Buffy The Vampire Slayer: 10 Great Moments In Mediocre Episodes

Even the weakest episodes of Buffy the Vampire Slayer feature some terrific moments...

Buffy the Vampire Slayer Gingerbread
Mutant Enemy

Despite its humble beginnings, Buffy the Vampire Slayer grew into a cultural phenomenon with seven seasons and more than 100 episodes. Most of the time, the show excels thanks to the sharp writing, the strong performances, and the unique tone of the story.

But like many iconic television shows, Buffy the Vampire Slayer is far from perfect. Every season has several mediocre episodes that suffer from a weak premise, pacing issues, forgettable villains, or even a combination of all three. Whilst such episodes aren’t flat-out terrible, they often leave us feeling disappointed.

Yet it’s all too easy to dismiss these disappointing episodes and overlook the positives they have to offer. Most of Buffy’s weakest adventures contain at least a couple of great moments, ranging from heartfelt, emotional exchanges to unexpected twists. There are also some light-hearted moments that elevate an otherwise forgettable episode with some well-placed humour.

These great moments are a testament to the quality of Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Even when the show is at a bit of a low point, it still manages to impress us with some exceptional storytelling.

10. Buffy And Faith Get To Know Each Other (Season 3, Episode 4)

Buffy Faith
Mutant Enemy

Season 3 is the most consistent season of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, but it still has a couple of rough patches. The fourth episode – though far from terrible – is let down by a dumb villain and a couple of vanilla romance scenes between Buffy and her new boyfriend Scott.

But towards the start of the episode, we do get a nice exchange between Buffy and Faith. Despite their disagreements in the previous episode, the two of them bond over a humorous conversation about man’s internal nature.

The conversation also highlights a key difference between the two Slayers. Faith, who’s had a much more difficult upbringing, has a cynical view of men, describing them as “beasts”. Buffy, on the other hand, is more optimistic about her new relationship.

As well as being a neat segue into the main theme of the episode, this conversation is a snapshot of Buffy and Faith’s contrasting personalities. Beneath the friendly banter, these young ladies hold conflicting values about love, pleasure, and human nature.


9. Buffy Drinks Kathy’s Milk (Season 4, Episode 2)

Buffy Drinks Milk Gif
20th Century Fox

Season 4 struggles to get off the ground to begin with. The first two episodes are a bit disappointing, particularly after the epic finale of Season 3. Thankfully, the second episode does contain some great splashes of humour here and there.

Buffy’s roommate Kathy proves to be an insufferable nuisance. She’s obsessed with rules and has a passive-aggressive personality that drives Buffy mad. As time goes on, their feelings of mutual hatred intensify, and Buffy decides to put her foot down… by drinking Kathy’s milk.

It’s an over-the-top moment, but it works within the context of the episode. Buffy’s moral compass – which is normally impenetrable – snaps in a matter of seconds. The comical score makes Buffy’s decision even more hilarious, and Kathy’s look of bewilderment is a great touch, too.

Whilst there are plenty of other funny moments in this episode – the ketchup splatter in the canteen is also a standout – the milk carton scene is the best of the lot.


8. Xander Comforts Dawn (Season 7, Episode 12)

The Potential Slayers are one of the weakest aspects of Season 7. We never get to know any of them properly, and they don’t add much value until the final battle. Episode 12 is no exception. Despite spending some extra time with the Potentials, none of them are particularly likeable when compared with the old friends.

But this episode isn’t totally without merit. The final scene features a great exchange between Xander and Dawn. The two of them have a heartfelt conversation about their lack of supernatural abilities, and Xander delivers some deep words of wisdom:

“They’ll never know how tough it is, Dawnie. To be the one who isn’t chosen. To live so near to the spotlight and never step in it. But I know. I see more than anybody realises because nobody’s watching me… You’re not special. You’re extraordinary.”

Both Nicholas Brendon and Michelle Trachtenberg are fantastic in this scene, balancing stoic maturity with emotional vulnerability. It’s a shame the rest of the episode is so flat, but this final scene is one of the best moments in the final season.


7. Buffy Gets Revenge On Parker (Season 4, Episode 5)

Due to Angel’s departure at the end of Season 3, Buffy arrives at college as a young singleton. In Episode 2, she encounters a handsome student named Parker Abrams, and they hook up in the next episode.

But Buffy soon realises that Parker has no interest in a long-term relationship. It’s an awkward state of affairs: Buffy feels she’s been misled, while Parker argues that he did nothing wrong. Then, in Episode 5, Buffy’s boozy night out has supernatural consequences, turning her into a human primate with basic communication skills. There are some funny moments here, but ‘Beer Bad’ is a pretty poor effort overall.

However, at least it ends on a high. When Parker asks Buffy for forgiveness, she responds by whacking him across the head with a club, knocking him out in the process. Whilst this isn’t enough to salvage the episode, it’s still a great moment that’s both amusing and satisfying.


6. The Parents Burn The Witches (Season 3, Episode 11)

Buffy the Vampire Slayer Gingerbread
Mutant Enemy

‘Gingerbread’ is an odd little episode. Stuck in the middle of a terrific season, this strange adventure centres around a demon who takes the form of two children and persuades the parents of Sunnydale to execute those with supernatural powers.

It’s a fun yet dispensable episode that peaks in the final act. Having captured Buffy, Willow, and Amy, Joyce and the other parents attempt to kill their captives by burning them alive. In response, Amy accidentally turns herself into a rat, while Xander and Oz attempt to infiltrate the room by crawling through a ventilation shaft. Giles and Cordelia, on the other hand, bicker away and attempt to save the girls with a German incantation.

The reason this ludicrous finale works so well is that it fully embraces the silly factor, and this is the perfect way to end what is essentially a filler episode. Even the final takedown – which involves Buffy plunging a giant stake through the demon’s throat – is wonderfully ridiculous.


5. Buffy Counsels The Students (Season 7, Episode 4)

Buffy the vampire slayer
Warner Bros.

At the beginning of Season 7, Buffy gets a new job as a School Counsellor at Sunnydale High, and we see her in action at the start of Episode 4.

What’s cool about this scene is that it’s a nice call-back to the earlier seasons. But rather than being a struggling student, Buffy is the one who’s in a position of authority. There’s also a nice balance of drama and humour. Whilst some of the students are seeking genuine advice, others have alternative motives – one boy even asks Buffy out on a date.

Yet the most memorable student is definitely Cassie, who tells Buffy that she’s going to die next Friday. It’s a fascinating conversation and a great hook into the rest of the story. Buffy’s concern is juxtaposed with Cassie’s relaxed attitude, making their exchange even more intriguing.

Though the remainder of the episode is fairly dispensable, this particular scene has a lot going for it. It balances drama with humour and demonstrates how much Buffy has changed since the first season.


4. Buffy Moves On From Spike (Season 6, Episode 15)

In the middle of Season 6, Buffy enters a self-destructive relationship with Spike that persists for several episodes. Crushed by the weight of depression, this toxic romance gives Buffy an escape from her troubled situation.

At the end of Episode 15, she confronts Spike and tells him their relationship can no longer continue:

“I do want you. Being with you makes things simpler… for a little while. I’m using you. I can’t love you. I’m just being weak and selfish, and it’s killing me. I have to be strong about this. I’m sorry, William.”

The use of Spike’s real name makes this closing statement particularly effective. By doing so, Buffy strips Spike of his bravado, viewing him as a man rather than a piece of meat. As for Spike himself, he’s clearly upset by Buffy’s words, yet he makes no attempt to stop her when she walks away – he simply accepts his fate.

It’s a terrific piece of dialogue that’s way more interesting than Riley’s return to Sunnydale. If it wasn’t for this final scene, there would be nothing in this episode worth watching.


3. Xander And Willow Have A Cute Conversation (Season 2, Episode 1)

The opening episode of Season 2 is a decent but dispensable episode that focuses on Buffy’s return to Sunnydale after the summer break. Whilst there is a cool fight sequence at the end, the best part of the episode is definitely the first scene.

Willow and Xander are enjoying a midnight stroll and are entertaining themselves by quoting lines from classic movies. Their friendly conversation soon takes on a romantic flavour when Xander teases Willow by bobbing the end of her nose with his ice cream. This is adorable enough, but the scene continues to up the cuteness when Xander wipes Willow’s nose and then leans in for a kiss.

Of course – being in the middle of Sunnydale – the two of them are interrupted by a vampire, and Buffy has to come to the rescue. But for a brief moment, Willow and Xander had the whole audience on tenterhooks as their true feelings blossomed before our eyes.


2. Spike Tells Buffy He Has A Soul (Season 7, Episode 2)

Spike Buffy
Mutant Enemy

Spike’s romantic involvement with Buffy ends in the worst possible way. So, at the end of Season 6, the blond-haired vampire leaves Sunnydale and takes on the Demon Trials in order to regain his soul.

He then returns to Sunnydale at the start of the next season as a new – and slightly unhinged – man. Buffy can hardly fail to notice this change, and Spike finally comes clean at the end of Episode 2:

“Angel, he should've warned me. He makes a good show of forgetting. But it's here. In me. All the time. The spark. I wanted to give you what you deserve, and I got it. They put the spark in me and now all it does is burn.”

Spike continues his monologue as Buffy looks on and accepts the truth. It’s an emotional sequence that benefits from two great performances and a haunting score to go along with it.

The rest of the episode – which centres around an underground monster called a Sluggoth Demon – is pretty dispensable. But it's worth sticking around till the end thanks to this brilliant closing scene.


1. Giles Sings Behind Blue Eyes (Season 4, Episode 18)

‘Where the Wild Things Are’ is one of the low points of Season 4. Buffy and Riley’s enthusiastic sex life somehow triggers a supernatural event, which causes huge vines to spread throughout the house. It’s a ludicrous premise, but the episode is redeemed by one outstanding scene.

Keen to find help, Willow, Tara, Xander, and Anya go looking for Giles, and they find him at Espresso Pump performing a cover of ‘Behind Blue Eyes’ by The Who.

The reactions from the other characters are just perfect. Xander’s look of mild horror clashes with the ladies’ stares of admiration. Willow – after gaping open-mouthed for several seconds – admits that she used to have a crush on Giles, making Xander even more uncomfortable.

As well as providing the audience with plenty of humour, this scene also presents the Watcher in a new light. Even though Giles has been a primary character since the very first episode, it’s the first time we get to experience his musical talents.

Though this scene is packaged within a lacklustre episode, it’s still one of the best moments of Season 4.


Harry Potter Or Buffy The Vampire Slayer Quiz: Who Said It – Ron Weasley Or Xander Harris?

Ron Weasley Smile Harry Potter And The Philosophers Stone
Warner Bros.

1. “I Wasn't Looking At Its Feet. I Was A Bit Preoccupied With Its Heads."

Contributor

Love to read and write. Have an unhealthy obsession with Harry Potter. Enjoy running up hills.