Deadwood: Ranking 15 Cast Members Worst To Best
Sorting all the colourful characters from scheming saloon owners to do-gooding outlaws.
In 2004, HBO released a western unlike any other. David Milch's Deadwood made a conscious choice to prioritise not the shootouts and train robberies that the genre is known for, but the authenticity of the time period, Shakespearean level dialogue and impeccably drawn characters. Deadwood enjoyed mixing real historical figures with fictitious individuals and watching them bounce off each other. It made for some of the greatest television ever produced.
Every character in this list stands on their own. Each one, completely unique and distinct from the next. We'll cover: lawmen, prostitutes, saloon owners, drifters, doctors, all the way up to a future senator of the United States. They're all so memorable that the list could easily have an extra 10 entries.
Deadwood's 2019 movie will also be taken into consideration as well as its three seasons. The show was a constant struggle of power between its players, so it's fitting we can finally decide who was the best of them all.
Spoilers will follow.
15. Mr. Wu
For a man who would feed dead bodies to his pigs, Mr. Wu was one of the more light-hearted elements of the show. Leader of the Asian community in Deadwood and Al Swearengen's opium supplier, Wu was often under immense pressure to provide safety for his people as well as make money through his illegal dealings.
The reason he is on this list is his surprisingly endearing relationship he had with Al Swearengen (or 'swedgin' a he called him). Wu speaks very little English and his boisterous business dealings with Al were a comedic highlight of the show. Both men trying to ascertain what the other is attempting to say using sign language, props and drawings never ceased to be hilarious.
What started off as both men shouting at each other soon became a more respectful relationship as they grew to trust each other. Wu was never treated as an equal in the camp but Al came closest and watching Wu protect an ailing Swearengen in Deadwood: The Movie was especially touching.
14. Alma Garret
Alma was the closest thing to a female lead the show had. After her husband is killed on the orders of Al Swearengen, Alma inherits his recently purchased land that is rich with gold. Land that practically everyone will attempt to buy from her.
Alma had to act steely and in control as various men approached her concerning the land and watching her gain confidence and swatting them away with ease was thoroughly entertaining. Where she faltered however, was her questionable behaviour and jealous nature concerning Seth Bullock and his wife.
After having an affair with Seth Bullock in the first season, Martha Bullock arrives in Deadwood in season 2 and the pair mutually agree the affair should stop. Despite that, Alma proceeded to be bitter and cold towards both Seth and his wife which was frustrating to watch.
Her relationship with the orphaned Sofia was sweet for the most part, except for when Alma decides she'd rather lean into drug use. Drug addicts aren't inherently bad characters, but it made Alma rather irritating to watch at times, especially since we know how awesome she could be when she was defending what was hers.
13. A.W. Merrick
Merrick was Deadwood's resident man of knowledge. He ran the Black Hills Pioneer, the local newspaper and was a good and honest man. His cowardly presence gave way to a warm and gentle persona that allowed him to get on with many people in the camp including Seth Bullock and Al Swearegen.
Despite his lack of bravery, Merrick would fight for what's right which he proved when he stood up to George Hearst along with the rest of the camp. A decision that would earn him a beating from Hearst's men.
He was a peculiar individual, with his big words and positive demeanour. He stands out as the most polite character on the show, and in a show where everyone is foul mouthed and angry, his manners prove significant.
12. Jack Langrishe
Jack Langrishe was a amazing addition to the season three cast. Jack moved to Deadwood with his theatre troupe in the hopes of bringing culture to the residents by exposing them to the arts. He planned to turn the former brothel-turned-school into a playhouse where his actors could perform for the locals.
Jack was an eccentric man who used flavourful language and flamboyant gestures to communicate with the more grounded members of the cast. Brian Cox brought a brilliant sense of other-worldliness to his performance as the larger-than-life character navigated his way through interactions with the very serious George Hearst.
He also has a long history with Al Swearengen which allowed for some great scenes where the two master socialites spar. Langrishe was a breath of fresh air in a final season that is rather bleak for the rest of the characters.
11. Dan Dority
We all need a friend like Dan. Fiercely loyal, supportive, sensitive and of course, he'll kill anyone that's bothering you. Dan Dority was Al Swearengen's right-hand man and main muscle. He may not have been the smartest man in the camp but he'll always have Al's back.
One of the first things we see Dan do is the brutal murder of Alma's husband Brom. It's surprising to think how likable Dan would become after such a heinous act of violence. Dan wanted to be better than what he was; he didn't want to give into his anger and rage and be a terrible person. We constantly saw him battle with his demons on this issue and it makes for a compelling watch.
Dan's relationship with Al and the rest of the Gem saloon also made him a more enjoyable character as we see first hand his dedication to his friends and colleagues. Dan's lack of ambition allowed him to be Al's most trusted ally in the whole camp.
Dan also has the privilege of being a part of the best fight in the whole show against Hearst's man Captain Turner. A fight that proved to be... a rather eye-popping affair.
10. 'Wild' Bill Hickock
In a lot of ways, Bill Hickock is a huge reason for Deadwood to have the legacy it does. It isn't hard to believe that one of the key scenes pitched to HBO by David Milch was the historically accurate murder of 'Wild' Bill Hickock while he played poker in a Deadwood saloon at the hands of Jack McCall. It was Deadwood's Game of Thrones moment, seven years before Ned Stark took to his knees at the steps of the Great Sept of Baelor.
Bill Hickock was a legendary gunslinger that enters the camp more myth than man at the start of the show. He's suave, he's calm and he is incredibly cool. He interacts with various members of the camp and seems just as important as Seth Bullock or Al Swearengen. Then he dies. Only four episodes in!
It was a huge moment for the show (especially if you don't know your history) and stands out as one of the most iconic scenes in the series. If only he was given the chance to hang around for a whole season because he'd definitely place higher on this list. Keith Carradine captured the gravitas of the character with every stare of his eyes and every step he took. After he's gone, his shadow loomed large over the season, as it should have.
9. Joanie Stubbs
Joanie had been many things over the course of the show. Madam of the Bella Union, brothel owner, schoolhouse proprietor and the owner of the Bella Union. She had taken on many roles with the hope of achieving some independence, but that had always proved difficult.
She seemed to be the only person that Cy Tolliver cared for other than himself and she always appeared kind and caring towards others. However, Joanie's life was plagued by tragedy, from her horrible childhood to her close friends being murdered in Deadwood camp by Francis Wolcott.
That is why Joanie's arc is one of the most satisfying in the show as we started to see her acquire some of the happiness, she had long been without, in her developing romantic relationship with Jane Canary. Joanie and Jane found each other at a time when they both needed companionship and their dynamic felt both genuine and tender hearted. Their reunion and subsequent rekindling in Deadwood: The Movie is one of the highlights of the whole series.
8. E.B. Farnum
Weasel, petulant, greedy. These are all words that accurately describe Deadwood's hotelier and later mayor E.B. Farnum. E.B. is like a Machiavellian figure without any sense of skill in the art of manipulation. Arguably the most despised permanent fixture in camp, people had no choice but to put up with E.B.'s scheming and plotting for more control and respect in the camp.
At first a creature of Al Swearengen's, E.B. falsely believed he was destined for greater things and demanded more authority in the camp. Even after being appointed mayor, the locals tolerance of E.B. proved low at best.
William Sanderson brings the right amount of pathetic entitlement to the role that he never became annoying as we were often treated to other members of the cast putting him down regularly. Without E.B., Deadwood wouldn't have its resident punching bag to lighten the mood once in a while.
7. Doc Cochran
No one enjoyed dressing down the inhabitants of Deadwood quite like its in-house doctor. Due to his extreme value as a medical professional, Doc Cochran would often say exactly how he felt to the more imposing figures in camp without fear of retaliation.
Doc had high morals and could be extremely stubborn as he was determined to treat the sick and ailing regardless of how ill he may be himself. His bedside manner would often be gentle and sweet to someone like Sofia but he would berate and taunt people like Al if they would ignore his advice. It was often better if they would just do as he said.
Doc has many moments that highlight him as a truly good man and is one of the few people in camp that manages to get on with everybody. This made him a true cornerstone of the community and one of the most memorable figures on the show itself.
6. Cy Tolliver
The late legend Powers Boothe was simply fantastic as the mean and sadistic Cy Tolliver. Owner of the Bella Union Saloon and direct rival to Al Swearengen, Cy was an abhorrent and cruel man who had aspirations of slowly taking over the camp.
It is easy to look at Cy as just Al Swearengen-light but there is a lot more to Cy than that. His obsessive relationship and unrequited affections for Joanie and his incessant power plays in the camp highlight a fragile insecurity in Cy. He is a man who wants things a certain way but often it seems like the world is against him and that only feeds into his psychopathy.
Cy becomes increasingly unhinged over the course of the three seasons, culminating in him brutally murdering one of his subordinates for seemingly no reason. It is sad that Powers Boothe passed away before filming on Deadwood: The Movie could begin as we'll never know quite what David Milch envisioned for his character. Regardless, what we got were three great seasons of a dangerous man slowly losing his mind.
5. George Hearst
George Hearst is one of the greatest television villains of all time. A wealthy mining magnate who would later become a U.S. senator came to Deadwood in the season two finale looking for gold claims to purchase. He brought with him his power and influence to choke the camp into giving him whatever he wanted.
Antagonistic characters like E.B. or Cy or even Al received a lot of pushback on their plans and had to adapt when things didn't go their way. No such problems for George Hearst, everything he wanted he got and he remained untouchable throughout the majority of his time with the series. He is the epitome of a love-to-hate character.
He was responsible for not one but two deaths of central characters (Ellsworth and Charlie Utter), he chopped off Al's finger, he shot at Alma in the street, he demanded Trixie's execution and we never got that moment of retribution we all craved. Hearst was so despicable in his actions and so without remorse that it can leave you shouting at the television for him to get what's coming to him.
One of the most tense moments in the whole show is when Trixie has had enough of his tyranny and makes an attempt on his life but fails to kill him. We're right there with her and when she misses, we feel her fear. That is a sign of a truly detestable and menacing villain.
4. Seth Bullock
Deadwood is an ensemble show but if it had a main character that would be Seth Bullock. As Sheriff of the camp, Bullock often found himself at odds with the criminal enterprises within the town. An honest man with principles, Bullock would clash on several occasions with the ever duplicitous Al Swearengen. Their rivalry turned uneasy alliance is one of the most fascinating dynamics that evolves over the course of the show.
Bullock had close relationships in the camp with his best friend Sol (who narrowly missed a spot on this list), Charlie Utter, and of course Alma Garrett. The latter of which became his lover until his brother's widow and new wife Martha arrived in the camp with his biological nephew William.
Bullock's relationship with his new family was slow moving at first but when William is crushed and killed by a stampeding horse, some of the best dramatic material in the whole show is Bullock reckoning with what he's lost and the fact he can't have anyone to direct his flaring temper at.
Bullock was a strong presence on the show. His constant rage at injustice highlighted a human element within him that made his struggles with the more immoral characters on the show incredibly compelling. His crowning achievement will be taking the unshakably arrogant George Hearst by the ear, not once, but twice.
3. Trixie
Foul-mouthed and full of determination, Trixie is one of the best characters on the show. A prostitute at the Gem Saloon, she was Al's favourite girl and the two had an incredibly complex relationship. He could treat her with great affection or he could make her fearful for her life but there is no doubt that the two cared deeply for each other. It is nice to see that in the end, the final note of their relationship was not one of violence but one of Al leaving the Gem to Trixie after he dies.
Trixie's other key relationship of course, was of her developing romance with Sol Star. It was incredibly sweet to see Trixie slowly realise that Sol isn't just another man that wants her body but is a genuine person that loved her deeply. Having their wedding and birth of their first child was a smart centrepiece for Deadwood: The Movie as it showcased how far Trixie had come over the course of the show.
Often aggressive, sometimes violent, Trixie refused to be a damsel in distress and truly stood as an independent figure on her own two feet. Her scathing manner contrasted well with her compassionate nature to make for an incredible character with the best developed arc of the entire series.
2. 'Calamity' Jane Canary
In a world where you were either a man's wife or a sex worker. Jane refused to be either, defying all expectations that were had of her as a woman. Shattering every convention of the time, Jane was a bombastic and unfiltered presence in the camp who drank excessive amounts and took great joy in being standoffish wherever possible.
After the death of 'Wild' Bill, Jane seeped into alcoholism and became depressed. Her drunken outbursts were often amusing, if a little sad to watch. Jane was caring and defensive of those in need and to watch her being in need herself for a good portion of the show can be difficult.
That's why her relationship with Joanie is incredibly gratifying as we see them pull each other off the ledge they both find themselves on. Jane was a constantly self destructing figure and is a great representation of someone struggling with substance abuse and mental health problems.
Her ferocious support of those she loved made her easy to get behind and she stood as the moral core of the whole show. One of the final moments of Deadwood: The Movie is Jane overcoming her fears and enacting a moment of true bravery. We felt just as proud of her as Joanie did.
1. Al Swearengen
Al Swearengen is the most iconic character from this show for a reason. The role that won Ian McShane a Golden Globe cannot be undersold as one of the greatest television characters in history. The owner of the Gem saloon and the unofficial leader of Deadwood camp is full of complexities to unpack.
Al could be vicious, despicable and downright evil at times. At one point, he attempted to arrange the murder of young Sofia and had got away with killing countless others. He was violent and narcissistic and had the foulest mouth on the show which makes his name equally fitting.
Al could also be incredibly charming, generous, loyal and even morally just. He showed a kind of backwards affection for his subordinates and had an even more problematic love for Trixie. Al hated injustices to the camp as a whole which put him directly at odds with the more straightforward villainy of George Hearst.
Al's criminal enterprise and manipulative nature painted him as the show's central antagonist early on, but as the series progressed, a more softer and generous side of Al was shown. He easily had the best lines (the majority of which are vulgar) and he tied the show together as he was connected to practically every storyline in someway. Forever deceptive and always unpredictable, Al Swearengen stands as the best character in all of Deadwood.