Breaking Bad: 9 Poor Story Choices

Breaking Bad isn't the greatest show ever, even if many think it is.

Breaking Bad was unanimously praised by fans and critics alike for its take on the extent one man will go to in order to provide for his family upon hearing he has a death sentence looming over his head. The praise is mostly justified. But beneath the stunningly complex narrative there are scores of problems with this show. Breaking Bad vaulted Bryan Cranston and Aaron Paul to the top of their respective field, and rightfully so, but the praise laden upon the show that brought them together is unjust; it doesn't deserve its 9.5 score on IMDB. Breaking Bad is good, but it isn't flawless. Yes, Breaking Bad is amazing, and yes Ozymandias is one of the best episodes of television EVER. But some aspects of the show could and should have been reworked. The audience are expected to extend the realms of plausibility in order to accept the extent of Walter€™s descent into criminality which, whilst entirely possibly, isn't probably in the given timeframe. So whilst the majority of the story told is exceptional there are several threads which mean Breaking Bad isn't as amazing as the masses claim it to be. Click next to find out just why Breaking Bad isn€™t entirely brilliant.

9. Walter's Transformation Into Heisenberg Isn't Believable

Lets get the big one out of the way first. Walter White starts the show as a loving family man who receives a devastating diagnosis of lung cancer. So what does he do upon receiving this news? He hooks up with one of his former pupils to cook meth, of course. This isn€™t the unbelievable part, however, and nor is much of Walter€™s story. At a push his ruthless ways, his murdering and his lies can be accepted. But what simply cannot be accepted is the fact that Walter began cooking meth to secure the financial future of his wife and children, and in doing so completely alienates them come the shows climax. Even after Skyler gets in on the action, Walter transforms into someone who barely resembles the man he started out as. And yes, similar things have happened in real life. However the time frame of Breaking Bad means that Walter turns from school teacher and family man to a murderer and near child killer in a matter of months. Surely his desperation for money wouldn€™t allow him to alter so drastically in such a limited period of time? It€™s a transformation which wouldn't at all be possible and as such becomes hard to believe. Had the show's story occurred over several years then yes, it would have been entirely believable. But in the pilot Walter exhibits little confidence or determination; he would not be able to change that much that quickly. Even if his criminality can be accepted, the fact that he alienates his wife and children completely renders all of his crimes pointless. In the final episode he supposedly dies with Skylar and Walter Jr despising him and there is no guarantees that his money will reach them. Surely a better way to spend his final months would have been in the arms of his loving family rather than destroying them completely. However, that would have made for dreary TV. Walter exhibits zero dark or murderous tendencies in the show's pilot, but come the final episode his kill total stands at an impressive 187 and counting. That€™s a bit of a stretch, right?

8. Walter Could Have Got Out Of The Meth Business And Didn't

Even if you do accept Walter€™s transformation, he is given the perfect opportunity to get out of the meth cooking business and he doesn€™t take it. The final episode of season four sees Walt murdering Gustavo Fring. The collapse of Fring€™s drug empire would have given Walt the perfect way out. Nobody comes after him (after Mike€™s prison pals are murdered, that is) and forces him to cook again €“ he chooses to do so entirely of free will. His greed gets the better of him. Surely a better way forward would have been for him to team up with someone to kill Mike€™s comrades and then retire until the cancer finally took him? This way he would have been able to spend the time he had left with his family and the money he had already earned. Alas, no. Walter willingly chooses to go back into the meth cooking business. And for what? No real reason is given. The carnage enacted by his choice is titanic, resulting in the death of several dozen people and possibly himself. It also sees his brother-in-law Hank finally piece together that he is Heisenberg and the financial ruin of his family. In a list of worst decisions ever, this has to be the icing on the cake. Unfortunately it isn't his only one though.

7. Skyler Turns Criminal

Skyler starts the show as a loving mother (albeit with tendencies to smoke whilst pregnant) and yet come the third season she joins Walt in the criminal world. Quite why is hard to fathom. No true reason is given. She was devastated by Walt€™s reveal, and in later episodes showed extreme distress from simply being around Walter, and yet she willingly chose to go into business with Walter and lie to her family. In doing so both Walt and Skyler pretty much forget that they have a new born baby daughter. It€™s a problem that plagues many programmes when one of the core characters gives birth, but Skyler€™s forgetfulness is extremely noticeable. She€™s off sleeping with her former boss whilst Walt Jr. is at school €“ who the hell is caring for Holly? Even more unbelievable, season five shows Hank give Skyler the perfect opportunity to rid herself once and for all of Walt and still remain, in the eyes of the law, a free woman. But she doesn€™t take it. She sides once more with Walt and in doing so her future becomes extremely uncertain. You can only guess that Walt was incredible in bed. Quite why she returns to him time and time again is perhaps the biggest mystery Breaking Bad ever posed. And that is saying something.

6. Walter Jr. And Marie Don't Do Much At All

Marginalised from the onset, Walt Jr. and Marie don€™t do much. At all. Walt Jr. goes through a period in which he wants to be called Flynn (for some bizarre reason) and Marie steals and pretends to be buying a house (for some bizarre reason) but aside from that both of them don€™t do much. They are clearly there to provide tense family dinners but that is pretty much all they do. Maybe this is enough though - those dinners make exceptional TV. They do both get their time to shine in the final season however. Walt Jr. fends off a deranged Walt to protect his mother, and Marie cries painstakingly when Hank€™s death is confirmed, but in the grand scheme of things they won€™t go down as memorable characters. They were both pretty pointless.

5. Fring Outstays His Welcome

Gustavo Fring was a brilliant character played by Giancarlo Esposito with relish. He was twisted, creepy, and had an amazing death-stare. That said he long outstayed his welcome. He was extremely interesting in the third season and utilised effectively, even if not to his full extent. The fourth season however saw him become a formidable threat clearly overcompensating for something, and as such fans cried for his end to come. His meth empire spirals out of control and whilst Salud was a brilliant episode, it probably should have come earlier in the shows run. If he had died in season three, or even part way through season four, another big bad could have been introduced to force Walt into more cooking. Thus, Walt€™s choice to get out of the meth world wouldn€™t have been there at all, and it would have spared us one of the many problems of the show. Taking all of this into consideration Gustavo Fring was a memorable character but it goes for something when his mode of death is even more memorable than the character himself. No one will forget his half-destroyed face. It should have happened earlier though. A lot earlier.

4. No One Is Given A Decent Ending

Walt probably dies at the end of Breaking Bad, but he is the only character whose ultimate fate we are certain of (to an extent, at least). The rest €“ Jesse, Skyler, Walt Jr., Saul and Marie €“ can only be guessed at. The last we see of Jesse he is driving deranged from his incarceration; Skyler is last seen allowing Walt one final moment with Holly (because, you know, she actually remembered she had a daughter for once); Walt Jr. walks into the safe house; Saul goes into hiding; and Marie phones Skyler. It€™s likely that Skyler et al benefitted from the Schwartz €œtrust fund€ later in their life, but in the present the viewer€™s aren€™t given any form of satisfying resolution to their beloved characters. Better Call Saul, the spinoff from Breaking Bad scheduled to premiere next year, will feature a flexible timeline to show the past, present and future, so Saul€™s ultimate end will likely be detailed. The rest of the characters however have been confirmed to not appear, so it is up to the viewer€™s to decide on their own ending for these characters unfortunately. Most endings can be excused however. But Jesse€™s can€™t. He and Walter were the main characters of Breaking Bad and as such Jesse deserved a much better ending than he received. The viewers had invested so much time into his character and they were left with a terrible ending. Whilst most finales utilise a cheesy flashfoward, even just a throwaway line would have worked here.

3. Too Much Animosity Between Walter And Jesse

Throughout the course of Breaking Bad Walter became a surrogate father to Jesse due to Jesse€™s parent issues. He began the show in a position of authority - that of a teacher, and at one time Jesse€™s teacher - so it is entirely possible that he would adopt this role when his relationship with the much-younger Jesse blossomed. But unfortunately this relationship was frayed from the offset. This did make for some sensational episodes, but at times it did grow extremely weary - particularly in the third season. Walter and Jesse fell out in every other episode and often spent many scenes plotting to off the other one. Ultimately Walter needed Jesse, and vice versa. Regrettably neither character realised this. The viewers did though, which made their numerous arguments hard to stomach. There is only so many times you can sit through two characters hating on one another before the scenes grow tiresome. Many scenes simply rehashed what had come before. Even in the face of unanimous animosity from their foes Fring and Salamanca, Walter and Jesse failed to find common ground. Had the writers cut out their numerous fights you probably would have lost a third of the episodes however, so maybe it isn't a bad thing that they retained them after all€

2. Mike Dies

Mike Ehrmantraut was a beloved character with much promise. Sadly he wasn't utilised efficiently until the final season, and barely eight episodes later he had been murdered and dissolved. This, for many, was Walt€™s worst crime. Mike spoke with an honesty many failed to acquire in the world of Breaking Bad; he was stoically determined to flee the criminal world until Walt sucked him right back in. There is so much that Mike could have brought to the final bout of episodes, but sadly none of that came to fruition. That said, Mike€™s death was necessary. In killing Mike viewers finally began to realise how far Walt had come and it showed that there was no going back for him. This was the proverbial nail in his coffin. After Walt killed Mike, many stopped caring for Walt.

1. Todd And Lydia Bring Little To The Story

Following the deaths of Fring and Mike, the writers had to draft in a new threat for the final stroke of episodes. Step in Todd and Lydia, both of whom were terrible characters. Lydia grated the moment she appeared on screens. Todd meanwhile showed a little promise; his dark streak was teased for a few episodes until he brutally slaughtered a young boy. But after this streak of evil Todd failed to do anything at all. It is Todd€™s uncle Jack who poses a formidable threat. This begs the question why involve them at all? Admittedly Todd was required to bring in Jack, but Lydia was completely unnecessary. Her pandering to Walt was fruitful in the opening episodes because their plans were scuppered. Once Jack was introduced Todd and Lydia both should have been offed; this would have allowed the finale to spend more time with the characters viewers had come to know and love rather than dealing with the additions. What do you think of our list of Breaking Bad€™s flaws? Do you agree with them? Are there any we missed? Let us know in the comments below.

In this post: 
Breaking Bad
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

English Language and Literature graduate. Creative Writing student. Aspiring creative and professional writer.