Community: The 10 Most Hated Episodes

We promise that there's more on this list than just every season four episode.

Community DeSalvo Matt Berry
Sony Pictures Television

There are good sitcoms and then there are great sitcoms. And then there are sitcoms that define the genre and doom everything that comes after it to fall short by comparison. Community is that third kind.

Initially premiering on NBC in 2009, Dan Harmon’s quirky tale about a gang of outcasts forming a community college study group took certain sections of the internet by storm. With full episode homages to specific film genres and Dan Harmon’s love of meta commentary, this was a show that was proud to be weird in a sea of ordinary.

But for as many amazing episodes that this show has put out, there’s more than a few that aren’t so well regarded. In fact, a few of them are downright hated, both by critics and the fanbase. These are the episodes that even the most diehard Greendale devotee will skip on a rewatch.

Did your most reviled half hour make it onto the list? Or maybe you’re about to find out that you’re the only one who actually likes your favourite episode? You’ll have to read on to find out…

10. Lawnmower Maintenance And Postnatal Care (Season 6, Episode 2)

Community Season 6 Frankie
Yahoo

The main problem that plagued Community’s later seasons was losing members of the original study group left, right and centre. By season six, Donald Glover, Chevy Chase and Yvette Nicole Brown had all departed the show, taking their beloved characters with them. Instead of just making do with the original cast members that they had left, Dan Harmon and his writing team decided to create all new main characters to plug the gaps.

The problem is that, while Keith David and Paget Brewster do their best with what they’re given, nobody can ever replace Troy, Pierce, and Shirley. And so we get this episode where these subpar replacements take centre stage and the main plot is quite simply dragged out for too long, following Dean Pelton as he becomes obsessed with a new VR computer system.

It’s the kind of plot that might have been something incredible back in Community’s golden years but in the post season 3 slump, it just ends up being somewhat of a chore to sit through.

The out of left field subplot involving Britta’s parents also fails to really go anywhere and it all ends up as an episode that you’ll completely forget about once the credits roll.


9. History 101 (Season 4, Episode 1)

Community Season 4
NBC

As long-time fans will know, Sony Pictures Television made the ludicrous decision to boot Dan Harmon out of the Community showrunner’s chair after season three and bring on two virtual unknowns, David Guarascio and Moses Port, to replace him. Naturally, the show’s quality took a major hit, and the decline is evident from the very first episode of the fourth season.

Beginning with Abed reimagining the show inside his head as “Abed’s Happy Community College Show”, the botched attempts to reverse engineer that winning Harmon formula only get worse from there. The Dean decides to hand out seats in a ‘History of Ice Cream’ class by hosting ‘The Hunger Deans’ in the cafeteria, a reference which was barely on the pulse in 2013 and has aged horribly upon rewatch.

What can be said is that the core cast are still on top form here, delivering the hollow dialogue with as much commitment as can possibly be mustered. But even their best efforts can’t help season four be anything more than a pale imitation of everything that came before it.


8. Advanced Safety Features (Season 6, Episode 7)

Community Season 6
Sony Pictures Television

Do you remember that incredible Subway episode from season three? The one where Britta fell in love with the human embodiment of the sandwich chain and the entire idea of product placement on a television programme was viciously mocked? Well, Advanced Safety Features takes everything that was good about that episode and sets it on fire.

Whereas the former Subway episode felt like Dan Harmon rebelling against Sony’s insistence on product placement in the show, Honda feels like a complete sell out. The physical embodiment of Subway returns, this time as a guerrilla marketer for Honda, and Britta can only go out with him so long as she starts promoting Honda vehicles with him.

It’s nothing more than a re-tread of themes that were better handled three seasons prior and a blatant attempt to shoehorn Honda marketing into the show. Looks like that’s what happens when you put an advertising paycheck above writing a good story.


7. Competitive Wine Tasting (Season 2, Episode 20)

Community Sheffield
Sony Pictures Television

Community has never been the type of show to be satisfied with churning out a standard sitcom plot, which makes it all the more disappointing when it does very occasionally stoop to those sorts of lows. The only real misfire from seasons one to three would probably be fine on another run-of-the-mill comedy show, but on Community? It feels like an insult.

The main plot of this episode follows Jeff and Pierce as they both vie for the affections of a new girl in one of their classes. She hits it off with Pierce and Jeff becomes convinced that she is up to something. Meanwhile, Troy and Britta attend an acting class where Troy lies about being molested by his uncle to garner sympathy and struggles to maintain the deception. There’s also a minor plot with Abed getting into a fight over the classic sitcom Who’s The Boss and do you see how middle of the road this all sounds?

The only reason this episode doesn’t attract even more vitriol is because of everything post season three but it’s still worthy of being looked down upon. Far from the study group’s finest hour here.


6. Basic RV Repair And Palmistry (Season 6, Episode 10)

Community Season 6 Dean Pelton Abed Nadir
Sony Pictures Television

Any time Community employs a gimmick in an episode, it can be very hit or miss. An episode set entirely inside an 8-bit video game? Hit. An episode that has a plot centring around driving a giant hand to a mysterious buyer, for some reason, and an extremely convoluted flashback subplot? A resounding miss.

The Save Greendale Committee, the season six replacement for the study group, are travelling in Elroy’s RV to sell a giant hand that Dean Pelton accidentally ordered off of the Internet when the RV breaks down. And then they just sort of…sit around for the rest of the episode while Abed keeps attempting to “flashback” to an earlier point in time with varying degrees of success and humour.

It’s the sort of meta commentary that the show has done far better in its previous seasons and usually with a much more satisfying emotional payoff. This feels far too much like season four, like someone attempting to capture the Dan Harmon meta essence and falling flat on their face.

Except this time, it’s Harmon himself who’s to blame for this damp squib.


5. Basic Sandwich (Season 5, Episode 13)

Community Season 5 Basic Sandwich
Sony Pictures Television

The fifth season of Community is a mixed bag to say the least. Episodes in the earlier half of the season like Cooperative Polygraphy and Geothermal Escapism are stone cold classics. But once beloved character Troy Barnes departs in episode five, the season quickly declines in quality and eventually lands at the disappointment that is Basic Sandwich.

Again, this is a finale that might have worked in a previous season. The first ever Dean of Greendale sealing himself under the college with a sentient computer and the gang going on a quest to find him and save Greendale from the evil clutches of the Subway corporation? The resulting thirty minutes should be chock full of wacky hijinks and instantly quotable one-liners.

But none of the jokes land, the characters are acting like exaggerated versions of who they used to be and the washed-out colour palette that plagued all of season five's cinematography does the episode no favours.

There was a time when this could have been the last ever episode of Community. Thank your lucky stars that it wasn’t.


4. Economics Of Marine Biology (Season 4, Episode 7)

Community Season 4
Sony Pictures Television

So here it is. The episode with the dubious honour of having the lowest IMDb score of any Community instalment. And it’s not hard to see why. Remember how the season two episode on this list is here because it descended into fairly standard sitcom fare? Well, this episode decides to go even lower.

The Dean tasks Jeff, Britta, and Annie with wooing Archie, a rich young man, played by one of the most annoying guest stars of all time, who is thinking about enrolling in Greendale and bringing a lot of money in with him. Of course, the guy is a completely unreasonable jerk who makes the group run around doing everything for him and, of course, Jeff eventually snaps and tells him that he’s a deeply unpleasant person.

And just to hit the bog standard sitcom episode hat trick, Archie actually appreciates Jeff being honest with him and enrols at Greendale anyway. This episode is about as engrossing as it sounds, and the entire plot summary honestly sounds like something a sitcom writers’ room would have passed on about thirty years ago.


3. Advanced Introduction To Finality (Season 4, Episode 13)

Community Paintball
NBC

Season four started with one whimper and it ended with another. This episode stinks of desperation, clearly exposing that the writing team for this season were completely out of ideas after just thirteen episodes. The graduation episode of Community was one that fans had been anticipating for years. Harmon himself has said that, were he still in charge, that this episode would have served as the entire show’s grand finale.

And instead of that, we get the unnecessary return of the evil study group from the darkest timeline, a one-off fan favourite joke from the previous season. There was absolutely no reason for the poignant themes of moving on from community college to be dwarfed by a headache inducing paintball showdown between the two groups.

Oh yes. The episode also brings back paintball too, because the formula for writing appears to have been just shoving everything that fans liked into a blender and serving up whatever sludge comes out on the other side.

Thank god that Dan Harmon was reinstated so that Community fans, and television audiences in general, didn’t have to sit through something this messy ever again.


2. Intro To Felt Surrogacy (Season 4, Episode 9)

Community Pierce
NBC

Tossing out your old showrunner and hiring new ones who have barely written for television before is generally a bad idea. The only thing that could make that idea even worse is if the old showrunner had a very specific style and tone to his writing that is almost impossible to replicate. Despite Harmon’s inimitable flair, the new creative team decided to go ahead and try to write a genre-busting episode anyway. What they wanted was a classic like Basic Lupine Urology or Abed’s Uncontrollable Christmas. What they got was Intro to Felt Surrogacy.

This is the sort of thing that Community used to make fun of. The study group are all refusing to speak to one another, so Dean Pelton gives them all puppets to communicate their feelings through and the rest of the episode is a recap through this medium.

The story is boring, the songs are ear-bleedingly bad and the ultimate reason for the study group’s initial frostiness is so underwhelming that you wonder why on Earth you sat through all this in the first place.


1. Grifting 101 (Season 6, Episode 9)

Community DeSalvo Matt Berry
Sony Pictures Television

Matt Berry is a British comedy legend. From his gloriously dramatic performance as Douglas Reynholm in The IT Crowd to his starring role as eccentric actor Steven Toast, there’s truly no punchline that cannot be enhanced by his genius. And yet even he struggles to do anything with this half-baked attempt at homaging The Sting, the 1974 Best Picture winner at the Oscars.

For one thing, there’s no real B plot to this episode which means that the story of the study group attempting to grift their teacher, Matt Berry’s role, after he grifts them first has to support all of the narrative weight. It is on this list because it totally fails to do so. The whole thing just drags on for too long, getting more and more outlandish by the minute, and ends up suddenly coming to a shuddering stop at the end.

Another season six episode, another concept that could have been done better in earlier years. And surely there are better films to parody for an episode than a 1930s set caper that nobody remembers?

Come on, Dan. You’re better than this.


Watch Next


The Ultimate Community Quiz

Community Chang And Annie In Class
NBC

1. What Class Was Used As A Basis To Create The Study Group?

In this post: 
Community
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Owen Davies hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.