Buffy The Vampire Slayer: Ranking Every Major Death Worst To Best
11. Caleb
A deeply religious follower of the First Evil, Caleb was one of the Scooby Gang's final major antagonists; a powerful man who killed several Potential Slayers, beat up Buffy and Spike, and took Xander's eye in an act that will never not make die-hard Buffy the Vampire Slayer fans squirm.
After being given extra power by the First Evil, Caleb seemed more unstoppable than ever. That is, until Buffy got her hands on the scythe he had been guarding the whole season.
In their final fight, Caleb was finally overpowered by Buffy, who sliced the misogynistic psychopath in half, offering up one of the show's most satisfying demises.