Dexter: Every Main Character Ranked Worst To Best
Tonight's the night.
8 years of serial killing thrills and spills met a controversial end in 2013. Dexter had captured millions of imaginations, broken ratings records and bagged several awards by the time it wrapped. The way so many lost their minds over closing scenes was a testament to the passion it had once inspired in its fans.
Brimming with gore, dark humour, sick-minded antagonists and one of TV's most charismatic leading characters, the age of the TV antihero was still young and Dexter Morgan was its best and brightest. As wildly popular as Michael C. Hall's performance was, the power of the show's acting doesn't end with him. Bolstered by a colourful supporting cast, Dexter's bloodthirsty adventures played off cops, crooks, family and love interests masterfully.
With some of the highest highs and lowest lows in television history, the show remains a much-discussed modern classic. Recent news of a season 9 has been met with joy and intrigue. Countless viewers are hoping the upcoming extension can restore the series to its original glory. Thus far, only Dexter himself has been confirmed for new episodes. Given the entertainment value of the main cast, let's hope some of the surviving main cast members join him.
Warning: spoilers ahead.
12. Jamie Batista
Angel Batista suddenly has a sister he neglected to mention from season 6 onwards. Replacing Sonya (we never get any clue as to what happened with her) as Harrison's nanny, Jamie proves to be invaluable to Dexter and the maintenance of his double life. Actress Aimee Garcia does a respectable job with the material provided and is especially humorous when butting heads with her older brother.
Never granted a full character arc in the series, Jamie enjoys romantic subplots with Masuka's tech wiz intern Louis and eventually Joey Quinn. Collateral damage in Louis' feud with Dexter, she's crushed to find out Louis records himself with prostitutes when she's not around. The suffering ramps up in season 8 when her pal/Dexter's neighbour, Cassie is murdered and she is dumped by Quinn.
It's all understandably upsetting but Jamie is rarely given the space to be fully fleshed out as a key character. While we sympathise with her plight, it's hard to grow attached in the way viewers would to the original leading characters. This rather lazy approach to development was a general problem throughout the final 3 seasons of the hit series. Jamie was among its many creative casualties.
11. Vince Masuka
Miami Metro's over-sexed goofball of a forensic scientist typically serves as comic relief. How effective he is in this role is questionable with many of his Glenn Quagmire-like zingers failing to land. Obsessed with the kinkier side of life, he frequently (and almost always unsuccessfully) propositions just about every female he encounters. It's not an endearing quality and, as revealed by Quinn, is one that renders him unpopular in the work place.
A positive character trait for Vince is his surprisingly strong sense of loyalty to his colleagues. Seeing Dexter's wife Rita kiss another man, he is horrified and grapples with the stress of needing to tell Dexter. It's obvious the pain this reveal might cause Dexter scares Masuka who still works up the courage to tell his colleague the ugly truth.
One of many flaws with season 8 is Masuka's ultimately pointless subplot with his surprise daughter. Born from a sperm donation he gave years prior, the 2 hit it off and their scenes eat up precious screen time in what was meant to be an epic send-off for the long running series. As was the case with most season 8 story arcs, it ultimately goes nowhere beyond giving Vince something to do outside of forensics (which, frankly, was far more interesting).
10. Hannah McKay
Dexter's final love interest has some skeletons in the closet. Accomplice to a spree killer during her adolescence, she's gradually become a master poisoner. Matching Dexter's all important code, he targets her as his new victim under the guise of wanting to be her boyfriend. What follows is one of the more polarising scenes in the series. Taped to the table, Hannah seems surprisingly accepting of her fate. Instead of execution, however, Dexter decides lovemaking is the way to go and the 2 get it on right there.
The chemistry between actors Michael C. Hall and Yhvonne Strahovski sizzles nicely throughout her appearances. Strahovski brings a dark charisma to the role that fits like a glove.
The issues with Hannah as a character lie mostly in her season 8 arc. Her rich, old English husband is an implausible, uninteresting storyline that bogs down the show. There's also her surprise return to poison the Morgan siblings only to ditch Dexter on the city outskirts and move on. It made the whole cliffhanger feel like a cheap ratings grab in the end.
Giving Dexter a love interest who understood his dark passenger was an intriguing concept but one that had already been done in season 2 with Lila. Saner and more calculated than her predecessor, Hannah provides some interesting points (particularly her blood feud with Debra) but is ultimately undone by uneven scripting.
9. Joey Quinn
Miami Metro's dodgiest detective is a breath of fresh air during seasons 3 and 4. For the first time, the series takes a look at the implications of a bribe-taking corrupt cop. Mysterious and unpredictable, Quinn has highly questionable dynamics with his informants and Internal Affairs. We want to know more about him but when we do, the explanations are rarely as interesting as the implications.
By season 4, he has replaced James Doakes as the one who suspects Dexter's sinister side. It's a storyline we've seen before and one that carried a billion times more intensity the first time. His romantic endeavours frequently prove to be his professional undoing also (not like he could've known Christine was the Trinity Killer's daughter in fairness) and the character gradually proves inept and self-destructive. His feud with Dexter is done away with via shenanigans with a much older, much more intact Robocop and from there, the writers box him in as Debra's on/off boyfriend.
The Quinn/Debra romance reveals a more sensitive side to the Quinn character. Actor Desmond Harrington infuses the character with an emotional intensity that keeps his topsy turvy plotting compelling. Subtle but effective, his poignant last scene with Dexter in the finale is one of the heavily criticised episode's few high points.
8. Thomas Matthews
This morally questionable official knows so much about the Morgan family you often wonder if he's aware of Dexter's secret. As commanding officer of the Homicide Division, Matthews butts head with Lieutenant María LaGuerta on a daily basis. His political ambition frequently leads to trouble including his burials of evidence and placing blame on LaGuerta for his own errors.
Season 6 reveals Matthews' scandalous night life. With his name turning up in a little black book from a notorious brothel, he finds himself blackmailed into promoting LaGuerta to captain. As if that weren't bad enough for a now deputy chief, Matthews covers up the heroin-caused death of a prostitute he hired. We discover a seedy underbelly of Miami Metro through Matthews' mishaps. Discovering much of the ugly truth through Debra's investigation, we realise how dark and dodgy Harry Morgan's best bud really is.
For all the less than likeable traits and moments Matthews exhibits, he stills enjoys some redeeming features. His friendship with Harry is proof of his loyalty and devotion to those he cares about. Promising to look after Dexter and Debra, Matthews keeps a close, comforting eye on the 2 throughout the series, frequently coming to their aid when needed. Played with a straight-laced conviction by Geoff Pierson, Matthews was an intriguing character that deserved more screen time.
7. María LaGuerta
The series' most professionally ambitious figure, LaGuerta is an ingenious political player. Sadly, her mastery of the game doesn't apply to actual police work. Ferocious in her drive to land every promotion on offer, she even sleeps with rival, Esme Pascal's fiancé in order to emotionally break the new lieutenant. Considering LaGuerta's demise, it's safe to say she probably regretted her treatment of Debra, something that was consistently unpleasant throughout the series.
LaGuerta's investigation of Dexter is one of the more thrilling components of the later seasons. In a nice callback to her friendship with Doakes, LaGuerta finally takes the investigative side of her work seriously. There's several sharp, dramatic moments between her and Dexter (a guy she once had a little thing for no less). It's in many ways the creative peak of the character with her death being the last good shock of the series.
While LaGuerta's character development was mostly consistent, there were a few scattershot moments. Her sudden relationship with Batista is only matched by the sudden nature of their divorce. Ultimately rather pointless for both characters, it appeared the writers didn't know what to do with either character. Played with a suitable dose of venom by Lauren Vélez, the actress manages to inject the often unsympathetic character with humanity and poise.
6. Rita Bennett
Dexter's ill-fated wife often served as a light in the lead character's darkness during her 4 season tenure. Initially looked upon as a tool in his disguise as a normal person, Dexter grows to love both Rita and her kids. Struggling with the trauma of her ex-husband's brutal abuse, Rita's confidence gradually returns with her becoming far more assertive by the time she and Dexter get hitched.
Played with a warm sensitivity by Julie Benz, it was easy to grow attached to the Rita character. Her (literal) bloodbath of a death scene remains one of the most shocking TV moments ever. Falling victim to John Lithgow's disgustingly evil Arthur Mitchell, the writers cruelly let us think it's all over in the final moments of the season 4 finale. Triumphant and ready to go on his honeymoon, Dexter discovers her body and his son in a pool of her blood. It's horrifying stuff, an unforgivingly dark moment even by the standards of this macabre series.
After playing such a vital role from the beginning, Rita's death essentially re-set the entire series. The difference between her 4 seasons and the 4 that followed is like night and day.
5. Angel Batista
Dexter's best friend (at least from Angel's perspective) on the job is a friendly, well-meaning but rather mishap-prone detective. Often emotional and impulsive, Batista cares a great deal for those he works with. When we first meet him, he is struggling through a messy divorce. He considers his status as a lonesome, divorced detective to be a cliché. His need for companionship often leads him into trouble with the likes of Lila and undercover vice cops posing as prostitutes.
His love/hate friendship with Quinn becomes a leading storyline for the character in later seasons. The actors bounce off each other well with the scenes between the 2 ranging from amusing to dramatic. Similar to Quinn, it's implied that he's fully aware of Dexter's self-defence lie in the final episode. Given the detestable nature of the Brain Surgeon killer and the harm he has done to Debra, Batista decides to turn a blind eye to his pal's actions. This is one of the few moments Batista plays outside the rules. It serves as a final reminder of his protective, caring nature towards his colleagues.
David Zayas brings Batista to life with a well-fitting everyman charm that keeps the character sympathetic and engaging throughout the series.
4. Harry Morgan
Portrayed with enigmatic gusto by James Remar, Harry is a fascinating fixture in seasons 1 and 2. Having passed away 10 years prior, we learn a great deal about him and his relationship with Dexter via flashback. The wise but jaded architect of Dexter's code, Harry turns his adopted son into the perfect murderer, ensuring the troubled youngster has a brighter future than the average serial killer ever will.
From season 3 onwards, Harry is basically Dexter's imaginary friend, putting a face on Dexter's internal dialogue. There are several dark reveals about Harry scattered throughout the series from his infidelities to his suicide. They paint the picture of a great cop with some truly debilitating flaws.
Much of his dynamic with Dexter is frustratingly retconned in season 8 with the arrival of Dr Vogel. No longer the mastermind behind Dexter's code, imaginary Harry eventually bids Dexter farewell and vanishes. A considerably different figure in the lives and memories of Dexter and Debra by the end of the series, Harry remained an interesting (if slightly inconsistent) influence from the pilot to the finale. His scenes with a young Dexter are some of the show's best and most realistic in depicting a future serial killer.
3. James Doakes
"Surprise mother****r!"
This brilliant but bad-tempered detective was the first one to see past Dexter's normality facade. The former US Army Ranger has hints of his own dark passenger, frequently brutalising suspects and playing poorly with others. Volatile and controlling, Doakes' once promising career has grown stagnant due to his idiosyncrasies.
Already suspicious of Dexter, Doakes grows unhealthily obsessed with exposing him in the wake of the Ice Truck Killer case. Alienating his colleagues, Doakes winds up shooting himself in the foot by becoming the primary Bay Harbour Butcher suspect. The scenes between him and Dexter in the latter half of season 2 are some of the best, most thrilling moments in the entire series.
Grappling with whether or not to kill Doakes, Dexter keeps him as a prisoner, almost succumbing to the sergeant's suggestion he turn himself in. Just as a successful escape is becoming likely, however, Dexter's crazed former lover Lila blows up the shack, incinerating Doakes in the process. It's a brutal ending to a memorable character, one made all the darker by the fact Doakes will forever be remembered as the Bay Harbour Butcher. Played with great vehemence and wit by Erik King, the whole show felt very different in the wake of his departure.
2. Debra Morgan
The smart but accident-prone daughter of Harry Morgan ultimately proves to be a tragic figure. Often unsure of herself, Debra nearly always proves to be a more than capable member of the force. We follow her initial rise through the ranks and then her sharp downturn into self-destruction during seasons 7 and 8. It's a sad and frustrating turn of events for a character as easy to root for as Debra.
Suffering every season, she embarks upon a series of ill-fated relationships including being engaged to the Ice Truck Killer, watching her beloved Frank Lundy be gunned down and briefly believing she's been in love with Dexter all along (the less said about that one the better).
Succumbing to despair over Dexter's serial killing ways, Debra suffers an identity crisis in the wake of killing LaGuerta to protect him. Her depression and bad habits form a dour end note for the character, topped off with a woeful death scene that'll leave some reaching for the remote. Despite several questionable creative decisions, Debra always remained gripping thanks to an exceptional performance by Jennifer Carpenter. Masterfully capturing both the cool and the awkward aspects of the character, Carpenter ensures Debra is a sympathetic, very human figure throughout the outlandish series.
1. Dexter Morgan
Did you really expect someone else?
Miami's Dark Defender is one of the all time great TV characters. Following up the timid, well-meaning David Fisher in Six Feet Under with something completely different, Michael C. Hall solidified himself as one of TV's finest leading men. A genius blood-spatter analyst by day and an ingenious murderer by night, he was like a superhero gone horribly wrong. Thanks to Harry's code, the lovable psychopath targets only the wicked, specifically fellow murderers.
Dexter's arc is one of self-discovery. When we first meet him, he knows little about himself or his need to kill, he considers himself incapable of love and empathy. Despite this, he forms meaningful relationships with family and lovers as the series wears on. While a sense of decency becomes more apparent in him as the show goes on, the need to satisfy his dark passenger never truly leaves. A dominant factor in his every waking moment, it often leads Dexter to abysmal decisions that make him his own worst enemy (and a danger to those close to him).
An unconventional heart throb and seminal antihero, Dexter's imminent return to the small screen can't come soon enough. Both he (and his fans) deserve a better goodbye.