Battlestar Galactica's 15 Biggest Plot Twists And Reveals
Battlestar Galactica liked to keep you on your toes!
The reimagined Battlestar Galactica TV series was a program that skillfully blended hard military action, intense character-based drama and complex science fiction themes. It explored a wide range of thought-provoking topics, including terrorism, religion, love, politics, ethics, and personal identity, all wrapped up in gripping plot that kept viewers tuning in episode after episode.
Throughout its run (which included a mini-series, four regular seasons and a variety of tie-in movies and web series) Battlestar Galactica took viewers on a roller-coaster of twists and turns which included shifting loyalties, dramatic reversals of fortune, and revelations that got to the very identities of the core cast.
One never knew which character was likely to have their lives sent in a tailspin by the end of the next episode. By the time the survivors reached the series finale, nobody had gone untouched by the unexpected trauma that lurked around every corner in the battle for survival. However, the fact that the road traveled was fraught with peril only made the eventual conclusion all the more satisfying.
Here are the 15 most startling and best delivered twists and reveals that Battlestar Galactica had to offer.
Obvious Spoilers lie ahead!
15. The Meaning Of The Opera House (Daybreak – Season 4, Episodes 19-21)
Throughout Battlestar
Galactica, multiple characters have visions of an Opera House. In the fourth season in particular, a
recurring dream shows President Roslin and the Cylon Sharon 'Athena' Agathon chasing young Hera
(Athena’s hybrid daughter) through the halls of this Opera House, before the
child is collected by a Number Six and Gaius Baltar, and taken through an
ominous door. There, Six and Baltar look
up at the robed figures of the Final Five Cylons standing on the balcony above
the stage.
In the series finale, the events of the vision finally come to pass. The halls of the Opera House are now Galactica, where both Roslin and Athena attempt to find young Hera who has run away after being rescued from the Cylon Colony. She is picked up by Baltar and Caprica Six, and taken through a final door into the Galactica control room, where the Five have gathered in the upper levels to recreate resurrection technology.
All of this action is intercut poetically with images of the vision, confirming that these events are what it was indicating all along. It’s a cool moment of revelation that while not being shocking, is highly satisfying.
14. The Truth About Aaron Doral (The Miniseries)
Given that a
big part of Battlestar Galactica is
that an artificial enemy has evolved to replicate humans, it’s no surprise that
a number of the items on this list are to do with discovering that certain
characters are in fact, Cylons.
As the miniseries begins, Aaron Doral is a slightly annoying public relations executive coordinating Commander Adama’s retirement ceremony. When the Colonies are destroyed in the initial attack, Doral is amongst the survivors.
But when Gaius Baltar needs to divert attention from himself, he picks the hapless Doral, seemingly at random, to accuse of being a Cylon agent. Doral desperately maintains his innocence, but his cries fall on deaf ears. He is eventually left behind at an abandoned space station.
In the closing moments of the miniseries, we get the twist—Doral is indeed a Cylon, and by what appears to be a complete coincidence, Baltar chose correctly (later episodes imply that there might be more to it than that).
Doral was never a major character, so this outing is not as dramatic as some others (one other in particular, which took place in the same scene), but it is still a surprising and cool little revelation.
13. The Cylon Change Of Heart (Downloaded & Lay Down Your Burdens—Season 2, Episodes 18-20)
Unlike a lot
of entries on this list, this twist doesn’t all happen in one dramatic moment, but
rather over several episodes. Still, it is
such a momentous shift that it earns a place on this list.
The episode Downloaded focuses on the Cylon society for the first time, especially on two individuals whose efforts to destroy humanity have been seen the most clearly by the audience.
One is Caprica Six, the Number Six who was responsible for making the Colonies vulnerable in the initial attack. The other is Sharon Valerii, the Number Eight who had thrown the fleet into chaos by shooting Commander Adama. Both of these Cylons have been reborn on Caprica, struggling to make sense of their actions, and eventually coming to see that the attack on the Colonies was wrong—indeed, that it was a sin. Eventually, they even gather enough support to change all of Cylon policy, leading to their withdrawal from Caprica.
Of course, it turns out that the reality of this new ideal is a hard thing to realize, but the whole twist reminds us that the show could and regularly did bring the story in many unexpected directions.
12. D’Anna Biers Has A Secret (Final Cut—Season 2, Episode 8)
In the
episode Final Cut, journalist D’Anna Biers comes to Galactica to film a
documentary about the military crew. Struggling
with their public image, Commander Adama and President Roslin surprise everyone
by giving her unfettered access, and permission to report the facts as she sees
them.
Over the course of her investigation, D’Anna does see one thing that Commander Adama insists she keep quiet—the birth of Sharon Valerii’s baby. Given that Sharon is a known Cylon who is thought by the public to be dead, this is a significant story. But D'Anna doesn’t include that information in her documentary, and the film ultimately tells its story in a way that honors the crew and affirms their commitment to duty and sacrifice.
In the end, it’s the audience who get the final scoop—D’Anna is a Cylon. A battle earlier with a couple of Raiders was really a cover-up for getting the documentary footage to the Cylons themselves. As several Cylons watch the footage, they are overjoyed to learn that Sharon Valerii is still alive, and that her baby has been born safely.
11. The Angels Walk Among Us (Downloaded—Season 2, Episode 19, And Daybreak—Season 4, Episodes 19-21)
Throughout Battlestar Galactica, a central question concerns the nature of the image of Number Six that regularly “haunts” Gauis Baltar. Is she a figment of Baltar’s imagination, the result of a computerized implant in Baltar’s brain, or something else? As the series progresses, “Head Six” (as she’s often known) displays increased amounts of emotion and autonomy, indicating that she is more than just an impression in Baltar’s mind.
But none of that prepares us for Downloaded, in season two, when we see the aftermath of the attack on the Colonies from the point of view the Number Six who helped make it happen. After resurrecting and being hailed as a hero, she finds herself visited by a similar mental impression—but of Gaius Baltar. His influence helps to shift her perspective of the attack, leading to a change in the Cylon’s long-term strategy.
Later, Six and Baltar find themselves together in the series finale, where they are both visited by Head Six and Head Baltar simultaneously. It’s only then that unambiguously clear to both the characters and the viewers that these entities are fully independent living beings, and not just projections (although their exact nature is never fully disclosed.)
10. The Cylon Civil War (Six Of One, The Ties That Bind—Season 4, Episodes 2-3)
Early in the
fourth season of the series, a dispute arises amongst the Cylons about how to
respond to Raiders who had refused to follow orders. This leads to outright
hostilities amongst the different Cylon lines, as seen in a pair of devastating
back-to-back sneak attacks.
First, a discontent Number Six leads a rebellion against the de facto leader of the Cylons, Cavil (Number One), by giving Cylon Centurion soldiers back their free will. Upset at the treatment of the Raiders, the Centurions join Six and her fellow conspirators, murdering Cavil and all his allies who are present.
This victory is short lived though. Under the pretense of making peace, a resurrected Cavil tricks his enemies into going on a journey which separates them from their Resurrection Ship. His vessels then close in on the rebels and ruthlessly destroy them, far away from any hope of downloading into new bodies.
Both of these twists helped make the drama amongst the Cylons as interesting as anything going on in the Colonial Fleet.
9. Boomer Shoots Adama (Kobol’s Last Gleaming—Season 1, Episodes 12-13)
All through
the first season of Battlestar Galactica, one of the running subplots concerns
Lt. Sharon “Boomer” Valerii coming to terms with the fact that she is really a Cylon and is
on Galactica as an unwitting “sleeper agent”.
Several times, Boomer finds evidence that she is working to sabotage the
Fleet, but works against that programming as much as possible to continue serve
the Colonies with loyalty.
All that changes in the closing moments of Kobol’s Last Gleaming, the first season finale. After being congratulated by Adama on accomplishing a particularly vital and strategic mission, Sharon abruptly pulls out her sidearm and shoots the Commander several times in the chest.
The series would later imply that Sharon’s failure to kill Adama was a result of her conflicted nature, but that doesn’t change how shocking the attack is, and how significantly it impacts the trajectory of the show for quite some time.
8. The Fifth Is Revealed (Sometimes A Great Notion—Season 4, Episode 11)
Battlestar
Galactica had always made an event out of the revelation of a new Cylon. By the time we got to the mid-point of the
final season, they were all known, but one.
And in an episode that is filled with many devastating moments,
Sometimes a Great Notion saves its biggest reveal for its final scene: the last Cylon is Ellen Tigh.
Ellen was a complex character—sometimes sympathetic, sometimes deplorable, and at times both devoted and faithless to her husband Saul. By the time her nature is revealed, Ellen had actually been dead for well over a season, executed with as much mercy as possible by her own husband for betraying the human resistance. So the discovery that she was actually a hidden Cylon is not what anyone was expecting.
It is only four episodes later that Ellen is shown to still be alive, having resurrected on the Cylon fleet after her death. From then on, she becomes one of the series’ most significant characters, helping to provide a lot of understanding about the backstory for the entire human-Cylon conflict.
7. Starbuck’s Death And Life
A series of revelations, all surrounding the death and return of Lt. Kara “Starbuck” Thrace,
gets underway in Season Three’s Maelstrom, when she experiences some bizarre visions which lead her to
her apparent demise while flying a mission.
Watching this scene, it’s hard to imagine that it is really the end of the
beloved character, and indeed the season closes off just a few episodes later
with her mysterious return, claiming to have found the way to Earth.
Not long afterwards, Kara finds her own dead body (and destroyed fighter) on that same Earth. Even so, she goes on to be instrumental in guiding the Fleet to their eventual home, before finally vanishing without a trace.
The storyline is certainly surprising, and provides lots of dramatic moments, but the lack of any full explanation about what is happening gives it all a random feel, and prevents it from being higher on this list. The implication is that a guiding divine power is behind it all, but any specifics are just conjecture.
6. Dee’s Death (Sometimes A Great Notion—Season 4, Episode 11)
Sometimes a Great Notion delivers no less than four items on this list. Even though the others are bigger game-changers in terms of the overall story, it is the death of Dee that is the most shocking.
The story is that series creator Ron Moore and the writing staff agreed that the stunning events of the previous episode (more on that later) had to have some sort of fallout—not everyone could just come to terms with those disappointments emotionally unscathed. The decision was that it would be Lt. Anastasia “Dee” Dualla who would decide that enough was enough, her journey was over, and it was time to end her own life.
Her suicide is abrupt and startling, coming after an evening of happiness with her ex-husband, Lee Adama. The tenderness between them even hints that perhaps they will get back together. Instead, it turns out that Dee is simply finding a last moment of contentment and peace before following through on her resolve not to go on any longer. Her death ends up being one of the series’ most memorable and terrible moments.
5. Sharon Valerii Is A Cylon (The Miniseries)
In the very last moments of the original mini-series, audiences are treated to a twist which sets the tone for the whole series: amongst the first group of humanoid Cylons that we see is a copy of Galactica pilot Sharon Valerii. This is quite the reveal—“Boomer,” as she is known, had been one of the central characters of the story so far. She is a trusted pilot, a senior member of Galactica’s crew, and a reimagined version of a familiar character from the original series.
Boomer’s “outing” as a Cylon of the line known as Number Eight sets the stage for many of the storylines that were to come. A lot of attention in the early series is given to her wrestling with her loyalties and her identity. Questions are also raised about what other Cylons agents are living within the Colonial fleet.
Boomer’s story later comes to a sorry conclusion—she falls under the influence of the malevolent Cylon Cavil, turning against humanity and even her own line. Ultimately, she is killed by a fellow Number Eight, “Athena”, who had found what Boomer had failed to—a permanent home amongst Galactica’s crew.
4. One Year Later (Lay Down Your Burdens—Season 2, Episodes 19-20)
A focus in the second season of Battlestar Galactica is the presidential election between Laura Roslin and Gaius Baltar. The question that ends up being at the center of the contest is whether to settle on a newly discovered planet, which Baltar favors, or to continue to search for Earth, as advocated by Roslin.
The election draws to a close in the midst of much chaos, but in the end Baltar wins and the decision to settle on “New Caprica” is made. On another show, this turn of events might have been undone in the next episode, but Battlestar Galactica instead surprised us by abruptly jumping us forward one year in the story.
For the last few minutes of the season, viewers were treated to life on New Caprica, including their eventual rediscovery by the Cylons. This turn of events completely upended the status quo of every part of the story.
Even though the survivors were back on Galactica a few episodes into the third season, the year on New Caprica continued to impact the characters deeply for the rest of the series.
3. Tory Foster Shows Her True Colors (The Ties That Bind—Season 4, Episode 3)
Much of Battlestar
Galactica’s final season deals with the revelation of some of the so-called
“Final Five” Cylons. Their attempts to
remain hidden are threatened when deckhand Cally Tyrol stumbles upon their secret
and learns that her own husband is one of them.
The news brings her to the breaking point, and leads her to nearly kill herself and her infant son Nicholas in an airlock. At the last moment, Tory Foster, one of the other revealed Cylons, appears and intervenes. Tory speaks tenderly and compassionately to Cally, but it is quickly revealed that her concern is only for Nicholas, who at that point is thought to be a Cylon hybrid. Once Nicholas is safe, Tory brutally strikes Cally and ejects her into space, allowing her death to be written off as suicide.
The decision to have one of the new Cylons embrace her true heritage was a strong one from a writing point of view, but it was shocking to see for the audience. Cally was not always the most pleasant character, but her death is harsh and painful, and made it clear that nobody was safe as the series drew to a close.
2. Four Are Revealed (Crossroads—Season 3, Episode 19-20)
In what is undoubtedly the biggest “Cylon Reveal” of the series, the finale to Season Three includes a thread where four disparate characters across the story keep hearing odd music that leads them to be drawn together in an obscure part of the ship. There, they realize that they are four of the “Final Five” Cylons that the series had spent the season building up questions about.
And so while viewers had expected to see new Cylons at some point, their specific identities were still a shock. Both Colonel Saul Tigh and Chief Galen Tyrol had been with the series from the beginning, and had suffered greatly in the battle against the Cylons. Samuel Anders had been around since season two, had led a resistance movement and married Starbuck. The idea that any of these people could be a traitor, even unknowingly, was devastating. Only Tory Foster, who had not appeared as much as the others, was the kind of character whose true nature was not so hard to believe.
While the series took these Cylons in unique directions that ultimately made it all easier to accept, that did not reduce the shock of the initial reveal.
1. The Truth About Earth (Revelations & Sometimes A Great Notion—Season Four, Episodes 10 & 11)
By far, the
biggest twist in Battlestar Galactica came around the mid-season break of the
last season, when the Colonials and Cylons are able to put aside their
differences to follow an obscure signal that leads to their long-held destination,
Earth.
They arrive with jubilant celebrations, but it’s all cut short when they discover the world is a lifeless, post-apocalyptic husk. It appears that the Fleet has finally arrived at their destination, but centuries after nuclear destruction has killed everyone. The search for Earth had been the driving thrust of the series from the very beginning, and the devastation that the characters feel was shared by the audience.
But the kicker was still to come. In Sometimes a Great Notion (an episode which has appeared three times on this countdown already), it is discovered that the ancient inhabitants of Earth were in fact Cylons themselves. And so the Colonials’ dream of reconnecting with humanity was not only dead, but a complete fantasy to begin with. It is a brutal blow which reshaped the remaining few episodes of the series, whilst also making their eventual victory all the more satisfying.