The Charlie Sheen/Chuck Lorre Debacle: How It Ended For Everyone

Screen Shot 2013 11 20 At 17 33 20 The much publicised fight between Charlie Sheen and Chuck Lorre is something that anyone who was conscious for a decent portion of 2011, rolling over into 2012 and finally we're still seeing the odd spark fly here in 2013. The ego's protruding from these two very rich television personalities have allowed the odd drug-addled comment to escalate in a snowball effect eventually winding up in the demise of a few shows and a few careers. I am talking, of course, of the rather heated debate that escalated from a mixture of cocaine and Hollywood in the once popular sitcom Two And A Half Men. Since this scuffle occurred, many of the cast and crew have jumped ship, with others being forced to do the same. Now that most of the arguments have died down (hopefully, unless you're a journalist or a late night talk show host hoping for an easy day at work), let's take a look at how these incredibly far from affable jests ended up for everyone, from Charlie Sheen and Chuck Lorre themselves to showrunner's and the guy who co-created The Drew Carey Show looking to make a quick buck off a newsworthy celebrity and a decade old Jack Nicholson/Adam Sandler comedy (don't worry, there's an introduction in there for the less sleazily cultured of readers). Click "next" to find out!

First, A Little Background

35 Charlie Sheen, at some point in his career, had a drug problem. There, I said it. Of course, it's no secret, and news about his problem (specifically cocaine) have been told as far back as 1994, wherein he decided to experiment with injecting cocaine, and had to go to hospital. This drug addiction was never more publicised than in and around 2010, in which he spent a brief period in a drug rehabilitation centre, cancelling the last two scheduled episodes of season 7 of Two And A Half Men (this was the season where Chelsea was a main character, so we couldn't really have been happier for him). No arguments just yet, as this is the tip of the iceberg. Somewhere in the summer of that year, Sheen decided he may or may not have had enough of the show. To keep him on the show, Sheen reached a deal with CBS to be given a 78% pay raise if he agreed to stay for another two seasons, which he did. That's $1.78 million. Per episode. For 24 episodes. In a year. For the more calculable among you, that's $42.72 million for filming about 8 or 9 hours of fart, beer and sex jokes. May I also remind you that Charlie Sheen was already being paid the sum of $1 million per episode of last year's fart, beer and sex jokes. As if this wasn't enough?! Now apparently, Sheen was once quoted as stating that "in perspective, I'm actually quite underpaid", and while it does make sense to some miniscule degree, just let it go! I understand how hard comedy can be, but this is just a fun, dumb little show that makes a lot of money because it's just that, fun and dumb. All you really had to do was nail the intonation of the word "bong" and you've made Two And A Half Men gold! But, I digress, as there is a lot more ground to cover here. Two And A Half Men moved along just fine throughout season 8, almost like clockwork, but with blackjack, and hookers. The biggest change was pretty much Charlie Sheen's shorter haircut, which co-star Jon Cryer mocked in the very first episode of this particular season. Then, in January, Sheen checked himself into rehab for the third time in a year, ceasing production of Two And A Half Men. It ended quite fittingly, actually, with Charlie's character (named Charlie, like every other character Charlie Sheen has ever played) going to Paris with Rose, who has held some strange and manic crush over Charlie for the entirety of the show's tenure. 27 During the hiatus, effectively cancelling the last third of the season, Sheen went on somewhat of a rampage, spouting several "allegedly" anti-Semitic claims and garnering controversy from the fact that he does, in fact, have tiger blood. But then again, all rock stars from Mars have tiger blood, right? The scandal was known to practically everyone, with the late night talk show hosts having their easiest weeks since Andy Kaufman was alive. In fact, CBS's own Craig Ferguson got Sir Michael Caine of all people to voice his opinion on the topic during an interview. Ferguson did, however, show his respect for his fellow man and claimed that he would "stop making Charlie Sheen jokes" due to his evident problem. Racism of any kind is both a sensitive topic as well as a difficult term to use, with each individual holding different limits and boundaries as to what they believe to be racist or offensive, so Sheen's comments could be seen as harmless (Sheen used Lorre's real name whilst calling him out during an interview), but to others, including Lorre himself, it was too far. In April 2011, Lorre decided that he had grown tired of Sheen, deciding to take the show in a new direction. This led to a rather popular and easy joke to make. Here's how it works: 1) Something bad happens because of someone and that someone needs replacing. 2) Tell your friend that said someone "will be replaced by Ashton Kutcher." Comedic genius! Needless to say, Ashton Kutcher made his first appearance at the very end of the premiere episode, "Nice To Meet You, Walden Schmidt." Much debate was present throughout this ordeal, with a sum of 28.74 million viewers turning in to see how the episode would play out. The episode was average at best, but the introduction of Kutcher's character, Walden Schmidt, through the ashes of Charlie was truly a moment worth remembering. More on that later. Now that you have been introduced/refreshed on the situation, click "next" to see how it turned out for all of the key players.

Everyone Deserves A 24th Chance: Charlie Sheen And Anger Management

36 With this level of public attention, it's not like Charlie will be dead in the water, squandering his last $20 million on his own private Sheen Island. Of course, on June 28, 2012, Charlie Sheen reluctantly left behind his Charlie Sheen-esque Charlie Harper character and donned the mindblowingly different role of the Charlie Sheen-esque Charlie Goodson (again, called Charlie). The new series was based on the 2003 film starring Adam Sandler and Jack Nicholson, which other than the fact that it features anger management therapy taking place, has absolutely nothing to do with the 2003 film starring Adam Sandler and Jack Nicholson. The television version actually details an ex-baseball player (Charlie) who ruined his career by way of his own anger issues. He is now an anger therapist, although still with anger issues, which surely would help his career path in any way, shape or form? But I digress. Charlie also continues to see his anger management therapist, Dr. Kate Wales (played by Selma Blair), while maintaining a balance with a whole array of different characters, including his ex-wife (played by Shawnee Smith), his daughter, his father (played by the still-brilliant Martin Sheen, whose character name is also Martin), his anger management group at a prison, starring such characters as Wayne, Ernesto, and two nameless "prison-gay" characters who I can only describe as Blaine Edwards and Antoine Merriweather. I'll give the show one thing, it has a hell of a cast. I didn't even mention two of Charlie's neighbours, played by Brian Austin Green and Sheen's old friend from Spin City, Michael Boatman (and you guessed it, he's also called Mike). The show itself started off extremely well, ratings wise, with 5.74 million viewers (an all time high for the premiere of a series on basic cable), and the show even had a few decent ideas and a few funny jokes going for it too. Thanks to it's impressive ratings, and it's rather bizarre production deal (if the first season of 10 episodes got a certain amount of viewers, then 90 episodes would be ordered into production immediately), Anger Management is now confirmed to last for an entire 100 episodes (Sheen advertised "after 100 episodes, I can stop whenever I want." Which has some truth, but the show will probably be cancelled before that time comes). Come to think of it, this show had rather intelligent and humourous advertising, such as the 24th Chance trailer below: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wbOHhDyjuQ4 However, not too long into the show, problems started to arise, and viewers started to leave. By episode 40, the show wasn't even being viewed by 1 million viewers, usually dwindling down at the 0.6-0.8 million mark, which is pretty dire, even for basic cable. The show was so unpopular that the only news site that seems to report news on the show is TMZ. In addition to this, Selma Blair was also fired due to disputes with Charlie Sheen, who was reportedly a "menace" to work with due to his punctuality and work ethic. Did you not read the news articles over the last two years when you were hired to work on the same show as him? It's your own damn fault, really. So, Charlie Sheen has sort of won on this front. He's getting paid for 100 episodes that don't even have to bring in viewers or have any quality about them, and is surrounded by an ever-suffering supporting cast that would probably be pretty stellar if they were in a much better show, particularly those who were once in good sitcoms like Spin City's Michael Boatman or Becker's Shawnee Smith (who's acting is really sucking here. I love her in anything else, but with this she really sounds and acts like she doesn't care), and such brilliant classic actors like Martin freakin' Sheen!

Chuck Lorre And Two And A Half Men

38 Chuck Lorre probably wouldn't even notice if Two And A Half Men disappeared. Currently, the man and his team of writers are working on their seventh season of The Big Bang Theory, their fourth season of Mike & Molly and are about a third of the way into their first season of the new show Mom, all the while spewing out the descent into the terrain of terror that is Two And A Half Men 2.0. I don't usually have a problem with the title not accurately describing the show anymore (Cougar Town, anyone?), but boy does this title not fit anymore. First off, the "half man" is a grown adult now who is in the army and, as of season 11, isn't even a main character anymore. Secondly, the two men are not that manly when it comes down to it (which is in relation to the theme song, admittedly). I suppose "Two Men" might be similar to "2 Broke Girls", which is just as bad in terms of quality. Thirdly and finally, Jenny, the new main character miraculously replacing both the Charlie and Jake characters at the same time, is not a man. Unless you consider a lesbian "pretty much the same thing", in which case you are probably dumb enough to continue to watch the show for it's quality. The question is, will Chuck Lorre's poor treatment of New And A Half Men (which I just made up and will now start calling it for the rest of my life) have any effect on Lorre's other shows? The answer, is no. One of Big Bang Theory's most recent episodes passed the 20 million viewer mark, while Mike & Molly seems to be doing about as well as usual, and Mom is getting decent ratings anyway, so what difference does it make to Chuck? None. Lorre came out of this with a dent in his career caused by New And A Half Men (don't tell me it's not catchy), but has three other critically adequate shows on the air too, so he really had nothing to lose on this front, which might account for the seriously lackluster jokes as of late (I hate to drive that point into the ground, but come one, there's only been one good storyline in the past three seasons and that was dropped after four episodes and didn't even involve the characters being themselves).

Angus T. Jones

37 Here was another easy work day for media sites. Angus T. Jones played Jake Harper, idiot son from the very first episode until today, starting his job at just 10 years old. In late 2012, Jones converted to the Seventh-day Adventist Church, and conducted numerous interviews with the church. These interviews lead to more hilarity for the viewer of the Two And A Half Men legacy, which at this point is just one huge laughable media spectacle. Jones claimed himself to be a "paid hypocrite" due to his newfound religion's conflicting views with the currently terrible show that he was starring in. Aside from insulting himself (?), he also insulted the show itself, calling it "filth." How did that cause controversy? It's entirely true. He also decided that he was sick of even being a part of it due to these beliefs. Speculation was also made that he was being unfairly influenced by his peers at the Church. Another speculation was that this was just an excuse to leave the show, since before "the change" he had appeared in all but one episode, and season nine had a very limited role for Jones (one episode just required him to walk in, look around and say "Dad?" Congratulations kid, here's your $300,000!) Half-expecting the show to end, the season 9 finale involved Jake Harper signing up to the army, with flashbacks and an entirely present cast to boot. Sadly, the show continued on, with Jones only making 14 appearances in the 23 episode season, albeit, with more focus on his character when he was actually present. As of season 11, Jones is M.I.A, and isn't even a main character anymore. Considering that he hasn't appeared outside of his Jake Harper role since a Hannah Montana appearance in 2010, I think it's fair to say that unless Jones is moving on to more qualitative things, then his career has most definitely taken a hit. But then again, it's hard enough for a child actor to continue his stardom through to adulthood, even those who appear in good movies or TV shows.

Amber Tamblyn And The Rest Of The Two And A Half Men Cast

310 Before we get to the focal points of New And A Half Men, let's focus on what used to be the supporting and the recurring casts. We haven't seen much of Amber Tamblyn's character of Jenny Harper, but what we've seen so far has been acceptable, so much so that she was upgraded to main cast status after one episode and that she is being given storylines straight off the bat (Aly Michalka has just been hired in a recurring role as her love interest). This is mostly due to two reasons: 1) Amber Tamblyn is a great actress who you can tell is just having fun being an on-screen drunken she-Charlie. 2) The writers can write Charlie Harper really well. That's what made the first eight seasons so enjoyable. That is also why they brought Kathy Bates in as Charlie's ghost in season 9 (which won her an Emmy for Best Guest Actress In A Comedy Series in 2012). In the good ol' days,we were gifted with what Conchata Farrell (Berta) described as "Two and a half men, three bitches and a psycho." The three bitches in question were ex-wife of Alan Harper, Judith (played by Marin Hinkle), alcoholic mother with a bias towards everyone who isn't Alan (played expertly by Holland Taylor), and the hilarious housekeeper Berta (Conchata Farrell). In the first few seasons they were joined by the "psycho" Rose (Melanie Lynskey), who harboured a rather sizable crush on Charlie. After the first two seasons, Rose became a recurring but still present character, and continues to appear in every season, although as each season passes, Rose's role diminishes. As of late, it seems that the writers aren't entirely sure what to do with the character, only having her come back out of some kind of sympathetic obligation. Numerous plot threads seem to arise with her, but none of them actually go anywhere. It seems to be "hey, let's make her the investor of--Never mind, it's no good", or "let's have her teach someone how to stalk--No. No good. Forget it." If it's not her career that's taken a nosedive, it most certainly is her character. Holland Taylor is an incredibly talented actress, who somehow resorts to films and shows far below her station, such as this or spy Kids 2 and 3, when she should be featured in more roles like the one she had in The Truman Show. Thankfully, her one woman play got her out of all but one episode of season 10, and unlike Judith's role, her's at least had enough screentime to deem it one worth of main billing. However, she is slated to appear in more episodes this season (which doesn't mean much, as she has already appeared twice, so that could be implied as if she has already filmed all of her scenes for this year). 312 Berta is played by the also hilarious and brilliant Conchata Farrell, who maintains her usual quota of appearances, which involves appearing in all but usually four or five episodes, cleaning in the background before spouting a one-liner or two before leaving again. She is essentially the Statler and Waldorf of the show. Rose isn't the only character to diminish in time, Judith, the never pleased ex-wife seems to have her own troubles keeping a role. Probably because Hinkle found something better to do, that something being another show by the name of Deception. Hinkle appears to have been stereotyped by this role, as on Deception she also plays the role of an estranged wife. It doesn't really matter though, as it was cancelled after eleven episodes anyway. As she was starring in another show, Judith was dropped from the storyline almost altogether, with her appearing in another Jake-like cameo (that being getting paid a ridiculous amount of money and a main cast credit for very little screen time), with a running total of ten seconds screen time during the entirety of season 10 (which was basically a throwaway gag at the end of an episode). Her new husband, Herb (played by the brilliant Ryan Stiles) appeared in four episodes that season in a much more interesting story arc, which just goes to show that it is the supporting cast that helped make the show so great at one point. For example, one of my favourite episodes of the show just involved Charlie, Alan, Ryan Stiles' Herb, guest star Michael Clarke Duncan and the surprisingly underrated character of Gordon (played by J.D. Walsh) just sit around in the Harper's lounge and have a hilarious conversation. There is a similar episode and situation the memory of which escapes me, but the fond memory of the former stopped me writing this article for four minutes while I watched the hilarity ensue. Here's the clip: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uk-TdlgPt6I The supporting cast is mostly absent in recent years, and good characters who remain can be counted on one hand. The aforementioned Michael Clarke Duncan and Gordon are gone, as are other classics such as Jane Lynch's Dr. Linda Freedman or Russell the Pharmacist (played by Roseanne's Martin Mull). The characters who remain, such as Lyndsey and Eldridge McElroy, are no longer enjoyable and new characters such as Walden's ex-wife Bridget, Zoey or Miley Cyrus' brief stint as Missi, are downright unlikable and have absolutely no redeemable qualities whatsoever. Today, the only truly good characters are Herb (who is only enjoyable due to Ryan Stiles' comedic talents, which are much more prevalent on the recently revived Whose Line Is It Anyway?), Billy Stanhope (played by superb comedian Patton Oswalt, who miraculously manages to appear in every recent show ever in at least a cameo role) and Kate (Brooke D'Orsay), who we'll talk about next...

The Remaining Stars: Ashton Kutcher And Jon Cryer

313 Before we conclude, let's talk about the main stars of 2.5 Men 2.0. "I can't replace Charlie Sheen but I'm going to work my ass off to entertain the hell out of people!" This was Ashton Kutcher's remark, and it's true. He didn't necessarily achieve his desired result but it is true. These two actors really are trying in their respective roles, and Kutcher's portrayal not as Walden Schmidt, but as alias Sam Wilson during a season 10 story arc wherein billionaire Walden Schmidt becomes tired of women liking him entirely for his money, and becomes the poor man by the name of Sam Wilson, who develops a relationship with fashion designer Kate (Brooke D'Orsay). This storyline was the needle in the haystack of good storylines. Especially with episodes being set around Christmas and heavily advertising the Christmas spirit and hope in general, this is something that made long-term fans rejoice. Sadly, the arc came to a tragic end after all of five episodes with Kate. By tragic end, we mean REALLY bad musical number. Seriously, the less said about it the better. The song basically bitch-slapped you back into the reality that this is a show way past it's prime. On the other hand, Jon Cryer actually won the Emmy in 2012 for Best Lead Actor In A Comedy Series, which was during the worst season yet, so it was clearly done purely out of sympathy for Cryer. You know what? Despite him appearing in Superman IV, I like this man as an actor. He seems like he's always trying no matter the quality (he was one of the only parts of Superman IV I liked, albeit only because I was laughing at what a bad part he had, something which I feel he knew as well). In fact, it seems that he's only staying on the show because somebody needs to hold the fort, or to mix a metaphor, go nobly down with the sinking ship. Even some of his Tweets advertising the latest episode seem kind of passive aggressive lately, such as the one pictured below. 44 In conclusion, the majority of these actors have a career too large to be tarnished by something that was frankly just a foolish couple of quotes by a drug-addled star. Most of the actors have (at the very least) tried to move on to other things, some of whom have succeeded, some of whom have not. The whole reason we are still hearing news about this incident is because the actors are continually moving onward and upward. These people's careers were too big to be affected by even such a sizable incident, so they will (mostly) live on in their respected qualities. Although, maybe the feud may come to an end, after this Tweet by Sheen, alongside a picture of Two And A Half Men's 2007 People's Choice Award for Best Comedy: 45 As we all know, however, Charlie Sheen is, by definition, WINNING. Anything you want to add to this debate? Post your comments below and thanks for reading!

Contributor
Contributor

Nerd. Not much else to say on that front. Television, film, comic book and general useless trivia enthusiast. Maybe you'll find me funny.