Black Mirror: Ranking Every Episode From Worst To Best

By which we really mean "great" to "stupendously great".

Black Mirror Season 3 Nosedive Bryce Dallas Howard 1
Netflix

Since its debut in 2011, sci-fi anthology series Black Mirror has grown from a minor cult favourite into one of the most critically-lauded shows around at the moment. Creator Charlie Brooker’s collection of nightmarish visions of the not-so-distant future could have been a po-faced, one-note series about the dangers of technology, but actually it is a lot smarter than that. Despite how it is often described, the show shines a light on our own flaws and mistakes, rather than those of the tech we create. It is humanity who is the villain in these tales, not corrupted robots or evil A.I.

With its move to Netflix for its third season, Black Mirror is now bigger than ever – with an inflated budget and all-cast guest cast. The change also seemed to free up Brooker and his team, as season three offered a lot more variation in tone and content than previous years. It could have warped the show out of recognition, but in the event the wider canvas was entirely welcome and probably necessary for its longevity.

So how did the recent batch of six episodes compare to the seven produced by original broadcaster Channel 4? Here’s our ranking of all 13 episodes of the anthology show from worst to best. By which we really mean from amazing to stupendously amazing.

13. The Waldo Moment

Black Mirror Waldo
Channel 4

In The Waldo Moment, a foul-mouthed animated comedy bear becomes such a figurehead against politics that his creator ends up being forced to make the character run for government.

When ranking the Black Mirror episodes, there is one outlier that has to come at the bottom. To be clear, it is not that The Waldo Moment is a poor hour of television. Far from it, like every instalment of the show, it has some worthy things to say – such as the dangers of running against the system so much that you become part of it.

The problem is that its wit just isn’t as sharp as other episodes, though that might be more the fault of the target rather than the material. Perhaps it's too difficult to successfully satirise politics nowadays because the current landscape is so ridiculous as it is?


12. Playtest

Black Mirror Palytest
Netflix

Playtest - directed by 10 Cloverfield Lane's Dan Trachtenberg – sees an American tourist volunteer for a state-of-the-art video game experience. One which reaches into his head and brings his deepest fears to life…

Unique for Black Mirror, this one is a straight-up horror – full of jump scares and psychological frights, it’s even partially set in a haunted house. With such a capable director on board, it naturally soars in this area, but Brooker's script is also excellent at keeping the viewer on the edge of their seats. It's not perfect, though, as the episode gets so caught up with peeling back the different layers of reality and pulling the rug from under the audience that it eventually sacrifices drama for shocks.

Even so, Playtest remains a deeply unsettling warning about the risks of giving over our senses to the virtual world.


11. Shut Up And Dance

Black Mirror Shut Up And Dance
Netflix

Shut Up And Dance poses a terrifying question: what if a malicious group hacked your laptop's webcam and used what they filmed to blackmail you into doing their bidding? That's the situation young Kenny faces when he accidentally downloads some extra-nasty malware.

This power of this episode comes from its fantastic central idea that reminds us of a very chilling point. We practically share everything about ourselves with our personal computers these days and we could well be in a vulnerable position if they were ever used against us.

The final pair of twists are also superb, completing shifting our perception of the episode’s events. This one only doesn’t come any higher in the ranking because its format is very reminiscent of a previous episode (I won’t mention which one for fear of spoilers).


10. White Bear

Black Mirror White Bear
Netflix

In White Bear, a woman with memory loss wakes up in a world where the majority of the population have apparently been turned into 'phone zombies' by an unknown signal. Most of those who are immune are just trying to survive, but others have become sadistic "hunters."

As a satire on how we watch the world through the lens of our phones nowadays, this episode is spot on. The everyday sight of someone filming on their phone becomes something as scary as the creepy hunters, with their faces hidden under weird animal masks.

Once we find out the truth of the situation, though, the episodes takes an even nastier turn, as it morphs into a knotty argument about corporal punishment and the public thirst for retribution. Overall, it’s a haunting, thought-provoking installment that leaves it ambiguous whose side you should be on.


9. White Christmas

Black Mirror Head Up Display
Channel 4

Black Mirror isn’t the first show that jumps to mind as a good fit for Christmastime, but nonetheless along came White Christmas – a feature-length portmanteau chiller containing three interlinked narratives each concerned with a sickening use of some new piece of tech.

Black Mirror: The Movie is a brilliant idea, although it has to be said that the vignettes vary in quality. The best is the final segment, which imagines a world where you can 'block' people in reality, instead of only on social media. It also features the show's first big American guest star in Mad Men's John Hamm, who is great value as someone with even fewer morals than Don Draper.

A cruel-hearted yet tongue-in-cheek subversion of what we expect from yuletide entertainment, there is little doubt that White Christmas is the bleakest Christmas special you will ever watch.


8. The Entire History Of You

Black Mirror Entire History
Channel 4

How would your life be affected if you had an implant that turned your head into an Ipod, saving your memories into easily-accessible files to play back later? That’s the question The Entire History of You poses.

Because this is Black Mirror, this episode takes this potentially helpful invention and demonstrates how it could totally wreck your life – as it follows protagonist Liam becoming so obsessed with the past that he forgets to live in the now.

Written by Peep Show creator Jesse Armstrong, what's interesting about this one is that it focusses on personal relationships over the more sociological edge of other episodes. If you would like to see the premise explored in a fuller way, you’re in luck – none other than Robert Downey Jr. has bought the rights to make a movie version.


7. The National Anthem

Black Mirror Pig PM
Netflix

The first ever Black Mirror episode made it clear from the off that this was a show unlike any other on TV. The National Anthem plays out like a serious political thriller, as the Prime Minister and his cabinet is forced to deal with a terrorist who has kidnapped the princess and is making an extreme demand. The trademark Black Mirror twist is that this demand is totally ridiculous - he says that he will kill her unless the PM has sex with a pig on live television.

The genius of this one is how Brooker manages to take this crass idea and play it completely straight. Just like the general public in the episode, we are glued to the screen as the incredibly tense, sickening and weirdly believable tale unfolds.

Of course, this episode is also notable for possibly getting closer to the truth than we realised at the time. But let's not get into that now...


6. Men Against Fire

Black Mirror San Junipero
Netflix

In a post-apocalyptic world, the American military is on a mission to wipe out "roaches" - ravenous zombie types. But when one soldier is struck with a strange light, he begins to see the world very differently.

It is surprising it took until season three for Black Mirror to tackle proper zombies, but this very original take on the genre made it worth the wait. Men Against Fire cleverly uses the tropes of zombie fiction to lull us into one perception of events before turning things completely on their head in its second half.

By the end, it has transformed from a familiar runaround of a well-worn genre into a condemnation of war and a thoroughly repulsive look at - and warning against - humanity's inherent xenophobic tendencies. A very timely message, considering all that's going on in the world.


5. Hated In The Nation

Black MIrror Hated In The Nation
Netflix

When internet hate figures start dying mysteriously, two detectives discover that there is a killer on the loose who chooses his victims by hashtag. But what is the connection to the nanodrones that have replaced the now-extinct bees?

The show’s second feature-length episode after White Christmas is a fantastic exploration of the hyperbolic, hateful things people spout on social media, all wrapped up in a tense crime drama flecked with moments from a Hitchcock horror/thriller. It's a potent blend that makes for a standout episode.

In particular, Black Mirror as a police procedural could have been a dud idea, but actually works a treat. Kelly Macdonald and Game of Thrones’ Faye Marsay rub together well as a hard-nosed detective and her gifted protégé. Any chance of a sci-fi crime drama spin-off for these two?


4. Be Right Back

Hayley Atwell Black Mirror
Channel Four

Agent Carter's Hayley Atwell and The Force Awakens' Domhall Gleeson give terrific performances in this disturbing meditation on grief that is one of the most mature episodes the show has yet produced. This could well be because it focusses on a very human and personal scenario rather than a grand, world-changing idea.

After a woman loses her husband, she signs up to an experimental service that creates a CleverBot-type messenger service based on a deceased person's social media interactions. Effectively bringing him back from the dead.

There are further twists in this tale, but we'll only say that things get distinctly unsettling as the story takes a turn towards Frankenstein territory by way of the Uncanny Valley. We all would do anything to have our loved ones returned to us but, as this episode’s escalating plot eerily demonstrates, you can’t defy death.


3. Nosedive

Black Mirror Season 3 Nosedive Bryce Dallas Howard 2
Netflix

Nosedive features a world in which your social standing is entirely governed by the ratings out of five you get on social media - leading to everyone having to present plastic, identikit versions of themselves. The focus is on low four-pointer Lacie, who sees an opportunity to increase her rating (to get a swanky new apartment) when she is invited to a fancy wedding. Unfortunately, due to a series of events that become more and more excruciating to watch, things don’t go to plan.

With a distinctive pastel-coloured visual palette, courtesy of director Joe Wright (Atonement), and a tour de force performance from Jurassic World’s Bryce Dallas Howard, Nosedive is not indicative of its title but rather sees the show firing on all cylinders. By imagining a time where the fake fronts we use online have become our everyday faces, it’s arguably the most shudder-inducing version of the future that Black Mirror has created to date.


2. Fifteen Million Merits

Black Mirror Fifeteen Million Merits
Channel 4

In one of the more overtly sci-fi instalments of the show, Fifteen Million Merits offers a look at a future where the lower classes work on X-Box Kinect-esque treadmills to create power for the unseen elite... and the only way to a better life is by going on talent show Hot Shots.

We don’t find out the ins and outs of this world like some others, but in its place we get a touching love story between two workers which, in classic Black Mirror fashion, takes a heart-breakingly cruel turn.

The breadth of what's in the firing range in this episode is what makes it a classic – from manipulative media to the increased digitalisation of our everyday lives - but chiefly it's a scary examination of when reality shows rule the world. I say when because we can't be too far off. We've already got a reality show star running for president.


1. San Junipero

Black Mirror Season 3 San Junipero Gugu Mbatha Raw And Mackenzie Davis
Netflix

Season three's San Junipero has quickly risen up the ranks to become, for many, the finest Black Mirror episode yet. A big reason for that is its willingness to try something new.

In a first for the show, the episode is set in the 1980s, as it follows two very different women who fall in love in the last place they expected to find it. Of course, there is more to the tale than this, but uniquely San Junipero doesn’t use its twists to paint a crueller world. It actually becomes a powerful study on how love can outlast death. Yes, this is still Black Mirror we are talking about.

Featuring a succinctly-told yet heartfelt romance, this is one of the most beautiful and affirming episodes of television in a while. For once, Black Mirror shrugs off its trademark cynicism and says: hey, maybe the future is actually going to be a nice place to live after all?


In this post: 
Black Mirror
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Spewing words on the internet daily. You can also read my stuff at StarburstMagazine.Com, WeGotThisCovered and TheQuiz.Com.