right, he insists that he has to go free, since his actions saved lives. Horrified at what they have become, the Circle disbands.

The final nail in the coffin is that this circle was commissioned officially by acting President Tom Zarek. No trial, no jury, just cold vigilante justice.


5. Maelstrom

Battlestar Galactica Maelstrom
Universal

One of the most difficult to understand episodes of the show, Maelstrom is the apparent death of central character Starbuck. At first she is haunted by the memories of her abusive mother and the diagnosis of cancer that she received just after Starbuck had graduated from flight school. She keeps finding that her dreams are betraying her, finding herself back in her long-gone apartment on Caprica, sitting with Leoben Conoy.

While the Galactica and its fleet are attempting to refuel within a gas giant planet, Starbuck's patrol sights a Cylon ship and she gives chase. But nobody else can see it and she has to be convinced to give up the chase. Her dreams start to bleed into reality, she sees her childhood self all around the Galactica and tells Apollo that she can't trust herself. When she goes on her next patrol, Apollo says that he'll fly on her wing.

Endlessly drawn towards a massive central storm, Starbuck sees the phantom Cylon again and again gives chase. Realisation and dreams wash over her as she accepts that this is a moment she can never turn back from and she flies into the storm. Apollo's screams for her to come back are a wrenching truth.

Starbuck's gone.


4. Six Of One

Battlestar Galactica Starbuck
Universal

Starbuck has returned from the Maelstrom and nobody will believe her when she says that she has found the mythical Earth that they've been searching for. While the leadership of the Colonial Fleet decides what to do about her, what she represents, Starbuck is confined to the brig. She starts to lose her mind, feeling every FTL jump that the fleet makes and eventually screams about how they're going the wrong way.

This is only one of the stories for this episode, for there is now also dissent amongst the Cylons. Brother Cavill and those Cylons loyal to him have started to lobotomise the Raiders, drilling into their skulls and removing their ability to reason. So Natalie, a leader amongst those Cylons who resist Cavill, informs the Centurions on what is happening. The Centurions start gunning down Cavill and his followers.

Of course, that's not enough to kill a Cylon, as he simply gets back up on another ship. The seeds of the Cylon civil-war have been planted.


3. Sometimes A Great Notion

Battlestar Galactica Dualla
Universal

The first episode of the second half of the final season (which due to the 2008 Writer's Strike was packaged as its own season) was a gut-punch in its own right. Following on from the discovery of Earth (a nuclear wasteland that's been uninhabited for 2,000 years), the human and rebel Cylons are completely devastated. Nobody knows what to do next, they've found their goal and it's nothing but wreckage.

Admiral Adama walks aimlessly through the corridors while fist-fights and weeping go unnoticed. The sense of loss and hopelessness is palpable, leaving a taste of ash in the mouths of everyone in the fleet. Amidst all of this, Anastasia 'Dee' Dualla suggests that she and Lee Adama (to whom she was previously married but amicably separated) spend the evening together. They have a pleasant time and go their separate ways.

Then Dee shoots herself in the head.

Eventually, the fleet realises that they will have to find a new world, but Colonel Tigh has a vision of his wife Ellen. A new course of action suggests itself.


2. Someone To Watch Over Me

Battlestar Galactica Ellen Tigh
Universal

As the saga draws near it's conclusion, Starbuck finds herself bereft of purpose and questioning whether or not it was her body on the devastated Earth. Is she real, or is she just a memory given form. While contemplating this in Joe's hanger bar, she makes friends with Slick, the man playing the piano. They talk about music, childhood and memories of times gone by. Starbuck talks about how, while her mother was abusive and mean-spirited, her father was always kind to her. He too, was a musician, a piano player.

Meanwhile, Sharon 'Boomer' Valerii (the one version of the Number 8's that is still loyal to Cavill and the hostile Cylons) has infiltrated the fleet and intends to abduct baby Hera Agathon. She is a prisoner to start with, but tricks Galen Tyrol into helping her escape. She finds her opposite number, Sharon 'Athena' Agathon, and beats her unconscious, just before Athena's husband Helo comes back to their quarters. Boomer pretends to be Athena, has sex with Helo and then, while he's asleep, steals baby Hera.

As Galen realises that he's been deceived and Sharon damages Galactica in her escape attempt, Starbuck finally recognises the piano player as her father. The tune that he's been working on is incomplete, but apparently finished by a drawing made by baby Hera. As it all comes crashing down on Starbuck, Slick simply isn't there anymore. Perhaps he wasn't there in the first place. Perhaps he was a real as she is.


1. Razor

Michelle Forbes Battlestar Galactica Razor
Universal Studios

Easily the best entry that the Battlestar Galactica franchise managed, Razor was also one of the most distressing. Told across various timelines, the story of Admiral Helena Cain and her powerful warship is one of warning and horror. While Galactica took a moral high-road with the influence of President Roslin, helping to shepherd a civilian fleet, Pegasus took a darker path.

When they encountered surviving civilian ships, they stripped them for useful parts, useful people and fuel. When they realised that they had a Cylon in their midst, they tortured, beat and raped her. All of the actions of Pegasus under the leadership were motivated by rage and vengeance, which Adama and Roslin did not let Galactica succumb too.

We also see flashback to the First Cylon War, the body horror of the creation of the first Cylon Hybrids and Helena Cain's own loss of her sister. Harrowing and powerful, Razor stands up as the entire franchise in a nutshell, exemplifying how dark humanity can fall when it's back is up against the wall.

While there were moments of hope and reassurance within this show, ultimately, Battlestar Galactica remains a grim reminder of what we could become. So say we all.


Contributor

Still bitter that Star Trek Enterprise got canned and almost old enough to angrily tell the kids to 'Get Off My Lawn!'