Black Mirror: Every Major Plot Twist Ranked From Worst To Best
Will this list have a twist ending?
In the grand tradition of The Twilight Zone and other classic anthology TV shows, Black Mirror is famous for its mind-blowing twists. That the series has become so synonymous with these surprising moments is a little unfair, as nearly all its episodes have a lot else going for them. But, hey, audiences love a good shock as that tends to be the thing that most sticks in your mind.
And Black Mirror has had some doozies over its four seasons so far. Due to its trademark gleefully bleak tone, the best of these reveals land like a gut punch, turning the whole episode on its head or adding a little extra spice to the story by leaving us with a big question mark or wider issue to ponder.
From "it was all a nightmare!" to "he's really dead!", Black Mirror has served up a whole range of twists, nearly all of which have left us with our jaws scraping the ground. But not all of them can be the best. In fact, some top-draw episodes of the show haven't featured particularly memorable last-minute reveals, while lesser episodes have. Let's see if there's a twist in the tale as we rank them from worst to greatest.
19. Lacey Finds Peace In Prison - Nosedive
Nosedive is a fantastic episode from writers Rashida Jones and Michael Schur, sporting a terrific performance from Bryce Dallas Howard. The thing is that its "twist", if you can call it that, is just more like a natural progression of how Lacey's life is torn asunder over the course of the episode.
After trying so hard to achieve that coveted four-and-a-half star rating, Lacey's meltdown at Naomi's wedding leaves her in jail. As she mouths off a stream of obscenities at her cellmate, it becomes clear that she is finally free of the fake world outside.
18. Liam's Fears Aren't Unfounded - The Entire History Of You
On a similar note, The Entire History of You is another great episode, from Peep Show's Jesse Armstrong this time. It focuses on how Liam (Toby Kebbell) and Ffion's relationship is destroyed by Liam's obsession with using his memory implant to decide whether Ffion (new Doctor Who Jodie Whittaker) is cheating on him.
The revelation that Ffion not only did cheat on him but that their daughter is also not his is another twist that is more of a natural progression of the "be careful what you wish for" nature of the plot, rather than a slap to the face that comes out of a left field.
17. Sara Beats Her Mother, Runs Away - Arkangel
Mother Marie (Rosemarie DeWitt) tries to control her daughter Sara's life too much in Arkangel, leading to her to intervene and scare her boyfriend away when she discovers Sara is engaging in underage sex and experimenting with cocaine.
While these actions were relatively understandable, Marie goes too far when she slips Sara a pregnancy terminating drug without her knowing. This pushes Sara over the edge. She bludgeons her mother in the face and then runs away from home.
It's a cruel development for a mother who was only ever trying to keep her daughter close to her but, again, it's not one of Black Mirror's biggest jaw-dropping moments.
16. It Was All For A Teddy Bear - Metalhead
Metalhead is unusual for Black Mirror in that it is a simple - but relentlessly grim - tale of survival which sees Bella (Maxine Peake) attempt to escape a killer robot dog in an unexplained post-apocalyptic wasteland. We know that she is trying to get something back to her sister's young son, Jack, who likely only has a few days to live.
After the episode leaves Bella to her doom, the camera pans back to the warehouse where Bella first gained the attention of the dog. It is revealed that she risked her life, and ultimately lost it, in the hunt for a teddy bear to replace the one Jack had presumably lost.
It's a moving moment of tenderness in an otherwise dark episode.
15. Bing Sells Out - Fifteen Million Merits
In Fifteen Million Merits, Bing (Oscar-nominated Daniel Kaluuya) spends all his cash on getting girlfriend Abi into talent show Hot Shots. When the cruel programme turns her into a porn star, Bing auditions himself, delivering an angry tirade against the system while threatening to kill himself.
In a slight jump to the future, it is revealed that Bing accepted an offer from the Hot Shot judges to host his own show where he can spout his (now toothless) rants.
This is one of the more ironic twists in Black Mirror's catalogue, as Bing began with the aim to bring down the system but ends up selling out in order and becoming a part of it.
14. Android Ash Lives In The Attic - Be Right Back
Hayley Atwell and Domhnall Gleeson star in Be Right Back as Martha and her late husband Ash, a chilling tale about what could happen if technology could recreate the dead. Eventually, Martha is so freaked out by the android replica of Ash that she orders him to jump off a cliff. However, there is enough of the real Ash in there to make her hesitate.
We fast forward a few years to discover that Martha has locked Ash away in the attic, with her daughter able to visit her "dad" on weekends. It's a creepy development - that kid is going to have serious issues when she grows up.
13. The Callister Crew Make It Out Alive - U.S.S. Callister
U.S.S. Callister plays with the usual Black Mirror format in many ways. Chiefly, you could say its big twist occurs only 15 minutes in, as the Kirk-like Captain Daly is revealed to be the villain of the piece. It's eventual final development, then, isn't so much of a rug pull but still comes as a surprise: the crew of the Callister make it out alive!
Throughout the episode, the crew believe the only way out of their 60s sci-fi hell is by flying into a wormhole and killing themselves. However, they actually manage to make it out of Daly's pocket universe intact and are free to explore the Infinity virtual reality. Cue the call for a spin-off.
12. Shazia's Son Was Blind... But The Guinea Pig Remembers - Crocodile
In season 4's Crocodile - or, as I like to call it, Black Mirror Knows What You Did Last Summer - Mia (Andrea Riseborough) will do anything to keep the dark secrets of her past in the closet.
Due to an insurance company that uses memory-viewing technology prying into her business, Mia ends up on a killing spree. In one of the show's darkest moments, Mia is forced to kill a toddler, thinking the boy's memories could be used against her.
The tragedy is that it's later revealed that the boy was blind, therefore he did not see her. However, Mia will still be found out as someone else witnessed the murder: the boy's pet guinea pig.
11. Nish Gets Revenge On Rolo Haynes - The Black Museum
The Black Museum is perhaps the most significant episode for Black Mirror's wider mythology as it introduces the man responsible for a lot of the twisted tech in the show: sadistic museum curator Rolo Haynes (Douglas Hodge). It's only fitting, then, that he gets a suitably grim ending.
Customer Nish (Letitia Wright) turns out to be the daughter of the prisoner Rolo manipulated and abused. In order to get revenge for her family, she kills Rolo and traps his A.I. copy in a permanent state of pain.
It's a skin-crawling twist but it has to come on the lower portion of this ranking as it is a little too familiar to the ending of a prior episode...
10. The Cabin Is An Artificial Reality, Joe Is Trapped Forever - White Christmas
White Christmas was the first extra-long episode of Black Mirror. A festive special, it was made up of three technological tales of terror connected by Jon Hamm and Rafe Spall telling stories in a wintery cabin.
The end of the episode revealed that the cabin was in fact an artificial reality taking place in a "cookie", a device used to hold a digital copy of a person. Matt (Hamm) was interviewing Spall's character Joe on behalf of the police, in order to get him to confess to a murder. As an extra bit of punishment, A.I. Joe is left trapped in the cookie, with "I Wish It Could Be Christmas Every Day" playing forever.
Happy Xmas, everyone!
9. Social Media Users Are The Real Targets - Hated In The Nation
Hated In The Nation plays with the idea of social media hate figures. When unpopular celebrities are being killed off, the #DeathTo hashtag starts trending with people naming the famous people they most want to die.
It turns out that the celebrities aren't the real target of the killer, but the social media users who are promoting the tag. It's all an exercise in teaching people the dangers of spreading hate on the internet while hiding behind online anonymity. What's more, the plan actually works and nearly 400,000 are killed by the murderous bee-like drones.
Similar to The National Anthem (more on that later), it's another shocking twist with a sociological message. But this one has that extra gut-punch of featuring mass murder on a huge scale.
8. The Roaches Are People, Stripe Chooses To Forget - Men Against Fire
At first, Men Against Fire seemed like a largely straight-laced zombie story, featuring a US military task force fighting the undead, dubbed "roaches", in some European country.
However, it was later revealed that these roaches were actually plain old people. In a bid to control overpopulation, the army has been fitted with reality-augmenting implants that translate the "excess" members of society into vicious monsters.
An extra added twist reveals that protagonist Stripe (Malachi Kirby) has chosen to have his memory of the truth wiped from his mind. He goes back home to an imaginary beautiful wife and lives out a lonely, fake life.
7. Waldo Is The Face Of A Dystopian Police State - The Waldo Moment
The Waldo Moment is probably one of the weaker Black Mirrors, but its final scene just gets more chilling with time - it's almost like a parody of the world in 2018.
Against all the odds, a joke candidate in a political election - a foul-mouthed CGI bear called Waldo - actually gains popularity with the anti-political crowd for his unconventional opinions. Though his creator ditches the campaign, it later turns out that this doesn't stop Waldo. In a flashforward, it appears that Waldo becomes the face of a dystopian nightmare of a world.
Give Waldo a fluffy blonde wig and the whole thing looks scarily familiar...
6. Cooper's Phone Killed Him - Playtest
Playtest isn't one of the absolute strongest Black Mirrors ever, as it's a bit too reliant on its twists. For the purposes of this article, though, it ranks highly due to its literally killer final reveal.
After a myriad of "is this real? No, it's not!" rug-pull moments, it is at last revealed that pretty much the whole episode has been a VR experience. The reason it was so trippy is because Cooper (Wyatt Russell) had left his phone switched on, meaning that the signals had messed with the tech, killing him.
This is a fiendish twist as it evokes that old warning that none of us actually pay attention to. Remember, turn your phone off when you're told to, guys. It really could save your life.
5. It's (Kind Of) A Happy Ending! - San Junipero
Within the narrative of Sun Junipero itself, there isn't a particularly massive twist to speak of. However, in the wider context of Black Mirror as a series, it has one of the most shocking developments of the lot: it actually ends on a mostly hopeful note!
Obviously, Yorkie and Kelly both die at the end of the episode, which isn't exactly happy. However, the elderly couple gets to be young again and be together forever thanks to the virtual reality afterlife of San Junipero. It's a beautiful ending and is guaranteed to reduce you to tears. Hands up who else can't make it through "Heaven Is A Place On Earth" without blubbing now?
4. Frank And Amy Are Dating App Simulations - Hang The DJ
Following on from season 3's San Junipero, season 4's Hang The DJ gave us another surprisingly sweet and optimistic love story.
The twist here was that the couple we had followed throughout the hour - Joe Cole's Frank and Georgina Campbell's Amy - were actually just one of 1000 simulations run by a high-tech dating app that works out how well-matched you and your date are.
Outside the app, the real Frank and Amy are about to embark on their first date, but we the audience know how perfect they are for each other. For once, we end a Black Mirror episode with a smile.
3. The Princess Was Already Released - The National Anthem
Black Mirror's pilot episode was also its grossest. With the royal princess kidnapped, the Prime Minister (Rory Kinnear) is forced to have sex with a pig on live television.
The whole of the nation is glued to their screens through the horrid event... Meaning that no one is around to see the princess released BEFORE the sex act is committed. The kidnapper was actually a twisted artist who wanted to perform a social experiment to prove society's obsession with the media.
The National Anthem isn't the show's subtlest episode but this twist is still one of the cruelest Charlie Brooker and his team have ever pulled off.
2. It's All A Show, Victoria Is A Child Killer - White Bear
In White Bear, a woman apparently wakes up in a world where most people have become mindless voyeurs, viewing everything on their phones, due to a digital signal. The rest of the population have gone insane, turning into vicious, masked killers.
At the end of the episode, though, it turns out this is all an elaborate performance. This is the White Bear Justice Park, an instillation where people can watch and engage with the punishment of Victoria Skillane (Lenora Crichlow), a woman convicted of child murder. Her memory is wiped and she experiences the same ordeal every day.
It's a twist that leaves you with a bunch of moral quandaries to ponder and just an all-round bad taste in your mouth.
1. The Truth About Kenny Is Revealed - Shut Up And Dance
Throughout Shut Up And Dance, we sympathise with teenager Kenny (Alex Lawther) as he is forced to do the bidding of his mysterious blackmailers who claim they will release a video of him masturbating if he doesn't comply.
At the end of the episode, it becomes clear why Kenny is so keen to do as they say - even going so far as to beat another man to death - when the type of pornography he was looking at is revealed: he's a paedophile.
It's very reminiscent of the twist from White Bear, but it gets a higher ranking as it's even more of a sickening rug-pull moment, with the reveal happening subtly but also suddenly. In short, it's a masterclass in manipulating the audience's emotions.
What do you think is Black Mirror's best twist? Let us know down in the comments.