Buffy The Vampire Slayer: Every Season 1 Episode Ranked
Buffy's debut is nostalgic supernatural fun with heaps of heart and plenty of cheese.
When it debuted in 1997, Buffy the Vampire Slayer shook the world. Leaning it genre clichés whilst simultaneously turning them on their head, it was a teen supernatural drama made with the intention of improving on the terrible cult movie that spawned it five years earlier.
Bringing in a cast of unknowns to play awkward high school students, mysterious teachers, vampires and the like, it proved from its debut to be a story as focussed on mythology and pop culture as it was on the real-life drama of the complex characters at its core.
Violent, cheesy and altogether exciting, Buffy's first season hasn't aged particularly well, but what it lacks in timeless effects and heavy-handed themes it more than makes up for with its compelling characters, action sequences, and equally sweet, harrowing and relatable coming-of-age twists.
Next year, the show's debut season will be celebrating its 25th anniversary, and to celebrate we're going to take a trip down memory lane and remember the highs and lows of its iconic first chapter. With that in mind, here are all 12 episodes from Buffy the Vampire Slayer's debut season ranked worst to best. Major spoilers follow.
12. The Pack
Like many great shows, Buffy struggled to find its voice through large portions of its first season, and The Pack represents the worst of what its early years had to offer.
Strange even by the show's standards, the episode follows Xander and the high school's resident bullies as they're possessed by a hyena spirit and begin acting out around town. The results make it a poor attempt at moody drama that comes off as both cringe-inducing and ill-conceived.
Though clearly aiming for something deep and meaningful to say about teenage hormones, The Pack misses every mark it attempts to aim for, but at least killed off Principal Flutie so Snyder could come in and steal the show with his stone-faced cynicism later in the season.
11. Teacher's Pet
Buffy's debut season is almost entirely made up of monster-of-the-week adventures, and they range from biblically awful to trailblazing and brilliant. It's safe to say that Teacher's Pet sits firmly in the former category.
Concerned with a teacher who all the boys fall for before she's revealed to be a giant praying mantis, the episode wanders through a myriad of tacky sex jokes before assaulting audiences with shoddy practical effects and heavy-handed statements about hormonal teenagers.
Struggling to find a balance between its bonkers premise and the finale's attempts at monster horror, Teacher's Pet makes for a good laugh for all the wrong reasons, and serves as a perfect reminder of how uncertain Buffy often was in its infancy.
10. I, Robot... You, Jane
If you ever want to be reminded of how old Buffy the Vampire Slayer is, just check out I, Robot... You, Jane, which follows Willow as she quickly falls for an unknown admirer over the Internet before learning he's a demon.
Watching the episode now is actually quite hilarious, what with its incredibly dated musings about stranger danger and catfishing, as well as its tragically dull rug pull. It's awkward and means well, but I imagine it felt dated even when it aired.
That aside, it's really not all bad, since it introduces Jenny Calendar and teases a relationship between her and Giles, it's just that this bright spot is massively over-shadowed by the episode's silly premise and poor attempts at playing things with a straight face.
9. The Puppet Show
The Puppet Show is another of Buffy's early monster-of-the-week titles that finds the series grappling with an identity crisis. Whether it's meant to be funny, scary, or oddly tragic is never entirely clear, but it's hard to argue with the episode's memorability.
Taking place during the school's talent show, the episode tracks the gang as they hunt for a deadly demon, only to inadvertently team-up with an animated puppet that's possessed by the soul of a vengeful demon hunter.
The initial mystery of who or what the demon is entertaining and actually quite tense, but once the puppet reveal is finished the episode loses all sense of its own tone or meaning. It's silly and knows it, offering up some brief laughs, but overall The Puppet Show is still far too odd for its own good.
8. Out Of Mind, Out Of Sight
The season's penultimate episode, Out of Mind, Out of Sight is far from subtle, but still paints a striking and unique portrait of what it's like to be the victim of a bully.
The episode follows Marcie, a neglected student who's so ignored by her teachers and classmates that she literally turns invisible. She then uses her new condition to torment resident mean girl Cordelia, and toe the line between victim and antagonist whilst Buffy and the gang hunt her down.
Out of Mind, Out of Sight makes from an interesting use of classic high school tropes, and the central mystery of Marcie's existence is both intriguing and tense, though it's letdown by one twist too many when she's weirdly taken in by the CIA to become an unseen assassin.
7. Witch
Buffy the Vampire Slayer's third episode Witch set the blueprint for every subsequent monster-of-the-week episode the series tackled, introducing a supernatural mystery to the gang before deceiving them with red herrings and deliciously dark twists.
Witch is one of the show's most iconic episodes, following an aspiring cheerleader who Buffy learns is much more than meets the eye. It features one of the series' best and darkest bolts from the blue.
As a standalone thriller, Witch is far from Buffy's best, but with its daring story and lofty themes of acceptance, it more than holds up, and better still it introduces a few big characters and recurring plotlines that would soon become integral to the rest of the show.
6. Never Kill A Boy On The First Date
One of the show's most underappreciated gems, Never Kill A Boy on the First Date introduces one of Buffy's core themes: the trials and tribulations of dating, both as a love-struck teen and as the Slayer.
Intent on balancing her destiny with a normal life, Buffy goes out with a guy called Owen, but there date is cut-short when Giles is put in danger and Buffy has to race to the rescue. The only hitch is that Owen is a bit of an adrenaline junky, and has tagged along for the ride.
On the surface your typical Slayer vs vampire joint, Never Kill A Boy on the First Date subverts expectations just enough to make Buffy's latest obstacle a bitter pill to swallow. The core of this episode will follow the series through to its very last day.
5. Angel
Of all the clever additions to the vampire subgenre Buffy brings to the table, the concept of there being a vampire with a soul is by far the most exciting. Up until now, Angel had just been a brooding anti-hero in the shadows, his intentions and nature unclear. In this eponymous episode, his past finally comes to light.
Clearly set-up as a future love interest for the Slayer, the sharp shock that Angel is a vampire may seem a bit on the nose now, but on first viewing is sure to hook you for a long time to come. When his soul is revealed, it only adds to the intrigue.
Intimate and spooky, Angel is one of the show's earliest narrative hooks, throwing a genius twist into Buffy's life whilst making it clear her world is far from black-and-white. From here, things would never be the same.
4. Welcome To The Hellmouth
Right where it all began, Welcome to the Hellmouth opens by having stereotypical victim Darla turn out to be a vampire, and from there effortlessly introduces audiences to Buffy's double life, Xander's wonderful awkwardness, and Willow's shy likeability.
Full of exposition but never overstuffed or rushed, the series premiere pits Buffy against Sunnydale's brewing evil, whilst she tries - and fails - to avoid her past and her fate.
It's cheesy in all the best ways, leaning into its many genre tropes whilst actively twisting them to suit the tone of the show. Welcome to the Hellmouth makes it clear Buffy's action and mythology will always be surprising, and sets the show up with a rock solid foundation.
3. Nightmares
Nightmares is as simple as simple concepts come, following the gang as they're haunted by their worst dreams in the real world and must race to save themselves.
Equally parts genuinely scary and refreshingly funny, the episode has Xander hunted by a killer clown he hilariously stands up to, follows Willow as she's forced to perform a play in front of a live audience, and finally reveals that Buffy's worst fear is that she'll be turned into a vampire.
Imaginative in its concept but even more accomplished in its execution, Nightmares is a definite high-point for Buffy's early years, and watching it all these years later makes it clear the series has so much left to say and do.
2. The Harvest
Following on from the cliffhanger of Welcome to the Hellmouth, The Harvest follows big bad The Master as he attempts to rise from the underworld with the help of his trusted minion Luke. Desperate to stop them and save their friend Jesse, the Scooby Gang team-up for the first time and ride into battle.
The Harvest is an episode of twists, the best of which comes from the death of Jesse (soon to be forgotten forever), and finally cements the fact that although Buffy wants to leave her destiny behind, in Sunnydale that won't be possible.
Upping the action and adding dense material to the show's backstory and growing mythology, The Harvest is just a small taste of the things to come, but it still holds up as a thrilling hour of supernatural fun that's impossible to resist in its own right.
1. Prophecy Girl
Buffy the Vampire Slayer would do far bigger and far better finales than this, but even so Prophecy Girl is still one of the show's best episodes.
The main focus of the season is all about Buffy and the disillusionment she feels about her destiny. She spends several episodes avoiding and sabotaging it so she can have some semblance of a normal life, but in the finale she must officially face it and accept herself once and for all.
Putting her high school drama on hold, Buffy wanders into the lair of The Master safe in the knowledge that she's going to die, and comes to terms with her fate. Though she does die, she's revived by Xander and kills The Master, but by then the episode has already reached its peak.
Driving home the show's themes of acceptance, destiny and friendship, Prophecy Girl was really only the beginning of Buffy the Vampire Slayer's phenomenal run, and what a fantastic start it is.