Batwoman Season 1 Review: 4 Ups & 3 Downs From 'Down, Down, Down'

Hush's arrival brings Batwoman to life in the show's solid but problematic third episode.

Batwoman Episode 2
The CW

Contains spoilers for Batwoman Season 1, Episode 3.

Ever since Batwoman arrived on our screens, the show has made it very clear that it's currently in a state of transition.

Sure, Kate Kane returned from wherever it was that she was training to do whatever it was she wanted to do in order to save the love of her life from a woman that may well be her supposedly dead twin sister - and she ended up donning her cousin's iconic Bat-suit to do it. However, completely removed from the fact that she's inadvertently been inspiring a city, Kate has very much been playing Batman in a bid to figure out the truth about Alice. But was "Batman" really who she wanted to be?

It's ironic that, after two narrative-heavy episodes, it's a relatively standalone adventure like 'Down, Down, Down' that ultimately forces Kate to confront the possibility of being a hero - but it's effective in doing so as the character realises that she can track down Alice and inspire people at the same time.

'Down, Down, Down' was, in many ways, the birth of Batwoman. But not just the character, as the show itself is now aware of what it is and, even though it's not all perfect, there is still hope that this reinvention will allow it to continue that upward trajectory towards greatness.

First, the negatives...


Downs...

3. Dodgy CGI Strikes During Another Huge Moment

Batwoman Episode 2 CGI
The CW

It's wrong to expect movie-worthy CGI from television (unless your Game of Thrones or Stranger Things, of course). The production budget just won't allow for it. So it's probably wrong to pull Batwoman up for the same thing in two out of its three episodes. But this isn't just about the use of dodgy CGI, it's about how its used in scenes that are pivotal to the story as it ends up undercutting the grandeur of the moment.

The build towards Kate donning the iconic Batwoman suit reached its conclusion when she met Tommy Eliot on the roof of his building. However, as we get our first look at her, it's incredibly noticeable that she's standing against a CGI blue night sky.

To make matters worse, an alternate angle of this particular moment (the "that's the point" scene) popped up in one of the show's earlier trailers and, as Batwoman was already standing on the roof (as opposed to the edge of it) there was no need for any CGI. And that made it all the more effective.

If only they had gone with that one instead...


2. No Depth To Catherine

Batwoman 2
The CW

We're three episodes in now and we still don't know anything about Catherine Hamilton-Kane. Sure, she's Jacob's wife, Mary's mother and the only person who insists on referring to her stepdaughter as "Katie", but who is she?

Last week's instalment suggested that she may have had something to do with the faking of Beth's death, as she seemed pretty scared by the fact that Alice might be Beth and, in response, ordered the destruction of the villain's knife just because it had the twin sisters' birthstone on it. And this was after the flashbacks revealed that she was the one who informed Jacob that they found Beth's bones. With that in mind, fans have been left wondering what she's hiding.

However, it's beginning to feel like the writers are single-handedly relying on this twist to make her come across as an interesting character because, other than that, there is literally nothing below the surface. She's rarely on-screen and whenever she is, she's sorely one-dimensional - giving disapproving looks and continually ordering her husband to stop Alice - and it's making her a rather annoying addition to the show.

In order for a twist to truly work, there must be a solid foundation there to work from. That's why it's called a "twist" - because it's so shocking and unforeseen that it literally twists your perception of something or someone. But, as of right now, there's no foundation to Catherine. She's just a well-dressed socialite with nothing to say and plenty to groan about.

It would be really nice to get to know her a little better going forward...


1. Tommy Elliot's Reinvention

Batwoman Episode 2 Thomas Elliot
The CW

It goes without saying that Batman fans were eager to see the first ever live-action adaptation of an adult Tommy Elliot/Hush in Batwoman (second overall if you include Gotham's teenage iteration). Unfortunately, it wasn't all it was cracked up to be.

Instead of the troubled surgeon who had transformed into a split personality of sorts, what we got was a corrupt businessman interested in nothing but being the king of Gotham and besting his supposed best friend Bruce - and, you know, killing him too. Why did he want to kill Bruce? Well, because the good old Dark Knight had only gone and saved his mother and thus, sentenced him to suffer for thirteen years as he looked after her. And what did this rob him of? Why, his inheritance of course!

The similarities to the comics' arc was there, but Tommy's transformation into Hush in the comics was so poignant and striking not just because of how close he and Bruce were, but because of how good of a man he was perceived and how good a surgeon he was. This was a one-dimensional caricature that everyone knew was selfish in the first place and they were right, because all he wanted was money and power. You see the problem, here?

Gabriel Mann did a fine job bringing the material to life - the only problem is that his performance was the only thing of real substance.

Now, for the positives...


Ups...

4. Mary Gets A Moment To Shine

Batwoman Mary
The CW

Unlike her mother, Mary Hamilton is a character who, in spite of limited screen-time, is really beginning to come into her own.

On the surface, she's a social media influencer who loves partying above everything else and a future socialite in the making, but underneath all that, there is a well-rounded character who actually really enjoys the medical side of med school and, more than that, wants to help people.

She may be a device for whenever Batwoman needs help in the future, but she's an interesting device that, in this week's instalment, got to shine without the shadow of the bat as she helped some seriously injured civilians in front of Sophie - changing her perception of her.

Now, if only her mother could do the same...


3. Alice's Side Of The Story

Batwoman Alice
The CW

One of the bonuses of giving Kate her own story this week was that allowed the main narrative to continue through Alice instead - giving Rachel Skarsten a chance to prove that her character's journey is anything but a secondary arc.

From the nightmare that she was having to her surprisingly poignant phone call with Jacob, the writers were very clear in their attempts to portray the character as more than a typically-unhinged villain, and they were incredibly effective in doing just that.

In spite of her eccentric personality, it's hard not to get drawn into the emotional side of things as we wonder if she really is Beth or not, and that's some darn good characterisation right there.


2. The Dynamic Between Kate And Alice

Batwoman Ruby Rose
The CW

Who would have thought that Kate's very first official mission as Batwoman would end with her being saved by the person that brought the Bat-within to life in the first place. But that's just an example of how complex the relationship between her and Alice already is - and we're only three episodes in.

Easily the most compelling dynamic on the show, the relationship between this pair has continued to subvert our expectations by laying all of the cards on the table pretty early on. Kate discovered that Alice might be Beth in the concluding moments of the premiere, while Alice figured out she was Batwoman by the end of the second, and it left us all wondering it it was peeling back the layers much too soon.

But if we learned anything from 'Down, Down, Down', it's that there are still more layers to this story and that, in spite of Alice's villainy (and blatant refusal to stop killing), Kate isn't ready to give up on her sister just yet. The secrets may be out in the open, and yet the stakes remain high. And with that, it's easy to see why the dynamic between the two is anchoring the show, and it's going to be interesting to watch as it develops further.


1. Batwoman Is Born

Batwoman Episode 2
The CW

Much like Oliver Queen before her, Kate spent the first few episode of her respective show telling us all the reasons why she wasn't a hero while inadvertently showing us that all the ways that she was. She may have been temporarily taking on the role of the city's saviour, but her reasons for doing so were personal and had nothing to do with the greater good. That is, until she realised all the good she could do.

Using the costume as the final rite of passage to becoming her own hero was a clever device that certainly made up for not seeing it in the first episode, and it was almost fitting that she donned it when she finally figured out what she wanted to be. And the sight of her standing there in that suit, atop that building as she looked down over her city was nothing short of magnificent.

The Batwoman that we know and love has finally been born, and this writer is looking forward to seeing where Kate Kane's journey takes her next - and wherever that may be, she's going to look incredibly badass going there.

-

What did you make of 'Down, Down, Down'? Tell us in the comment section below.


You'll Never Get 100% On This Arrowverse Quiz

Arrow Oliver Queen
The CW

1. According To The Reverse-Flash, What Age Does Oliver Queen Live To Be?

Contributor
Contributor

Michael Patterson is an experienced writer with an affinity for all things film and TV. He may or may not have spent his childhood obsessing over WWE.