Batwoman: Ranking Every Character From Worst To Best

Who became Gotham City’s greatest hero in Batwoman’s debut season?

Batwoman Season 1
The CW

It's a strange time for fans of The CW's Batwoman. With the season recently wrapping its run, they should be looking forward to what comes next for the Arrowverse series when the second season arrives in January 2021, but many of them are still reeling from the discovery that Ruby Rose has officially hung up the red wig. And with that, Greg Berlanti and co. are on the hunt for the next Scarlet Knight.

However, we shouldn't let the uncertainty surrounding Rose's sudden departure take away from the show's solid debut offering. Though it did struggle to find its footing early on in its run, it turned things around following Crisis On Infinite Earths and produced the best back half of any Arrowverse season - Arrow aside - this year.

Of course, that wouldn't have been possible without its ensemble of characters, most of whom created a unique dynamic on-screen and managed to keep viewers invested throughout the whole season. That said, not all of them pulled their weight.

With that in mind, let's get to know Batwoman's line-up of heroes and villains a little better and, while we're at it, rank them.

10. Tommy Elliot/Hush

Batwoman Hush
The CW

It's hard to deny that the sight of Tommy Elliot in his Hush get-up is pretty sick. No, it's not perfect but given that we're on a TV budget here, it's pretty damn awesome - and the fact that they managed to come up with a unique origin story for him that seamlessly fit into the whole Alice/Mouse skin debacle is actually quite admirable.

That said, the Tommy Elliot character isn't even remotely engaging and the reason for that is down to the simple fact that he's nothing like his comic book counterpart. No, this isn't some enraged comic book fan moaning about Batwoman's deviation from the source material - because occasionally that can work - it's simply pointing out that this Tommy lacks any of the depth that made the original Hush such a compelling villain.

Yeah, he was intentionally written as a henchman for the primary villains and, yeah, he works in that capacity, but to think what he could have been if he had been saved for a future Big Bad role instead.


9. Catherine Hamilton-Kane

Batwoman Episode 3 Truth
The CW

It's hard to believe that Elizabeth Anweis was ever a series regular on the show because Batwoman did so little with her in the first half of the season that Catherine Hamilton-Kane rarely, if ever, felt like a main character.

Showing up in maybe one or two scenes per episode, all she did was spout some cliché lines that made her sound incredibly one-dimensional. Furthermore, all the emphasis placed upon her secret was essentially deflated before we even found out what that secret actually was because she wasn't portrayed as having even the slightest of depths in the lead up to the reveal.

However, that all began to change as the show approached the midseason finale because, as Catherine's world fell apart, she began to exhibit more humane qualities. And the incredible mother-daughter chemistry Anweis shared with Nicole Kang in the pair's final scene together was an example of what we could have had.

Catherine did a really awful thing by convincing Jacob that Beth had died all those years ago, but she redeemed herself with her heroic sacrifice for her daughter. Unfortunately, the character work in between could have been a little stronger.


8. Jacob Kane

Batwoman Jacob Kane
The CW

Like Kate and Alice, Jacob Kane has one of the strongest backstories on the show but, unlike those two, it doesn't make up his often confusing motivations.

A father broken by the disappearance of his daughter and the death of his wife, Jacob very much personifies his grief from the offset. Dougray Scott helps him do just that, playing him as the heartbroken-turned-angry man that he is written as. However, as time goes on he begins to progress and regress interchangeably and he isn't on-screen enough for any of it to be convincing.

There's definitely potential for a great character there but as it stands Jacob's hatred of Batwoman comes off as annoying more than anything else and his decisions to go off and do things his own way have left viewers beyond the point of caring about him because he simply doesn't learn.

He's still grieving yes, but if the writers are intent on continuing down that route, he needs to be on-screen in order for us to buy his rash decisions.


7. Mouse

Batwoman Mouse
The CW

Mouse's introduction early-on in the season seemed like it was going to be short-lived, but his genuine devotion to Alic was refreshing change of pace for the show and, as a result, the writers found a way to develop him in a short amount of time.

A naive character who experienced the horrors of the world because of his corrupt father - whose wrong side he and Alice ended up on throughout their childhoods - he looked to Alice to protect him because she was the only person who never judged him for how he looked.

In among all of the darkness this show shrouded itself in, the kinship between these two tortured souls was surprisingly endearing and it was one of the many reasons why the second half of the season was far superior to the first.


6. Julia Pennyworth

Christina Wolfe
The CW

The moment that Julia Pennyworth turned up in Gotham City, Batwoman was infused with an unexpected vibrance as the character quickly turned things upside down with her undeniable charm. And even though it looked like she was a one-and-done character, her return later down the line ended up gifting the show with one of its most mysterious arcs - all while allowing her to become an unexpected obstacle in the inevitable Kate/Sophie romance.

The daughter of Alfred, Julia is another nice tie to the wider DC Universe, but it's her position as a spy and her romantic past with Kate that have proven to be the most fruitful stories thus far. Though she hasn't exactly been around long enough to learn much as a character, there is a well of story just waiting to be unearthed - and that is just one of the many reasons why Christina Wolfe should be promoted to a series regular next season.

Truth be told, when Julia is on-screen, you're guaranteed a thrilling experience, love.


5. Sophie Moore

Batwoman Sophie Moore
The CW

In the beginning, Sophie Moore didn't always come off as one of Batwoman's best characters in the present-day narrative, but her rich backstory - in which she was forced to hide her sexuality (and relationship with Kate) at her military academy - always contained the promise of some groundbreaking storytelling. And halfway through the season, the writers finally struck gold with the character.

Sure, there were times when the show wasn't quite sure what to do with her, but Sophie's struggles with her sexuality and subsequent coming to terms with it provided Batwoman with perhaps its most important storyline. And by showcasing her journey towards self-acceptance, the writers not only enhanced Sophie as a character, they told an inspirational story that no doubt resonated with countless fans all over the world - one that Meagan Tandy absolutely nailed with her performance.

The truth is that Agent Moore has great potential as a character, and Batwoman has only begun to scratch the surface of that. Expect her to shine in Season 2.


4. Mary Hamilton

Mary Hamilton Kane Batwoman
The CW

A character that caught so many people off-guard from the very beginning, Mary Hamilton's charms lay in the fact that she was nothing like she wanted herself to be seen. Yes, the Gotham City socialite and social media superstar lapped up her famous facade and portrayed herself as a vacuous shell that would have made the playboy billionaire persona of Bruce Wayne proud.

However, like the Dark Knight himself (and now, his cousin too), Mary wore that persona to protect her identity as one of Gotham's unsung heroes. Operating an unsanctioned clinic in the city, Mary puts her skills as a medical student to the test in order to help those in need. And in the process, she proved herself to her stepsister.

Now a fully-fledged member of Team Batwoman, Mary never fails to stand up for what is right even if it means disagreeing with those she loves. And that's a sign of a true hero.


3. Luke Fox

Batwoman Luke Fox Camrus Johnson
The CW

Batwoman's right-hand man, Luke Fox is to the Scarlet Knight what his father Lucius was to Batman, offering her assistance in the face of any intimidatingly complex situation and providing her with both the technology and knowledge required to get her out of said situations.

In many ways, Luke functions like Cisco Ramon on The Flash or Winn Schott on Supergirl in that he not only guides the titular hero through their missions, he also provides levity whenever any situation finds itself getting too dark. And like those aforementioned characters, he's also a well of unexplored depth that absolutely shines when the spotlight is on him.

The backstory involving the death of his father provided the season with one of its most powerful episodes, all while highlighting how strong a character Luke truly is. And to top it all off, just like he does with all of the humour and techno mumbo jumbo, Carmus Johnson absolutely bloody nailed it.


2. Kate Kane/Batwoman

Batwoman Kate Kane Ruby Rose
The CW

Kate Kane proved to be a formidable hero right from the offset during her appearance in Elseworlds, but there was a concern that Ruby Rose's moody protagonist may not be deep enough to carry a show of her own. Batwoman put those concerns to bed very early on.

Hardened by the trauma of losing her sister during her childhood, Kate is fully aware of her scars and she wears them like a badge of honour - something that aids her well in her vigilantism. That also lends itself nicely to her development throughout the season as her journey to becoming the Dark Knight leads her further into the light, paving the way for some real nice character development.

She's a fighter and she'll certainly have no problem telling you that, but she's an inspirational one who finds a way to deal with her own trauma by helping others. And just like Batman was, she's the hero that Gotham needs and the one it deserves.

Ruby Rose overcame the criticism to deliver an empowering performance and whoever ultimately replaces her is going to have a hard time filling her red and black boots.


1. Alice

Batwoman Alice
The CW

The way in which an actor tackles a villainous role can often result in a career-defining performance. We've seen it with greats like Heath Ledger, Vincent D'Onofrio and the Arrowverse's own Tom Cavanagh. At this point, it goes without saying that Batwoman's Rachel Skarsten has added her name to that list.

Unquestionably the very best thing about Batwoman, Skarsten's performance was nothing short of magnificent as she brought the unhinged, emotionally conflicted and at times downright chilling Alice to life.

Of course, it helps that she had great material to work with. We mentioned some of the show's shortcomings earlier on, but not a single one of them had to do with Alice. A character so well defined, the creative team did a fantastic job of making this psychopath strangely endearing to us pretty early on, gifting what could have been a one-dimensional wacko with a rich conflict, unusually understandable goal and excellently fleshed-out backstory.

Alice wasn't just a great villain; she was a great character and, by far the best to grace the Arrowverse in a very long time. For that reason, viewers were gripped every single time she was on-screen as she took them through the looking glass with ease.

-

Which Batwoman character was your favourite? Tell us in the comment section below.


The Flash Quiz: How Well Do You Remember Season 6?

The Flash The Void
The CW

1. On Which Date Did The Flash Season 6 Premiere?

In this post: 
Batwoman
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.